Bitcoin Forum
May 23, 2024, 07:55:58 PM *
News: Latest Bitcoin Core release: 27.0 [Torrent]
 
   Home   Help Search Login Register More  
Pages: [1] 2 3 »  All
  Print  
Author Topic: Trump just killed Rule 1031 all BTC trades now taxable  (Read 431 times)
1bitcoinsnet (OP)
Member
**
Offline Offline

Activity: 84
Merit: 10


View Profile
December 27, 2017, 01:25:31 AM
 #1

Sad day for traders

Tax code 1031 the like for like exemption that shielded traders is no more

Trump the moron killed it

Time to exit the USA

http://bitcoinist.com/cryptocurrency-investors-lose-tax-break/
Re3urst
Newbie
*
Offline Offline

Activity: 45
Merit: 0


View Profile
December 27, 2017, 01:46:09 AM
 #2

Sad day for traders

Tax code 1031 the like for like exemption that shielded traders is no more

Trump the moron killed it

Time to exit the USA

http://bitcoinist.com/cryptocurrency-investors-lose-tax-break/

As always, not a single reply.

I don't think anyone wants to even know anything about Bitcoin taxes. Just sitting there like an ostrish with your head in the sand, pretending that no one told you Bitcoin is taxable is most people's strategy.
Pearls Before Swine
Sr. Member
****
Offline Offline

Activity: 1190
Merit: 306



View Profile
December 27, 2017, 01:59:40 AM
 #3

I am definitely not a lawyer, but weren't we required to pay taxes on any bitcoin
capital gains anyway?  Can you break down what's new in this?  I'm sure whatever
IS new is going to be summarily ignored by the bitcoin using masses anyhow.
ladadadiweliketoparty
Member
**
Offline Offline

Activity: 97
Merit: 10


View Profile
December 27, 2017, 02:02:00 AM
 #4

The last sentence though Cheesy Cheesy, oh god can barely contain myself. Yeah I would argue that is the consensus among the community here although that seems to be short-sighted to me. People in the USA are going to get screwed more but there are a few places which you can avoid getting taxed double or even avoid altogether. In the end though you gotta realize 20% is much less than 40-50% which would be the normal rate given how much people are making so we should be happy to pay the little tax we have to.

gentlemand
Legendary
*
Offline Offline

Activity: 2590
Merit: 3013


Welt Am Draht


View Profile
December 27, 2017, 02:02:49 AM
 #5

I'm not US based but I do watch r/bitcoinmarkets which has lots of them and it seemed to me that a fair few of them were already thinking this was a thing. It is theoretically in the UK and always has been but I'd guess most will roundly ignore it away from the obvious honeypots like GDAX.
1bitcoinsnet (OP)
Member
**
Offline Offline

Activity: 84
Merit: 10


View Profile
December 27, 2017, 02:02:56 AM
 #6

Sad day for traders

Tax code 1031 the like for like exemption that shielded traders is no more

Trump the moron killed it

Time to exit the USA

http://bitcoinist.com/cryptocurrency-investors-lose-tax-break/

As always, not a single reply.

I don't think anyone wants to even know anything about Bitcoin taxes. Just sitting there like an ostrish with your head in the sand, pretending that no one told you Bitcoin is taxable is most people's strategy.


They still think it's 'anonymous'

haha

try to cash out in an exchange

you got to give more id than you can imagine

then they limit you to a lousy 50K a week

so if you made a big hit, it would take years to withdraw

yet the irs wants taxes on it as soon as the exchange sells it

and the main exchanges know who you really are

so

1. it's not anonymous when you exit
2. the exchanges are a trap for big exits, they won't let you take out huge wins

the more you look at all crypto the more you see big brother

sure when it's in a wallet you can't use it is anonymous

try to spend it, impossible so you sell it have big wallet in cash in exchange then you can't move much out

haha

so no one is really talking about what is the end game

all it did is trap you into the coin with no real hope of exiting mega millions even if you made them

now, they want to instantly collect on gains when you just move into a new coin

so forget about coinbase, they will soon be feeding the irs every account holders info

then bitcoin gains will pay off the debt

Re3urst
Newbie
*
Offline Offline

Activity: 45
Merit: 0


View Profile
December 27, 2017, 02:04:28 AM
 #7

The last sentence though Cheesy Cheesy, oh god can barely contain myself. Yeah I would argue that is the consensus among the community here although that seems to be short-sighted to me. People in the USA are going to get screwed more but there are a few places which you can avoid getting taxed double or even avoid altogether. In the end though you gotta realize 20% is much less than 40-50% which would be the normal rate given how much people are making so we should be happy to pay the little tax we have to.

The only thing I am unclear about: is it just the crypto that we cashed out into $$ that is taxable (on a cost-basis, capital gain) ? or is it every single crypto trade? I am leaning to just treat the former as taxable. It will certainly simplify the accounting greatly.
gentlemand
Legendary
*
Offline Offline

Activity: 2590
Merit: 3013


Welt Am Draht


View Profile
December 27, 2017, 02:09:09 AM
 #8

The only thing I am unclear about: is it just the crypto that we cashed out into $$ that is taxable (on a cost-basis, capital gain) ? or is it every single crypto trade? I am leaning to just treat the former as taxable. It will certainly simplify the accounting greatly.

It's every single crypto trade now. That's what's changed with this new law passing. Cashed out crypto was already taxed. Good luck if you have rampant bots. You'll need your own bot army to calculate the tax.
1bitcoinsnet (OP)
Member
**
Offline Offline

Activity: 84
Merit: 10


View Profile
December 27, 2017, 02:09:20 AM
 #9

I am definitely not a lawyer, but weren't we required to pay taxes on any bitcoin
capital gains anyway?  Can you break down what's new in this?  I'm sure whatever
IS new is going to be summarily ignored by the bitcoin using masses anyhow.

what changed was the like for like exemption

it's how mega millionaires avoided capital gains for decades

oh you got a nice 10 mil ocean front mansion, I got a picasso let's TRADE

well now 1031 is gone so the I got 1 mil in btc for 1 mil in eth is gone

you move 1 mil in btc into 1 mil in eth, the irs wants 20% NOW on the gains

so you got in btc at mining costs, gear and elect and time, you made maybe millions

you don't cash it out, but merely trade, and now that trade is taxable and you got no cash

all I can say is BINANCE

coinbase will now be crushed by this rule

it's one thing to pay on exit money, but when you have to pay gains on trades, no way

so I guess coinbase is okay to buy coin in, then you move to gdax then you move to binance or whatever and do the trades outside the usa

so now your gains is in china or korea or where ever

you do trades in gdax they are taxable

that's how I see it

you never do anything now on gdax

it will eventually end up with the irs

so the question becomes how do you exit out of the foreign exchanges into fiat

I think the centra card is nice exit to spend gains

but if you plan on using coinbase for exits or trades the irs has you big time

so coinbase will never go public now, 1031 killed the future of coinbase

Re3urst
Newbie
*
Offline Offline

Activity: 45
Merit: 0


View Profile
December 27, 2017, 02:09:35 AM
 #10

Sad day for traders

Tax code 1031 the like for like exemption that shielded traders is no more

Trump the moron killed it

Time to exit the USA

http://bitcoinist.com/cryptocurrency-investors-lose-tax-break/

As always, not a single reply.

I don't think anyone wants to even know anything about Bitcoin taxes. Just sitting there like an ostrish with your head in the sand, pretending that no one told you Bitcoin is taxable is most people's strategy.


They still think it's 'anonymous'

haha

try to cash out in an exchange

you got to give more id than you can imagine

then they limit you to a lousy 50K a week

so if you made a big hit, it would take years to withdraw

yet the irs wants taxes on it as soon as the exchange sells it

and the main exchanges know who you really are

so

1. it's not anonymous when you exit
2. the exchanges are a trap for big exits, they won't let you take out huge wins

the more you look at all crypto the more you see big brother

sure when it's in a wallet you can't use it is anonymous

try to spend it, impossible so you sell it have big wallet in cash in exchange then you can't move much out

haha

so no one is really talking about what is the end game

all it did is trap you into the coin with no real hope of exiting mega millions even if you made them

now, they want to instantly collect on gains when you just move into a new coin

so forget about coinbase, they will soon be feeding the irs every account holders info

then bitcoin gains will pay off the debt




Exactly! That is the big elephant in the room that no one wants to address.

Bitcoin and crypto is highly illiquid, highly unusable, and highly taxed. That is why I am only spending 0.25% of my net worth investing in crypto. Its not a viable asset for the reasons you mentioned. Also, Bitcoin and crypto produces NO INCOME.

I will continue to invest in real estate which have made me financially free at an early age, and pays me every month. Also, it had the best tax benefits out of any investment known.
gentlemand
Legendary
*
Offline Offline

Activity: 2590
Merit: 3013


Welt Am Draht


View Profile
December 27, 2017, 02:13:17 AM
 #11

you move 1 mil in btc into 1 mil in eth, the irs wants 20% NOW on the gains

Quite probably a very stupid question but where is the actual gain? Your initial dollar Bitcoin buy in versus the Bitcoin value at the time of the ETH swap? Is it all dollar denominated?
Re3urst
Newbie
*
Offline Offline

Activity: 45
Merit: 0


View Profile
December 27, 2017, 02:15:44 AM
 #12

I am definitely not a lawyer, but weren't we required to pay taxes on any bitcoin
capital gains anyway?  Can you break down what's new in this?  I'm sure whatever
IS new is going to be summarily ignored by the bitcoin using masses anyhow.

what changed was the like for like exemption

it's how mega millionaires avoided capital gains for decades

oh you got a nice 10 mil ocean front mansion, I got a picasso let's TRADE

well now 1031 is gone so the I got 1 mil in btc for 1 mil in eth is gone

you move 1 mil in btc into 1 mil in eth, the irs wants 20% NOW on the gains

so you got in btc at mining costs, gear and elect and time, you made maybe millions

you don't cash it out, but merely trade, and now that trade is taxable and you got no cash

all I can say is BINANCE

coinbase will now be crushed by this rule

it's one thing to pay on exit money, but when you have to pay gains on trades, no way

so I guess coinbase is okay to buy coin in, then you move to gdax then you move to binance or whatever and do the trades outside the usa

so now your gains is in china or korea or where ever

you do trades in gdax they are taxable

that's how I see it

you never do anything now on gdax

it will eventually end up with the irs

so the question becomes how do you exit out of the foreign exchanges into fiat

I think the centra card is nice exit to spend gains

but if you plan on using coinbase for exits or trades the irs has you big time

so coinbase will never go public now, 1031 killed the future of coinbase



Hey, do you mind if we catch more about this off of this forum? Shoot me a PM and lets get on an email (and maybe whatsapp) chat. Very interesting.
1bitcoinsnet (OP)
Member
**
Offline Offline

Activity: 84
Merit: 10


View Profile
December 27, 2017, 02:23:53 AM
 #13

you move 1 mil in btc into 1 mil in eth, the irs wants 20% NOW on the gains

Quite probably a very stupid question but where is the actual gain? Your initial dollar Bitcoin buy in versus the Bitcoin value at the time of the ETH swap? Is it all dollar denominated?

actually that was very bright, miners can claim not 'investment' since no buy, just work from assets

so their coin has no clear investment

but other than miners everyone else traded or bought with fiat

so you're a drug czar and traded coke for coin

how much did the coke cost

haha

oh, you bought 5 buck coin from mt gox and cold storaged it before the hacks

so you had very minor cost

but literally the irs is now saying as soon as btc moves from btc into anything pay them 20% on gain

so miners, how do you cost out your gain? good question, it could be the work is not an investment no cash or fiat to get it

so they could challenge first trade rule

but everyone else, how did you get your btc

you bought in on exchange you know the cost

you traded, well what did you trade for

so non fiat buys you can say you traded whatever and put huge value on it and low gains if any, you could take losses all day

I traded my 52 mint mantle worth 100k for 50k of coin, so I lost 50K so now the 90K I got is a 10K loss

so miners and real traders can play games

but if you took fiat into btc, they know the cost

and most with profits are in really cheap

but think what this does to traders

you have huge numbers in btc now with a few coins

you want to test eth and ltc or xrp

you do it after the end of this year, instantly the trade is taxable

so don't use gdax and coinbase or winkies gemini or the vegas exchange

this law just pushed crypto exchanges all outside the usa

in a year or two you won't have one usa based exchange due to this

great move donald you just killed off any hope of the usa having crypto exchanges

the game now is trading btc into ico's and taking some profits to the moon with new ico's

you want to hodl btc forever, okay, good luck, the next 3 years is all ico plays

and the hope of coinbase being a legit ipo is over

1031 has killed any usa based exchange

so if you got coins and cash MOVE IT NOW

coinbase will have problems soon paying people

as it is they limit accounts to a lousy 50k fiat exit a week, expect it to go down to 5k now

haha

anyway, that is what the end of 1031 means, it means usa exchanges can no longer compete with foreign exchanges

if you are a us citizen and want to pay gains on the btc you got cheap, go ahead, sure exit into fiat is fair 20%

but when you're talking about moving into other coins, that's just wrong

Reid
Hero Member
*****
Offline Offline

Activity: 2898
Merit: 642


View Profile
December 27, 2017, 02:25:50 AM
 #14

So it is full of coinbase.
In the end, it is like you just want coinbase to stand their ground but they cannot.

You really need to look for another option instead of all just Coinbase. Hell I am not using that service anymore. The lack of support for other countries tells it all. It is like they are just specialize for one group or just their own.
1bitcoinsnet (OP)
Member
**
Offline Offline

Activity: 84
Merit: 10


View Profile
December 27, 2017, 02:27:31 AM
 #15

I am definitely not a lawyer, but weren't we required to pay taxes on any bitcoin
capital gains anyway?  Can you break down what's new in this?  I'm sure whatever
IS new is going to be summarily ignored by the bitcoin using masses anyhow.

what changed was the like for like exemption

it's how mega millionaires avoided capital gains for decades

oh you got a nice 10 mil ocean front mansion, I got a picasso let's TRADE

well now 1031 is gone so the I got 1 mil in btc for 1 mil in eth is gone

you move 1 mil in btc into 1 mil in eth, the irs wants 20% NOW on the gains

so you got in btc at mining costs, gear and elect and time, you made maybe millions

you don't cash it out, but merely trade, and now that trade is taxable and you got no cash

all I can say is BINANCE

coinbase will now be crushed by this rule

it's one thing to pay on exit money, but when you have to pay gains on trades, no way

so I guess coinbase is okay to buy coin in, then you move to gdax then you move to binance or whatever and do the trades outside the usa

so now your gains is in china or korea or where ever

you do trades in gdax they are taxable

that's how I see it

you never do anything now on gdax

it will eventually end up with the irs

so the question becomes how do you exit out of the foreign exchanges into fiat

I think the centra card is nice exit to spend gains

but if you plan on using coinbase for exits or trades the irs has you big time

so coinbase will never go public now, 1031 killed the future of coinbase



Hey, do you mind if we catch more about this off of this forum? Shoot me a PM and lets get on an email (and maybe whatsapp) chat. Very interesting.

sorry brother got no free time

and I sure don't want to brag about my crazy rates for 15 min consults

I say my mind here, so read it a few times

I yell at my girl friends when they call me, I multi task all day coding, designing and investing

had a little time over holidays but I don't chat for free, sorry

1bitcoinsnet (OP)
Member
**
Offline Offline

Activity: 84
Merit: 10


View Profile
December 27, 2017, 02:30:50 AM
 #16

So it is full of coinbase.
In the end, it is like you just want coinbase to stand their ground but they cannot.

You really need to look for another option instead of all just Coinbase. Hell I am not using that service anymore. The lack of support for other countries tells it all. It is alike they are just specialize for one group or just their own.

this tax cut killed every usa exchange
 no one with huge wallets will ever move them into gdax now and trade, and why would they at .25% when you can do it at 1% or .05% all day in asia and europe

I can see cayman exchanges now being the only place to trade crypto

no relationship with usa caymans

so cayman crypto exchanges are the future, anyone know of one

I play at a caymans crypto casino now

but now I want a caymans exchange to trade in

the usa really blew their future with crypto with this

they will be left out of the loop

crypto will now be asia and europe and rest of world, usa will stay fiat slaves




PointHope
Full Member
***
Offline Offline

Activity: 317
Merit: 110


View Profile
December 27, 2017, 02:31:55 AM
 #17

People will quit using cash now that a true global p2p system is distributed around the planet.
Screw the government oppression and their wars.
We now have the tools for true liberty; crypto currencies!
1bitcoinsnet (OP)
Member
**
Offline Offline

Activity: 84
Merit: 10


View Profile
December 27, 2017, 02:33:25 AM
 #18

People will quit using cash now that a true global p2p system is distributed around the planet.
Screw the government oppression and their wars.
We now have the tools for true liberty; crypto currencies!

just keep your crypto far away from usa based exchanges

irs wants instant tax on any trades
player514
Legendary
*
Offline Offline

Activity: 1414
Merit: 1039


View Profile
December 27, 2017, 02:36:05 AM
 #19

Sad day for traders

Tax code 1031 the like for like exemption that shielded traders is no more

Trump the moron killed it

Time to exit the USA

http://bitcoinist.com/cryptocurrency-investors-lose-tax-break/

As always, not a single reply.

I don't think anyone wants to even know anything about Bitcoin taxes. Just sitting there like an ostrish with your head in the sand, pretending that no one told you Bitcoin is taxable is most people's strategy.


They still think it's 'anonymous'

haha

try to cash out in an exchange

you got to give more id than you can imagine

then they limit you to a lousy 50K a week

so if you made a big hit, it would take years to withdraw

yet the irs wants taxes on it as soon as the exchange sells it

and the main exchanges know who you really are

so

1. it's not anonymous when you exit
2. the exchanges are a trap for big exits, they won't let you take out huge wins

the more you look at all crypto the more you see big brother

sure when it's in a wallet you can't use it is anonymous

try to spend it, impossible so you sell it have big wallet in cash in exchange then you can't move much out

haha

so no one is really talking about what is the end game

all it did is trap you into the coin with no real hope of exiting mega millions even if you made them

now, they want to instantly collect on gains when you just move into a new coin

so forget about coinbase, they will soon be feeding the irs every account holders info

then bitcoin gains will pay off the debt



There are ways to cash out smaller amounts without even having to go through an exchange. You can do peer to peer transactions and even then, you can actually use bitcoin as a currency. You're looking at the coin as if it were just an investment, not also a currency. If more services start accepting bitcoin, not only will the price change, but that holding of bitcoin that you have will be a more than valid form of payment. Also, you can just transact peer to peer and avoid any exchanges at all. That's one way to keep it anonymous.

This area is up for grabs! PM me if you're interested.
PointHope
Full Member
***
Offline Offline

Activity: 317
Merit: 110


View Profile
December 27, 2017, 02:38:54 AM
 #20

People will quit using cash now that a true global p2p system is distributed around the planet.
Screw the government oppression and their wars.
We now have the tools for true liberty; crypto currencies!

just keep your crypto far away from usa based exchanges

irs wants instant tax on any trades

I would reckon the USA based exchanges will simply move outside the USA. Bitcoin and crypto don't recognize borders.

Perhaps a new country called planet earth
Pages: [1] 2 3 »  All
  Print  
 
Jump to:  

Powered by MySQL Powered by PHP Powered by SMF 1.1.19 | SMF © 2006-2009, Simple Machines Valid XHTML 1.0! Valid CSS!