🌙🌙🌙 Moonlite Signature Campaign 🌙 🌙🌙 [MEMBERS+]

[Bolt Brownie]

Hello aTriz, I will rank to Hero member on next Tuesday. How do things normally work with you?
Should I inform you when the change happens, and then you will update the info on the spreadsheet if a spot is available?

I will also change to a segwit address, I just need to update my wallet, I should do it during this weekend and in time for next payment.

[1715208480]

1715208480

[1715208480]

1715208480

[1715208480]

1715208480

[1715208480]

1715208480

[Unicorn_Heart]

Bitcoin Talk Name: Unicorn_Heart
Bitcoin Talk Profile: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=profile;u=1231811;sa=summary
Rank:  Member
Post Count (including this post): 66
BTC Address: 35EKfn21TgoUUhWftzf66Wn2EH1cJJQGCn
ETH Address: None

Hi, Manager,

Hope you will consider my application please.

Thank you so much!

[krishnaverma]

Bitcoin Talk Name: krishnaverma
Bitcoin Talk Profile: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=profile;u=1341921
Rank: Member
Post Count : 62
BTC Address: 34Hkz3LMrmjwSkxJwYHWUby4okJgCb6JGD
ETH Address: 0xfb2f50845ca46663dd80cf55bd2cedbc7e32f1b9

Have updated the signature and personal message.

Edit: Taking my name back from this campaign.

[donovank]

Bitcoin Talk Name: donovank
Bitcoin Talk Profile: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=profile;u=1338913
Rank: Member
Post Count (including this post): 76
BTC Address: 1JK4eGgEudpsFpxZn3JZCsL4stU1yajCX4
ETH Address: 0x4D3abF769B0Ed6f00fdc6A395CBA7e52E3e01806

[Kprawn]

Payment made - https://www.blocktrail.com/BTC/tx/3d1ca085a97224519f38297c0320e5cc466d7d5fb42abbf80f85b17088dc9589

Thanks to the people who moved to segwit. Around 50 percent of the campaign is now segwit. You have 2 more weeks to get segwit addresses.

New enrollments will be announced in 1 hr

Just a couple of questions :

1. People are saying not to use P2SH-P2WPKH addresses (the ones that start with 3) but to use bech32 native Segwit addresses starting bc1.

2. You can't sign messages with Segwit addresses that was created with Green Address or Greenbits because they are multisig addresses? {This might create problems in the future, when you need to sign a message}

3. People cannot check bech32 addresses over blockchain.info's explorer, they will have to switch to btc.com explorer. {Some people might use Blockchain.info and think that they were not paid, which would lead to frustration for campaign managers.}

4. Most common exchanges did not implement SegWit. {cashout problems?}

So what do we use? P2SH-P2WPKH addresses ? / bech32 addresses / Multisig addresses?

I think someone should provide a manual or guide to newbies to create the appropriate SegWit addresses to reduce frustration

and confusion and possibly confrontation, if something might go wrong in the future.  

[Bolt Brownie]

I completely agree with you, and I also have a few questions, now that I was about to upgrade to a segwit address myself. It seems that electrum, that is the wallet I use, uses native segwit address (the bech32). From what I've read this is the best solution, since it's more efficient in memory use, but by using these addresses you will not be able to receive bitcoin from a normal address, and right now, they seem to be the only wallet actually using the native format (ledger and trezor for example, are using the P2SH-P2WPKH addresses).

I'm not sure if this is true or not, since I haven't tested yet, but this makes the decision to upgrade to segwit "harder". We normally keep going from one campaign to the other, and a lot of users on this one, will upgrade to segwit, so we should be aware that if we choose to use the bech32 format, we might not be able to use those address if we join another campaign that doesn't pay using segwit.

Anyone has any information on this?

Edit: aTriz I will delete this post if you want to, since it's not directed related to the campaign. But since most of the users here will upgrade to segwit, I though this would be a good place to "collect some information" about this matter.

[aTriz]

1. People are saying not to use P2SH-P2WPKH addresses (the ones that start with 3) but to use bech32 native Segwit addresses starting bc1.

Hmhm, I don't really see a question here.

2. You can't sign messages with Segwit addresses that was created with Green Address or Greenbits because they are multisig addresses? {This might create problems in the future, when you need to sign a message}

This might be an issue, especially if the user has changed email/password and it might look like a hacked account. This is why I would recommend using a ledger or a bech32 address (which you can sign messages with)

3. People cannot check bech32 addresses over blockchain.info's explorer, they will have to switch to btc.com explorer. {Some people might use Blockchain.info and think that they were not paid, which would lead to frustration for campaign managers.}

Not sure if this will an issue, people can just open their wallets and see an incoming transaction.

4. Most common exchanges did not implement SegWit. {cashout problems?}

Maybe. Not sure what to do with this.

So what do we use? P2SH-P2WPKH addresses ? / bech32 addresses / Multisig addresses?

Any of them is fine, but bech32 address and ledger wallets are recommended. Mostly for signing messages.

[crypto4lambo]

Please do consider my application. Thanks.

Bitcoin Talk Name: crypto4lambo
Bitcoin Talk Profile: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=profile;u=1123197
Rank: full member
Post Count (including this post):324
BTC Address: 39A7YirXANCsqMWUPPypus26oVEu6NbAWN
ETH Address: 0xD10a9c35F4eE85002DcF8D8CB2517b62A799a416

[jonsi]

Bitcoin Talk Name: jonsi
Bitcoin Talk Profile: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=profile;u=104461
Rank: Legendary
Post Count (including this post): 1252
BTC Address: 15Y5gbHLCZ51aCbCPyKr52QGt9kDMs3rwd
ETH Address: 0xC0011fB63624adB370955Ff0c3B8c1DBf18243FC

Signature, personal message and avatar have been changed.

Thank you for considering my application.

Kind regards,
jonsi.

[BitcoinTurk]

Bitcoin Talk Name: BitcoinTurk
Bitcoin Talk Profile: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=profile;u=511692
Rank: Full Member
Post Count (including this post): 593
BTC Address: 1NkL64QN1SrYgamLZL9QKA6URWS695qQ5w
ETH Address: Updated today.

[lvsca]

Bitcoin Talk Name: lvsca
Bitcoin Talk Profile: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=profile;u=721731
Rank: Sr. Member
Post Count (including this post): 826
BTC Address: 1FuygLsN8KYD8cJtD1JVNYJWu1csbWXCP6
ETH Address: 0x45F625d1B4eaED944Ab2af1D95D5fF1601a8199F

[Welsh]

Bitcoin Talk Name: Welsh
Bitcoin Talk Profile: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=profile;u=84521
Rank: Legendary
Post Count (including this post): 3064
BTC Address: 12NfYxGMCKt4KtjucqHfjQ1KZj5sMU1qUt
ETH Address: 0xf17f7eEeE810116D1E1f349e2eab2eE1B63228B0

[aTriz]

Hello aTriz, I will rank to Hero member on next Tuesday. How do things normally work with you?
Should I inform you when the change happens, and then you will update the info on the spreadsheet if a spot is available?

I will also change to a segwit address, I just need to update my wallet, I should do it during this weekend and in time for next payment.

Sorry didn't see this post, I'll upgrade you if there are available slots (which is looking like it)

Bitcoin Talk Name: Welsh
Bitcoin Talk Profile: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=profile;u=84521
Rank: Legendary
Post Count (including this post): 3064
BTC Address: 12NfYxGMCKt4KtjucqHfjQ1KZj5sMU1qUt
ETH Address: 0xf17f7eEeE810116D1E1f349e2eab2eE1B63228B0

Accepted, rest all denied

[lvsca]

Bitcoin Talk Name: lvsca
Bitcoin Talk Profile: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=profile;u=721731
Rank: Sr. Member
Post Count (including this post): 826
BTC Address: 1FuygLsN8KYD8cJtD1JVNYJWu1csbWXCP6
ETH Address: 0x45F625d1B4eaED944Ab2af1D95D5fF1601a8199F

withdrawing application, thanks for answer, sir.

[Direwolve735]

Bitcoin Talk Name: Direwolve735
Bitcoin Talk Profile: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=profile
Rank: Full Member
Post Count (including this post): 292
BTC Address: 1JPstrsPDUKj1cfCxTm3Fwbg1y8L11SNqM
ETH Address: 0x5750257D9052B2554afff750C78A05A33e4B711a

Hope to participate in your campaign!

[degraff]

Bitcoin Talk Name: degraff
Bitcoin Talk Profile: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=profile;u=1216085;sa=showPosts
Rank: member
Post Count (including this post): 89
BTC Address: 1PCy6QHY35YVpqax57pASnVQshhG3FfSZo
ETH Address:  0xbd48dE8BE4280674386Af57f274302aF7559f40d

Please consider my application for Moonlite Signature Campaign. Thank you!

[niceone]

Bitcointalk name: Niceone
Bitcointalk Profile:https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=profile
Rank: Member
Post Count (including this post): 78+1
BTC address: 3Gsn5d2PffDdkLhpRCncswzkzHphftF7tF
ETH Address:
0xe82aa70667e46BcCE4EeB2469070B2fc005Bfa8F

Good Day to you Sir a Triz, I see you still have some slot in your campaign i hope you consider me to be a part of your campaign sir. Thank You for your Consideration sir, You'll not gonna regret if you accept me. Thanks again

[Koger]

Bitcoin Talk Name: Koger
Bitcoin Talk Profile: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=profile;u=201896
Rank: Member
Post Count (including this post): 65
BTC Address: 1BQvugugGKiZT913hmJNH33BE24H3TinX4 bc1qhp24ppncyu2rytr63mwrwdp2yryrva78cv4qnw (migrated to segwit)
ETH Address: 0x694bB47D1f305Fffe3c8cFEb385070E57c41B0BF

[Bonsaiav]

Sir, because there is an upgrade process done by my online wallet service provider, on January 26, 2018.
My bitcoin address has changed to a new bitcoin address that supports segwit.

Here's my new bitcoin address, sir..
3HUqrKr3b8THPoPxgeNEQLmSaqer7BVi1R

Sorry
if maybe my message has interrupted your activity
thank you, sir.

[Bugoy.koykoy]

Bitcoin Talk Name: Bugoy.koykoy
Bitcoin Talk Profile: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=profile;u=1280902;sa=summary
Rank: member
Post Count (including this post): 88
BTC Address: 3GYdcyNycy922cGE1etppXTPotHwfhDUXL
ETH Address: n/a