<snip>
{/quote}
Fantastic post!!! THIS is productive. Again, I am new to the crypto currency world...but my education and trading experience in other tradable markets goes back nearly 20 years. So, yes I am a 'newbie' on here...but I am confident my experience can be of some minimal value as ideas get bounced around.
Back to the topic...seeing that I am new to cryptos... can you help me understand why you feel there is no value in crypto world versus any other value that tool may (or may not) have in other asset classes, like FOREX? Because, when I am looking at a market cap..the information i am seeking is EXACTLY how you classified it: simply a rough idea of an assets 'value' at any given snapshot in time. Why would the value of knowing that information be different for a coin versus a currency or stock or whatever?
The more research i do, the more and more i realize the crypto trading world (and just in general) is much different than other markets. I am finding there are many different things to take into consideration as i start to put some small money at work here...especially in very short term scalping trades. granted, these coins may not have revenues like GOOG or whatever...but still...the price of the coin is still its perceived value at any given moment in time. In that sense...why is it any different than any other asset class? All the formalities and technical stuff aside...should a short term trader care how its fundamentally different than a stock or futures trading?
(and just for full disclosure for whatever its worth..i own small amounts of BTC and ETH as well as a scalping position in BNB/USDT hoping for decent bounce off upward trending support line on 6hr chart)
What I mean when I say that a market cap is a rough snapshot is that it just shows the total sum of potential value, not realized value, if the entire asset was to have all of its tokens liquidated at the current market price. It doesn't help when we have such a large variety of coins which each have their own uses, supplies, and rules to govern each of them individually.
The big difference as to why market cap for stocks is a decent metric for guesstimating and not for crypto relates to what I just said; cryptos have variety in their rules and concepts, stocks do not.
A stock with a small market cap but operating as a productive company and bringing in a revenue an x% the size of a large company could comparatively have a market cap in a 2-4% range of the larger one, and then if it is under it could be seen as undervalued and if it is over it would be overvalued, so on and so forth. Same goes for comparing individual stock prices.
Market cap is also great for companies since it helps investors see just how much money is embedded within a certain company, consequently how much their own money impacts the stock and how much investment potential may exist.
None of what I have said in my last two paragraphs has any sort of relationship when it comes to crypto. That is why market cap is a bad metric of measurement for cryptos; because it was made for something completely different which could be used as overall comparisons and numbers for a bigger game. Crypto doesn't have ANY of those same traits or comparisons.
I have included a link below, in plain text with some address portions spaced apart so you can read it and it doesn't get blocked, which demonstrates why market cap has more value in stocks, and I hope you can extrapolate why it is less effective for crypto.
https://www. fidelity .com/learning-center/trading-investing/fundamental-analysis/understanding-market-capitalization
This is also the longest post I have written in a long time so thanks for that, it's not often I really get to grind into something and talk about it on here.