People are always going to moan. Moan that theymos doesn't do anything and then when he does moan at that but wont ever offer any solutions themselves. People will make the same arguments against this system that they do with the feedback system but no merit or feedback system will ever be perfect but this new one is meant to reward quality contributions whilst defacto punishing poor ones as they'll never get anywhere now.
This is a huge centralization risk to a decentralized Bitcoin forum.
Who told you this forum was decentralised? It's not. It's the opposite.