Recalescence Coins Raffle! [CLOSED] [WINNER WINGSUIT!]

[Hexadecibel]

CLOSED



Thank you everyone who participated!

Drawing Starts September 22 8pm PST Via U STREAM, at which point the winner will be chosen at random from the ticket holding device.

This post will be updated to provide the link.

Ustream link:
http://www.ustream.tv/channel/recalescencecoins

list of raffle entrants:
https://docs.google.com/file/d/0B7sLcZ4VNET7dmIwQ2tuUWJHX1E/edit?usp=sharing

wingsuit, Please PM me with your shipping information! Congratulations!

For those of you who missed the drawing:

http://www.ustream.tv/recorded/39149617

[1715421942]

1715421942

[1715421942]

1715421942

[danieldaniel]

I bought 3!

[Hexadecibel]

I bought 3!

Odds are in your favor so far 

https://blockchain.info/address/1L1bA6R4rEBwHEwBMo61JitLt2Q8pvtYr8

[Boelens]

How do I include a note?

[sinner]

would rather see 1 BTC than 1000 mBTC.. if you're trying to distinguish yourself from Casascius, maybe make smaller denomination coins where it would make sense to list in mBTC... like 25 mBTC is better than .025 BTC

[Hexadecibel]

would rather see 1 BTC than 1000 mBTC.. if you're trying to distinguish yourself from Casascius, maybe make smaller denomination coins where it would make sense to list in mBTC... like 25 mBTC is better than .025 BTC

The art distinguishes me from Casascius, mBTC just makes more sense to me at Bitcoins current value.

Smaller denominations are forthcoming 2014 though

[Hexadecibel]

How do I include a note?

If you use the blockchain.info wallet, there is a field to include a public note while sending btc,

I'm... not sure how to do it in the bitcoin-qt client...

what client do you use?

[willphase]

public notes are blockchain.info specific and cannot be added/viewed outside the blockchain.info client since they are not a part of the bitcoin protocol.

might be better to let the raffle to just take place, post the transaction, then the person who sent the winning transaction sign a message from one of the txin bitcoin addresses to prove that they entered the raffle and sent that tx.

Will

[Boelens]

How do I include a note?

If you use the blockchain.info wallet, there is a field to include a public note while sending btc,

I'm... not sure how to do it in the bitcoin-qt client...

what client do you use?

I use Qt. I've never used blockchain before, can I just give you the TX ID?

[Hexadecibel]

public notes are blockchain.info specific and cannot be added/viewed outside the blockchain.info client since they are not a part of the bitcoin protocol.

might be better to let the raffle to just take place, post the transaction, then the person who sent the winning transaction sign a message from one of the txin bitcoin addresses to prove that they entered the raffle and sent that tx.

Will

I'd like keep it as simple as possible... for me. 

I'm literally putting names in a hat!

I think considering the fact that making a blockchain.info wallet is free and easy,  I'll just update the OP to reflect that blockchain.info wallet must be used to add a note.

But buggers, I figured adding a note was a QT feature as well...

Cheers

[Luke-Jr]

The only way to know who sent a transaction is to create a unique address for it.
If you use blockchain.info messages, you are trusting a centralised entity to tell you, and forcing your customers to use a centralised wallet.
The "sign message" feature only supports signing with addresses (ie, proving you can receive), there is no current way to sign as a sender of a transaction.
Bitcoin-Qt 0.9 will be adding support for the payment protocol to make this kind of thing simpler.

[Luke-Jr]

Also, please note that importing private keys is generally dangerous.
If your wallet doesn't support the "sweep private key" feature (Bitcoin-Qt does not!), I suggest using a throwaway wallet and sending the full balance to your real one when done.

[Hexadecibel]

How do I include a note?

If you use the blockchain.info wallet, there is a field to include a public note while sending btc,

I'm... not sure how to do it in the bitcoin-qt client...

what client do you use?

I use Qt. I've never used blockchain before, can I just give you the TX ID?

I'd like to keep things consistent. But fortunately making a blockchain.info wallet is easy

I really didn't intend on forcing people to use blockchain.info, but I assumed adding a public note to a transaction was a multi-client feature. Well guess whose an ass now. This guy.

sorry.

[Hexadecibel]

The only way to know who sent a transaction is to create a unique address for it.
If you use blockchain.info messages, you are trusting a centralised entity to tell you, and forcing your customers to use a centralised wallet.
The "sign message" feature only supports signing with addresses (ie, proving you can receive), there is no current way to sign as a sender of a transaction.
Bitcoin-Qt 0.9 will be adding support for the payment protocol to make this kind of thing simpler.

Well.. I don't fundamentally disagree with you, but a few things:

1, the address they're sending money to for the Electronic Frontier Foundation donation is a paper wallet generated offline.

2, I don't think they're technically my customers... contestants maybe?

3, blockchain.info does support sweeping private keys, but I think the sweeping of private keys was in referecnce to the destination address, which I already said was a paper wallet that was generated offline. But I have been drinking so I could be wrong.

4, I like blockchian.info...

5, I love you damn developers and all your coding hobnobery! cant wait for 0.9.
  ... and about 0.9... I went through a lot of freaking effort incorporating pgp signed addresses in my site. Is 0.9 pretty much going to nuke that effort?

[willphase]

public notes are blockchain.info specific and cannot be added/viewed outside the blockchain.info client since they are not a part of the bitcoin protocol.

might be better to let the raffle to just take place, post the transaction, then the person who sent the winning transaction sign a message from one of the txin bitcoin addresses to prove that they entered the raffle and sent that tx.

Will

I'd like keep it as simple as possible... for me. 

my suggestion is simple for you.  All you have to do is wait until the raffle period ends, then go through and count all the payments to the raffle address and put them into a spreadsheet weighted by the amount they paid, then pick one at random, look up the tx, find the source bitcoin address, then post it here and ask that the winner comes forward with a signed message...

Will

[Hexadecibel]

public notes are blockchain.info specific and cannot be added/viewed outside the blockchain.info client since they are not a part of the bitcoin protocol.

might be better to let the raffle to just take place, post the transaction, then the person who sent the winning transaction sign a message from one of the txin bitcoin addresses to prove that they entered the raffle and sent that tx.

Will

I'd like keep it as simple as possible... for me.  

my suggestion is simple for you.  All you have to do is wait until the raffle period ends, then go through and count all the payments to the raffle address and put them into a spreadsheet weighted by the amount they paid, then pick one at random, look up the tx, find the source bitcoin address, then post it here and ask that the winner comes forward with a signed message...

Will

Your suggestion is not a bad one, but I'm already committed to the current scheme. I like the idea of pulling forum handles out of a hat.

So basically, instead of having people do the extra work required to make a signed message, I'm requiring people to do the extra work to make a blockchian.info wallet (if they don't already have one).

*shrug*

[Luke-Jr]

1, the address they're sending money to for the Electronic Frontier Foundation donation is a paper wallet generated offline.

2, I don't think they're technically my customers... contestants maybe?

Ok, fair point. Hopefully the EFF will use a proper paper wallet at some point instead of address reuse

3, blockchain.info does support sweeping private keys, but I think the sweeping of private keys was in referecnce to the destination address, which I already said was a paper wallet that was generated offline. But I have been drinking so I could be wrong.

I meant in reference to redeeming the coins themselves.

5, I love you damn developers and all your coding hobnobery! cant wait for 0.9.
  ... and about 0.9... I went through a lot of freaking effort incorporating pgp signed addresses in my site. Is 0.9 pretty much going to nuke that effort?

Well, sending to addresses will still work of course.
Unfortunately, the only user-accessible solution is to rely on CA-based SSL instead though.

[tiberiandusk]

Will be entering as soon as my coins get into a blockchain.info wallet. The EFF are good people.

Edit:

Entered.

[Boelens]

Bought 5 tickets.

[Mitchell]

Shit. I thought Electrum supported note message's...
TX: 8759e1dd1b201a5b80e73e2abdfa55e22a4a2bfdea9c1080ba4625a1c3487987
Address: 1ESKhXAnw8MuEus52DsC4Hp9UcaDBN9Xjk

I can sign with the address if needed. I bought 5 tickets.

[Hexadecibel]

Shit. I thought Electrum supported note message's...
TX: 8759e1dd1b201a5b80e73e2abdfa55e22a4a2bfdea9c1080ba4625a1c3487987
Address: 1ESKhXAnw8MuEus52DsC4Hp9UcaDBN9Xjk

I can sign with the address if needed. I bought 5 tickets.

I'll refund your purchase out of my own pocket, and you can submit a new transaction with a public note included this time

Give me an address you would like to receive the refund with.

[Mitchell]

Shit. I thought Electrum supported note message's...
TX: 8759e1dd1b201a5b80e73e2abdfa55e22a4a2bfdea9c1080ba4625a1c3487987
Address: 1ESKhXAnw8MuEus52DsC4Hp9UcaDBN9Xjk

I can sign with the address if needed. I bought 5 tickets.

I'll refund your purchase out of my own pocket, and you can submit a new transaction with a public note included this time

Give me an address you would like to receive the refund with.

Give me a second to create a blockchain address ;p

[Mitchell]

Please send it to this address: 1JwxVSwvrPELhbkR9KU88UfnQxnunat1x2

[Hexadecibel]

Please send it to this address: 1JwxVSwvrPELhbkR9KU88UfnQxnunat1x2

BTC sent!

https://blockchain.info/tx/f29002f2e0ecec864a9985bc97678b5996ca92448f1688f6092418bcc69960e1

[Mitchell]

Send it again this time with a note:
TX: 9e1bef0602c46359af2218e964328a5144b499a8f8e92349f8d3ab26c556481e
Address: 1JwxVSwvrPELhbkR9KU88UfnQxnunat1x2

[rafsoaken]

Enjoy two high resolution images from the front and backside of the coin (#66 is mine ).
Full resolution images:
https://i.imgur.com/gSZBIj9.jpg
https://i.imgur.com/v5HRWBh.jpg



Edit: Images are freely reusable under the MIT license,
concerning the coin itself (quoted from https://recalescencecoins.com/terms/)
>>All artworks, writings, and content (unless otherwise noted) are copyright Recalesence coins, LLC. Distribution allowed for non commercial use.<<

[danieldaniel]

DAMNNNNNNNN

[wingsuit]

Awesome thanks, tickets have been bought 

[rafsoaken]

I'm in with 5 tickets!

[Boelens]

Sweeet jesus those are some HQ pictures. I better win this!

[Hexadecibel]

Sweeet jesus those are some HQ pictures. I better win this!

Even if you do not, this is BTC towards a worthy organization

1000 mBTC so far to the EFF!

[danieldaniel]

I want to buy more, but I really shouldn't gamble. 

[Mitchell]

I want to buy more, but I really shouldn't gamble. 

Story of my life. 

[Hexadecibel]

I want to buy more, but I really shouldn't gamble. 

I can't help but notice that you are advertising a gambling site in your sig...

[danieldaniel]

I want to buy more, but I really shouldn't gamble. 

I can't help but notice that you are advertising a gambling site in your sig...

I get paid for it!

[Mitchell]

Send it again this time with a note:
TX: 9e1bef0602c46359af2218e964328a5144b499a8f8e92349f8d3ab26c556481e
Address: 1JwxVSwvrPELhbkR9KU88UfnQxnunat1x2

If my crappy transaction doesn't get confirmed before 20-9, then I will send a new one.

[fishy]

How did you make these?  They are looking great!

[Hexadecibel]

How did you make these?  They are looking great!

Thank you 

These coins are a collabrative effort between myself and a multitude of artists, mints, and developers. The short answer is made this happen with about 250 BTC, determination, and pretty much all of my spare time since April...

[danieldaniel]

How did you make these?  They are looking great!

Thank you 

These coins are a collabrative effort between myself and a multitude of artists, mints, and developers. The short answer is made this happen with about 250 BTC, determination, and pretty much all of my spare time since April...

Can you give me a raffle discount if I want to buy one? 

[Hexadecibel]

How did you make these?  They are looking great!

Thank you 

These coins are a collabrative effort between myself and a multitude of artists, mints, and developers. The short answer is made this happen with about 250 BTC, determination, and pretty much all of my spare time since April...

Can you give me a raffle discount if I want to buy one? 

I was actually mulling over adding some flare to the backs to the certificates for those who participated in the raffle, should they make a purchase. I might find some time later this week to fully flesh that out, since the flare should be not so specific as to make no sense should you re-sell the coin.

The raffle winner will definetly get some flare, along with my signature on the cert.

Were working on code to implement more flexible pricing, discounts will be part of that in the next revamp of the site. For instance, customers could enter a promotion code "raffle" and receive a 10% discount.

So I guess your answer is no, not because I don't want to, but because we don't have a practical way of doing so with the way the site currently works.

[danieldaniel]

How did you make these?  They are looking great!

Thank you 

These coins are a collabrative effort between myself and a multitude of artists, mints, and developers. The short answer is made this happen with about 250 BTC, determination, and pretty much all of my spare time since April...

Can you give me a raffle discount if I want to buy one? 

I was actually mulling over adding some flare to the backs to the certificates for those who participated in the raffle, should they make a purchase. I might find some time later this week to fully flesh that out, since the flare should be not so specific as to make no sense should you re-sell the coin.

The raffle winner will definetly get some flare, along with my signature on the cert.

Were working on code to implement more flexible pricing, discounts will be part of that in the next revamp of the site. For instance, customers could enter a promotion code "raffle" and receive a 10% discount.

So I guess your answer is no, not because I don't want to, but because we don't have a practical way of doing so with the way the site currently works.

You can always manually send me 10% back! 

[Hexadecibel]

Send it again this time with a note:
TX: 9e1bef0602c46359af2218e964328a5144b499a8f8e92349f8d3ab26c556481e
Address: 1JwxVSwvrPELhbkR9KU88UfnQxnunat1x2

If my crappy transaction doesn't get confirmed before 20-9, then I will send a new one.

heh, yeah I see that

Include a fee guys! 

[Baitty]

How many have been sold in total now?

[danieldaniel]

How many have been sold in total now?

100, exactly.  If more don't get sold, I'm gonna buy some on the 21st.

[Hexadecibel]

Here's a bump with some t-shirt design concept art.



©Recalescence Coins, LLC

[danieldaniel]

(not so subtly disguised spam-bump above) <3

[Mitchell]

Send it again this time with a note:
TX: 9e1bef0602c46359af2218e964328a5144b499a8f8e92349f8d3ab26c556481e
Address: 1JwxVSwvrPELhbkR9KU88UfnQxnunat1x2

If my crappy transaction doesn't get confirmed before 20-9, then I will send a new one.

heh, yeah I see that

Include a fee guys!  

Well I just send it using the normal blockchain form, thinking that it would include fee's. Nope.

[Rez]

Okay, so I set up a Blockchain wallet and transferred BTC.0606 for tickets.  

First time using blockchain.info - I'm a cold storage/Armory kind of guy.

I couldn't find a place on the Android wallet or the website to include a public notice along with the transaction.  I probably sound incredibly noobish right now, but where do you enter the public notice?

Edit: HURRRRRRR.  Found it. 

[rafsoaken]

Okay, so I set up a Blockchain wallet and transferred BTC.0606 for tickets.  

First time using blockchain.info - I'm a cold storage/Armory kind of guy.

I couldn't find a place on the Android wallet or the website to include a public notice along with the transaction.  I probably sound incredibly noobish right now, but where do you enter the public notice?

On the blockchain.info website, login to your wallet, go to "Send money", then choose transaction type "Custom" (box to the left), then you have to option to add a "public note".
Edit: Also there you can add miners fees to the transaction. The quick send does not seem to include any.

[Rez]

Thanks!  Also on the Android wallet, once the transaction is confirmed, you're given the option to enter a note when you look at the Transaction Details for that payment.  

EDIT: Or not. Why does the note in my transaction say "fydv"?

https://www.dropbox.com/s/t3btjlewxvo53ih/Screenshot_2013-09-20-10-12-20.png

https://www.dropbox.com/s/y2125p68jgmozpt/Screenshot_2013-09-20-10-17-27.png

[Hexadecibel]

Thanks!  Also on the Android wallet, once the transaction is confirmed, you're given the option to enter a note when you look at the Transaction Details for that payment.  

EDIT: Or not. Why does the note in my transaction say "fydv"?

https://www.dropbox.com/s/t3btjlewxvo53ih/Screenshot_2013-09-20-10-12-20.png

https://www.dropbox.com/s/y2125p68jgmozpt/Screenshot_2013-09-20-10-17-27.png

fydv was the previous transaction. Looks like you didn't include a note...

[Rez]

Ugh.

Consider it a donation, then.  It's fine.

[Hexadecibel]

Ugh.

Consider it a donation, then.  It's fine.

Nah, I'll refund you out of my pocket. give me an address to send your BTC back to, then you can resubmit with a note.

[Rez]

Nah! It's good! I'll try again when I'm home.

I was trying to do it all on my tablet since blockchain.info is blocked by the web filter in the office. ;-)  Just frustrated with myself!

[Hexadecibel]

Nah! It's good! I'll try again when I'm home.

I was trying to do it all on my tablet since blockchain.info is blocked by the web filter in the office. ;-)  Just frustrated with myself!

You sure? Its really no problem, and I'd like you to get all the tickets you deserve for your donation

[Rez]

Hahaha, okay. Send them to 1K7VgVHRyrdKQo8tL9xd5EFnQK1LtsvsMs and we'll give it another go. I just didn't want you to be out of pocket due to my derp. :-)

[Hexadecibel]

Hahaha, okay. Send them to 1K7VgVHRyrdKQo8tL9xd5EFnQK1LtsvsMs and we'll give it another go. I just didn't want you to be out of pocket due to my derp. :-)

eh. Its all for the EFF anyway. Ill get the coins to you later today.

Edit: transaction sent

[Rez]

Okay! I'm in for 15 entries.

Note to self: Public Notes can only be sent from the web client.

[Mitchell]

Resend it with fee's:

TX: 09c00a5cc26020b4846a9b70971dfdbd038e75c42ec877eefe6356f234f29bcd
Amount: 5 tickets

[Hexadecibel]

I extended the deadline to 4pm PST to let a couple more people participate.

[Mitchell]

Did you receive my new transaction? (Just a double check )

[Hexadecibel]

Did you receive my new transaction? (Just a double check )

Yeah, Its there for all to see 

https://blockchain.info/address/1L1bA6R4rEBwHEwBMo61JitLt2Q8pvtYr8

[Mitchell]

Did you receive my new transaction? (Just a double check )

Yeah, Its there for all to see  

https://blockchain.info/address/1L1bA6R4rEBwHEwBMo61JitLt2Q8pvtYr8

Good good. Stupid fee's Anyhow, good luck everyone!

[Hexadecibel]

Raffle entry is closed.

Making donation to the EFF now

Donation made



https://bitpay.com/invoice/WHjqeviG9y3foYTihPkgqd

[danieldaniel]

Raffle entry is closed.

Making donation to the EFF now

Donation made 

Did I win?  I won, right?  RIGHT?

[Hexadecibel]

Raffle entry is closed.

Making donation to the EFF now

Donation made 

Did I win?  I won, right?  RIGHT?

We'll find out tomorrow 

[danieldaniel]

Raffle entry is closed.

Making donation to the EFF now

Donation made 

Did I win?  I won, right?  RIGHT?

We'll find out tomorrow 

Wrong answer. 

[Hexadecibel]

First post updated with streaming link.

[Hexadecibel]

Here is the list of raffle entrants.

https://docs.google.com/file/d/0B7sLcZ4VNET7dmIwQ2tuUWJHX1E/edit?usp=sharing

[Rez]

Congrats, Wingsuit!

[Mitchell]

Congrats Wingsuit!

[Boelens]

*throws confetti into Wingsuits' eyes*

Congrats!

[danieldaniel]

Damn!  I feel sorry for the people who bought 15+ tickets!

Congrats, wingsuit.

[rafsoaken]

Damn!  I feel sorry for the people who bought 15+ tickets!

Congrats, wingsuit.

Hindsight fallacy. The average payout is better than any bitcoin dice game, considering the coin's worth at current 1.64BTC.
Of course you must look at the big picture where people continously make bets in life, if the expected return is greater than what you gamble the more often you play the surer you will come out ahead.