escrow.ms, TomatoCage, John K(MIA) are all popular choices.
Bitpop has been around since before there were computers on the planet, so he would be another choice.
If you feel like rolling dice, I can escrow up to 1 BTC for 1%. I'm not comfortable with amounts higher than that (until I gain trust).
I don't know what other escrow's policies are on PayPal transactions, but I don't accept them. Anyway, good luck.
My Commodore 64 is very secure and I charge no fee.