Local Board request for Bengali

[BitCoinDream]

#############################################################################################
New Application (2021)
#############################################################################################

I am running Bengali Thread since 2014. Before implementation of merit system, it was a cesspool for account farmers. I have deleted 1200+ posts by 170+ users so far to clean up spam. But, thanks to some great contributors in the thread, it has lately turned into a great place to discuss All things Crypto in Bengali. Though I do not login everyday, I do constantly check the thread to keep it clean.

Unfortunately, community growth is now being hampered for not having our own sub-forum. People are trying to run their own buy/sell service, writing wallet & exchange reviews, discussing alts, planning meetup and a lot more. But, all these are getting cramped into a single thread. Part of community has also started to move to other forum and platforms.

Charts prepared by Rikafip is showing that we are consistently doing better than many existing local boards.

Post activity per local board during October 2020

Post activity per local board during November 2020

Post activity per local board during December 2020

I think, the current bull run will bring in lots of people to Crypto. If we can't sort out things before that, it might be too late. For now, just a local board will do. As we grow, we may decide whether we need any sub forum under that as well.





#############################################################################################
Old Application (2018)
#############################################################################################

1. Our thread is very active - https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=631891.0

2. I am getting huge no. of PM from Bengalis for various type of help.

Note: There are people asking real questions in Bengali. These legit queries have increased lately after the thread was stickied. I am getting similar questions in Bengali like 'Where to buy Bitcoin in Bangladesh?', 'Where to earn Bitcoin?', 'How start developing on top of Bitcoin?', 'How to use Bitcoin in Bangladesh?' etc. in PM as well. I cant reply all of them 24x7. Hence, I think, a sub would be great to organize legit questions as well as to control spam.

[1714809399]

1714809399

[1714809399]

1714809399

[stompix]

hello,good noon

Vinh is gay

good morning

Good nightj

How are you?

All I see in the last 5 pages are one-liners and one user who is angry at users posting crap.

[TryNinja]

We don't want terrorist scam shit posters spamming this forum.

Then, why are you here? ROFL

The Internet of Things is fast approaching requiring billions of machine to machine transactions that will all need processed.  Marinecoìn, -MTC- has developed a high speed, zero transaction fee, blockchain specifically designed to meet the needs of this emerging industry.  Artificial intelligence will drive the blockchain freeing up developers to build IOT applications for the Marinecoìn blockchain.  This DEV-less functioning of the chain will be guided by Jarvis, the AI engine.  Marine coin and iot are here to stay  They recently started an airdrop campaign where you can earn 20,000 -MTC- daily.  The coins are being rewarded with time dilution technology.  Take a look here at their website, search your favorite search engine for their website location if you would rather not follow links.   marineco.ìn/ico

OP: Your local thread is a shitshow of spam and shitposts. I doubt theymos would create a sub forum so those users can spam more for their bounties and signature campaigns. Just look at those Newbies in the last page spamming to increase their post count.

[InvoKing]

We don't want terrorist scam shit posters spamming this forum.

Look to who is talking about shit posting and spamming and using the word terrorism to describe a bunch of people is disgusting... To the ignore list forever.

-snip-

Had the same remark and i was almost to post the same thing, pretty much if their "discussion" topic will continue like this, it will end up like the Vietnamese...locked. Besides, using "urgently" in the title will make things just worse.

[Joel_Jantsen]

1. Our thread is very active - https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=631891.0

How urgent it is ? I mean people can't really wait to wish each other

Good night fiend

&

hello,good noon

right?
But I agree we do have a superhero in that thread and here he come

Notice:
It's Not a forum to talk about (hi,hello,how are you,good morning,good night)....I am giving last warning for you guys who are posting this type of shitpost..I am saying this for your safety. You will understand it very badly when you will see you're counted as a spammer and your account will be banned....

Make that guy a moderator or something which will be a ideal way to reduce spam on the section and encourage constructive posting.I have also heard rumour that these neighbouring countries like  Pakistan/Bangladesh are butt-hurt because Indians have their own sub these countries also want the same..

[LoyceV]

OP: Your local thread is a shitshow of spam and shitposts.

I was going to suggest to make a new, self-moderated thread, but it is already self-moderated! So BitCoinDream, why don't you start by deleting all useless posts in that thread?

1. Our thread is very active

Let me do some math:
-On average, 2.5 posts per day in the 4 years.
-On average, 16 posts per day in the past month
-About 20 posts per day in the past week
If that's all activity coming from an entire country, it doesn't need its's own sub-forum. If you don't count the spam, you may not even reach one decent post per day.

Notice:
It's Not a forum to talk about (hi,hello,how are you,good morning,good night)....I am giving last warning for you guys who are posting this type of shitpost..I am saying this for your safety. You will understand it very badly when you will see you're counted as a spammer and your account will be banned....

Make that guy a moderator or something which will be a ideal way to reduce spam on the section and encourage constructive posting.

He's only been active for a week, otherwise I'd suggest he should open a new self-moderated thread and give it a shot.

[pkmoney]

I'm also a Bangladeshi. It will be nice if we have a sub forum. But you should know how much persons are here from Bangladesh.

1. Our thread is very active - https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=631891.0

Active but with lots of spam. Having lots of reply doesn't mean active.
For example, check mohiulbd's post on your Bengali thread. I'm surprised that his account is still not banned.

2. I am getting huge no. of PM from Bangladeshis for various type of help.

Why don't you create a thread by answering all the question and update it regularly? It will really be appreciated. If you don't have enough time, please send me all the questions and I will create one.
Also you can update your OP there by answering all the question.

We don't want terrorist scam shit posters spamming this forum.

wut?
Tell me where you from. I'm building a list of shitposters and I will find some from your country too.

[LTU_btc]

OP, your local thread is self-moderated, but it's full of spam. You had to remove all that spam before asking to create local board. Then you would have better chance to get dedicated board for Bangladesh then. Now it's unlikely that theymos will create it. And if you remove all that spam, your thread will be not active enough.
And I'm wondering, why Bangladesh have two sticked topics on Other languages and locations section?

[BitCoinDream]

Once again, I am hereby requesting theymos to look into the appeal for a sub-forum for Bangladesh. Now, the thread is having much more constructive discussion and I have added some information in the OP for newbies as well. But, discussion of multiple topics in the same thread is very difficult.

[Cogy]

I'm also form Bangladesh, in this local section I saw a lot of spam and shit post. I already tried to tell the forum modarator. Bangla is a language where you can't mixed it up with other language, but some people are still mixed it. I think they don't have any respect in there native language. If you are good in English then why you try to post in English in other thread like Bitcoin discussion, meta, altcoin discussion etc. This thread created for writing in Bangla only, so why people write in English? This forum modarator don't know Bangla as well, when someone complained about it they (modarator) check the content meaning using Google translator and they didn't found any error because they mixed with Bangla and English. Google translator convert Bangla to English, other side it's already have some English so result represent good quality content with appropriate grammar also. If you think as a Bangladeshi it's totally wrong. All of the world know we are only the nation who are fight for native language. We will lose our reputation in this forum if we don't stop spamming and near future people will treat Bangladeshi people as a spammer.

This post don't have any intention to hurt anyone's feelings, but this is the real fact, we should avoid spamming. From today we will post good quality Bangla content in this thread.


I request from my heart to theymos please make a sub-forum for Bangladeshi.

[The Cryptovator]

Once again, I am hereby requesting theymos to look into the appeal for a sub-forum for Bangladesh. Now, the thread is having much more constructive discussion and I have added some information in the OP for newbies as well. But, discussion of multiple topics in the same thread is very difficult.

To be honest, you are also a one line poster, that are consider as a spam activity. Than how you expect sub-forum? Lot of spam on your thread, also merit abuse. Vist on Reputation you will find. Another sub-forum means make a opportunity to spam more. You should concentrate first on your self moderated post. Your activity is very less on your thread. Most of post there only 5/6 word even native language. So how you expect a decent sub-forum with them?

[Jrashid]

To be honest, you are also a one line poster, that are consider as a spam activity.

One line posts are never considered as spam activity as long as those are on-topic and add value to a discussion.

Lot of spam on your thread, also merit abuse.

Merit abuse is here and there, not only in Bengali thread, isn't it?

Another sub-forum means make a opportunity to spam more.

Not agree with you. Indeed sub-forums are the way to remove spamming.

You should concentrate first on your self moderated post. Your activity is very less on your thread. Most of post there only 5/6 word even native language. So how you expect a decent sub-forum with them?

Agreed.
But he is not active doesn't mean there is no one active from Bangladesh. We have a lot of active users, they are not active in Bengali thread because of spamming. But whenever there will be a sub-forum, we can control the spamming and we will see some more traffics.

@Theymos
Please consider adding a subforum for Bangladeshi users. There are lots of people who want to learn about Bitcoin.

[BitCoinDream]

The thread is much more clean & readable now. It is evident from the last few pages that spam is under control after the minimum merit restriction is imposed on newbies. I regularly delete spam from the thread, but if any of you still notice any, feel free to Report to moderator. Till we get our own sub, some global mod may handle those reports.

[Tszunami98]

We don't want terrorist scam shit posters spamming this forum.

Said the terrorist scam shit poster who is spamming the forum.

[TigerMart]

Give these guys their own sub-forum. Otherwise they're turning Regional Languages (India) into a Bangladesh sub-forum. Since the shady disappearance of Benson Samuel, India sub-forum does not have any dedicated moderator. So, there is none to take care of this flood.

[shasan]

1. Our thread is very active - https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=631891.0

2. I am getting huge no. of PM from Bangladeshis for various type of help.

Note: There are people asking real questions in Bengali. These legit queries have increased lately after the thread was stickied. I am getting similar questions in Bengali like 'Where to buy Bitcoin in Bangladesh?', 'Where to earn Bitcoin?', 'How start developing on top of Bitcoin?', 'How to use Bitcoin in Bangladesh?' etc. in PM as well. I cant reply all of them 24x7. Hence, I think, a sub would be great to organize legit questions as well as to control spam.

There are a lots of spam post. I think more than 50% posts are spam. And your mentioned thread is self moderated. Archive: https://archive.fo/rqlVg
But you have no time/Do not want to remove spam post/spammer from the topic. If you cant remove spam post/spammer from a single topic then how you will mange/someone manage too much spammer from a board. If you want to manage then want to say how it is possible? From last 3 weeks you are offline.

We don't want terrorist scam shit posters spamming this forum.

You are the best example as a spammer.

Notice:
It's Not a forum to talk about (hi,hello,how are you,good morning,good night)....I am giving last warning for you guys who are posting this type of shitpost..I am saying this for your safety. You will understand it very badly when you will see you're counted as a spammer and your account will be banned....

Make that guy a moderator or something which will be a ideal way to reduce spam on the section and encourage constructive posting.

I am not agree with you. The topic is on: বাংলাদেশ (Bengali) but the person posting on English so how effective it can be?

Let me do some math:
-On average, 2.5 posts per day in the 4 years.
-On average, 16 posts per day in the past month
-About 20 posts per day in the past week
If that's all activity coming from an entire country, it doesn't need its's own sub-forum. If you don't count the spam, you may not even reach one decent post per day.

I am agree with you. But Bangladeshi people posted on https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=1979138.0 too. And also they posted on many other local topics too as they are bengali.
In this case I suggest if theymos ceate a sub forum/board then it should be base on language. If it is base on Bengali Language then it will be more fit. There are a lots of user who talks in Bengali even the numbers of Bengali people out of Bangladesh are more than Bangladeshi.

[BitCoinDream]

1. Our thread is very active - https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=631891.0

2. I am getting huge no. of PM from Bangladeshis for various type of help.

Note: There are people asking real questions in Bengali. These legit queries have increased lately after the thread was stickied. I am getting similar questions in Bengali like 'Where to buy Bitcoin in Bangladesh?', 'Where to earn Bitcoin?', 'How start developing on top of Bitcoin?', 'How to use Bitcoin in Bangladesh?' etc. in PM as well. I cant reply all of them 24x7. Hence, I think, a sub would be great to organize legit questions as well as to control spam.

There are a lots of spam post. I think more than 50% posts are spam. And your mentioned thread is self moderated. Archive: https://archive.fo/rqlVg
But you have no time/Do not want to remove spam post/spammer from the topic. If you cant remove spam post/spammer from a single topic then how you will mange/someone manage too much spammer from a board. If you want to manage then want to say how it is possible? From last 3 weeks you are offline.

First of all, I do remove spam periodically. But, it is difficult to keep up to the huge spam influx just by self moderation. This is one of the reason I want a board, because as a moderator I'd be able to nuke a spammer or handle spam reports at one go. For now, I'd suggest you and other sane active members of the thread to keep reporting spam, so that global mods can handle those quickly.

[S_Therapist]

This is one of the reason I want a board, because as a moderator I'd be able to nuke a spammer or handle spam reports at one go.

I doubt local moderator can nuke an user. An user can have posts in other section too. So, logically, you will not be able to nuke an user.
In addition, from the comments above, it seems you are not active in the forum, almost not at all. How will you manage if you be a local moderator?

[SpaceSuite]

I think, it is high time we revisit this application. Because of the constant moderation of OP and continuous contribution of many, Bangladesh thread is now much better than before. Since page 195, at least one person has received merit on almost every page from various members of Bangladesh. At this stage, I would request theymos, to reconsider the appeal to create a sub-forum for বাংলাদেশ (Bangladesh).

[tranthidung]

Very active, I don't think so. From stats I have, that thread has about 2 posts per day, in average. That is too low to require for a specific local board.

I know it is not what you want to hear but it is what it is.

Code:

     +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
     | rankpost    boardname   npost_daily   npost   daysbetween    birthday       today |
     |-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
  1. |        1   vietnamese           3.9    8250          2090   18feb2012   08nov2017 |
  2. |        2    ukrainian           2.3    5416          2355   18jun2013   29nov2019 |
  3. |        3   bangladesh           2.1    4276          2009   30may2014   29nov2019 |
  4. |        4     srilanka           1.7    1433           831   20aug2017   29nov2019 |
  5. |        5      serbian           1.5    4275          2941   10nov2011   29nov2019 |
     |-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
  6. |        6    hungarian            .6    1911          3083   21jun2011   29nov2019 |
  7. |        7        czech            .5    1418          3044   30jul2011   29nov2019 |
  8. |        8     malaysia            .5    1472          2734   04jun2012   29nov2019 |
  9. |        9    singapore            .4     922          2380   24may2013   29nov2019 |
 10. |       10     slovenia            .4    1217          3077   27jun2011   29nov2019 |
     |-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
 11. |       11         thai            .4     815          2057   12apr2014   29nov2019 |
 12. |       12      persian            .3     537          2017   22may2014   29nov2019 |
 13. |       13       latvia            .2     404          1747   16feb2015   29nov2019 |
 14. |       14     georgian            .2     411          1972   06jul2014   29nov2019 |
 15. |       15    bulgarian            .2     568          2886   04jan2012   29nov2019 |
     |-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
 16. |       16    esperanto            .1     172          3322   25oct2010   29nov2019 |
 17. |       17   lithuanian            .1     394          3075   29jun2011   29nov2019 |
 18. |       18       canada            .1     140          2412   22apr2013   29nov2019 |
 19. |       19   uzbekistan             0      23           883   29jun2017   29nov2019 |
 20. |       20   azerbaijan             0       4          2303   09aug2013   29nov2019 |
     |-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
 21. |       21      finnish             0     138          3130   05may2011   29nov2019 |
 22. |       22     estonian             0     124          3077   27jun2011   29nov2019 |
 23. |       23     armenian             0      25           894   18jun2017   29nov2019 |
     +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------+