shared this project with few friends and most of them considered this a ponzi scheme. To be honest it does fit the textbook definition of a ponzi scheme except the buyer is not tricked into buying for a guaranteed ROI. The buyer knows well that he will not get his 1.12x ETH if there are no new buyers. However the buyer does get to advertise a message to the world which is fascinating.
Let's take the wikipedia definition and take it apart.
"Ponzi scheme is a fraud scheme in which a victim is tricked into investing in a company that does not actually do business, and only generates a return on investment when more marks invest. As a result, when the scheme can no longer attract new investors, it dies."
So:
- a fraud scheme in which
It can't be fraud because the rules of game are known beforehand and published as a smart contract code. The rules of game can't be changed either since they are in blockchain.
- a victim is tricked
The buyer of coin is aware about these rules so nobody tricks him.
- in a company that does not actually do business
Owning the coin gives the buyer a real value - ability to advertise her message.
- when the scheme can no longer attract new investors
If nobody buys the coin from the last owner, she just keeps receiving value by advertising her message
Think of this project as a modern version of the milliondollarhomepage (
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Million_Dollar_Homepage) except the messages are stored in blockchain rather than being just on a website.