[LOG] sMerit HODLers who sent merits for the first time

[Coin-1]

I was always astonished by members who have received airdropped sMerits on the day the merit system was implemented on the Bitcointalk forum, but they kept and did not send them to other members for a long time.

According to my rough estimate, on January 24, 2018, users have been credited with:

• Legendary - not less than 88 sMerits
• Hero Member - not less than 32 sMerits
• Sr. Member - not less than 7 sMerits
• Full Member - not less than 1 sMerit
• Member - 0 or 1 sMerit
• Jr. Member - 0 sMerit

And behold, on September 17, 2018, when the new enhanced restrictions and requirements have been introduced on the forum, these HODLers, who had been holding "assets" for so long, started sending their sMerits aged eight months (!) mostly to newbies.

sMerits are already aged 5 years! Aged to perfection!


^{Image source: shutterstock.com}

I decided to log the users who registered a relatively long time ago and were active on the forum, hence on January 24, 2018, they received airdropped sMerits but began to send their merits only from September 17, 2018, and later. Note: I will not log the users who were Members because their number is quite large.

The table below shows the user name, his rank on the day the merit system was implemented, the date of his first merit send, and the amount of merits he earned before this sending. The currently red tagged members will be marked in italic, permanently banned users will be strikelined.

sMerit HODLers who sent merits for the first time

Note: I will only list the latest data.

	User name	Rank on Jan 24, 2018	Date of the first merit send	Earned before sending
2201)	Bitcall	was Full Member	11/29/2021	2 merits
2202)	superman184	was Full Member	11/29/2021	0 merit
2203)	bhooscream	was Full Member	11/29/2021	1 merit
2204)	alch1mista	was Sr. Member	12/3/2021	1 merit
2205)	Marenos	was Full Member	12/9/2021	2 merits
2206)	PanosGr36	was Full Member	12/14/2021	0 merit
2207)	delong	was Full Member	12/16/2021	0 merit
2208)	aruldaroy	was Full Member	12/21/2021	0 merit
2209)	nibor	was Sr. Member	12/23/2021	37 merits
2210)	gradovalik	was Sr. Member	12/24/2021	0 merit
2211)	btcnastia	was Full Member	12/25/2021	0 merit
2212)	JackQwerty	was Full Member	12/26/2021	1 merit
2213)	Juse14	was Full Member	12/29/2021	0 merit
2214)	Haliburton	was Full Member	1/5/2022	16 merits
2215)	cafucafucafu	was Hero Member	1/7/2022	9 merits
2216)	Arkann	was Full Member	1/8/2022	4 merits
2217)	ChiliPowder	was Sr. Member	1/10/2022	4 merits
2218)	houseworx	was Full Member	1/12/2022	0 merit
2219)	Congyang	was Full Member	1/12/2022	6 merits
2220)	rahmad2nd	was Legendary	1/15/2022	2 merits
2221)	Kocret02	was Sr. Member	1/19/2022	0 merit
2222)	chum_yum	was Legendary	1/19/2022	0 merit
2223)	connesa	was Full Member	1/25/2022	0 merit
2224)	Hurtman	was Full Member	1/27/2022	0 merit
2225)	From Above	was Hero Member	1/31/2022	20 merits
2226)	ffischer	was Full Member	2/2/2022	0 merit
2227)	celot	was Sr. Member	2/3/2022	19 merits
2228)	allcoinminer	was Hero Member	2/11/2022	3 merits
2229)	darkmule	was Legendary	2/13/2022	5 merits
2230)	nordtyt	was Full Member	2/13/2022	0 merit
2231)	Drnice	was Sr. Member	2/13/2022	1 merit
2232)	bluebit25	was Sr. Member	2/19/2022	3 merits
2233)	PascalCoin	was Sr. Member	2/19/2022	13 merits
2234)	rby	was Sr. Member	2/21/2022	10 merits
2235)	thinkinger	was Hero Member	2/21/2022	0 merit
2236)	isyet	was Sr. Member	2/23/2022	0 merit
2237)	FallingKnife	was Legendary	2/24/2022	20 merits
2238)	hero1111	was Hero Member	2/26/2022	14 merits
2239)	JeWay	was Hero Member	2/27/2022	2 merits
2240)	mobilestrike	was Hero Member	2/27/2022	0 merit
2241)	Bobrox	was Full Member	2/28/2022	5 merits
2242)	kentrolla	was Hero Member	3/7/2022	15 merits
2243)	romeitaly	was Full Member	3/9/2022	3 merits
2244)	Luter01	was Sr. Member	3/14/2022	0 merit
2245)	nasip35	was Full Member	3/21/2022	9 merits
2246)	nebiki	was Sr. Member	3/23/2022	0 merit
2247)	ICOmagazine	was Full Member	3/26/2022	0 merit
2248)	RoxxR	was Full Member	3/26/2022	4 merits
2249)	dmz241	was Hero Member	3/28/2022	2 merits
2250)	rojan	was Sr. Member	3/29/2022	3 merits
2251)	d3nz	was Sr. Member	3/29/2022	3 merits
2252)	indah rezqi	was Full Member	3/30/2022	7 merits
2253)	bering	was Legendary	4/1/2022	5 merits
2254)	CryptoPanda	was Sr. Member	4/1/2022	10 merits
2255)	fakecryptsynagger	was Sr. Member	4/3/2022	1 merit
2256)	||bit	was Hero Member	4/3/2022	6 merits
2257)	boty	was Full Member	4/6/2022	0 merit
2258)	fitinplace	was Full Member	4/14/2022	0 merit
2259)	harapan	was Full Member	4/26/2022	2 merits
2260)	|MINER|	was Sr. Member	4/27/2022	0 merit
2261)	hashrateproducts	was Full Member	4/28/2022	13 merits
2262)	salad daging	was Sr. Member	4/29/2022	1 merit
2263)	jimboscott	was Full Member	5/1/2022	5 merits
2264)	lahmacunkuregi	was Sr. Member	5/2/2022	0 merit
2265)	tarable	was Full Member	5/4/2022	4 merits
2266)	fortuner	was Full Member	5/4/2022	0 merit
2267)	hZti	was Sr. Member	5/5/2022	2 merits
2268)	beveryu778	was Full Member	5/7/2022	12 merits
2269)	0verseer	was Full Member	5/9/2022	3 merits
2270)	CryptoCoderz	was Hero Member	5/12/2022	6 merits
2271)	tunth	was Sr. Member	5/12/2022	0 merit
2272)	Stemby	was Legendary	5/17/2022	7 merits
2273)	iamsange	was Sr. Member	5/19/2022	0 merit
2274)	arimamib	was Hero Member	5/19/2022	2 merits
2275)	m_nief	was Sr. Member	5/25/2022	0 merit
2276)	erick94	was Sr. Member	5/25/2022	2 merits
2277)	shai_	was Hero Member	5/26/2022	0 merit
2278)	Peeps Place	was Legendary	5/26/2022	32 merits
2279)	Pesona1	was Sr. Member	5/29/2022	0 merit
2280)	uswa56	was Full Member	5/30/2022	8 merits
2281)	Piesel	was Sr. Member	5/30/2022	0 merit
2282)	YaRAMBO	was Full Member	6/2/2022	2 merits
2283)	GeePeeU	was Sr. Member	6/8/2022	1 merit
2284)	len01	was Hero Member	6/10/2022	0 merit
2285)	G_Besar	was Sr. Member	6/11/2022	0 merit
2286)	ArthurY	was Sr. Member	6/13/2022	3 merits
2287)	turneps	was Full Member	6/18/2022	0 merit
2288)	BCwinning	was Hero Member	6/19/2022	0 merit
2289)	spiderbrain	was Legendary	6/20/2022	13 merits
2290)	coinerer	was Hero Member	6/23/2022	2 merits
2291)	dinastycoin-dcy	was Full Member	6/24/2022	1 merit
2292)	GigaBit	was Sr. Member	6/27/2022	20 merits
2293)	CPNpr	was Hero Member	6/27/2022	0 merit
2294)	Tomohisa	was Full Member	7/4/2022	0 merit
2295)	2020GD	was Full Member	7/5/2022	4 merits
2296)	ObscurePen	was Sr. Member	7/7/2022	6 merits
2297)	shaggy404	was Full Member	7/13/2022	0 merit
2298)	Ayers	was Legendary	7/15/2022	1 merit
2299)	blue_hurricanger	was Full Member	7/16/2022	3 merits
2300)	wiggi	was Sr. Member	7/21/2022	1 merit

Look at my next post below.

[Coin-1]

sMerit HODLers who sent merits for the first time (Continued)

	User name	Rank on Jan 24, 2018	Date of the first merit send	Earned before sending
2301)	Fara Chan	was Sr. Member	7/22/2022	0 merit
2302)	BitcoinBarrel	was Legendary	7/29/2022	4 merits
2303)	airdata	was Hero Member	7/31/2022	1 merit
2304)	Nubitcoinerr	was Sr. Member	8/2/2022	4 merits
2305)	kensaii	was Full Member	8/5/2022	0 merit
2306)	BitDane	was Sr. Member	8/6/2022	15 merits
2307)	Kayeshlyn	was Full Member	8/10/2022	1 merit
2308)	Sr.Urbanist	was Full Member	8/21/2022	10 merits
2309)	ajiz138	was Sr. Member	8/24/2022	0 merit
2310)	MarjorieZimmermanGinger	was Full Member	8/24/2022	0 merit
2311)	DudeAtWork420	was Full Member	9/12/2022	0 merit
2312)	Wildwest	was Sr. Member	9/15/2022	1 merit
2313)	davidspitzer	was Hero Member	10/3/2022	0 merit
2314)	fathafraink	was Full Member	10/6/2022	0 merit
2315)	Todamont	was Sr. Member	10/8/2022	0 merit
2316)	alexandr1115	was Hero Member	10/12/2022	1 merit
2317)	tomos81	was Hero Member	10/17/2022	3 merits
2318)	OhShei8e	was Legendary	10/17/2022	44 merits
2319)	Warkop	was Sr. Member	10/18/2022	0 merit
2320)	topman21	was Legendary	10/20/2022	15 merits
2321)	NicNacCoin	was Sr. Member	10/21/2022	3 merits
2322)	Rigon	was Sr. Member	10/23/2022	42 merits
2323)	rendravolt	was Hero Member	10/26/2022	4 merits
2324)	MatthewLM	was Legendary	10/28/2022	4 merits
2325)	ginsan	was Hero Member	11/7/2022	3 merits
2326)	mattsaronx	was Full Member	11/11/2022	0 merit
2327)	Pancharick	was Full Member	11/12/2022	2 merits
2328)	Xcode7	was Sr. Member	11/13/2022	0 merit
2329)	aisyah88	was Hero Member	11/20/2022	0 merit
2330)	maknyos	was Sr. Member	11/24/2022	0 merit
2331)	Shurik25	was Full Member	11/24/2022	0 merit
2332)	Edwardard	was Hero Member	11/28/2022	5 merits
2333)	TechnoX_X	was Full Member	12/4/2022	0 merit
2334)	tigerwood0432	was Hero Member	12/6/2022	4 merits
2335)	Mamun74	was Full Member	12/22/2022	4 merits
2336)	n3lz0n	was Hero Member	12/26/2022	0 merit
2337)	BenCodie	was Hero Member	12/27/2022	24 merits
2338)	speeder	was Hero Member	12/28/2022	0 merit
2339)	bangjoe	was Sr. Member	12/31/2022	6 merits
2340)	Dickiy	was Sr. Member	1/3/2023	24 merits
2341)	zaki12	was Full Member	1/5/2023	1 merit
2342)	Ultros	was Sr. Member	1/11/2023	0 merit
2343)	Antibit	was Full Member	1/12/2023	2 merits
2344)	s3v3nh4cks	was Legendary	1/13/2023	11 merits
2345)	Pofick	was Hero Member	1/15/2023	11 merits
2346)	lousie9	was Sr. Member	1/18/2023	0 merit
2347)	jakedeez	was Sr. Member	1/25/2023	0 merit
2348)	RealHummer	was Full Member	2/1/2023	11 merits
2349)	OKtoshi	was Legendary	2/1/2023	3 merits
2350)	owengtam09	was Full Member	2/4/2023	27 merits
2351)	Funeral Wreaths	was Full Member	2/8/2023	0 merit
2352)	Supreemo	was Full Member	2/8/2023	0 merit
2353)	kenshi222	was Legendary	2/8/2023	0 merit
2354)	lukikato	was Full Member	2/10/2023	0 merit
2355)	Powell	was Sr. Member	2/12/2023	5 merits
2356)	Tadic	was Full Member	2/24/2023	0 merit
2357)	Deff	was Sr. Member	3/1/2023	10 merits
2358)	Benchman	was Full Member	3/6/2023	0 merit
2359)	Kuttingcorners	was Sr. Member	3/7/2023	0 merit
2360)	texv	was Full Member	3/8/2023	2 merits
2361)	omgitsmehehe	was Full Member	3/8/2023	7 merits
2362)	efreeti	was Full Member	3/10/2023	4 merits
2363)	johnsaributua	was Full Member	3/12/2023	0 merit
2364)	visionE2	was Full Member	3/13/2023	1 merit
2365)	balotelli	was Full Member	3/17/2023	1 merit
2366)	pingu39	was Full Member	3/20/2023	0 merit
2367)	loopes	was Sr. Member	3/28/2023	29 merits
2368)	Hirose UK	was Hero Member	3/28/2023	0 merit
2369)	gdassori	was Legendary	4/5/2023	2 merits
2370)	muddafudda	was Legendary	4/6/2023	7 merits
2371)	ewibit	was Legendary	4/22/2023	45 merits
2372)	CohibAA	was Full Member	4/27/2023	26 merits
2373)	matt608	was Legendary	4/29/2023	0 merit
2374)	Wend	was Sr. Member	5/6/2023	17 merits
2375)	SyndicateLabs	was Full Member	5/30/2023	0 merit
2376)	nlovric	was Full Member	6/2/2023	19 merits
2377)	Fritwakky	was Full Member	6/3/2023	1 merit
2378)	Jateng	was Full Member	6/5/2023	17 merits
2379)	LightZ	was Sr. Member	6/8/2023	10 merits
2380)	99Percent	was Full Member	6/12/2023	0 merit
2381)	Tuturtinular	was Full Member	6/12/2023	0 merit
2382)	bitLeap	was Sr. Member	6/16/2023	15 merits
2383)	deadsea33	was Hero Member	6/22/2023	243 merits
2384)	stoner19	was Hero Member	7/18/2023	0 merit
2385)	Joori	was Full Member	7/24/2023	0 merit
2386)	DeQuade	was Legendary	7/27/2023	9 merits
2387)	red4slash	was Sr. Member	7/28/2023	0 merit
2388)	Btc_1856	was Sr. Member	8/10/2023	5 merits
2389)	BitcoinVSfiat	was Sr. Member	8/17/2023	4 merits
2390)	EmpoEX	was Sr. Member	8/20/2023	14 merits
2391)	PYramid Head	was Full Member	8/23/2023	0 merit
2392)	allthebitandbobs	was Sr. Member	8/27/2023	2 merits
2393)	BlockaFett	was Sr. Member	8/28/2023	5 merits
2394)	X-ray	was Hero Member	9/15/2023	16 merits
2395)	bit-emperor	was Full Member	9/17/2023	0 merit
2396)	henmark	was Sr. Member	9/17/2023	20 merits
2397)	jeha2015	was Full Member	9/19/2023	7 merits
2398)	fachant	was Sr. Member	9/23/2023	2 merits
2399)	Sophokles	was Hero Member	9/24/2023	7 merits
2400)	bisba	was Full Member	9/29/2023	0 merit

Look at my next post below.

[Coin-1]

sMerit HODLers who sent merits for the first time (Ended)

	User name	Rank on Jan 24, 2018	Date of the first merit send	Earned before sending
2401)	Winterfrost	was Full Member	10/1/2023	6 merits
2402)	culexevilman	was Legendary	10/7/2023	0 merit
2403)	Best Dreams	was Full Member	10/13/2023	1 merit
2404)	greek_hephaestus	was Full Member	10/15/2023	0 merit
2405)	jeanvandame	was Full Member	10/17/2023	0 merit
2406)	n00ber	was Sr. Member	10/18/2023	3 merits
2407)	stonehedge	was Legendary	10/23/2023	1 merit
2408)	minor-transgression	was Sr. Member	10/24/2023	0 merit
2409)	pusaka	was Hero Member	10/29/2023	1 merit
2410)	twa	was Full Member	10/31/2023	0 merit
2411)	Sword Smith	was Sr. Member	11/8/2023	10 merits
2412)	booktiger	was Sr. Member	11/9/2023	15 merits
2413)	LesterD	was Full Member	11/15/2023	9 merits
2414)	maisie53	was Full Member	11/15/2023	0 merit
2415)	BitJohnW	was Full Member	11/15/2023	2 merits
2416)	DewlanceVPS	was Full Member	11/17/2023	2 merits
2417)	ShetKid	was Sr. Member	11/19/2023	0 merit
2418)	Visbay	was Sr. Member	11/26/2023	1 merit
2419)	mistercoin	was Legendary	11/29/2023	0 merit
2420)	neutraLTC	was Legendary	12/5/2023	21 merits
2421)	googee	was Full Member	12/7/2023	0 merit
2422)	martinex	was Full Member	12/13/2023	9 merits
2423)	rika0223	was Full Member	12/17/2023	28 merits
2424)	lebuen	was Full Member	12/18/2023	0 merit
2425)	Lykslyks	was Full Member	12/20/2023	0 merit
2426)	tottong	was Hero Member	12/20/2023	0 merit
2427)	Kuingsudaqila	was Sr. Member	12/29/2023	0 merit
2428)	Koloulinger	was Sr. Member	12/29/2023	0 merit
2429)	JariKriting	was Hero Member	1/3/2024	17 merits
2430)	Toro iskandar	was Hero Member	1/15/2024	0 merit
2431)	oll	was Full Member	1/17/2024	13 merits
2432)	cengsuwuei	was Hero Member	1/19/2024	0 merit
2433)	TurboMen	was Legendary	1/22/2024	0 merit
2434)	liuka	was Hero Member	1/22/2024	5 merits
2435)	Odalv	was Legendary	1/24/2024	0 merit
2436)	Quontoloue	was Sr. Member	1/26/2024	0 merit
2437)	TheBobyHunter	was Sr. Member	1/26/2024	244 merits
2438)	DenyAryanto	was Sr. Member	1/28/2024	0 merit
2439)	xusxuquade	was Hero Member	1/28/2024	0 merit
2440)	memequiserle	was Hero Member	1/29/2024	1 merit
2441)	Icefrag	was Hero Member	1/29/2024	0 merit
2442)	kuriboh	was Sr. Member	1/29/2024	0 merit
2443)	Ratters	was Sr. Member	1/31/2024	0 merit
2444)	foggyb	was Legendary	1/31/2024	2 merits
2445)	SCCFX	was Sr. Member	2/1/2024	0 merit
2446)	PokerDiceMan	was Hero Member	2/2/2024	0 merit
2447)	junder	was Hero Member	2/11/2024	6 merits
2448)	Loepuenkyou	was Hero Member	2/27/2024	0 merit
2449)	Omikifuse	was Legendary	2/28/2024	9 merits
2450)	bubilas	was Hero Member	3/6/2024	9 merits
2451)	Xeelee	was Full Member	3/13/2024	0 merit
2452)	barto123	was Sr. Member	3/13/2024	64 merits
2453)	kobri0815	was Full Member	3/13/2024	0 merit
2454)	Zyro	was Sr. Member	3/14/2024	3 merits
2455)	Bregan	was Full Member	3/16/2024	0 merit
2456)	Narydu	was Hero Member	3/21/2024	10 merits
2457)	MURONDI	was Sr. Member	3/24/2024	7 merits
2458)	CYPER	was Hero Member	3/24/2024	2 merits
2459)	sportis	was Sr. Member	3/31/2024	2 merits
2460)	bSpend	was Sr. Member	4/1/2024	8 merits
2461)	endut15	was Full Member	4/2/2024	0 merit
2462)	Akbarkoe	was Legendary	4/19/2024	4 merits
2463)	NABiT	was Sr. Member	4/22/2024	9 merits
2464)	CoinMin3r	was Hero Member	4/27/2024	0 merit
2465)	massimodamassa	was Full Member	5/23/2024	1 merit
2466)	lembang	was Hero Member	7/8/2024	1 merit
2467)	agan husaeni	was Full Member	7/10/2024	0 merit

The chart below illustrates how many users who were Members or higher on the day the merit system was introduced, on January 24, 2018, sent merits for the first time since September 17, 2018.



These posts are relevant for July 26, 2024, and have been updated on July 31, 2024.

[cryptovigi]

...
I wished to log the users who registered a relatively long time ago and were active on the forum, hence on January 24, 2018, they received airdropped sMerits but began to send their merits only from September 17, 2018, and later.

The table below shows the user name, his rank at the day when the merit system has been implemented, the date of the first merit send by him, and the amount of merits that were earned by him before this sending. The currently red tagged members will be marked in italic, permanently banned users will be strikelined.
...

I can't get the point of publishing that loooong list.
Do you think you put a pressure on them to send more merits or do it often? I don't think so... (probably none of them will ever visit it)

Sorry but for me it's boring and pointless...

What's much more important - by publishing this list you "punish" users, who sent at least one merit, but thousands of users who didn't send any merit will stay in shadow... unnoticed maybe forever...

[The Cryptovator]

Another merit analysis... forum became Merittalk instead of Bitcointalk. However OP did hard work. I don't see any point of your image that you used on original post. To be honest I didn't find the point how is it useful for us?

[Marcel666]

The OP is probably thinking along the lines of those members sending out merits for the first time because demoted junior members needed it and were probably willing to pay for it.
Unfortunately, there is no substantial evidence to support a merit abuse claim.

[Coin-1]

What's much more important - by publishing this list you "punish" users, who sent at least one merit, but thousands of users who didn't send any will stay in shadow... unnoticed maybe forever...

It's just the list of sMerit HODLers who sent their merit for the first time. No any punishment to them. I will shorten my posts in the future.

The OP is probably thinking along the lines of those members sending out merits for the first time because demoted junior members needed it and were probably willing to pay for it.

No, I don't think like that. Moreover, I see that your merited post is good.

I don't see any point of your image that you used on original post. To be honest I didn't find the point how is it useful for us.

I wished to represent some things aged to perfection.

[Marshall14]

Isn't it obvious that when the new merits system was introduced,the willingness to also hand out merits was stimulated,members(high ranked) became more liberal in handing out merits to good posters(at least so they could rank up/differentiate them from shitposters....

Even during the period came an increase in the merit sources,so that's enough to prove that merits were handed out more during this period than others(with the exception of the day the merits itself was introduced)

I don't see the reason making this boring list,if you have any proof against them, report to a MOD or DT

[TMAN]

Taking 6months to send 1 merit is suspicious, but I don’t think you are handing the data in the best way here OP.  You could be onto something although it will probably take one of the better data guys to come and sort through it all.

Got to give you some merit though as this must of taken fucking ages

[Coin-1]

Isn't it obvious that when the new merits system was introduced,the willingness to also hand out merits was stimulated,members(high ranked) became more liberal in handing out merits to good posters(at least so they could rank up/differentiate them from shitposters....

As I remember, people sent a huge amount of sMerits in the early days when the merit system has been introduced. This analysis takes in consideration only those members who did not make any merit transaction until September 17, 2018.

I don't see the reason making this boring list,if you have any proof against them, report to a MOD or DT

I don't blame sMerit HODLers. It's just statistics that can be interesting and probably useful.

[CryptopreneurBrainboss]

Another merit analysis... forum became Merittalk instead of Bitcointalk.

you're also a contributor to this. One way or the other we all are I don't even understand the need of this

Merit fan of top merited user (all time) and recognize rank.

[Harlot]

I can't get the point of publishing that loooong list.
Do you think you put a pressure on them to send more merits or do it often? I don't think so... (probably none of them will ever visit it)

Sorry but for me it's boring and pointless...

Maybe you didn't read the whole post that is why you are saying it is pointless. But to keep you up to speed he basically created this long list of members who have started sending their merits (mostly to newbies) when theymos created a new ranking system that ranked down a lot of Jr. Members back to newbies, this day marked this members who have hodl their sMerits and finally started sending merits to this Jr. Members turned newbies. Bottom line is I think he is trying to connect this newbie accounts of being alt accounts of this merit hoarders.

[The Cryptovator]

Snip

Look like you are still live on childhood. If I am not wrong second time you attack me with same reference. I replied on your thread what is true. More than 7 post you have created with similar subject about merit. That's why you are always trying to counter me ? Well then do it. May be it will help improve your rank because your activity 290 but merit is only 39 and you are still member. But I am ok with my merit as well my merit is more than faster my activity. I bothered to reply you because I am going to put you on my ignore list. So wherever and whatever you reply it will not visible for me. You are free to post against me. I don't have much time to bother myself in nonsense work. Best of luck.

[cryptovigi]

Taking 6months to send 1 merit is suspicious, but I don’t think you are handing the data in the best way here OP.  You could be onto something although it will probably take one of the better data guys to come and sort through it all.

Not necessarily suspicious (for sure not in all cases) - that list comes from merit database (unless Coin-1 correct me)

1. this case we don't know anything about their activity from January till September some of them could not have been active at all and that's the reason of not giving merit away
2. there are a lot of Members who didn't earn any merit so they wasn't interested in meriting... probably they didn't even know they have 1 smerit after 17 IX whole forum start to talk about merits and that's how they know about it (it could also refer to upper rank as well most of them wasn't also active on merit field)

... It's just statistics that can be interesting and probably useful.

Sorry but listing all rows from prepared dataset you you can not call statistics...
If you at least compare how many people sent their first merit during a month before introducing 1 merit revolution to the amount of people who did it during a month after that day and we could see a difference which would show us something - it would be a statistics.

Don't get me wrong - i like some of your previous work but not this one.

Maybe you didn't read the whole post that is why you are saying it is pointless. But to keep you up to speed he basically created this long list of members who have started sending their merits (mostly to newbies) when theymos created a new ranking system that ranked down a lot of Jr. Members back to newbies, this day marked this members who have hodl their sMerits and finally started sending merits to this Jr. Members turned newbies. Bottom line is I think he is trying to connect this newbie accounts of being alt accounts of this merit hoarders.

Connecting peple who send first their first merit ever with downgraded jr. members would be better idea - many people from OPs list actually did it but there are also many of them who sent their first (and only) merit to members, full members and upper rank as well (actually more than 42% merits from users who give away first merit after 17.09.2018 went to members and upper ranks)....

[Steamtyme]

Another merit analysis... forum became Merittalk instead of Bitcointalk.

you're also a contributor to this. One way or the other we all are I don't even understand the need of this

Merit fan of top merited user (all time) and recognize rank.

Snip

Look like you are still live on childhood. If I am not wrong second time you attack me with same *snip*

Hardly an attack in any way shape or form. Just accurately using information, and it even seemes to be done in jest, either way.


To play devils advocate as to why some of these members(likely a small percentage) would engage in this behavior.

Perhaps they didn't accept the merit system. Silently chanting "Not my Merit System". In this case they didn't engage or partake in the merit system and continued on in blissful abstention. They may have then taken exception with the new part of the system and then decided to go out meriting newbies.

 

[Coin-1]

Taking 6months to send 1 merit is suspicious, but I don’t think you are handing the data in the best way here OP.

I agree with you. Perhaps here is too many data. I just excluded from these lists the users who were Members on January 24, 2018.

To play devils advocate as to why some of these members(likely a small percentage) would engage in this behavior.

Of course, most of these members who sent merits for the first time are decent and honest, but some of them look suspicious.

[Coin-1]

I updated the logs.

958 users who were Full Members or higher on the day the merit system was introduced have already been listed in the first posts of this thread, so I published parts of the logs in other posts.

I also created a chart that shows how many users sent merits since September 17, 2018. Here I do not omit users who have received 10 airdropped merits, so the red curve reflects their number. I added this chart to one of the first posts.

[Coin-1]

The logs and chart have been updated. I also published another part of the logs in my third post above.

The list of sMerit HODLers who sent merits for the first time continues to grow. There are already 1207 users who began to send their airdropped merits from September 17, 2018, and later.

[Coin-1]

Since another 136 users, who were Full Members and above on January 24, 2019, decided to use the merit system and sent sMerits for the first time, I updated the three tables and chart on the first page.

There are already too many users in the logs, so I published the forth part in an external post.

According to the chart, it seems that some members still do HODL their airdropped sMerits.

[Coin-1]

Another 5 months elapsed, so I decided to update these lists and chart.

I was surprised that many users still hold their airdropped sMerits. It seems that some users who recently sent merits to others for the first time either were red tagged by DT members or woke up after a long period of inactivity.