There is any problem if anyone make any post on behalf of banned user?

[sujonali1819]

Suddenly yesterday I discovered this curiosity.    

Suppose your friend is banned for few days  and unable to make any post. But he needs to make an announcement which is urgent/necessary. So if he asked you for making a post on behalf of him. And you make the post.

So, In this case is there any problem can happen with your account? Is there any rules about this case?    Just want to be clear about this. Thanks

[1715482381]

1715482381

[1715482381]

1715482381

[1715482381]

1715482381

[1715482381]

1715482381

[1715482381]

1715482381

[ChuckBuck]

I think there won't be any problems here, as long as you're not the owner of both accounts  Are you worried about your notice on behalf of Hhampuz  I think it would be quite absurd if someone has a complain about it. Dont worry!

[TheBeardedBaby]

Suddenly yesterday I discovered this curiosity.    

Suppose your friend is banned for few days  and unable to make any post. But he needs to make an announcement which is urgent/necessary. So if he asked you for making a post on behalf of him. And you make the post.

So, In this case is there any problem can happen with your account? Is there any rules about this case?    Just want to be clear about this. Thanks

If your friend is banned, he has the right to create a new account only to post in meta regarding his case.
If you are going to post an annoucnent that the guy is banned and if anyone wants to contact him to do it outside the forum, should be OK, at least for me.
If you want to take over a proejct, this should be fine too.
Normally those who post "of behalf of " somebody most offen turn to be alt accounts.

[rosezionjohn]

So, In this case is there any problem can happen with your account? Is there any rules about this case?

There is no specific rule for this. There are some accounts here that are paid to post ANNs or Bounty threads. They just put a disclaimer at the end saying they're only posting on behalf of that project BUT they're not part of the team. I don't see them having issues so that must mean it's allowed. I think that is also similar with your case posting on behalf of Hhampuz.

[sujonali1819]

I think there won't be any problems here, as long as you're not the owner of both accounts  Are you worried about your notice on behalf of Hhampuz  I think it would be quite absurd if someone has a complain about it. Dont worry!

No dear, I am not worried about it. I also think that maybe there is no problem and I also seen previously someone did that. Yesterday Suddenly I thought about this case. And decide to get some clarification so that me and all the people here can know have any problem or not. Just it.

[hilariousandco]

Things like this will be taken on a case by case basis. Making an update of something important is probably fine if it's essential, but you can't just use another account as a proxy to ban evade. One or two users in the past have been banned and then just attempted use another member to continue to bump their thread and continue their business which isn't ok. Probably best to ask in Meta and give the circumstances.

[sujonali1819]

Things like this will be taken on a case by case basis. Making an update of something important is probably fine if it's essential, but you can't just use another account as a proxy to ban evade. One or two users in the past have been banned and then just attempted use another member to continue to bump their thread and continue their business which isn't ok.

Yes, this is what I am searching for. If anybody banned from here means there is no right to come back again here if permanent banned. So if anybody continuously posting on behalf of 'banned user' it does not look good to me too.[ 1 or two urgent and essential announce it is ok]
Hope we will see some informative reply...

Probably best to ask in Meta and give the circumstances.

This post already in Meta.

[o_e_l_e_o]

Hope we will see some informative reply...

Given that hilariousandco is a global moderator, than that is your informative reply - you need to give the circumstances of this "urgent and essential" announcement.

[hilariousandco]

Things like this will be taken on a case by case basis. Making an update of something important is probably fine if it's essential, but you can't just use another account as a proxy to ban evade. One or two users in the past have been banned and then just attempted use another member to continue to bump their thread and continue their business which isn't ok.

Yes, this is what I am searching for. If anybody banned from here means there is no right to come back again here if permanent banned. So if anybody continuously posting on behalf of 'banned user' it does not look good to me too.[ 1 or two urgent and essential announce it is ok]
Hope we will see some informative reply...

Probably best to ask in Meta and give the circumstances.

This post already in Meta.

I'm talking about people who have an actual case. I don't know whether you're speaking hypothetically but as I said above they will be taken on a case by case basis.

[LoyceV]

Are you worried about your notice on behalf of Hhampuz 

What happened to Hhampuz? If I remember correctly he was banned for sending unsolicited PMs a while ago. What happened this time?

[mprep]

Are you worried about your notice on behalf of Hhampuz  

What happened to Hhampuz? If I remember correctly he was banned for sending unsolicited PMs a while ago. What happened this time?

Same thing - he got temp banned for sending unsolicited PMs again.


As for the "posting on behalf of someone", as hilariousandco pointed out, it really depends. I'd say a short "hey, I'm unable to post on the forums; everything is fine and I'll be back in a bit" should be fine if it's related to something time-sensitive and important (e.g. bounty campaigns).

[acroman08]

Are you worried about your notice on behalf of Hhampuz  

What happened to Hhampuz? If I remember correctly he was banned for sending unsolicited PMs a while ago. What happened this time?

Same thing - he got temp banned for sending unsolicited PMs again.

regarding about temporary ban. is there a thread that lists the members who got temporarily banned to notify the community of which members of the forum got the punishment?

[joniboini]

regarding about temporary ban. is there a thread that lists the members who got temporarily banned to notify the community of which members of the forum got the punishment?

Temp-ban data aren't public. Only global mod that can view it iirc. That being said, there are tools such as https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5092983.0, modlog or BPIP to view the status of a user (banned/inactive, etc).

[ChuckBuck]

Same thing - he got temp banned for sending unsolicited PMs again.

Can I ask a bit about the ban this time   What is the cause for this ban? Recently, his only scandal was blender.io's signature campaign. But I think this is not the cause, right? I have been curious about it since sujonali1819 posted a notice on his behalf, can you guys reveal a bit about the ban?
I see him online now  

[The Sceptical Chymist]

There is no specific rule for this.

There's definitely not, and personally I don't see a problem with what OP is proposing as long as there's actually a second individual involved--and there's no real way to tell that for sure.  And honestly, I don't think there's anything preventing people from just creating a new account after they're banned anyway, and I'm pretty sure most banned users do just that. 

I recall hilariousandco mentioning that mods/admins don't check IP logs on any banned members, and so there's nothing to prevent someone from making an announcement from an alt account or from having a friend speak on someone's behalf.  In any case, since there's no way to tell if a friend is involved and no way to prevent ban evasion, this is really a non-issue.

[PrimeNumber7]

Same thing - he got temp banned for sending unsolicited PMs again.

Can I ask a bit about the ban this time  What is the cause for this ban?

You literally quoted the reason...

[ChuckBuck]

Same thing - he got temp banned for sending unsolicited PMs again.

You literally quoted the reason...

Are you serious  what does it mean  temp banned for sending unsolicited PMs I thought it was a form of ban, I means this ban doesn't allow him to send PM. Am I wrong? Is that the reason for the ban? I seem to be getting confused here 

[rhomelmabini]

Are you serious   what does it mean   temp banned for sending unsolicited PMs I thought it was a form of ban, I means this ban doesn't allow him to send PM. Am I wrong? Is that the reason for the ban? I seem to be getting confused here  

unsolicited - not asked for; given or done voluntarily.

He send some PM to other users but someone had reported it as spam message (be careful sending PMs to users you never know) to admins/global mods then one of them temporarily ban him for sending unsolicited PMs. Temporary ban is still a ban so understanding the ban ruling is you can't send PM to anyone or post to any other boards (you can post though by creating another account to appeal in it but just only on your ban appeal thread here in Meta) until your ban is lifted.

[LoyceV]

Same thing - he got temp banned for sending unsolicited PMs again.

Lol say what? The first time, he didn't know it wasn't allowed. I would have expected him to learn from that ban.
So my guess is the ban got longer this time?

[rhomelmabini]

Same thing - he got temp banned for sending unsolicited PMs again.

Lol say what? The first time, he didn't know it wasn't allowed. I would have expected him to learn from that ban.
So my guess is the ban got longer this time?

I think that is expected. My wild guess is that it would be around 2 weeks, a month or it varies from the rule broke.