Where are the Bitcoin PTCs, PPM, PPC and RevAdShare Sites gone?

For your info,
PTC - Paid to clicks
PPM - Paid per 1000 impressions
PPC - Paid per clicks
RevAdShare - Revenue Ad sharing websites

All these types of sites were available before when BTC used to be under $1000, where have they gone now? Do you guys know about the current state on their existence as of now?

This is what I found(https://www.bit-sites.com/best-bitcoin-ptc-sites/), don't know if it's true.

They have this thing "Offerwalls" a new type of PTC, I guess.

They're mostly still around, it's just that every time the bitcoin price multiplies, for example from $1000 to $9000 now, these sites can't replenish their funds while feasibly paying everyone at the same rate they used to give, because it's like all the users of these services suddenly need several times the amount of money they used to get, as the result of the bitcoin price increase. At that point they have two options, lower the payout rates drastically or shut down operations.

I imagine there would be an outage among customers if they get much lower payouts than they used to so most of the times, the revenue ad sharing sites just shut down.

Quote from: asu on May 26, 2020, 09:09:31 PM

They have thing thing "Offerwalls" a new type of PTC, I guess.

Offerwalls are just PTCs that pay you to complete surveys and install apps instead of clicking on links, so they are subject to the same process I described above.

Quote from: NotATether on May 26, 2020, 09:11:54 PM

Quote from: asu on May 26, 2020, 09:09:31 PM

They have thing thing "Offerwalls" a new type of PTC, I guess.

Offerwalls are just PTCs that pay you to complete surveys and install apps instead of clicking on links, so they are subject to the same process I described above.

Oh yeah, I remembered, I've seen something like that, but it's an Bitcoin related app in Play store or App store that will pay you to install such apps that they recommend. So, that's how it called, nowadays...

I think they're still around though not to the same degree as they were before. With the value of bitcoin skyrocketing, it would honestly be a good lure to the newbies to join such websites in order to make a quick profit. It was replaced mostly by ad-watching and installing apps for a certain time period before you get paid. Kinda like mturks back in the day. Not gonna lie, I tried completing those quests/offers and try to reach the bare minimum to withdraw but it's just not attainable given the limited number of tasks these sites issue per day.

Quote from: NotATether on May 26, 2020, 09:11:54 PM

I can definitely understand that, but what about those sites that were paying BTC that was bound to fiat (USD) rates? I mean, there were some good PTC sites which were just using BTC as a mode of deposit and withdrawal based on the USD values mentioned there per click or the deposit withdrawal amounts.

They are still around but as you have noticed, most of them were gone. Probably the lack of traffic and there's no solution to it but to stop their operations. I don't know most of them but I've found this list: https://medium.com/@kensahotra/list-of-best-bitcoin-ptc-sites-25a7554df3d4

And most of the sites there are still alive. I'm not sure if they pay but with the small number of payouts, I guess they won't scam for tiny amounts.

Quote from: Stedsm on May 26, 2020, 10:24:14 PM

Technically they would be safe since they base their funding at USD rates which isn't super deflationary like bitcoin.

Quote from: NotATether on May 27, 2020, 09:20:32 AM

Quote from: Stedsm on May 26, 2020, 10:24:14 PM

Technically they would be safe since they base their funding at USD rates which isn't super deflationary like bitcoin.

Are you aware of any such websites that currently pay that way?

Quote from: asu on May 26, 2020, 09:09:31 PM

This is what I found(https://www.bit-sites.com/best-bitcoin-ptc-sites/), don't know if it's true.

They have this thing "Offerwalls" a new type of PTC, I guess.

Offer walls are not PTC, that's an area where you can get some good offers like surveys and anything that's targeted for your area and if you complete that offer, you get paid either in points or cashbacks (in fiat or BTC based on their policy).

I've been an user on a few such sites out of which CoinURL got me the most revenue and A-Ads is probably still running although I have no idea how much BTC I have left in my account (it's set for auto-withdrawal).

CoinURL went offline a few years ago after refusing to pay me the account balance I had so basically scammed me and A-Ads is still going but I'm not sure if they offer the best payrates. I have noticed that a lot of websites that existed years ago do not exist anymore - scams, bankruptcy or who knows what else may be the reason, the thing is you can't really trust websites that aren't well known and without a large userbase nowadays.

There was a time when I saw some social media earning groups and channels are full of this PTC, PPC, revadshare advertising posts. I have also tried many PTC and revadshare sites. But now all social media are full of fake giveaways/airdrops and doubler sites. So we can guess those scammers have changed their way and turned into fake giveaways and doubler ways.

Coinad used to be one of my very favorites when it came to earning a good amount of BTC as I also had around 10 referrals for which I was getting paid 5% per each of my referral's clicks. That used to make me a handsome revenue but I stopped doing it as times began to change in my life and things started worsening IRL.

Such websites still exists, but obviously, best time of it is already in past. And it's not about just Bitcoin websites, but all these kind of websites in general. Time is changing and such earning methods becomes obsolete. Before I started to use Bitcoin, I used lot of PTC, Surfing and similar websites and I earned my first money online there. It was good for me as beginner, but in general, it's not the best way to make money. So, less people is interested in it.
I think this type of websites were seriously hit by bounties few years ago. It was much more profitable than various PTC and it was possible to earn good money from bounties, so people just switched there. And despite that bounties is shit nowadays, people don't look back at PTC's.
I think we can add faucets in same order with your mentioned websites. Yes, there is still many faucets online, but it's waste of time now and you hardly can make money from it. While few years ago it was possible to earn decent money from faucets without struggling

I think high withdrawal fee killed all of these "small transaction" businesses. Users can claim few satoshi's per clicks, but withdraw cost them more than one month his hard work. Of course if service legit.
I see some bigger faucet services are also out of business. I guess it doesn't pay to do it anymore (I mean from the owner side)

PTC, PPC, sites were many good sites as a money maker But now they are scamming to pay higher prices. Therefore, these sites are disappearing and their demand has decreased a lot. Users are afraid to use it But now PTC sites have given new offers. It is possible to earn money through links Since it has been scammed before it is better to check before clicking on the links.

historically (even before bitcoin) these types of websites have never stayed around for long because they always fail to make enough profit for the owners to stay viable. in certain types specially like PTCs there is always only one direction to go and that is to turn into a Ponzi scheme which as you may already know can not last long. there is also a lot of fraud happening in this group from both users and the owners which either bankrupts the owners or disgusts the users enough to leave.
in any case there are always some number of these sites around, most of which can be found in Micro Earning board: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?board=212.0