why different markets show different movement on the same pair?

[farrellronald]

hello guys what do you think:
why different markets show different movement on the same pair?
why brokers do not use a certain chart for their deals?
is that possible for a broker to maintain a chart defines all of the market movement and everyone use it as the only single chart for this pair?

please give me your Idea on this 

[usekevin]

hello guys what do you think:
why different markets show different movement on the same pair?
why brokers do not use a certain chart for their deals?
is that possible for a broker to maintain a chart defines all of the market movement and everyone use it as the only single chart for this pair?

please give me your Idea on this 

Actually it's not a standard price for certain pair in all the exchanges.Because the price of all the cryptocurrency is based on the market demand and not based on the exchanges.In the exchanges like binance, we can get a good price for any pair because due to the huge traders using to inverse their money. The will be a competition between the buyers and it's easy to get good price for the pairs.

[dunfida]

-snip-

Actually it's not a standard price for certain pair in all the exchanges.Because the price of all the cryptocurrency is based on the market demand and not based on the exchanges.In the exchanges like binance, we can get a good price for any pair because due to the huge traders using to inverse their money. The will be a competition between the buyers and it's easy to get good price for the pairs.

To think that there would be no competition if the price of those pair would be just the same in all sorts of platforms and as mentioned it will vary on each exchange
yet it all matters with the liquidity and volume.They wont really be on huge gap though because of possible arbitrage thing and its a rare case to happen.
They differ but only on minimal as possible.

[Kupid002]

hello guys what do you think:
why different markets show different movement on the same pair?
why brokers do not use a certain chart for their deals?
is that possible for a broker to maintain a chart defines all of the market movement and everyone use it as the only single chart for this pair?

please give me your Idea on this  

That's the reason there are what do we called arbitrage in trading they are the people taking advantage of  price difference in  exchange.

They have different price because they have different users and buyers and it's open market any one can set and buy from the exchange in the price they want  and no one can force and teach you when the price you want to buy it . It's always depend on the market and the liquidity of that exchange ..
If you found big difference in price you should take that as another opportunity to earn. don't ask why they are different in price it's normal because they have different users and price setter.

[boyptc]

why different markets show different movement on the same pair?

They have different indicators and depending on their own base prices.

But as you can see they're also close to the other price of pairs with other exchanges. What's their basis for the difference in the price? I don't know, they have their own tools to determine it.

[Salauddin1994]

The reason why markets show different movements at the same time is because it depends on the market situation and price when the demand of a market increases other markets compete with it and try to rise but these are not a form of subsequent movement. But even if there is a movement at the same time it will depend on the traders where they will exchange the market's currency is priced based on the needs of buyers negative attitudes are a risky movement.

[noorman0]

It depends on how active the exchange is and what coins are being compared between exchanges. But for popular coins, there is very little chance of experiencing significant gaps, as most liquidity and high volume exchanges are filled with trading bots that users on time follow global price movements. And most exchanges use the well-known chart window service, TradingView.

[Coin_trader]

Difference on market maker is the answer to this question. They are the main liquidity provider in the exchange that make order in the order book of the exchange. Its not about how famous the exchange is because not all traders are setting orders on exchange. Market maker services is the one that filling the order book to provide liquidity for traders that opening a market order. Most exchange that has a small liquidity/volume don't have a good market maker.

[Vispilio]

There is no universal abstract perfect price movement for any asset, the charts you see are the tick data printed from exchange based trading activity...

Different exchanges list the same pairs, thus leading to different price action variations on the same underlying.

This is more rare in fiat asset classes because for traditional financial products it's much rarer for dual (or more) listings to occur, and even then usually they don't share the same symbol...

[michellee]

hello guys what do you think:
why different markets show different movement on the same pair?
why brokers do not use a certain chart for their deals?
is that possible for a broker to maintain a chart defines all of the market movement and everyone use it as the only single chart for this pair?

please give me your Idea on this 

That is because every market doesn't have the same number of traders who trade, so the market shows different movements. The brokers use different charts or indicators to trade, so they don't get the same point to enter or exit the trading. They also have different calculations about what is happening to current situations. But the price will not have too big a gap in the price, so that is not a problem for the traders.

The bigger the exchange will have big traders who trade on one pair to make the price moves fast than the other exchanges. If you comfort to stay at one exchange, you don't have to move to another exchange that has fast movement because that can confuse you to determine the time to trade.

[MI6]

If all exchange use the same idea of chart and uses all that chart in general then it is not a decentralized exchange anymore. If you can see we all have decentralized exchange meaning that every exchange the trader put price on the coin and so it would not be possible that all of the exchange have the same price.

[mu_enrico]

They have different price because they have different users and buyers and it's open market any one can set and buy from the exchange in the price they want  and no one can force and teach you when the price you want to buy it . It's always depend on the market and the liquidity of that exchange ..

True.

In theory, in efficient markets, we won't have a huge spread between exchanges because of

arbitrage

However, there are cases when the flows of funds are disrupted because of the regulation (crypto ban) and stuff. And it will lead to more risk (or more difficulties) of doing arbitrage, which resulted in a significant spread between some exchanges.

[Psynthax]

Because the chart in each exchange actually comes from the exchange user's activity on making buy and sell and not from external resource. The chart you usually sees in website like coinmarketcap are those charts of various exchanges blended into one altogether. it's just impossible for exchange to have the same movement because it doesn't make sense.

[Smartvirus]

It's lathing due to price variation between exchanges as the BID and ASK price varies amongst them, traders will always tend to trade where price is considered favourable to them and as such, the more volatile that exchange will tend to be and base on the prevailing news or circumstances, the trade placed on one exchange will always tend to move more faster than others. Though, I don't think it's going to be in a different direction, it's just the momentum that would vary slightly.

[FanEagle]

Because it is exchanged by different people and they are not connected to each other. There is rarely any big difference because if there were any big difference that would have meant that arbitrage traders would use that and close the gap while making a profit, however if there is smaller amount of difference with low volume that would usually mean arbitrage wouldn't be profitable and people would leave those small differences there.

When in one exchange there is a big buyer and not enough sellers price could go up and be different 1-2% at max, whereas all other exchanges do not have that whale or have enough volume to cover it. So, each exchange is making its own market without looking at others until the difference is huge enough for arbitrage.

[nelson4lov]

why brokers do not use a certain chart for their deals?
is that possible for a broker to maintain a chart defines all of the market movement and everyone use it as the only single chart for this pair?

please give me your Idea on this 

All exchanges always try to maintain the average price of any asset across their platforms but there is always room for arbitrage opportunities (A situation where traders can take advantage of higher prices on other exchanges). A lot of things determine the spread - volume, MM, liquidity, orderbook too. I think they do use an API in order to get updated price from other exchanges and then try to keep it as close as possible.

[CryptopreneurBrainboss]

hello guys what do you think:
why different markets show different movement on the same pair?

What you're demanding for will just make the trading experience boring as you won't be able to arbitrage trade with exchanges having different price for certain coins. Arbitrage trading is quite interesting because you make your profit almost instantly without having to wait for the market movement to go in your favour.

Adding to what others have said in regards to exchange having different price, it boils down to the trdaers on the exchange, the volumes plays a major role as it provide liquidity on the exchange and also gives room for this price difference to be created. On Binance, coins pumps quite easily compared to other exchange simply because the trading volumes are there.

[pankowri]

It makes the market more valuable when there has competition. The different market gives us a different pair, volume, liquidity so that the market gets traffic. So you don't need to be surprised if you have seen such things in different markets. It depends on volume and liquidity.

[palle11]

hello guys what do you think:
why different markets show different movement on the same pair?

I believe this is because it is a business and different exchanges have their way to make the business move and get their own profit. Some exchanges increase fees from platform and other aspect of the business is different from others. Because of that, someone who is expecting a particular strategy can choose above the other because of that maybe the aspect is there.

[seleme]

The first reason is the lack of centralization which exchanges can use as the main source for liquidity. If the liquidity is adjusted with the trading bots and the lag happens on the automated trades, the fluctuations on the market will happen in different order sizes. Binance became the main source nowadays but the Bitstamp rates were the original source years ago. Market fluctuations can change the daily trading behavior of crypto traders, so the exchanges can use this against the margin traders.