help, thebitcoinreview has a major porblem

[adamstgBit]

the question has come up.

Why should i trust any of the reviews posted on thebitcoinreview.com?

right now all i can say is anyone can write a review for any listing, but only one review per listing (based on their ip), this means someone would have to change his ip to write many reviews for the same listing.... thus making the reviews somewhat reliable.

this isn't good enough.

anyone have better ideas on how i can establish trusted reviews

note this site is meant to be used by non-tech people, and so making a review should be painless and require no tech. skills

[1714055508]

1714055508

[Raoul Duke]

Email validation before reviews go live should also help.
Ofcourse emails are like IP's, a dime a dozen, but it's one more loop.

[adamstgBit]

Email validation before reviews go live should also help.
Ofcourse emails are like IP's, a dime a dozen, but it's one more loop.

Thanks!

ya i thinking about that, all the ideas i came come-up with just make the user jump though hops to get the review online...
I wanted it to be Super easy to write a review, this is why i based it on ip so the user wouldn't even have to login.

I'm now toying with the idea of requiring a btc address & amount paid, as a proof of payment... needless to say this idea has problems aswell.

and / or

the more reviews they post the higher their reputation, the more impact their rating will have on the listings score.

[FreeMoney]

Paying came to my mind too, but users are less likely to pay X than a new business that needs quick reputation is.

I imagine a future where you sign nearly every posting (right click sign, easy as pie) and anyone can search the web for your other signed activity to make sure you are a person, and maybe even an honest one.

Of course just like bitcoin addresses you can make a new one any time and unlike bitcoin you won't as easily connect them unwittingly. Of course you could merge identities simply by stating it and signing with both keys.

[MaxSan]

use openID to verify. simple.

[zellfaze]

A combination of the above could work.  Require that they use OpenID or an email address to make the post and then charge them something in Bitcoin (like 0.001 BTC).  The amount in Bitcoin has to be small enough to not really matter to most people, but just having it there will make it that much harder (and expensive) to post fake reviews.  Anytime you ask people to pull out money, no matter how little, it gets them thinking twice about what they are doing.