Bitcoin Forum
November 18, 2026, 01:15:22 AM *
News: Latest Bitcoin Core release: 32.1 [Torrent]
 
   Home   Help Search Login Register More  
Pages: « 1 2 3 4 [5]  All
  Print  
Author Topic: Seed Generation in Hardware Wallets  (Read 1436 times)
dkbit98 (OP)
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 3150
Merit: 8993


AntiSwap.io - NO AML/KYC EXCHANGER MONITORING


View Profile WWW
September 04, 2026, 07:20:25 PM
 #81

There is one interesting new webiste that can be used for offline air-gapped devices only.
We had something similar in the past with Ian Coleman website, but in EntropyLab there are also dice, cards and other options included.
Everything is released as open source, and it is created by OogaBoogaX developer, but please READ carefully, and use at your own risk,
Note that this is early testing phase, and you should NOT use it as your main setup!


https://entropylab.online/
https://github.com/OogaBoogaX/entropylab

Forsyth Jones
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 2086
Merit: 2374


I love Bitcoin!


View Profile WWW
September 04, 2026, 07:47:39 PM
 #82

There is one interesting new webiste that can be used for offline air-gapped devices only.
We had something similar in the past with Ian Coleman website, but in EntropyLab there are also dice, cards and other options included.
Everything is released as open source, and it is created by OogaBoogaX developer, but please READ carefully, and use at your own risk,
Note that this is early testing phase, and you should NOT use it as your main setup!

Code:
[img height=335]https://www.talkimg.com/images/2026/09/04/UekToT.jpg[/img]
https://entropylab.online/
https://github.com/OogaBoogaX/entropylab
One of its advantages is that it creates the descriptor for supported wallets (like Bitcoin Core, Sparrow, etc), which makes things a bit easier. But, I still think Seed Tools is more complete, with this one, you have to constantly load the current wallet (copying and pasting the seed phrase).

Pmalek
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 3682
Merit: 9871



View Profile
September 12, 2026, 03:50:20 PM
Merited by vapourminer (1)
 #83

This doesn't really matter if you are using seed phrase generated with weak entropy.
One developer proved this with example of recent c0oldcard crap addresses, he added multiple passphrases with different complexities, and all addresses got emptied withing minutes.
You can't depend on strongest passphrase when weak base will crumble everything.
The passphrase can make no difference or an enormous difference, depending on its complexity. The examples that Dragon guy is talking about are all bad. Those are weak passphrases that can be bruteforced. Why didn't he do the same experiment with 6-8 words? Why didn't he do it with 10 words? 8 random words in lowercase and uppercase letters, maybe with a few numbers or special characters in the mix aren't hackable even with Coldcard's weak entropy of the foundation as you call it.

Does trezor really have a choice? If their entropy lags behind that of competitors, they will lose marketing ground (market share).
Trezor doesn't lag behind and isn't generating seeds with less entropy than the competition. What you are comparing is the entropy of a 12-word vs a 24-word seed. Of course the latter will have more entropy. It's got double the amount of words. Generate a 24-word seed with Trezor and you will get the same results assuming of course that everything is random enough.

▄▄███████████████████▄▄
▄███████████████████████▄
███████████████████▄█████
█████████████████████████
███████████▀█████████████
█████████▀███▀██████▀████
██████████████████▄██████
█████████▄▄█▄▄███████████
██████████▄▄▄████████████
███████████████████▀█████
████████████████▀▀███████
▀███████████████████████▀
▀▀███████████████████▀▀
 
 EARNBET 
|⚽ 🏀
 
🏈 🏓
 
🎯 🥊
 
⚾ 🎾
 
⛳ 🏐
 
🏏 🏎️
|


███████▄▄███████████
████▄██████████████████
██▄▀▀███████████████▀▀███
█▄████████████████████████
▄▄████████▀▀▀▀▀████████▄▄██
███████████████████████████
█████████▌████▀████████████
███████████████████████████
▀▀███████▄▄▄▄▄█████████▀▀██
█▀█████████████████████▀██
██▀▄▄███████████████▄▄███
████▀██████████████████
███████▀▀███████████

....HIGHEST....
VIP REWARDS

 ✔ G U A R A N T E E D  
| 
 🜲 
KING OF
THE CASTLE

$200K in prizes
| 
..PLAY NOW..
dkbit98 (OP)
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 3150
Merit: 8993


AntiSwap.io - NO AML/KYC EXCHANGER MONITORING


View Profile WWW
September 17, 2026, 09:01:10 PM
 #84

...maybe with a few numbers or special characters in the mix aren't hackable even with Coldcard's weak entropy of the foundation as you call it.
Sorry but that is simply not true and you don't know what you are talking about.
Sure anyone can create super complex mambo-jumbo passphrase with 1024 words and special symbols, in addition to their 12 or 24 words,
and this is the perfect recipe to lose access to all coins, if you don't write and backup that also.
Forgetting or losing passphrase is one of the main reason why people lose their coins, this is a fact.

Pmalek
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 3682
Merit: 9871



View Profile
September 18, 2026, 06:37:32 AM
 #85

Sorry but that is simply not true and you don't know what you are talking about.
Sure anyone can create super complex mambo-jumbo passphrase with 1024 words and special symbols, in addition to their 12 or 24 words,
and this is the perfect recipe to lose access to all coins, if you don't write and backup that also.
Forgetting or losing passphrase is one of the main reason why people lose their coins, this is a fact.
You are comparing apples to oranges, as they say. I wasn't talking about the difficulty of creating complex passphrases, the problem of backing them up, or entering them in a device to recover a wallet. Forgetting or losing passphrases wasn't the point of discussion either.

I will repeat. You will not be able to brute force a passphrase of 8 random words (or more) with today's technology without prior knowledge of the words and the construction of the passphrase. Add to that numbers, uppercase & lowercase letter, and special characters (as I said earlier) and the search space is simply to big to crack in any lifetime. If you claim the opposite, put some sources on the table. You were already asked about this earlier. The one-to-three-word-passphrase examples you showed earlier have nothing to do with what I am saying.

▄▄███████████████████▄▄
▄███████████████████████▄
███████████████████▄█████
█████████████████████████
███████████▀█████████████
█████████▀███▀██████▀████
██████████████████▄██████
█████████▄▄█▄▄███████████
██████████▄▄▄████████████
███████████████████▀█████
████████████████▀▀███████
▀███████████████████████▀
▀▀███████████████████▀▀
 
 EARNBET 
|⚽ 🏀
 
🏈 🏓
 
🎯 🥊
 
⚾ 🎾
 
⛳ 🏐
 
🏏 🏎️
|


███████▄▄███████████
████▄██████████████████
██▄▀▀███████████████▀▀███
█▄████████████████████████
▄▄████████▀▀▀▀▀████████▄▄██
███████████████████████████
█████████▌████▀████████████
███████████████████████████
▀▀███████▄▄▄▄▄█████████▀▀██
█▀█████████████████████▀██
██▀▄▄███████████████▄▄███
████▀██████████████████
███████▀▀███████████

....HIGHEST....
VIP REWARDS

 ✔ G U A R A N T E E D  
| 
 🜲 
KING OF
THE CASTLE

$200K in prizes
| 
..PLAY NOW..
Forsyth Jones
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 2086
Merit: 2374


I love Bitcoin!


View Profile WWW
September 18, 2026, 08:39:15 PM
Merited by Pmalek (3)
 #86

Sorry but that is simply not true and you don't know what you are talking about.
Sure anyone can create super complex mambo-jumbo passphrase with 1024 words and special symbols, in addition to their 12 or 24 words,
and this is the perfect recipe to lose access to all coins, if you don't write and backup that also.
Forgetting or losing passphrase is one of the main reason why people lose their coins, this is a fact.
You are comparing apples to oranges, as they say. I wasn't talking about the difficulty of creating complex passphrases, the problem of backing them up, or entering them in a device to recover a wallet. Forgetting or losing passphrases wasn't the point of discussion either.

I will repeat. You will not be able to brute force a passphrase of 8 random words (or more) with today's technology without prior knowledge of the words and the construction of the passphrase. Add to that numbers, uppercase & lowercase letter, and special characters (as I said earlier) and the search space is simply to big to crack in any lifetime. If you claim the opposite, put some sources on the table. You were already asked about this earlier. The one-to-three-word-passphrase examples you showed earlier have nothing to do with what I am saying.
A user can lose access to their wallet by losing or forgetting the seed phrase or passphrase, regardless of the seed phrase or the strength of the passphrase, it is the user's responsibility to store this sensitive data securely and responsibly. If the user loses or forgets either of these, it is their responsibility, their fault, and they must bear the consequences.

Of course, a strong passphrase helps enhance security by adding more data/entropy to the wallet, it can protect funds if the seed phrase's bit number and entropy are weak (as seen in cold_hack scenarios) and can also be used strategically to hide funds if someone finds your seed phrase or you are forced to hand it over. However, if your seed phrase has already been exposed to someone or leaked online, it would be wise to generate a new seed phrase (i think you don't even  need to create a new passphrase) and move your funds from there, once it's on the internet, who can guarantee that a bot isn't brute-forcing that specific seed phrase? I emphasize here, depending on the strength and length of the passphrase, it is impossible to get access to an hidden wallet protected by a strong passphrase.

In short, a passphrase can be used strategically for 2 purposes: protecting you against brute-force attacks on the seed phrase (of course, a weak passphrase or one consisting of only 2 or 3 words would be easily rekt) and providing plausible deniability. For the latter, it is a good idea to have "decoy wallets" containing a small amount of sats to convince an attacker that it is "all you have."

Cricktor
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 1680
Merit: 4696



View Profile
September 19, 2026, 08:40:49 AM
Merited by vapourminer (4), Pmalek (3)
 #87

In short, a passphrase can be used strategically for 2 purposes: protecting you against brute-force attacks on the seed phrase (of course, a weak passphrase or one consisting of only 2 or 3 words would be easily rekt) and providing plausible deniability. For the latter, it is a good idea to have "decoy wallets" containing a small amount of sats to convince an attacker that it is "all you have."
As long as the underlying entropy of a mnemonic seed phrase (the recovery words) isn't severely flawed and weakened by a defektive RNG or other stupid methods of bad entropy generation, I see no feasible way for brute-force attacks on a good entropy mnemonic seed phrase. There's not enough energy and time left to execute such an attacks on this planet or solar system we're bound to.

I see a use case for an additional mnemonic passphrase to protect a wallet from the risk that somehow the mnemonic seed phrase could become compromised, e.g. at a remote backup location which you can't control and monitor all the time.

For the "decoy wallet" with no added mnemonic passphrase I would recommend to use some "convincing" amount of coins, not just a "small amount" only. How much "convincing" might be, is at your discretion. You should also very much pay attention to have no connection of the sacrificial coins to your main stash, otherwise decoy won't quite work, the blockchain doesn't forget.

The "decoy wallet" also serves as a canary that your mnemonic recovery words have been exposed and compromised when it gets emptied by someone else than you. Therefore the need for a convincing decoy amount which likely will be swept by an attacker.

Another nice use case is that any unique mnemonic passphrase generates a new wallet if you need more than one. You could simply append a number to your mnemonic passphrase and count up for any new wallet you need. No additional redundant backups for the recovery words and base mnemonic passphrase needed which simplifies backup needs significantly.

Sure, this upcounting doesn't add much entropy to the new wallets. I'd argue that this isn't needed when the entropy of your recovery words and your base mnemonic passphrase part are good and strong enough, that brute-force attacks on them aren't any feasible at all.

For me this is simpler than multi-sig setups which have way more redundant backup fuss.

dkbit98 (OP)
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 3150
Merit: 8993


AntiSwap.io - NO AML/KYC EXCHANGER MONITORING


View Profile WWW
November 13, 2026, 06:39:11 PM
 #88

I didn't know where to write about this, but I found interesting new thing that can be used for generating entropy.
Modulo key is the name of the ''thing'', it's made from stainless steel, and it can be used as physical entropy generator.
It can be used for Bitcoin or anything else that requires entropy, and it has two versions 128-bits MINI key (12 words) and 256-bits FULL key (24 words).
Modulo key is working offline and it's fully compatible with BIP-39 and signing devices, with price ranging from $80 to $265.
For me this is better option than purchasing stainless steel metal plates because it can serve both as backup and entropy generator.


https://theleathermint.com/product/modulo-key/

decodx
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 1596
Merit: 1022



View Profile
November 13, 2026, 06:55:46 PM
 #89

Modulo key is the name of the ''thing'',
<...>

Cool-looking "thing", but I don't get how this actually works? I checked the website, but it doesn't say anything about the actual seed generation process, other than "the Modulo Key allows entropy to be created through the physical assembly of individual bits." Where does the randomness come from? From the user?

██████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████
███▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄█
██████████████▄▄██████████████████████████████████████████████████████████
█████████████████▄████████████████████████████████████████████████████████
█████████▀▀▀▀███████████▄▄▄▄▄████████▄▄▄▄▄▄██▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄██████████████████
█████████████▐███████▄█████████▄███▄██████████████████████████████████████
█████████▄▄▄▄█████▀█████████████████████▀▀▀███████████████████████████████
█████████████████▀██████████████████████████████▀███▀█████████████████████
████████████████▄███████████████▀███████████████▄███▄█████████████████████
███████████▀████████▀████▄▄▄▄▄▄▄██████████████████████████████████████████
████████████▀████████▀████████████████████████████████████████████████████
███▀▀▀▀▀▀██████▀▀▀▀█████▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀███▀▀▀▀▀█████▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄███▀▀▀▀▀██▀▀▀▀▀███
██████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████████

..WAGER ON  ❼ SLOTS  ⚂ ORIGINALS  ♣ POKER  TO GAIN  $REROLL..


..JOIN NOW..
Pmalek
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 3682
Merit: 9871



View Profile
November 14, 2026, 08:59:21 AM
 #90

Cool-looking "thing", but I don't get how this actually works? I checked the website, but it doesn't say anything about the actual seed generation process, other than "the Modulo Key allows entropy to be created through the physical assembly of individual bits." Where does the randomness come from? From the user?
This video shows how to assemble the key. It's better than reading the website description:
Modulo MINI 128-Bit | From Entropy to Bitcoin Seed Words

You build the key yourself by randomly adding the small pieces on the blades or whatever you want to call them. 128 small pieces exist for the mini version, 256 pieces for the full key (128 bits vs 256 bits of entropy). The pieces slide in place one way or the other and this I guess determines whether the value is 0 or 1.

When you put all the pieces in their place, you unscrew the bottom part. There should be some symbols at the bottom of the key. You pick one of the blades to start with and write down the bits on a piece of paper. I didn't understand this part myself. What determines a 0 and what a 1 Huh
The entropy is then converted into words from the BIP39 wordlist.

▄▄███████████████████▄▄
▄███████████████████████▄
███████████████████▄█████
█████████████████████████
███████████▀█████████████
█████████▀███▀██████▀████
██████████████████▄██████
█████████▄▄█▄▄███████████
██████████▄▄▄████████████
███████████████████▀█████
████████████████▀▀███████
▀███████████████████████▀
▀▀███████████████████▀▀
 
 EARNBET 
|⚽ 🏀
 
🏈 🏓
 
🎯 🥊
 
⚾ 🎾
 
⛳ 🏐
 
🏏 🏎️
|


███████▄▄███████████
████▄██████████████████
██▄▀▀███████████████▀▀███
█▄████████████████████████
▄▄████████▀▀▀▀▀████████▄▄██
███████████████████████████
█████████▌████▀████████████
███████████████████████████
▀▀███████▄▄▄▄▄█████████▀▀██
█▀█████████████████████▀██
██▀▄▄███████████████▄▄███
████▀██████████████████
███████▀▀███████████

....HIGHEST....
VIP REWARDS

 ✔ G U A R A N T E E D  
| 
 🜲 
KING OF
THE CASTLE

$200K in prizes
| 
..PLAY NOW..
Cricktor
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 1680
Merit: 4696



View Profile
November 14, 2026, 04:06:57 PM
 #91

From the website I couldn't quite figure out how it works, but the Youtube video that Pmalek linked made it pretty clear.

My personal opinion on this gadget:
Too many moveable parts, you're fine as long as the nut is screwed tightly. If this contraption still holds all stuff together after being submitted to intense heat? I can't tell. I can only hope that thermal expansion at relevant house fire temps doesn't play bad tricks with it.

My biggest critique is actually when a human picks the small pieces and constantly makes some decisions, even when those are somewhat subconscious; which slot, which way in the slot (resembling a '0' or a '1') and so on and forth. Even when the pile of small pieces is basically random, a human still makes some sort of decisions anyway.

OK, the end result might still be of good enough entropy. I just don't believe in humans producing random results in such a way necessary here with this gadget.

Next point of critique is that there are so many ways to make errors which potentially could shoot you in your foot. Getting the read-out of bits error-free is certainly possible, but I would highly recommend to do it in at least two independent passes and verify they match. Next is translating the 11-bits chunks into mnemonic recovery words, just another spot where an error could easily happen.

I wouldn't want to buy this, regardless of the price. That's maybe just me as I don't see it any superior to shaking 10 dice in a box and use those to create my own entropy. True, I need a tool to convert dice readings into a bitstream and finally to mnemonic recovery words, but this isn't a show-stopper for me. Doing all by hand is OK, but it's not OK if the chance for errors is significantly larger.

Meuserna
Sr. Member
****
Offline

Activity: 460
Merit: 875


View Profile WWW
November 14, 2026, 06:55:14 PM
 #92

I think Entropia by BTC Hardware Solutions is the best way to generate your own seed phrase randomly and manually.

Entropia is plastic seed words you dump in a bowl. Scramble 'em up. Pick a random word. Write it down. Put it back in the bowl and pick again. Do this 23 times and let a hardware wallet calculate the 24th word which serves as a checksum.

Easy.

You don't even have to buy it. They made it open source and share everything you need to do it yourself on github.

But even if you don't have access to a 3D printer (I don't!) you can easily take this same idea and do it manually.

One way is to print the words on paper and chop 'em up so you have each word on its own slip of paper. The easiest way to do this is to make a text document with a table (6 columns works nicely). Paste the BIP39 wordlist into the table. It works out to being 342 words per column across 6 columns (the last column will have 338). It ends up being around 6 pages.

I've been doing this for years... but Entropia by BTC Hardware Solutions is worth paying for if you ever teach Bitcoin self custody because the moment people see it... well... in my experience, it instantly clicks. It helps people think of seed words and Bitcoin self custody in a less abstract way.

I think Entropia is awesome.

Cricktor
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 1680
Merit: 4696



View Profile
November 15, 2026, 02:26:46 PM
Last edit: November 15, 2026, 03:23:30 PM by Cricktor
 #93

The Entropia pieces I could like more than self-made paper strips. See my concern below on the latter.
Post edit: what I don't quite like about the Entropia set is that it consists of 1024 pieces, so two recovery words per physical piece. It might not matter, but how do you determine which side you've picked?

If you'd spent money on Entropia, would you actually also check and verify that your set of 2048 pieces is complete? I mean, why wouldn't you. Don't trust, verify! Quite a tedious verification...


I've some small concerns with methods that use paper strips. If you're careful it might not be any issue. Just keep in mind what it actually tells you.

Regarding the setup of 2048 paper strips, each with a distinct mnemonic recovery word from the BIP39 wordlist. While you mix them up the following could pose an issue.
  • Paper strips can adhere to each other distorting a random distribution and mixup.
  • Paper strips can fold around others and create local chunks that don't easily separate and distort a random distribution and mixup.
  • When you use your hand to mix up the strips, your hand moves chunks of strips around which might stay more together than what you'd wish for a randomization mix-up.
  • There's maybe more, I'm not aware of. Personally, I find it a bit too tedious. The paper strips should be of same size, more or less accurately cut to not produce any inequality between them. How much would this matter? Frankly, I don't know. I wouldn't want to start the journey with this route, anyway. YMMV...

I hope you get the point of what kind of issues can happen with such a physical setup of stuff that's close together and which is not easily separated to produce a total random distribution of such stuff.

I don't want to dismiss such setups, just keep in mind what could happen and how it could affect the outcome. From just looking at a set of picks, you can't really tell if it's good entropy or not.

Know what you're doing, be aware of its limitations and potential issues. And, well, don't do stupid things, whatever they are, it's sometimes hard to tell. Wink

Meuserna
Sr. Member
****
Offline

Activity: 460
Merit: 875


View Profile WWW
November 15, 2026, 07:30:20 PM
 #94

Post edit: what I don't quite like about the Entropia set is that it consists of 1024 pieces, so two recovery words per physical piece. It might not matter, but how do you determine which side you've picked?

Which word did you read first? That's the word you picked. Or, drop the thing. The side that faces up is the side you chose.

Regarding the setup of 2048 paper strips, each with a distinct mnemonic recovery word from the BIP39 wordlist. While you mix them up the following could pose an issue.
  • Paper strips can adhere to each other distorting a random distribution and mixup.

That would be random, which means it just adds randomness to the randomness.

Actually, this is true for each issue you mentioned.

Remember: The point of randomness in a seed phrase is to make it impossible for anyone to predict your words. Since even you can't predict which two pieces of paper might get stuck together, you can't predict or even guess the results.

  • Paper strips can fold around others and create local chunks that don't easily separate and distort a random distribution and mixup.
  • When you use your hand to mix up the strips, your hand moves chunks of strips around which might stay more together than what you'd wish for a randomization mix-up.
  • There's maybe more, I'm not aware of. Personally, I find it a bit too tedious. The paper strips should be of same size, more or less accurately cut to not produce any inequality between them. How much would this matter? Frankly, I don't know. I wouldn't want to start the journey with this route, anyway. YMMV...

Each of those adds randomness if it happens, because a thief can't predict which of your pieces of paper might have been less likely to be chosen for whatever reason.

Randomness is part of the entropy.

But in my experience from doing this, none of those things actually happen. What happens is, you end up with a ton of little strips of paper in a large bowl. You have to use common sense. Only use a dry bowl... but that's so obvious, right?

The point I was making about using paper is, there are other ways of choosing random words from a predefined list, and that's exactly what a seed phrase is. It's random words from the BIP39 list, used as entropy.

I suspect some folks here are so used to computers doing the randomness that you think randomness needs to be computerized. Computers can't really do true randomness, which is why some hardware wallets like Trezor and DIY wallets like Krux bring in other unpredictable data to increase the randomness.

I think there's wisdom in not trusting code to generate a random seed phrase. ColdCard proved that.

Before ColdCard's mess, I used to tell people to let a hardware wallet generate a random seed, then wipe it out and generate another to see that it's random... but I was wrong because that doesn't prove the seed is random. An attacker could find a way to have the device spit out BIP85 child seeds. To the user, they'd look random, but they'd all come from the same parent seed and the user would never know.

I know my seeds are random because I did the work.

Pages: « 1 2 3 4 [5]  All
  Print  
 
Jump to:  

Powered by MySQL Powered by PHP Powered by SMF 1.1.19 | SMF © 2006-2009, Simple Machines Valid XHTML 1.0! Valid CSS!