It's very simple, we don’t even know if the answers refer to the same country and same taxation structures. So it really is hard to seek advice from everyone. Much better if you will seek and consult the tax professional so that they will guide you because they know more than us.
I guess that’s the reason why some answered incorrectly as they assumed that all of the structures are the same. But they definitely don’t.
And the golden rule: Do not seek tax advice from unknown people on the Internet.
Exactly, because they only based on what rumors they heard. Not on the fact.