<…>
As mentioned, at least one of those screenshots is displaying the trust scores using a Customized Trust List, or having modified the Trust depth.
What happens with a Customized list is that Trusted Feedback is conceptually moved between the "Trusted feedback" and the "Untrusted feedback", and since the counters display the scores according to the "Trusted feedback", these display different numbers depending on who is viewing the data.
Bear in mind, nevertheless, that 99,9% of the forum profiles use the DT2 depth 2 view, which is the default setting, so they all share a common visualization. In case you've got a Customized List, you can see the default view by adding ";dt" to the profile you are viewing on its URL (without adding the quotation marks).