there is no Play-to-Earn Game

[virasog]

As of this writing there is no play-to-earn games exist in the market. You must be saying Axie Infinity is one play to earn game and there are many more, but i will tell you that they are not play-to-earn games, they are infact play-to-earn jobs. 

Taking the example of Axie Infinity, you get game token SLPs when you do certain tasks in adventure mode and also complete daily tasks. This is like a job that you do daily and the maximum earning limited on daily is also fixed. You are allowed to take 20 turns and after that even if you play more, there is no reward. You are in fact doing job to collect the tokens.

Real games are like you play unlimited times daily and there should be no limit on the earnings or turns. The more you play and win, the more you should get the tokens. This realistic model of earning is missing in all the famous P2E games like Axie infinity or star sharks etc.

[jackg]

The limit is likely there for a good reason though and I think, without it, there would be much greater fluctuations on the market and potentially less demand on SLPs.

I think the initial investment in games like axie stop it from being as much of a play to earn game - though you can sell back your axies whenever you want just for a variable price.

[PX-Z]

Because it was considered as a "job", so it's not already a game? So you can't make a job out of the game? When it was considered as that?

It's like facebook, as a social media, just because anyone can make a job of out it, so it's not already considered as a social media? but a job? So what you can call that now?

I say, whether what you explains on how you can make a job, earn, win, lost, invest, sell, buy in the platform it is still the platform as it is, game, job is just another category is considered out of it.

[hd49728]

Have you known about this one?

Upcoming season 20 and economic balancing. SLP is no longer be earned by playing Axie Infinity in Adventure mode as well as in Daily quest

It is implemented because Axie Infinity team realize that their ecosystem is big enough and has jumped to a slow down period of its growth. Without huge new gamers, investors, its ecosystem becomes vulnerable to collapse if they don't have adjustment and maintain big rewards in Play to Earn mode.

[franky1]

The limit is likely there for a good reason though and I think, without it, there would be much greater fluctuations on the market and potentially less demand on SLPs.

simpler reason.

company only gets $WXYZ a day income from advertisers, sponsors and investors. and only wants to hand out $XYZ a day to users

meaning
10x users but same $WXYZ income now playing means only $YZ for users
or
10x less income means $XYZ income but same users means $YZ for users

[Amph]

those games are indeed a waste, and you also need to invest, it's not different than investing in a serious project and waiting for it to increase in value

they were probably profitable at the early stage....

[stompix]

Because it was considered as a "job", so it's not already a game? So you can't make a job out of the game? When it was considered as that?
~
It's like facebook, as a social media, just because anyone can make a job of out it, so it's not already considered as a social media? but a job? So what you can call that now?

Pretty simple.
You don't do the required task you don't earn money, you play how you want for fun you don't get a penny.
Same with Facebook and Instagram and Twitch you need to the things constantly be online every day to answer to your fans do what the fans want otherwise you make pennies not money, the moment you do whatever you want and do not care what others want from you is the moment you stop making money because you don't work anymore and you're having fun.

And to the poeple who will say but there are poeple out there who on youtube do the things they like, yeah, with one slight major difference. It takes an enormous amount of work to do those clips, I have a friend that is doing drawing lessons on yt, he often tells me he spends 10 times more time editing cutting and clipping, and redoing scenes than he is actually drawing stuff. Plus he only likes drawing some type of things, but he has to do every time something different there because he needs views, so in the end, is 1% fun 99% work.

The sister of my cousin-in-law is a photographer, I've driven her and her friends once to a lake for some pics, wouldn't call it cosplay but whatever it was it was pretty close, 5 hours plus 1-hour driving for about 40 pictures and I wasn't impressed by any to be honest, whatever.
Is that having fun or working your ass on a full schedule?

Have you known about this one?

Upcoming season 20 and economic balancing. SLP is no longer be earned by playing Axie Infinity in Adventure mode as well as in Daily quest

Oh, they've realized the money printing machine was printing worthless tokens that nobody wanted?

[Maus0728]

Real games are like you play unlimited times daily and there should be no limit on the earnings or turns. The more you play and win, the more you should get the tokens.

If these earning mechanism limit isn't applied, you'll end up with a fuck ton of useless tokens, which is a surefire recipe for disaster. They even need to slash the SLP issuance in ADV and Daily Quest to prevent the game's economy from the brink of collapse despite the fact that the earning limit is in place.

And yeah! After a long period of time, they now give a shit about the massive minting of SLP's  . And I hope that the other burning mechanism^[1] could be of any help with their current tokenomics problem.

[1] https://axie.substack.com/p/origin

[OgNasty]

As of this writing there is no play-to-earn games exist in the market. You must be saying Axie Infinity is one play to earn game and there are many more, but i will tell you that they are not play-to-earn games, they are infact play-to-earn jobs. 

Taking the example of Axie Infinity, you get game token SLPs when you do certain tasks in adventure mode and also complete daily tasks. This is like a job that you do daily and the maximum earning limited on daily is also fixed. You are allowed to take 20 turns and after that even if you play more, there is no reward. You are in fact doing job to collect the tokens.

Real games are like you play unlimited times daily and there should be no limit on the earnings or turns. The more you play and win, the more you should get the tokens. This realistic model of earning is missing in all the famous P2E games like Axie infinity or star sharks etc.

The video game grind is real.  I'm not sure how many games you've played lately, but the model for video games has been for a while that you grind doing tasks you otherwise wouldn't do for rewards that you probably don't care about.  At least with games like Axie Infinity you're grinding something you can sell.  It's just that we are very very early in this play to earn for crypto game.  It will probably be another 10 years before you're able to play Call of Duty and sell gun skins as NFTs.  Even then, I'm sure the tasks you'll have to do will feel like work instead of fun if you're doing it just for the money. 

The Sandbox is pretty cool and has lots of ways to earn money.  Maybe give that a look?

[kryptqnick]

The limit on earning doesn't automatically make it a job, and the way you describe going through adventures and doing some tasks as a job-like activity means that many games (even whole types of games, such as platformers) don't qualify as gaming experience for you. As for the limits, I think they should exist for various reasons: so that it's harder to abuse the system, so that nobody is motivated to spend as much time as possible in front of a screen, so that companies don't lose more money than they expect to lose.

[dothebeats]

I agree. Axie Infinity, over time, became somewhat of a job rather than a game, as everyone treats it as something that will always net them profit, and the enjoyment part is already taken away by the stress of grinding SLP, or to be part of the leaderboards to grind for more profit. Due to people's initial investment on Axie Infinity, they are obligated to play the game even though they are not into it, and most jobs feel like the same way, right?

[cheezcarls]

I only lasted 2 weeks playing Axie Infinity and I called it quit. Sold it back to another buyer at the same price that I've bought back then.

That was last year before the reduction of SLP rewards happened. I quit Axie because it wasn't for me. I find this game boring to be honest, especially if we grind everyday. Not all of us are gonna be satisfied with Axie Infinity.

It's like Axie is for everyone, but not for "everyone".

[Distinctin]

Game is a form of play or sport, especially a competitive one played according to rules and decided by skill, strength, or luck.

Definition of Game

Technically, Axie Infinity is a type of game where you can earn that's why it is dubbed and called a "Play-to-Earn". And of course every game has its own set of rules to be followed for the fairness of all who play it. Limiting the supply or earnings you collect per quest on daily basis has its own reason as well. It's up to your own perspective if you see and view Axie as a game or job, either way it doesn't matter as long as you're playing it.

[Kakmakr]

A lot of the previous Play-to-Earn types of games with no Cap or limit has been farmed to death by bots. This is why Axie Infinity universe is placing a cap on the tokens you can farm. (or in-game item called Smooth Love Potions)

It is still fun battling the monsters in Adventure Mode (PVE) and fighting other players in Arena Mode (PVP) and doing all the daily missions & quests. 

An Axie by the name of Angel was sold for $130,000 in 2020. (So if you a good breeder, you might make a ton of money)  or you can try the AXS staking... but I am not going to wait that long for my money to work. 

[DaveF]

How about CoinHunt.

https://coinhunt.world/
Or for a shameless referral link: https://coinhunt.gsc.im/8WhD8htct0

They were here on the forum a while ago but now are mostly on telegram.
Limited locations in the world (US / Canada / GB / a few other places) but they do pay and do exist.

BTC & ETH so not some fake token thing either.

Active development and contests.
No, you are not going to get rich, but you can make a buck or two.

-Dave

[seoincorporation]

A lot of the previous Play-to-Earn types of games with no Cap or limit has been farmed to death by bots...

This is the real problem about the Play-to-Earn games they can be automatized.

Some years ago I used to play FlappyCoin, and it was a Flappy bird version to earn BTC. But the bots made the owners lower the profit to users and in the end, they had to close it because the bots were getting more than 90% of the bankroll.

Even if you are running ADS in the app that will not be enough to pay the users, if someone wants to create a Play-to-Earn game they will have to put money from their pockets.

[amishmanish]

I don't think anybody is ever going to be serious about a P2E game. There is only so much real market and revenue you can generate from a set of zombies willing to just grind away at game after game in the hope of getting tokens. This is not sustainable as the space has no real gamers. Gamers do it for the fun of it.

Instead of P2E games, incorporating NFTs into games and making rarer achievements as NFTs can probably work. The game would need to have a scaled in-game economy for that . This can only be possible with a lot of passionate players and fans. Most of the games in P2E are just low effort in terms of the game graphics, mechanics and storyline. They are focussing on the greed of people rather than being great games to play.

[hatshepsut93]

I like this idea. Play-to-earn should really be called what it is - a microearning task, and everyone should realize that microearnings aren't worth anyone's time, not only because of tiny payment for hours of repetitive tasks, but also because there's no career growth in microearnings and no job security. Microearnings should be left only to the most uneducated and poor people on the planet, and something tells me that if someone can find this forum and knows English well enough to read it, they can already find much better job opportunities.

[RiskySanchez]

That's the reality, we all know some crypto game publishers that play to earn they all use an investment system first so they are eligible to earn profits. Honestly the games on Play to Earn are trash. This is a new method to attract players and use their money as an initial way to get players but by providing poor game quality and daily rewards. I'd rather play games like Pubg or Ragnarok which provide good quality games without payment

[julerz12]

As of this writing there is no play-to-earn games exist in the market. You must be saying Axie Infinity is one play to earn game and there are many more, but i will tell you that they are not play-to-earn games, they are infact play-to-earn jobs. 

Taking the example of Axie Infinity, you get game token SLPs when you do certain tasks in adventure mode and also complete daily tasks. This is like a job that you do daily and the maximum earning limited on daily is also fixed. You are allowed to take 20 turns and after that even if you play more, there is no reward. You are in fact doing job to collect the tokens.

Real games are like you play unlimited times daily and there should be no limit on the earnings or turns. The more you play and win, the more you should get the tokens. This realistic model of earning is missing in all the famous P2E games like Axie infinity or star sharks etc.

I guess the problem here is how you view it, you see it as a job because of the repetitive tasks? Well, hate to break it to you but that's how most games are built, endless repetitive tasks.
If you're looking for a game with no limitations on your daily activities then Axie Infinity is certainly not for you. That game is built that way, turn-based with limited moves, not much you can do about it.
Limitations on any online game are there for a reason. While many might not like it, it is a necessary step to avoid having the entire game get overwhelmed with cheaters and bots, and such.
These limitations are also put in place by developers to guard the in-game economy which is important for the longevity of the entire game. You will never find a game that has no limitations.