Does all the money from luna have to go somewhere?

[jackg]

I'm wondering if the money that might've been used to dca or diversify into luna from some crypto investors have already noticeably been put into other coins and had an impact on them.

Considering $10-20bn in liquid assets might've had to be reassigned quickly and a lot of people who understood the fundamentals of luna probably converted their ust and sold each for a dollar (and dumped their luna too) - but I'm not sure if this actually happened much or how much ust there were before the crash.

[mk4]

Before the crash, UST had a marketcap of around $18.5b, and in just around 6 days it's down to around $1.4b. All that sold UST was mostly sold for Curve-supported stablecoins like DAI/USDT/USDC as they had the most on-chain liquidity.

[hatshepsut93]

Marketcaps are not a good methods to measure how much money actually got moved. It should be possible to pull the data on all the transactions and their value to know exactly how much money was moved out of Luna, especially if it happened on-chain and not centralized exchanges, because the latter probably don't keep their logs publicly available for many days.

[AmoreJaz]

Marketcaps are not a good methods to measure how much money actually got moved. It should be possible to pull the data on all the transactions and their value to know exactly how much money was moved out of Luna, especially if it happened on-chain and not centralized exchanges, because the latter probably don't keep their logs publicly available for many days.

what i am wondering here is that the team is claiming that they haven't benefited from this crash? then who? those large holders? but how did they know that it was time to cash out and buy another stablecoin or alt? i have the feeling that there's inside job in this situation. a large amount of money got liquidated for few days and nobody knows anything? that's bs! and now, do kwon is trying to save his face by introducing their luna 2.0? i hope people are not dumb enough to fall for another crap.

[jackg]

Before the crash, UST had a marketcap of around $18.5b, and in just around 6 days it's down to around $1.4b. All that sold UST was mostly sold for Curve-supported stablecoins like DAI/USDT/USDC as they had the most on-chain liquidity.

I'd imagine if that happened then any salvaged luna that was sold - it wasn't too low when the peg first fell, I think it dropped by about a third in the first 12 hours - was probably converted to coins like eth to have a stake in the ecosystem with a lot less of the risk too then.

those large holders? but how did they know that it was time to cash out and buy another stablecoin or alt?

You might want to check their website's quick explanation video on how luna works to understand this better or see if it clicks while you watch it but essentially:
The protocol is based on the idea that a UST was always equal to a dollar of luna and a dollar of luna always equalled a UST (the luna and UST could both be minted via an interaction with their smart contracts on chain). When UST finally fell and lost its peg, each UST could still be burnt for a dollar's worth of luna causing that to crash too as the price of UST wasn't sustained - essentially, you could buy a dollar of luna for 95 cents for a while (and then 60 cents). The smallest losers in this scenario were the UST holders.

i have the feeling that there's inside job in this situation. a large amount of money got liquidated for few days and nobody knows anything? that's bs!

Terra Luna's redit made for an interesting read for me when this initially broke and more things have come to light since - apparently SK law enforcement have made attempts to freeze the assets of anyone involved with luna (afaik - there was a tweet about stopping any reserve funds from being moved out of their accounts).

It's speculated Do Kwon did a large OTC transfer just before that to trade newly minted UST for BTC (or something).

and now, do kwon is trying to save his face by introducing their luna 2.0? i hope people are not dumb enough to fall for another crap.

This has probably done even worse for his repuation and the price of original Luna (since even its creator has abandoned the coin).

Marketcaps are not a good methods to measure how much money actually got moved. It should be possible to pull the data on all the transactions and their value to know exactly how much money was moved out of Luna, especially if it happened on-chain and not centralized exchanges, because the latter probably don't keep their logs publicly available for many days.

This was something I've been thinking would be quite interesting, I might try to get a script going if I can find ethereum blockchain data for the past few weeks as exchanges like uniswap will definitely show up there.

[adaseb]

It’s like the stock market regarding market caps. Some stocks have market caps in the trillions like Apple however that just means if everyone sold at the last traded price which obviously is impossible unless an equal amount of bids were at that price.

When in reliability all it takes is a small percentage of that market cap in sell pressure to reduce the market cap by like half or so.

Same with Luna. Most bought it when it was cheap and never sold. And some bought it a few months back when they were buying BTC to fund the stable coin. And that money is gone now.

[Ojengonggu]

Before the crash, UST had a marketcap of around $18.5b, and in just around 6 days it's down to around $1.4b. All that sold UST was mostly sold for Curve-supported stablecoins like DAI/USDT/USDC as they had the most on-chain liquidity.

But you can see that the current sales volume is decreasing again, even there are only around 338 million left and this is a sign that UST has a very big impact due to the problems that Luna is experiencing.
I hope everything gets better soon

[hugeblack]

I think that most of the trading volume went to Binance, considering the high trading volumes, and most of the bitcoin went to that platform.
As for altcoins (a lot of USDT were burned), I think most of them went to decentralized platforms like Curve.

Generally, there is a manipulation of prices, so if a good investigation is opened, you will find that most of these currencies were sold to Bitcoin again or withdrawn to cash, given that the market capacity of USDT has greatly decreased after 10/May.

[mk4]

But you can see that the current sales volume is decreasing again, even there are only around 338 million left and this is a sign that UST has a very big impact due to the problems that Luna is experiencing.

I mean, it obvious decreased because a lot of people have sold already.

I hope everything gets better soon

Lol this isn't getting any better. They're trying to revive the chain with a hard fork (turning the old chain into Terra Classic), but the damage has been done. Do Kwon and the Terra project has already lost it's reputation. It's just going to temporarily be a traders haven for now — with them taking advantage of the ignorant few that's still going to buy in to their promises.

[davis196]

Before the crash, UST had a marketcap of around $18.5b, and in just around 6 days it's down to around $1.4b. All that sold UST was mostly sold for Curve-supported stablecoins like DAI/USDT/USDC as they had the most on-chain liquidity.

This might be good news, because a big portion of those stablecoins might get converted back to BTC, when the bloodbath is over and the market goes into another bull run.
I don't know how much did Do Kwon profit from the Terra/Luna project? He must be hiding big amounts of BTC/altcoins and fiat money somewhere.
I hear rumors that Tether might cause next big cryptocurrency price crash, but this might be just some FUDsters trying to spread panic.

[mk4]

This might be good news, because a big portion of those stablecoins might get converted back to BTC, when the bloodbath is over and the market goes into another bull run.

If this was in 2016-2018 I'd agree, but we already have USDC and USDT. The only reason they'd convert to BTC is if they think that it would go up, in which they'd already be holding BTC if they actually think that.

I hear rumors that Tether might cause next big cryptocurrency price crash, but this might be just some FUDsters trying to spread panic.

People have been saying this since like 2017 if I remember correctly.

[wiss19]

This might be good news, because a big portion of those stablecoins might get converted back to BTC, when the bloodbath is over and the market goes into another bull run.

If this was in 2016-2018 I'd agree, but we already have USDC and USDT. The only reason they'd convert to BTC is if they think that it would go up, in which they'd already be holding BTC if they actually think that.

That is what he is saying as well. That money may have gone to USDT or USDC or BUSD, but at the end of the day when people think that the market is reversing, they could buy it. That's exactly what he said, otherwise why would they buy right now, if they do not think that it wouldn't go up.

So, you guys are saying the same thing, it may not be used to buy bitcoin as of right now like you said, but it could be used later on to buy bitcoin later on when it starts to go back up like he said. Simply put, money doesn't disappear in the market unless withdrawn to bank accounts, which may have happened a bit, but all the other ones are still in the market.

[Dhaniii]

In my opinion, between large investors and Luna coin owners, their contracts have been cancelled, so investors' funds that are already in liquidity should be transferred to other, more secure and stable coins. many small investors and amateurs who suffered losses due to disputes that occurred so that this case was considered a deliberate accident.

[Renampun]

I'm wondering if the money that might've been used to dca or diversify into luna from some crypto investors have already noticeably been put into other coins and had an impact on them.

Considering $10-20bn in liquid assets might've had to be reassigned quickly and a lot of people who understood the fundamentals of luna probably converted their ust and sold each for a dollar (and dumped their luna too) - but I'm not sure if this actually happened much or how much ust there were before the crash.

what happened to LUNA I suspect there is a scenario behind it...

I also think that is it a technical fault for the crash that occurred in LUNA? maybe this was carefully planned a long time ago! Terra (Luna) has done a rebranding, it looks like they are planning to do this again, hopefully binance doesn't list this token.

[adaseb]

Luna has a lot of conspiracy behind it. After the fact many people came out and said they knew it was going to fail, basically they all said that in hindsight.

There is fud in every coin pretty much even today. Eventually some of those fud will turn out to be true and people will start bragging that they were right from the beginning.

[pooya87]

I hear rumors that Tether might cause next big cryptocurrency price crash, but this might be just some FUDsters trying to spread panic.

All shitcoins are going to fail at some point, one after another and Tether is not an exception to this rule. The more centralized and useless they are the higher the chance of failure. But nobody can predict when they are going to fail just like they couldn't predict Luna's failure date only that it will fail.

[fzkto]

Before the crash, UST had a marketcap of around $18.5b, and in just around 6 days it's down to around $1.4b. All that sold UST was mostly sold for Curve-supported stablecoins like DAI/USDT/USDC as they had the most on-chain liquidity.

But you can see that the current sales volume is decreasing again, even there are only around 338 million left and this is a sign that UST has a very big impact due to the problems that Luna is experiencing.
I hope everything gets better soon

How can UST stabilise or recover if the developers have made a new fork of LUNA with no peg to Stablecoin? I think everyone will soon forget about it and use new network, although I don't see why it's  needed at all after such a rollercoaster ride. It wouldn't be a bad idea to put these scammers in prison.

[PrimeNumber7]

Marketcaps are not a good methods to measure how much money actually got moved. It should be possible to pull the data on all the transactions and their value to know exactly how much money was moved out of Luna, especially if it happened on-chain and not centralized exchanges, because the latter probably don't keep their logs publicly available for many days.

what i am wondering here is that the team is claiming that they haven't benefited from this crash? then who? those large holders? but how did they know that it was time to cash out and buy another stablecoin or alt? i have the feeling that there's inside job in this situation. a large amount of money got liquidated for few days and nobody knows anything? that's bs! and now, do kwon is trying to save his face by introducing their luna 2.0? i hope people are not dumb enough to fall for another crap.

There was apparently a large holder of the "stablecoin" that was "backed" by luna that was in a lending platform that was paying high interest rates for coin stored there. There are reports that this large holder quickly exchanged their stablecoin for various stablecoins and for luna (which they subsequently sold).

The above holder apparently sold enough for the stablecoin to fall below its $1 peg, and eventually, confidence in the stablecoin was lost, and the price of luna fell through the floor.

I hear rumors that Tether might cause next big cryptocurrency price crash, but this might be just some FUDsters trying to spread panic.

Tether is backed by actual assets that are liquid, and USDT can be exchanged for real dollars. If the price of USDT falls far enough below $1, traders will buy USDT at market prices, and will exchange those USDT for actual dollars to make an arbitrage profit.

[GreatArkansas]

This might be good news, because a big portion of those stablecoins might get converted back to BTC, when the bloodbath is over and the market goes into another bull run.

If this was in 2016-2018 I'd agree, but we already have USDC and USDT. The only reason they'd convert to BTC is if they think that it would go up, in which they'd already be holding BTC if they actually think that.

I hear rumors that Tether might cause next big cryptocurrency price crash, but this might be just some FUDsters trying to spread panic.

People have been saying this since like 2017 if I remember correctly.

UST (Terra Luna) is different from USDT and USDC, I believe that UST started as an experiment stablecoin and which cause this tragedy. With how the Terra works, their Luna and UST work, it's unique and I believe it is very useful but the only worst happened, they didn't expect it and I believe there are also some mistakes from the team behind Luna. They can fix this issue but the trust of the people is impossible to fix.

[mk4]

That is what he is saying as well. That money may have gone to USDT or USDC or BUSD, but at the end of the day when people think that the market is reversing, they could buy it. That's exactly what he said, otherwise why would they buy right now, if they do not think that it wouldn't go up.

So, you guys are saying the same thing, it may not be used to buy bitcoin as of right now like you said, but it could be used later on to buy bitcoin later on when it starts to go back up like he said. Simply put, money doesn't disappear in the market unless withdrawn to bank accounts, which may have happened a bit, but all the other ones are still in the market.

Sure, but you're saying this as if it's guaranteed for these people to buy bitcoin again sometime in the future and that a lot of them wouldn't withdraw to banks. A lot of them will buy in the future, but a lot of them would withdraw the stables to banks as well. Especially knowing that we're talking to mostly retail investors here.