Why Some People think that long term Bitcoin holding is a dumb idea?

[fennic]

I saw some people saying that long term holders are dumb because they keep holding on the losses and this is a stupid meme. But i don't agree with that, since we believe btc will grow even more. What do you think?
In my opinion that Both short term and long term have their own advantages and disadvantages. With long term, you may get bigger reward without taking much hassle. On the other hand, with short term, you have to follow a lot of things.
Long term investments are sometimes risky in case of cryptocurrency space, you know a lot of altcoin have disappear and it's possible that your holding will not be existed someday. On the other hand, short term investors can move anywhere since they are updated with the market.
I personally prefer long term holding but of course only the top ranked coin.

Still not got any merit, just kidding 😂

[crwth]

People who say something like that only look at a small part of the whole picture. They probably think they can time the market with all the opportunities it gives, and just dollar cost averaging bitcoin is a bad idea. That is just a short-term mindset; we need to be looking forward.

If the holders had sold their positions, they wouldn’t have probably been where they are now, enjoying the fruits of holding it.

To make it easier, just do what you want, believe in, and don't care about what other people say.

[Asiska02]

Whether you hold investments for the long term or the short term, it depends on your point of view and how mentally prepared you are to begin investing. Both have benefits and drawbacks.

As a long-term investor, you'll have a thorough grasp of the market and be able to avoid losses and gain profit when the time is right. Depending on how dedicated you are, these methods may take you longer for you to learn and begin reaping the benefits.

Investors that invest for the short term should be willing to lose what they can afford; they don't risk their whole savings account in the hopes of making a quick, large profit. Let me suggest that it's a 50/50 chance for you, more like gambling. Investors in short-term investments don't require a thorough understanding of the market because they can sell their investments as soon as they have made a small profit.

[lovesmayfamilis]

You write in the section about Bitcoin. So I think it's the other way around. Those who are ready to hold bitcoin will make a profit. Bitcoin will not go anywhere, which cannot be said about alternative coins. Honestly, I only read such nonsense from you, so you need to reconsider your views. You probably still do not understand the full value of Bitcoin.

[pooya87]

I honestly have not seen anybody who actually thinks holding bitcoin in long term is a bad idea! There are definitely a lot of idiots who spread FUD but even those people don't think that since they are buying bitcoin themselves, specially in the dips.
13 years of going up and more up has proven that.

[bakasabo]

People that are new to cryptocurrency (bought Bitcoin at $69k, year has passed, not price is $20k, long term holding is a failure), can only think of such think or people to whom "long term = several months". Such people see that during several months the price of Bitcoin barely changed, then they look on inflation chart and make their "smart" conclusions that "inflation > Bitcoin price growth = long term holding is dumb".

[mirakal]

I'm not sure but I think they don't mean bitcoin alone because if that's what they are thinking, what could be their basis to say that hodling long-term is a bad idea. It's the exact opposite, long-term will give you the profits you want but enduring the seasons will always test you and your patience especially if you're that someone who often looks at the market situation and price.

[348Judah]

I saw some people saying that long term holders are dumb because they keep holding on the losses and this is a stupid meme. But i don't agree with that, since we believe btc will grow even more

I want to believe that this same set of people does not invest in bitcoin, but have you personally make some moves or attempts to find out the reality with choosing bitcoin, holding it and then the appropriate time to selling it, if you may need a good positioner to learning this then the bitcoin history right from 2009 price to 2022 current price will give you every solution and answers to counter those people saying what they don't know,

In my opinion that Both short term and long term have their own advantages and disadvantages

We need to fish out the truth here, there's no magic in dealing with bitcoin, if you don't know how to trade don't start yet until you learn, if you want to invest as well, give it time to mature and during that process, seek to acquire more knowledge on bitcoin investment, if you do it the wrong way you will always loose and have bad result, so either long or short term investment needs adequate knowledge to when you need to buy, sell, hold and the strategies involved, your first security asset is your knowledge.

[Oasisman]

I saw some people saying that long term holders are dumb because they keep holding on the losses and this is a stupid meme. But i don't agree with that, since we believe btc will grow even more. What do you think?
In my opinion that Both short term and long term have their own advantages and disadvantages. With long term, you may get bigger reward without taking much hassle. On the other hand, with short term, you have to follow a lot of things.
Long term investments are sometimes risky in case of cryptocurrency space, you know a lot of altcoin have disappear and it's possible that your holding will not be existed someday. On the other hand, short term investors can move anywhere since they are updated with the market.
I personally prefer long term holding but of course only the top ranked coin.

I'm kinda confused whether you're talking about Bitcoin or you're talking about altcoins lol.
Both have their own risk though.
Those who says Bitcoin hodling is a dumb way of investing are either anti Bitcoin or trying to drag down Btc's price.
But then again, I'm kinda confused whether you're talking about Bitcoin or altcoin. Does these people mean hodling Bitcoin is dumb? Or altcoin? Lol. 

[Hyphen(-)]

Long-term Bitcoin investors have a high level of trust in Bitcoin and believe that it will be worth more than what people expect, which is why they buy Bitcoin to hold for an extended period of time. Imagine people who bought Bitcoin in early 2009/2010 and are still holding today; if they are still holding, they would be multi-millionaires; some of them are still holding because they trust the process.
There is no doubt that both short-term and long-term investors profit, but long-term investors benefit more.

[TheUltraElite]

Long term holding is good but cycling the money to buyback at the low and selling at the high also needs to be done to keep the profit flowing in every few weeks. There needs to be a good balance between these two because the stupid thing to do here is to convert to day trading a few days after starting long term, which is commonly done by impatient newbies.

Nothing is stupid as long as you are making money from it. If you are making it work, you are the boss. I found buyback and selling at the top in fractions of the entire portfolio worked and hence I am confident about it.

[Kemarit]

I saw some people saying that long term holders are dumb because they keep holding on the losses and this is a stupid meme. But i don't agree with that, since we believe btc will grow even more. What do you think?
In my opinion that Both short term and long term have their own advantages and disadvantages. With long term, you may get bigger reward without taking much hassle. On the other hand, with short term, you have to follow a lot of things.
Long term investments are sometimes risky in case of cryptocurrency space, you know a lot of altcoin have disappear and it's possible that your holding will not be existed someday. On the other hand, short term investors can move anywhere since they are updated with the market.
I personally prefer long term holding but of course only the top ranked coin.

Of course, only those who have been in the market for so long known this, for those who are saying that long term holders are dumb, probably are those short term speculators and traders or those who missed the boat and wanted to buy at cheap price by creating this idea that holders should sell. I'm not sure about altcoin, but if you have seen bitcoin tremendous growth just like in the last bear and bull run, from $3k to $69k, that is a huge profit already for holding like 3 years.

[Jawhead999]

Long term investments are sometimes risky in case of cryptocurrency space, you know a lot of altcoin have disappear and it's possible that your holding will not be existed someday. On the other hand, short term investors can move anywhere since they are updated with the market.

Who did suggest you to hold shitcoins for long term purpose? there's no reason to hold shitcoins for long term due to it's high risk.

I personally prefer long term holding but of course only the top ranked coin.

Actually top ranked coin doesn't guarantee the coin wouldn't become scam or dead coin. Have you remember with LUNA? it's a coin which ever reach top 10 on CMC before, but after they suffered hack, now the coin price is worthless and drop to 33th position. Most of investors has no choice rather than hold it until the price can came back like the previous ATH.

Don't get blinded with the position on CMC, it's useless. Just stick with Bitcoin.

[8rch7]

If anyone thinks that holding bitcoins long term is a stupid idea, then I can confirm that people who make such statements are actually stupid, maybe they are saying that because they want to provoke people holding bitcoins to scare people, in fact everyone already knows . that long-term investments are made as a way to get big profits from time to time, we also don't need to monitor market movements every minute, like trading, of course the profits we get are different, because they are different from trading.

[Frankolala]

 I don't think your are talking about bitcoin because bitcoin price is volatile, long term has benefits in so many trade how much about bitcoin holdings. The volatility is its nature and in every bull or bear market the advantages are always more than the disadvantage.

The people that bought when its bull market are now regretting because they don't understand how bitcoin works if no,t why will they be in a rush to sell,long term means a long period of time. Let people stop giving wrong information on bitcoin since they are not bitcoin analyst.

[SquirrelJulietGarden]

I can say the opposite, if you don't hold your Bitcoin long enough, you are dumb enough.

Holding your Bitcoin and in the meantime, you can still work to get salary. The Bitcoin you hold will be like your saving. If you want to hold your Bitcoin, you must avoid to store it on exchanges. Because if you look at it every day, you will almost impossible to hold it long enough.

Emotionally, who can reject to take profit if price of Bitcoin increases 30% or 50% but you won't get rich if you take profit at 30% or 50% rate.

[Rruchi man]

I personally prefer long term holding but of course only the top ranked coin.

Bitcoins remain the best option for long-term holding,  and it is adviced that you hold for as long as possible if you wish to enjoyed for benefits and reward for your patience and holding onto bitcoin over the years. And it would remain that many people do not have the understanding of the importance to hodl, hence they will criticize and speak bad about others who have been holding for long time.

I saw some people saying that long term holders are dumb because they keep holding on the losses and this is a stupid meme.

Also some of people do not have the discipline to hold for long-term so they say all these sort of things to make themselves feel better.

[Rockstarguy]

The problem people have about bitcoin they try to predict the time when they can make profit from bitcoin. Bitcoin is volatile which no one can predict how the market is going, when these set of people lost their patience to them they totally give up on bitcoin and feel like what they want from bitcoin can't be achieved. People who always complain about bitcoin are just greedy set of people who are not ready to understand that bitcoin is always profitable when it is invested for long-term.

[bitzizzix]

Perhaps what people mean by saying long-term bitcoin holders are stupid is that long-term holders are stupid for not notifying or inviting them at the time. So they feel jealous or regret when the bitcoin price reaches 60K more than the very low price.
I don't understand people saying that, because the bitcoin price trail is proof that long term is a smart choice. And also evidence that a lot of new rich people or those who are already rich are getting richer because of bitcoin, because they are long term holders or strong hands.

[kryptqnick]

I don't know which meme the op is referring to, but I believe whether hodling makes sense depends on a situation and a coin. If it's an altcoin which suffered from an exit scam or something very similar, then it's best to cut the losses and pull out. The chances of it being fixed and recovering are low and losing more is making things worse. If it's Bitcoin and nothing truly devastating happened to it (which is so far the case), then the chance of recovery seems very high and thus hodling through the bear market gives a real prospect of making profit instead of cutting losses. As for dependence on a situation, I think a person should sell if the money is truly needed or if a person could use it now (not urgent, but still significant) and it's not at a big loss or is at some profit.