Question About Report to moderator

[Sarah Azhari]

I have 2 reports, so far all my reporter is good, the question is,
1. how to look the history report?,
because I have noticed: You have reported 2 posts with 100% accuracy., which mean all my 2 report is perfect.

I am just curious about 1 of my reports that feel is looking bad, I reported 1 thread to move to economic board, but when I look again the thread has moved to the bitcoin discussion board, which means I have a bad report?, correct if I am mistaken.

so in this case,
2. if the moderator moves the topic, whatever the reporter did (if not in accordance with the board) will mark as good?

[1715263336]

1715263336

[1715263336]

1715263336

[1715263336]

1715263336

[1715263336]

1715263336

[1715263336]

1715263336

[Despairo]

1. how to look the history report?,

After you make 300 good reports.

I am just curious about 1 of my reports that feel is looking bad, I reported 1 thread to move to economic board, but when I look again the thread has moved to the bitcoin discussion board, which means I have a bad report?, correct if I am mistaken.

Usually moderators are not really demand 100% correct report, even if you say you report the post should be moved to economic board, but if the thread is more correctly to be moved to Bitcoin discussion board, your report wouldn't become bad report. It still a good report if you report for a correct reason, although it could be a soft-bad report.

2. if the moderator moves the topic, whatever the reporter did (if not in accordance with the board) will mark as good?

Yes.

[_morghulis]

I myself have reported a post that fail to provide the correct reference link to where he/she copied the article they posted, I guess mine must have been marked as good since the post got deleted. It actually feels good to see mods respond to your reports.

anyway I guess this quoted post answers your question.

Report History
Only users who have reported 300 good reports have access to this page
This is probably one of the most useful features related to reporting. Basically, this shows you a history of your reports, and whether they have been marked good, bad or are unhandled. This page can be used for ongoing evaluation of your reporting habits. Use the information on this page to improve the quality of your posts.

full thread here: [Unofficial Guide] Reporting effectively

~valar~

[yahoo62278]

You may not get 100% accuracy, it's not really a big deal. Just keep reporting what you think is an infraction. I wouldn't worry about how many good or bad or even the number of reports you do, just trying to help is enough.

[Shaha98]

Moderators are always searching for the right information but cannot search for all of it. If your post is moved to the economic thread Transfer if you think is correct. But since you've created a board other than Bitcoin Bot, here's yours The report will be good. I think you'll do best posting on Bitcoin Sed.

[hosseinimr93]

2. if the moderator moves the topic, whatever the reporter did (if not in accordance with the board) will mark as good?

As far as I know, if you report a topic and the topic is moved to another board, the moderator must select the status (bad or good) manually. So, it's not that your report would be definitely marked as good. That depends on the moderators' decision.
It's also possible that a moderator see your report, mark it as bad and don't take any action on the post. Then another moderator move the topic. In this case, your report will be still bad.

[Pmalek]

As far as I know, if you report a topic and the topic is moved to another board, the moderator must select the status (bad or good) manually. So, it's not that your report would be definitely marked as good. That depends on the moderators' decision.

That's a good report if you ask me. By reporting a thread to be moved, what you are saying is this thread doesn't belong in this sub. Please take a look at it and consider moving it to sub X. The fact alone that you are correct and the discussion doesn't belong there should be enough for your report to be marked as 'good'. Maybe you were wrong about the final destination, and that decision in on the moderator, but you were right about where it doesn't belong.

[acroman08]

2. if the moderator moves the topic, whatever the reporter did (if not in accordance with the board) will mark as good?

As far as I know, if you report a topic and the topic is moved to another board, the moderator must select the status (bad or good) manually. So, it's not that your report would be definitely marked as good. That depends on the moderators' decision.
It's also possible that a moderator see your report, mark it as bad and don't take any action on the post. Then another moderator move the topic. In this case, your report will be still bad.

I've had dozen/s of reports where I put where I think the thread should be but it was instead put on another board, yet my report was still marked as good(at least as far as I remember). I guess as long the moderator agrees that the thread should not be in that board the report will be marked as good, despite them not following where you think the thread should go.

[lovesmayfamilis]

OP, you must understand that you are not the only one submitting the report. Simultaneously, someone submits the exact same report, claiming that the topic belongs in the Bitcoin section. 
The moderator agreed with one of the reporters and moved the topic to a more appropriate place. 
As for the moved topic, if the move request was correct, then the report will look good. 
As an example, today's topic, originally posted in the meta, has moved to the reputation section.

[hosseinimr93]

That's a good report if you ask me.

I completely agree with you. That's a good report.
My point was that it's not that the report is marked as good automatically if the topic move to another board. As the moderator must select the status manually, it's possible that the report is marked as bad.

As far as I know, when a post is reported and the post is deleted, the report is automatically marked as good even if you have reported the post for something else.
It's not the same when a post is moved. The decision should be made by the moderator and I agree that the moderator should mark the report as good.

[BitcoinGirl.Club]

Why are some of you too serious about reporting and it's stats? LOL

My reporting accuracy is 89%.
Who can tell after all these years how many reports I made?
I have some BTC to spare, 0.00098414 BTC.
Closest one will receive 0.0003 BTC

Rest will be sent to two more members.
You will post the number of total reports you made so far.
The top two will get the reward.

Highest number will receive 0.0004 BTC
The 2nd highest will receive the rest excluding the fees the transaction need
Don't cheat LOL

Shall we go?
Post your btc address with answer. Deadline is 31 October midnight forum time 😂

Staff, moderator and admin are excluded 😉

[BitcoinGirl.Club]

Staff, moderator and admin are excluded 😉

I expect LoyceV and other user who make statistic thread would be happy to make extrapolated assumption.

Additionally LoyceV can not join. Human only. 🤣

I sent a self message with the number of reports I made so far. In case it requires to prove then the PM will be reported to the staff.

[aysg76]

I think you should not worry a lot about accuracy of your reports and keep working on it as moderator will take action according to what they find suitable and mark your report as good.In your case if it's moved to bitcoin discussion instead of other board your recommended because someone else might have said so or moderator find it perfect board for that particular thread but still your report should be marked as good.

I expect LoyceV and other user who make statistic thread would be happy to make extrapolated assumption. Anyway, here's my guess.

I know a name which has really high amount of reports submitted and with good mark and he is none other then @Ratimov who has also previously dedicated a thread for it here in which he has submitted 100,000 reports as good so this is old record so he might have gone above it not checked now so one of top in this matter.

[BitcoinGirl.Club]

I expect LoyceV and other user who make statistic thread would be happy to make extrapolated assumption. Anyway, here's my guess.

I know a name which has really high amount of reports submitted and with good mark and he is none other then @Ratimov who has also previously dedicated a thread for it here in which he has submitted 100,000 reports as good so this is old record so he might have gone above it not checked now so one of top in this matter.

I just felt we are going to hijack the thread. To avoid it I reposted this game to the Games and rounds sub board. Submit your answer on that post please: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5418636.0

[cryptoaddictchie]

Just keep reporting. I think the odds of getting more good than bad is bigger as long as you are familiar with the board and threads which you report should be the post belong. Like others said, as long as you are helping the accuracy isnt matter at all. In fact, even long timer might got wrong also when it comes to that. Keep up the good work.

[dkbit98]

how to look the history report?,

If you want to contribute forum and make it better than just keep reporting bad posts and you will soon see your reports in this page:
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=reportlist;mine

if the moderator moves the topic, whatever the reporter did (if not in accordance with the board) will mark as good?

Yes in this case it will be market as good report, but sometimes it gets unhandled and nothing happens, so it all depends from moderators.
I just checked my reported post accuracy and it is around 97% but I don't really care about this stats, and I don't check history of reported post unless there is something suspicious.

[UserU]

Who can tell after all these years how many reports I made?
I have some BTC to spare, 0.00098414 BTC.
Closest one will receive 0.0003 BTC

Here's my shot in the dark

243

[Rikafip]

That's a good report if you ask me. By reporting a thread to be moved, what you are saying is this thread doesn't belong in this sub. Please take a look at it and consider moving it to sub X. The fact alone that you are correct and the discussion doesn't belong there should be enough for your report to be marked as 'good'. Maybe you were wrong about the final destination, and that decision in on the moderator, but you were right about where it doesn't belong.

That's definitely how it works as I quite often report topics to be moved and sometimes mods move topic in another board and not the one I suggested is the right one and it still gets marked as good.

As a matter of fact, you don't even have to mention where topic that you are reporting should be moved if you are not sure. Its enough just to report it and write that "topic doesn't belong in this board" or something along those lines and if mods agree with you and topic gets moved, it will be marked as good.

[FatFork]

OP, as long as you have more good reports than bad ones, you don't have to worry about your reporting accuracy too much. Once you have more than 300 good reports, you will be able to see your report history, which will help you to learn from your mistakes and improve upon future reports. Just keep reporting!

That's a good report if you ask me. By reporting a thread to be moved, what you are saying is this thread doesn't belong in this sub. Please take a look at it and consider moving it to sub X. The fact alone that you are correct and the discussion doesn't belong there should be enough for your report to be marked as 'good'. Maybe you were wrong about the final destination, and that decision in on the moderator, but you were right about where it doesn't belong.

That's definitely how it works as I quite often report topics to be moved and sometimes mods move topic in another board and not the one I suggested is the right one and it still gets marked as good.

As a matter of fact, you don't even have to mention where topic that you are reporting should be moved if you are not sure. Its enough just to report it and write that "topic doesn't belong in this board" or something along those lines and if mods agree with you and topic gets moved, it will be marked as good.

I follow this same policy. When I'm not sure where a discussion thread should be moved, I leave that decision to the moderators. But I also do everything I can to make their jobs easier, so for example, when it comes to reporting multiposting, I always refer to other posts so that the moderators don't have to look through the user's history.

[_BlackStar]

-snip-

OP, your question has been answered and I don't think there's anything else to confuse you about it.

Now listen, if you want to be spam buster then try to report more low quality posts from forum users. You don't have to worry about the report but try to have a good standard for reporting other users' posts.

I know reporting spammers takes time and good knowledge of judging posts, but I think reporting extensions can save you a lot of time. I used it, it was very helpful.