Demand for non-Telegram forum notifications?

[ZAINmalik75]

Now the question: Is there is demand for those notifications outside Telegram?
Would you use a website, setup email or browser notifications, etc... for all the stuff I wrote above?

I loved your enthusiasm towards this forum and providing easiness I cannot imagine what my life would become if I didn't have the opportunity to use your bot, and here I am more than happy to use this bot only on Telegram, and I don't think it's a big deal to download telegram because in my country we have to use VPN or have to use telegram proxy in order to use it because Telegram is banned here.

Even after that many hurdles, we have to use Telegram and almost every person who is in crypto must have at least one Telegram account so I don't think that would be a problem.

But if we go with you then I vote for email because browser notification would become too annoying as we do have to use browsers for other stuff too, but if you ask me frankly I don't want it on email too I love Telegram.

[1715087621]

1715087621

[1715087621]

1715087621

[LTU_btc]

Personally I'm using your Telegram bot, but I have read comments that some people aren't using Telegram because it requires their phone number and they don't want to reveal it. So, I guess there is demand for notifications outside Telegram.
I think that browser extension with notifications would be something perfect. Another option would be notifications through email, but I'm not big fan of it as I already getting too much stuff to my email.

Even after that many hurdles, we have to use Telegram and almost every person who is in crypto must have at least one Telegram account so I don't think that would be a problem.

I don't think that Telegram is must use app for everyone in crypto world. As you can see replies in this thread, there is quite a lot people who don't use it.

[DYING_S0UL]

I have been using the telegram bot for some times. Does the job like a charm. Pretty satisfied, nothing major to complain. But despite it's usefulness many users doesn't use this. Only because it's connected with telegram. When it comes to telegram many people have an negative feelings towards it.

Maybe seeking alternative solutions can help. Like the one I previously saw, a push notification extension. Or something like that I presume.   

[Synchronice]

First of all, your telegram notifier is a very good thing but since you want to meet the demand and reach those users who don't use Telegram, then I think that Whatsapp bot will be a very good idea because in Europe almost everyone uses whatsapp, it's the most popular messenger. Is it possible for you to create a whatsapp bot?
By the way, just wanna know, does your telegram bot has access to user IPs? I mean, can you see the IPs of those who use your telegram bot? Or it's completely private?

[TryNinja]

Is it possible for you to create a whatsapp bot?

I can't see enough demand for that. Also, I would have your phone number, a privacy nightmare I don't want.

By the way, just wanna know, does your telegram bot has access to user IPs? I mean, can you see the IPs of those who use your telegram bot? Or it's completely private?

No, it's not possible for me to get your IP. All I know is your telegram handle (not your IP, location, telegram phone number, etc).

[Ambatman]

I don't know
I feel even if you pick another option
Not everybody would subscribe to it
Some prefer Websites
Some would prefer the email
Their preference stems from various reasons
Imo, wouldn't creating another come along with some costs especially in cases of setting up a website
I don't really use my telegram account for anything at part from using your Bot.
But some users are concerned about their privacy
So a website to send the notification would be good and subscription can be based on their Bitcointalk handle.
Something like a web push Notification
This can help protect privacy especially when used together with a good VPN or browser that supports users privacy.

[EarnOnVictor]

Now the question: Is there is demand for those notifications outside Telegram?
Would you use a website, setup email or browser notifications, etc... for all the stuff I wrote above?

Sorry if this is coming late, I just saw it. First, let me thank you for the good notification work done with the Telegram integration, I must say that I'm enjoying it.

But using the notification service on another channel could only mean more compromise and the risk is too high for those who want to keep their privacy. Telegram has been the best shot for people these days when it comes to a thing like this. Not even Whatsapp can be able to compare itself in this regard.

I wouldn't want it in my email for personal reasons, but if it can pop up when I am actively surfing the Bitcointalk is a very good option. I am not a tech-savvy guy, but so long as it's working fine without compromising one's privacy, I think it is a good one.

[Peanutswar]

Im using the telegram bot notification since it was released its great help to me get notified of the merits, replies and topic posts created, i guess for enhancement is the SMS but sure I know this needs to pay a subscription if use this feature, other than this it could possible if there's discord? I dont know if Discord has an API many active users in the world of crypto and NFT use this platform another is If a notifier uses an extension I guess it's a good feature too.

[Synchronice]

Is it possible for you to create a whatsapp bot?

I can't see enough demand for that. Also, I would have your phone number, a privacy nightmare I don't want.

Is there demand on Telegram bot? Can you reveal the number of people that use your Telegram bot?
If there is a privacy issue with whatsapp, then I think that there won't be enough demand for it.

No, it's not possible for me to get your IP. All I know is your telegram handle (not your IP, location, telegram phone number, etc).

Okay, that's cool.

By the way, if it's possible for you to create an extension that will let us to view notifications directly on website, that will be great. But easy solution for many people right now is to use a browser like Opera that lets you to have a sidebar with telegram extension. You receive telegram notification on the left, open it and then immediately access the link.

[uchegod-21]

Your telegram notifier is great if it does those jobs you listed in OP. I haven't used them because I am not that kind of a forum popular guy. I could go all weeks without being mentioned by anyone. But if someone quotes me, I have a way to know about it. For merit notification, I don't think that I need that. I can always check who merited me whenever I come online.

Would you use a website, setup email or browser notifications, etc... for all the stuff I wrote above?

Email notification might be spammy.
Website might be expensive to maintain.
Browser notification could be the second nice option after telegram notification.

[TryNinja]

Is there demand on Telegram bot? Can you reveal the number of people that use your Telegram bot?

Of course, or else I wouldn't even keep it up.

I've shared the numbers many times. Now:

972 users
6~7k notifications per day

The plan is to eventually refactor the code and launch a website (inside ninjastic.space) with all features currently available on the bot.

[Richbased]

The Bitcointalk super notifier bot created by @ TryNinja have been of great help to forum members over the years as it has made navigating the forum very easy for users because most people ain't too stable or always online to monitor activities in the forum but through the help of the super notifier, it has made the forum more accessible to users over the years.

Just like the OP said, not every one uses telegram simply because some persons doesn't like the use of telegram or maybe their devices doesn't support the installation of telegram just like me, my mobile device doesn't support installation of telegram though I do get notifications through my email address but I think the telegram super notifier bot by TryNinja updates informations about the forum as quick as possible more than the use of email address so creating a website for users that doesn't use telegram to also be a beneficiary of this enhanced method of navigating the Bitcointalk forum would be a welcome development.

[FatFork]

But easy solution for many people right now is to use a browser like Opera that lets you to have a sidebar with telegram extension. You receive telegram notification on the left, open it and then immediately access the link.

I believe there are Telegram extensions for all major web browsers (like this one for Chrome, or this one for Firefox). Or you can use something like Twitter messenger, which unifies multiple platforms and works very similar to what you have in the Opera browser.

[hugeblack]

Would you use a website, setup email or browser notifications, etc... for all the stuff I wrote above?

I have not used your Telegram bot, but I see that many people prefer this type of notifications. Creating a website inside ninjastic.space would be ideal, although I prefer userscript, as you will get a box between MY MESSAGES MEMBERS called Notifications, where you can customize your notifications.

[LoyceV]

Now the question: Is there is demand for those notifications outside Telegram?

Yes

Would you use a website

You mean you're going to compete with my notification bot, and improve it? Do it! You're better at it, and your setup is far more flexible than mine.

setup email or browser notifications, etc... for all the stuff I wrote above?

I never use browser notifications, and won't install any add-on, but I can see a use for email notification. It's easy to create a private email address, and works on any device you want.