Bitcoin Forum
November 18, 2026, 06:04:38 AM *
News: Latest Bitcoin Core release: 32.1 [Torrent]
 
   Home   Help Search Login Register More  
Pages: [1] 2 »  All
  Print  
Author Topic: Ledger Recovery Key: Ledger Recover 2.0?!  (Read 373 times)
Pmalek (OP)
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 3682
Merit: 9871



View Profile
June 24, 2025, 12:05:40 PM
Last edit: July 25, 2025, 06:57:08 AM by Pmalek
Merited by vapourminer (2), ABCbits (1), DireWolfM14 (1), satscraper (1)
 #1

Ledger doesn't seem to have learned much following the debacle of Ledger Recover or did they? They have announced the release of their new physical recovery tool called Ledger Recovery Key.

In contrast to Ledger Recover, Ledger Recovery Key will be a physical offline card that doesn’t require user identification. The tool is supposedly open-source not counting the closed-source OS by the chip manufacturer. This is a smart card with an NFC connection that will be used to store and recover seeds and private keys. The cards are protected with PIN codes. Ledger Recovery Key uses the NXP P71D600 Secure Element that has a EAL6+ security certification.

The Recovery Key is water resistant up to 1 meter for 30 minutes. A card will be included in all future purchases of Ledger Stax and Flex. Existing Stax and Flex owners can order the card for free with discounted shipping.

Which hardware wallets are supported?
- Ledger Recovery Key will support Ledger Flex and Ledger Stax hardware wallets.

How does Ledger Recovery Key work?
- It works over NFC wireless connection by tapping the smart card on the Ledger Flex/Stax and connecting to the device to recover your keys. Unlike the old Ledger Recover, there are no 3rd-party intermediaries this time.


Here is the first image of the Ledger Recovery Key:


Ledger Recovery Key’s code is posted on the following GitHub page:
https://github.com/LedgerHQ/applet-recovery-key

Here is an image of all Ledger Recovery Key components:


The company has also released a Ledger Recovery Key whitepaper.

Ledger Recovery Key can now be purchased from the company's official online store for $39 or €39.


Source:
https://cointelegraph.com/news/hardware-wallet-ledger-offline-recovery-keys-new-wallets

▄▄███████████████████▄▄
▄███████████████████████▄
███████████████████▄█████
█████████████████████████
███████████▀█████████████
█████████▀███▀██████▀████
██████████████████▄██████
█████████▄▄█▄▄███████████
██████████▄▄▄████████████
███████████████████▀█████
████████████████▀▀███████
▀███████████████████████▀
▀▀███████████████████▀▀
 
 EARNBET 
|⚽ 🏀
 
🏈 🏓
 
🎯 🥊
 
⚾ 🎾
 
⛳ 🏐
 
🏏 🏎️
|


███████▄▄███████████
████▄██████████████████
██▄▀▀███████████████▀▀███
█▄████████████████████████
▄▄████████▀▀▀▀▀████████▄▄██
███████████████████████████
█████████▌████▀████████████
███████████████████████████
▀▀███████▄▄▄▄▄█████████▀▀██
█▀█████████████████████▀██
██▀▄▄███████████████▄▄███
████▀██████████████████
███████▀▀███████████

....HIGHEST....
VIP REWARDS

 ✔ G U A R A N T E E D  
| 
 🜲 
KING OF
THE CASTLE

$200K in prizes
| 
..PLAY NOW..
DireWolfM14
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 3052
Merit: 6138


فلسطين


View Profile WWW
June 24, 2025, 12:22:51 PM
 #2

How well will it hold up if submerged in water or subject to a fire?

Well, better than Ledger Recover, but still not as appealing as a piece of paper locked up in a document safe.  A water and fire resistant document safe can be found for around $50, requires a combination (PIN) for retrieval of the backup, and isn't likely to suffer from failure due to electrical or magnetic discharge.  Well stored paper has been known to last for centuries, so this really seems like a solution to a problem that doesn't exist.

Maybe I'm just an old-fashioned luddite, so what do I know.

m2017
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 2674
Merit: 1813


keep walking, Johnnie


View Profile
June 24, 2025, 05:06:14 PM
Merited by Pmalek (2)
 #3

How well will it hold up if submerged in water or subject to a fire?
You need to tell Pascal Gauthier to make a Ledger Recovery Key from metal, like stainless steel or titanium. Or even better, from cryptonite. Smiley

To protect against fire and water, you can put it in a special package or case, which will solve this problem. But it would be better if it was made of refractory plastic, for example. In water, I believe, this material is resistant and the internal components should not be damaged due to the tightness.

Well, better than Ledger Recover, but still not as appealing as a piece of paper locked up in a document safe.  A water and fire resistant document safe can be found for around $50, requires a combination (PIN) for retrieval of the backup, and isn't likely to suffer from failure due to electrical or magnetic discharge.  
I suppose the metal case would have served a protective function of shielding from electromagnetic waves.

Well stored paper has been known to last for centuries, so this really seems like a solution to a problem that doesn't exist.
The text on paper can be read by anyone who has access to it, but the seed phrase can't be accessed without a pin code.

And in the end, Ledger must somehow increase sales. Smiley

Meuserna
Sr. Member
****
Offline

Activity: 460
Merit: 875


View Profile WWW
June 24, 2025, 06:18:26 PM
Merited by dkbit98 (3), vapourminer (2), ABCbits (1)
 #4

It's open source!  ...except for the part that isn't, which means you can add that lie to the long list of Ledger lies.

Any closed source code means the code isn't open source, because the code contains code that isn't published and thus cannot be verified to be safe.

Forsyth Jones
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 2086
Merit: 2374


I love Bitcoin!


View Profile WWW
June 24, 2025, 07:51:05 PM
 #5

Well, at least it's not the usual infamous ledger recover.  Cheesy

But it seems to be a recovery product restricted to Ledger devices, the company's most expensive: Flex and Stax.

It's good news, in a way, yes, but not the kind of news that gets me excited.

It's just more of the same, Coldcard's TapSigner seems to be superior.

Pmalek (OP)
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 3682
Merit: 9871



View Profile
June 25, 2025, 07:01:47 AM
 #6

Ledger released their first video about the Recovery Key card yesterday. Nothing special here. It's an 8-minute introduction to the tool where they spend the first 3 minutes patting themselves on the shoulders and congratulating themselves on everything they have achieved and done so far.
Ledger Recovery Key: Physical Backup for Your 24 Words | Technical Deep Dive

How well will it hold up if submerged in water or subject to a fire?
It's probably made out of plastic so it's not going to survive a fire. When it comes to water, I guess it depends on how long the card will be in the water. It's surely splash-resistant and could survive being submerged in water for a short period of time (like being dropped in it and taken out). I doubt it will work if it took a lengthier swim.

It's open source!  ...except for the part that isn't, which means you can add that lie to the long list of Ledger lies.

Any closed source code means the code isn't open source, because the code contains code that isn't published and thus cannot be verified to be safe.
True, but that's the case with anything in the hardware wallet space that has a secure element chip. Lets not forget that there is no open-source secure element and there probably never will be a fully open-source SE regardless of what anyone says. The manufacturer's code on the chips is always closed-source. This is just more of what we have already seen or perhaps worst.

But it seems to be a recovery product restricted to Ledger devices, the company's most expensive: Flex and Stax.
It requires NFC connection and that's something the old Nano S (Plus) and Nano X don't have. Stax and Flex do, so they are supported.

▄▄███████████████████▄▄
▄███████████████████████▄
███████████████████▄█████
█████████████████████████
███████████▀█████████████
█████████▀███▀██████▀████
██████████████████▄██████
█████████▄▄█▄▄███████████
██████████▄▄▄████████████
███████████████████▀█████
████████████████▀▀███████
▀███████████████████████▀
▀▀███████████████████▀▀
 
 EARNBET 
|⚽ 🏀
 
🏈 🏓
 
🎯 🥊
 
⚾ 🎾
 
⛳ 🏐
 
🏏 🏎️
|


███████▄▄███████████
████▄██████████████████
██▄▀▀███████████████▀▀███
█▄████████████████████████
▄▄████████▀▀▀▀▀████████▄▄██
███████████████████████████
█████████▌████▀████████████
███████████████████████████
▀▀███████▄▄▄▄▄█████████▀▀██
█▀█████████████████████▀██
██▀▄▄███████████████▄▄███
████▀██████████████████
███████▀▀███████████

....HIGHEST....
VIP REWARDS

 ✔ G U A R A N T E E D  
| 
 🜲 
KING OF
THE CASTLE

$200K in prizes
| 
..PLAY NOW..
satscraper
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 1652
Merit: 3177


AntiSwap.io - NO AML/KYC EXCHANGER MONITORING


View Profile
June 25, 2025, 08:04:09 AM
 #7

It requires NFC connection and that's something the old Nano S (Plus) and Nano X don't have. Stax and Flex do, so they are supported.

The published script enables communication with wallets that support NFC, i.e. Stax and Flex currently, the aim being to extract SEED. Additionally, SEEDs can also be extracted over USB from the s+ and X models. This reinforces my suspicion that what was once deemed "impossible" (as they claimed) is very much achievable. Now, the question is how long will it take for hackers to exploit such opt.


 AntiSwap 
█████▄▄▄█████▄▄▄
█▄████████████████▄▄▄
▐█████████████████████▄
█████████▀▀█▀██████████
███████▀▄▄▄██▀████████▌
██████████▄▄█████████▀
██████▀▀████▀███████▀
▐█████▄████▄███████▀
████████▄█████████▀
█████████████████
███████████████▀
████▀████████▀
██████▀███▀

│❌ NO AML / KYC
███████████████████████
█████▀█▀▀▀▀██████████████
█████▀▀▀▀▀▀███████████████
███████████████████████████
███████████████████████████
██████████████████████████
████████████████████████▀█▄
███████████████████████▀██▄█▄
█████████████████████████▀████▄
███████████████████████████▀████▄
█████████████████████████████▀██▀
🔎︎ 900+
EXCHANGERS

██ ██ ██ ██ ██ ██
│
3 TIER
RATING
SYSTEM

🟢 Fair
🟠 Neutral
🔴 SCAM!
│
 BTC   ➤ 
Pmalek (OP)
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 3682
Merit: 9871



View Profile
June 25, 2025, 03:21:35 PM
 #8

The published script enables communication with wallets that support NFC, i.e. Stax and Flex currently, the aim being to extract SEED. Additionally, SEEDs can also be extracted over USB from the s+ and X models. This reinforces my suspicion that what was once deemed "impossible" (as they claimed) is very much achievable.
This is clear to everyone ever since information about Ledger Recover came out. Secure Element chips do what the accompanying code tells them to. When it's written not to extract keys and send them to third-parties over the internet, it doesn't. If a Brainiac developer decides that's a good idea and writes the code for it, then that's exactly what's going to happen. Secure Elements can't protect secrets if manual intervention makes it possible to reveal them.

▄▄███████████████████▄▄
▄███████████████████████▄
███████████████████▄█████
█████████████████████████
███████████▀█████████████
█████████▀███▀██████▀████
██████████████████▄██████
█████████▄▄█▄▄███████████
██████████▄▄▄████████████
███████████████████▀█████
████████████████▀▀███████
▀███████████████████████▀
▀▀███████████████████▀▀
 
 EARNBET 
|⚽ 🏀
 
🏈 🏓
 
🎯 🥊
 
⚾ 🎾
 
⛳ 🏐
 
🏏 🏎️
|


███████▄▄███████████
████▄██████████████████
██▄▀▀███████████████▀▀███
█▄████████████████████████
▄▄████████▀▀▀▀▀████████▄▄██
███████████████████████████
█████████▌████▀████████████
███████████████████████████
▀▀███████▄▄▄▄▄█████████▀▀██
█▀█████████████████████▀██
██▀▄▄███████████████▄▄███
████▀██████████████████
███████▀▀███████████

....HIGHEST....
VIP REWARDS

 ✔ G U A R A N T E E D  
| 
 🜲 
KING OF
THE CASTLE

$200K in prizes
| 
..PLAY NOW..
satscraper
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 1652
Merit: 3177


AntiSwap.io - NO AML/KYC EXCHANGER MONITORING


View Profile
June 26, 2025, 05:21:10 AM
 #9

The published script enables communication with wallets that support NFC, i.e. Stax and Flex currently, the aim being to extract SEED. Additionally, SEEDs can also be extracted over USB from the s+ and X models. This reinforces my suspicion that what was once deemed "impossible" (as they claimed) is very much achievable.
This is clear to everyone ever since information about Ledger Recover came out. Secure Element chips do what the accompanying code tells them to. When it's written not to extract keys and send them to third-parties over the internet, it doesn't. If a Brainiac developer decides that's a good idea and writes the code for it, then that's exactly what's going to happen. Secure Elements can't protect secrets if manual intervention makes it possible to reveal them.

I think it's clear to most that Ledger has the technical capability to do this, but what many may not realize is that they have effectively left the open door for hackers. This could potentially allow unauthorized extraction of SEEDs from Ledger devices. That’s the point I was trying to make in my previous post. They must realize that Secure Elements in HW have to be sure as hell sealed.



 AntiSwap 
█████▄▄▄█████▄▄▄
█▄████████████████▄▄▄
▐█████████████████████▄
█████████▀▀█▀██████████
███████▀▄▄▄██▀████████▌
██████████▄▄█████████▀
██████▀▀████▀███████▀
▐█████▄████▄███████▀
████████▄█████████▀
█████████████████
███████████████▀
████▀████████▀
██████▀███▀

│❌ NO AML / KYC
███████████████████████
█████▀█▀▀▀▀██████████████
█████▀▀▀▀▀▀███████████████
███████████████████████████
███████████████████████████
██████████████████████████
████████████████████████▀█▄
███████████████████████▀██▄█▄
█████████████████████████▀████▄
███████████████████████████▀████▄
█████████████████████████████▀██▀
🔎︎ 900+
EXCHANGERS

██ ██ ██ ██ ██ ██
│
3 TIER
RATING
SYSTEM

🟢 Fair
🟠 Neutral
🔴 SCAM!
│
 BTC   ➤ 
Pmalek (OP)
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 3682
Merit: 9871



View Profile
June 26, 2025, 07:05:11 AM
 #10

I think it's clear to most that Ledger has the technical capability to do this, but what many may not realize is that they have effectively left the open door for hackers. This could potentially allow unauthorized extraction of SEEDs from Ledger devices. That’s the point I was trying to make in my previous post. They must realize that Secure Elements in HW have to be sure as hell sealed.
The code for remote seed extraction for the Ledger Recover feature should have never been allowed to find its way to the Universal firmware that gets installed on all Ledger hardware wallets when you update your firmware. They basically tricked their users to install it and only then announced that the code has been merged but each user can decide to activate the feature or not. The only way this should have happened (since they made the decision to create Ledger Recover) was to create a separate firmware with Ledger Recover on it, announce it, and allow each HW owner to decide whether to install the Universal and clean firmware or the one bearing Ledger Recover.

▄▄███████████████████▄▄
▄███████████████████████▄
███████████████████▄█████
█████████████████████████
███████████▀█████████████
█████████▀███▀██████▀████
██████████████████▄██████
█████████▄▄█▄▄███████████
██████████▄▄▄████████████
███████████████████▀█████
████████████████▀▀███████
▀███████████████████████▀
▀▀███████████████████▀▀
 
 EARNBET 
|⚽ 🏀
 
🏈 🏓
 
🎯 🥊
 
⚾ 🎾
 
⛳ 🏐
 
🏏 🏎️
|


███████▄▄███████████
████▄██████████████████
██▄▀▀███████████████▀▀███
█▄████████████████████████
▄▄████████▀▀▀▀▀████████▄▄██
███████████████████████████
█████████▌████▀████████████
███████████████████████████
▀▀███████▄▄▄▄▄█████████▀▀██
█▀█████████████████████▀██
██▀▄▄███████████████▄▄███
████▀██████████████████
███████▀▀███████████

....HIGHEST....
VIP REWARDS

 ✔ G U A R A N T E E D  
| 
 🜲 
KING OF
THE CASTLE

$200K in prizes
| 
..PLAY NOW..
dkbit98
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 3150
Merit: 8993


AntiSwap.io - NO AML/KYC EXCHANGER MONITORING


View Profile WWW
June 26, 2025, 04:26:12 PM
Merited by ABCbits (1)
 #11

Another non-open source crap coming from ledger  Tongue

They again lied claiming that source code is open source, but I can clearly read what they posted on their github page, and this is NOT open source license:
https://github.com/LedgerHQ/applet-recovery-key/blob/develop/LICENSE.md

This license is NOT open source, it only allows personal use, redistribution is prohibited, you can't modify or make update for other platforms, you can't modify and share your version, no community improvements, only works with ledger software.


https://x.com/P3b7_/status/1937501356723699980

There are much better alternatives for backup in form of java cards that are open source, like Satochip Seedkeeper or Keycard:
https://satochip.io/
https://keycard.tech/keycard

I don't know the price for ledger backup crap, but I am sure it's going to be more expensive than Satochip Seedkeeper and Keycard.

It's open source!  ...except for the part that isn't, which means you can add that lie to the long list of Ledger lies.
Typical ledger liar stuff... but hey they are prabaly targeting people who can't read and do they own research  Tongue

Pmalek (OP)
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 3682
Merit: 9871



View Profile
June 27, 2025, 07:12:56 AM
 #12

This license is NOT open source, it only allows personal use, redistribution is prohibited, you can't modify or make update for other platforms, you can't modify and share your version, no community improvements, only works with ledger software.
Source-verifiable or software with verifiable source code would then be the correct ways to explain Ledger Recovery Key. Under the condition, of course, that it is possible to reproduce it from the code available on GitHub. They seem to be using the same tricks that Coinkite and Coldcard were using in the past when they called their hardware wallets open-source for having publicly available code, but not meeting other conditions necessary to be open-source. They changed those claims to source-verifiable eventually.

▄▄███████████████████▄▄
▄███████████████████████▄
███████████████████▄█████
█████████████████████████
███████████▀█████████████
█████████▀███▀██████▀████
██████████████████▄██████
█████████▄▄█▄▄███████████
██████████▄▄▄████████████
███████████████████▀█████
████████████████▀▀███████
▀███████████████████████▀
▀▀███████████████████▀▀
 
 EARNBET 
|⚽ 🏀
 
🏈 🏓
 
🎯 🥊
 
⚾ 🎾
 
⛳ 🏐
 
🏏 🏎️
|


███████▄▄███████████
████▄██████████████████
██▄▀▀███████████████▀▀███
█▄████████████████████████
▄▄████████▀▀▀▀▀████████▄▄██
███████████████████████████
█████████▌████▀████████████
███████████████████████████
▀▀███████▄▄▄▄▄█████████▀▀██
█▀█████████████████████▀██
██▀▄▄███████████████▄▄███
████▀██████████████████
███████▀▀███████████

....HIGHEST....
VIP REWARDS

 ✔ G U A R A N T E E D  
| 
 🜲 
KING OF
THE CASTLE

$200K in prizes
| 
..PLAY NOW..
Lucius
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 4158
Merit: 8058


Heroes live forever - Vukovar 1991-2026🕊


View Profile WWW
June 27, 2025, 01:44:04 PM
 #13

The published script enables communication with wallets that support NFC, i.e. Stax and Flex currently, the aim being to extract SEED. Additionally, SEEDs can also be extracted over USB from the s+ and X models. This reinforces my suspicion that what was once deemed "impossible" (as they claimed) is very much achievable. Now, the question is how long will it take for hackers to exploit such opt.

I think it's not a question of whether they will succeed, but when they will succeed. When you have such an option, which is built into the firmware, then it's only a matter of time before someone malicious will find a way to use it to their advantage. Maybe someone has already succeeded in doing that, but if they are at all intelligent, they will take advantage of it quietly and steal a little from everyone, hoping that no one will notice so soon.

▄██████████████████████▄
████████████████████████
███████████▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀████
████████▀███████████████
███████████▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄████
████▀███████▀▀▀▀▀▀▀█████
███▀███████████████▀▀▀██
██▀██████████████████▄██
████████████████████▄███
████▄████████████▄██████

████████████████████████
████████████████████████
█▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
░░░▄▄███████▄▄▄
▄███▀▀▀░░░▀▀▀███▄
▀▀░▄▄███████▄▄░▀▀
░░░██▀░░░░░▀██

░▄█████████████▄
██▀███████████▀██
█████████████████
█████████████████
█████████████████
█████████████████
█████████████████
▀▀▀█
█








█
▄▄▄█
▄██████████████████████▄
████████████████████████
██████▀▀████████████████
████▀██████████████▄▄███
███▀██▄▄█▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀██████
████▄█▀██████████▄██████
████▀██████▄▄▄▄█████████
████████▄███████████████
████████████████████████
████████████████████████
███▄▄███████████████████
████████████████████████
█▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀

░░░░░░░░░▄███▀
░░░░░░░▄████
░░░░▄██████
░░▄██████▀
▄███████████████▄
▀███████████████▀
░░░░░░░░▄█████▀
░░░░░░░▄████▀
░░░░░░▄███▀
░░░░░░██▀
▀▀▀█
█








█
▄▄▄█
satscraper
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 1652
Merit: 3177


AntiSwap.io - NO AML/KYC EXCHANGER MONITORING


View Profile
June 28, 2025, 03:09:25 PM
Merited by vapourminer (2), Lucius (1)
 #14

The published script enables communication with wallets that support NFC, i.e. Stax and Flex currently, the aim being to extract SEED. Additionally, SEEDs can also be extracted over USB from the s+ and X models. This reinforces my suspicion that what was once deemed "impossible" (as they claimed) is very much achievable. Now, the question is how long will it take for hackers to exploit such opt.

I think it's not a question of whether they will succeed, but when they will succeed. When you have such an option, which is built into the firmware, then it's only a matter of time before someone malicious will find a way to use it to their advantage. Maybe someone has already succeeded in doing that, but if they are at all intelligent, they will take advantage of it quietly and steal a little from everyone, hoping that no one will notice so soon.

Looks like you are not far from the truth. Look how they advertise their device on Las Vegas sphere:



Lettering glows: "The most secure Bitcoin wallet"  .... [ Ledger ]  Grin Grin Grin

Users responded to this lettering in their comments below:



 AntiSwap 
█████▄▄▄█████▄▄▄
█▄████████████████▄▄▄
▐█████████████████████▄
█████████▀▀█▀██████████
███████▀▄▄▄██▀████████▌
██████████▄▄█████████▀
██████▀▀████▀███████▀
▐█████▄████▄███████▀
████████▄█████████▀
█████████████████
███████████████▀
████▀████████▀
██████▀███▀

│❌ NO AML / KYC
███████████████████████
█████▀█▀▀▀▀██████████████
█████▀▀▀▀▀▀███████████████
███████████████████████████
███████████████████████████
██████████████████████████
████████████████████████▀█▄
███████████████████████▀██▄█▄
█████████████████████████▀████▄
███████████████████████████▀████▄
█████████████████████████████▀██▀
🔎︎ 900+
EXCHANGERS

██ ██ ██ ██ ██ ██
│
3 TIER
RATING
SYSTEM

🟢 Fair
🟠 Neutral
🔴 SCAM!
│
 BTC   ➤ 
Lucius
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 4158
Merit: 8058


Heroes live forever - Vukovar 1991-2026🕊


View Profile WWW
June 29, 2025, 10:41:02 AM
Merited by vapourminer (2)
 #15

Looks like you are not far from the truth. Look how they advertise their device on Las Vegas sphere:
~snip~


Although there is some kind of explanation behind some of the cases of mysterious disappearances of cryptocurrencies from their devices, it seems that there may be something more, considering that there are more and more people who are left without everything even though they claim that their backup is safe and that they have not used their device for a long time.

Given that Ledger secretly "spies" on its users via Ledger Live, perhaps someone is using this data to specifically target those users who have not been online for a very long time because they are apparently the last to discover that someone has emptied their accounts.

That ad should read something like this: "Ledger, the safest way to lose your cryptocurrencies or have thieves knock on your door - we share all your secrets."

▄██████████████████████▄
████████████████████████
███████████▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀████
████████▀███████████████
███████████▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄▄████
████▀███████▀▀▀▀▀▀▀█████
███▀███████████████▀▀▀██
██▀██████████████████▄██
████████████████████▄███
████▄████████████▄██████

████████████████████████
████████████████████████
█▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
░░░▄▄███████▄▄▄
▄███▀▀▀░░░▀▀▀███▄
▀▀░▄▄███████▄▄░▀▀
░░░██▀░░░░░▀██

░▄█████████████▄
██▀███████████▀██
█████████████████
█████████████████
█████████████████
█████████████████
█████████████████
▀▀▀█
█








█
▄▄▄█
▄██████████████████████▄
████████████████████████
██████▀▀████████████████
████▀██████████████▄▄███
███▀██▄▄█▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀██████
████▄█▀██████████▄██████
████▀██████▄▄▄▄█████████
████████▄███████████████
████████████████████████
████████████████████████
███▄▄███████████████████
████████████████████████
█▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀

░░░░░░░░░▄███▀
░░░░░░░▄████
░░░░▄██████
░░▄██████▀
▄███████████████▄
▀███████████████▀
░░░░░░░░▄█████▀
░░░░░░░▄████▀
░░░░░░▄███▀
░░░░░░██▀
▀▀▀█
█








█
▄▄▄█
Cricktor
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 1680
Merit: 4696



View Profile
July 06, 2025, 09:15:58 PM
Merited by vapourminer (2), Pmalek (2), Lucius (1)
 #16

I just rushed through the Recovery Key whitepaper. Not really interested in a deep dive, because... it's Ledger again.

So now a wireless protocol (NFC) can trigger events, some challenge-response magic and Ledger Flex and Stax are more than willing to transmit an encrypted piece of data that contains the wallet's entropy (the random stuff that is represented by the mnemonic recovery words, with 24 of those that Ledger crap uses, the entropy is 256 bits) via NFC to the Recovery Key or vice-versa.

Because communication between the hardware wallet and the recovery key are local, all keys for encryption must be either hard-coded (I hope that's not the case) or derived from some already existing data. This security by obscurity seems flawed to me, there's a chance of an attack vector here.

While Ledger tries to paint a picture of a secure communication channel, nobody can easily verify it. With the right equipment you could "wiretap" the NFC communication, decompile firmware samples and so on and so forth. And as usual you have to trust the bros around the french lord of the rings. But why would you?

I still don't like the design concept that allows the most important secrets to leave the secure elements. That's fundamentally wrong by idea and design.

Pmalek (OP)
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 3682
Merit: 9871



View Profile
July 07, 2025, 07:14:48 AM
 #17

<Snip>
These physical backup cards that communicate over NFC aren't anything new. Coinkite's Tapsigner exists. There is also Satochip's Seedkeeper that can store recovery phrases and passwords. I haven't done any research into how any of those work under the hood. If you have, what would be your arguments for picking one of those cards instead of the Ledger Recovery Key, not taking into account that Ledger's solution works only with their selected hardware wallets and the dilemma about how open-source (or not) it is? 

▄▄███████████████████▄▄
▄███████████████████████▄
███████████████████▄█████
█████████████████████████
███████████▀█████████████
█████████▀███▀██████▀████
██████████████████▄██████
█████████▄▄█▄▄███████████
██████████▄▄▄████████████
███████████████████▀█████
████████████████▀▀███████
▀███████████████████████▀
▀▀███████████████████▀▀
 
 EARNBET 
|⚽ 🏀
 
🏈 🏓
 
🎯 🥊
 
⚾ 🎾
 
⛳ 🏐
 
🏏 🏎️
|


███████▄▄███████████
████▄██████████████████
██▄▀▀███████████████▀▀███
█▄████████████████████████
▄▄████████▀▀▀▀▀████████▄▄██
███████████████████████████
█████████▌████▀████████████
███████████████████████████
▀▀███████▄▄▄▄▄█████████▀▀██
█▀█████████████████████▀██
██▀▄▄███████████████▄▄███
████▀██████████████████
███████▀▀███████████

....HIGHEST....
VIP REWARDS

 ✔ G U A R A N T E E D  
| 
 🜲 
KING OF
THE CASTLE

$200K in prizes
| 
..PLAY NOW..
Cricktor
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 1680
Merit: 4696



View Profile
July 07, 2025, 06:45:15 PM
Merited by Pmalek (2)
 #18

This is clearly my personal point of view. I didn't much find those smartcards a compelling solution as safe storage for either my recovery secrets or as a wallet. I might be wrong as I didn't really do much of research on such products.

It's plastic, thus not fire-resistant. Even if it's open-source and a battle-tested Java smartcard, it doesn't attract me. It needs an app and likely additional hardware (smartcard reader) to be used on a desktop or laptop (if laptop doesn't have a smartcard reader). I don't like to use a mobile phone with wallets of more than pocket money value. Daily usage mobile phones are no secure platform in my opinion.

For a hardware wallet, I want it to have an own display which is not accessible from a potentially infected computer. You need a trusted display to verify all details of a transaction you are about to sign. Those smartcards don't have that, thus I'm sort of less interested to look deeper.

I'm fully aware, I might not do Satochip and similar well deserved justice. It's just me, that those products likely don't tick all my boxes. Besides the hardware wallet I own and use, I've no real use case for those smartcards.

The situation with Ledger Recovery Key is fundamentally different to those other smartcards. The Ledger Recovery Key is a key to unlock their Ledger hardware crap to have your Ledger wallet's entropy leave the secure element. At least the recovery blob is encrypted, so they tell us (believe us, bro!). How well, we don't know. Ledger can blabber all sorts of marketing bullshit and we can't verify anything, because I can't remember they made anything of Ledger Recovery shit open-source (they said, they will do it, but that was merely a fog candle to distract people). Whitepapers are whitepapers, nothing more. They aren't a concrete verifiable implementation.

Pmalek (OP)
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 3682
Merit: 9871



View Profile
July 08, 2025, 06:55:25 AM
 #19

<Snip>
Got it. So you are generally against the idea of these type of smartcards because of the shortcomings you mentioned, and you don't like any of them. Ledger just tops the list because you don't trust them and there is a big question mark above everything they have done lately. I get that and they deserve it. Regarding Ledger Recovery Key, though, the software running it is allegedly open-source. So if you have the needed skills, you could investigate what the code does and how everything works. Still, it combines with other closed-source systems within the Ledger ecosystem. 

▄▄███████████████████▄▄
▄███████████████████████▄
███████████████████▄█████
█████████████████████████
███████████▀█████████████
█████████▀███▀██████▀████
██████████████████▄██████
█████████▄▄█▄▄███████████
██████████▄▄▄████████████
███████████████████▀█████
████████████████▀▀███████
▀███████████████████████▀
▀▀███████████████████▀▀
 
 EARNBET 
|⚽ 🏀
 
🏈 🏓
 
🎯 🥊
 
⚾ 🎾
 
⛳ 🏐
 
🏏 🏎️
|


███████▄▄███████████
████▄██████████████████
██▄▀▀███████████████▀▀███
█▄████████████████████████
▄▄████████▀▀▀▀▀████████▄▄██
███████████████████████████
█████████▌████▀████████████
███████████████████████████
▀▀███████▄▄▄▄▄█████████▀▀██
█▀█████████████████████▀██
██▀▄▄███████████████▄▄███
████▀██████████████████
███████▀▀███████████

....HIGHEST....
VIP REWARDS

 ✔ G U A R A N T E E D  
| 
 🜲 
KING OF
THE CASTLE

$200K in prizes
| 
..PLAY NOW..
Cricktor
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 1680
Merit: 4696



View Profile
July 08, 2025, 08:30:54 PM
Merited by satscraper (1)
 #20

I certainly don't like Ledger and their products and how they market their Recovery stuff as something great, because wallet's entropy should not be exfiltrated from hardware wallet's secure elements at all. There should be no firmware code that aids this.

I'm not comfortable and agree with your interpretation that I don't like the other smartcards like Satochip. I said, I don't have a use case for them for me personally and as wallets they lack a crucial and in my opinion mandatory own independent display that can't be manipulated by a host device. I'm ok though, if we still disagree. That's life.

I can't say I studied smartcards thoroughly, so I might have missed a detail or two.

I'm not a code auditer and because I dislike what Ledger does, I won't invest time to check if and what Ledger has published as open-source for their new Recovery Key. Yes, I'm biased, seen too much crap and marketing bs from Ledger.

Pages: [1] 2 »  All
  Print  
 
Jump to:  

Powered by MySQL Powered by PHP Powered by SMF 1.1.19 | SMF © 2006-2009, Simple Machines Valid XHTML 1.0! Valid CSS!