um, no i disagree.
at least for the kind of forum members and posts this place needs (or should rate, as its pretty much the birthplace of bitcoin) anyway.
quality poster gonna post quality posts no matter what reward or acknowledgements they may or may not get.
Well, here I agree fully with you, those who're thankful to this forum and are happy to be part of it will try their best to make quality posts even if they don't get much acknowledgement or merits for the posts that they make.
Actually quality posters will continue to make a quality posts even though they posts is not been merited..But it's discouraging if you're posting without earning merit, you will be imagine if you're post quality is good or you're posting a shitpost...if you earn a merit in what you post, it will encourage you to post more quality than the one you have posted.
main aim is to be as optimistic on this forum as possible because this forum is very important for most of us and if we don't visit it a day or two we feel quite unsatisfied.
They are some people who does not post often in the forum, but they go through almost all the boards especially Reputation, Meta And Technical boards and ready and a new thread.
There're many good members who give proper time to write the posts and do very high quality posting and very helpful discussions on the forum but still they don't get as many merits
But they earn small amounts of merit, the problem is that, you will be making a post for two to three months without earning merit, it will discourage you, If you're a quality poster.