Air-gapped Electrum Wallet to Air-gapped Coldcard-Q Privkey Migration Workflow

[matrix01]

Here is my workflow (as much as I understand) and I hope an Electrum Super User can fill in the gaps in my workflow which moves from left to right. At the left side beginning point I have a key list text file exported from my obsolete air-gapped signer PC. This text file contains legacy P2PKH Bitcoin Public Addresses, PrivBase58, and PrivHexBE data.  At the middle point of the workflow, I have setup an air-gapped Electrum Wallet version 4.6.2 AppImage to receive only the PrivBase58 and Address data stored in the exported key list text file data (PrivHexBE data excluded in migration).  And at the end of the workflow is an air-gapped Coldcard-Q wallet which receives unsigned transactions from the Electrum software and signs them. Once signed by the Coldcard-Q the transaction gets broadcasted to the BTC blockchain via a Start9 BTC node I have setup. Listed below are the workflow gaps I have I hope somebody out there can clarify:

• Is it 100% mandatory I convert the PrivBase58 privkeys data in the text file over to a WIF (Wallet Import Format) format before importing into Electrum?   Google provides conflicting information on this matter. So, I am not 100% certain if I need to somehow convert all my PrivBase58 keys to a WIF format. If yes, what tool do I use to make this conversion over to WIF possible? And am I correct to exclude the PrivHexBE data from this migration workflow?
• At the midpoint in the workflow my plan is to SWEEP the privKeys as opposed to IMPORT them into Electrum. This way I get new issued Privkeys and Public Addresses and I think this provides financial privacy benefits.  Is my sweeping provides better onchain financial privacy assumption correct or incorrect?  And how does my BTC remains spendable if I am getting issued new privkeys via this sweeping operation? In other words, what mechanism makes the BTC blockchain aware my old private keys have been replaced by new ones?
• At the end point of the workflow, it is not clear to me if using a JSON file from the Coldcard-Q is the best option to use for transferring the unsigned Electrum Wallet transactions over to the Coldcard-Q for signing?  In short, I am not 100% on how I integrate the Coldcard-Q with the Electrum Wallet unsigned transactions so that once broadcasted my BTC remains spendable under new issued Privkeys and Public Bitcoin Addresses?

Lastly, can anybody point me to any great online written or video instructional material that explains this entire workflow for a newbie like me.  Thank you for your time.  

[nc50lc]

• Is it 100% mandatory I convert the PrivBase58 privkeys data in the text file over to a WIF (Wallet Import Format) format before importing into Electrum?   Google provides conflicting information on this matter. So, I am not 100% certain if I need to somehow convert all my PrivBase58 keys to a WIF format. If yes, what tool do I use to make this conversion over to WIF? Am I correct to exclude the PrivHexBE data from this migration workflow?

Those export labels look familiar. (I also saw you in Armory board)
I assume that those are from Armory; if so, those "PrivBase58" export are actually already WIF without uncompressed flag byte. (all start with '5', omit the spaces)
Electrum supports it and importing it will restore your legacy P2PKH addresses.

You can exclude those "PrivHexBE" since those are your private keys in bare HEX format.
But keep them safe.

• At the midpoint in the workflow my plan is to SWEEP the privKeys as opposed to IMPORT them into Electrum. This way I get new issued Privkeys and Public Addresses and I think this provides financial privacy benefits.  Is my sweeping provides better onchain financial privacy assumption correct or incorrect?  And how does my BTC remains spendable if I am getting issued new privkeys via this sweeping operation? In other words, what mechanism makes the BTC blockchain aware my old private keys have been replaced by new ones?

If you have a lot of bitcoins, it's better to keep the workflow that involves your private keys completely offline.
Using Sweep will require the wallet to be online while typing the private keys.
Sweep is basically a simple transaction that sends all of the UTXO that the private keys can spend to a single address of the target wallet.
In terms of privacy, it's even worse since you can't use coin-control if you want to pick certain inputs plus it links all of your previous transactions to a single point.

If you want the same result while keeping the private keys offline, use my example in your first thread about "Cold-Storage" import and spending method.
You'll get the same result as Sweep since you will still send it to your new wallet with different private keys in the end (e.g. your ColdCard Q).

Regarding "coin-control" that you can do on the watch-only wallet, here's how: bitcoinelectrum.com/how-to-spend-specific-utxos-in-electrum (unofficial documentation)

• At the end point of the workflow, it is not clear to me if using a JSON file from the Coldcard-Q is the best option to use for transferring the unsigned Electrum Wallet transactions over to the Coldcard-Q for signing?
  

I can't help much on this part since I'm not using a ColdCard-Q.
But they have an official tutorial for that:coldcard.com/docs/quick/#using-coldcard-offline-with-electrum

[Abdussamad]

If you're using a hardware wallet then you have no need for an offline electrum setup. You also don't have to mess about with private keys.

[matrix01]

Nc50lc, thank you for your post. It’s great to see you in the Electrum board. I figured the Armory board was your board of choice considering your high level of Armory expertise.

Today I added all of the private keys I exported out of Armory to a spreadsheet running on an air-gapped/offline laptop setup with the Linux Mint OS and Electrum v4.6.2.  After reviewing the two spreadsheets I have encountered a new gap in the workflow I hope you can clarify.  I have a Test Wallet I deleted and Seed Phrase recovered for test purposes. This Test Wallet only holds around $50 in Sats and it shows 4 PrivBase58 keys if the “Include Unused (Address Pool)” box is left unticked. However, if the “Include Unused (Address Pool)” box is ticked the PrivBase58 key count for this Test Wallet goes up to 650 (which is a lot). So, this has me wondering which set of PrivBase58 keys do I push through my offline Electrum Wallet? Is it only the 4 keys or is it the 650 keys that only display when the “Include Unused (Address Pool)” box is ticked?  Additionally, I also have a Cold Storage Wallet with a lot more funds compared to the $50 my Test Wallet holds. However, this Cold Storage Wallet only shows a 24 PrivBase58 key count only if the “Include Unused (Address Pool)” box is ticked and shows a Zero PrivBase58 key count if the “Include Unused (Address Pool)” box is left unticked.  Therefore, for this Cold Storage Wallet I am assuming all 24 PrivBase58 keys need to be pushed through Electrum considering I am not being made to choose between pushing through Electrum 4 PrivBase58 keys or 650 PrivBase58 keys like my Test Wallet is making me choose.  My honest assumption was the PrivBase58 key count would be dependent to the amount of Bitcoins one owns. But I figure all of this has proved my assumption to be incorrect because the PriveKey58 count does not seem to be correlated to the amount of BTCs one owns.

As for Sweep vs. Import workflows my basic understanding of the two approaches is summarized below:

• Sweep = Funds will be put into a new address with a new private key.
• Import = Continues to exist in same private key and public address.

For this reason, I thought the Sweep approach did a better job of protecting your onchain financial privacy post migration.  However, I was not aware using the Sweep approach require I have the wallet be online while typing the private keys. And I also wasn't aware of "coin-control". I plan to read up on how "coin-control" works before I do anything.  Additionally, I have reviewed your post below several times:

https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5524213.msg64885706#msg64885706

Would it be too much trouble for you to modify your post so it integrates an air-gapped hardware wallet of your choice that you are familiar with?  I ask because this will most likely yield better results compared to what I was thinking of doing which was to study how your post at the link above integrates to the AI workflow content I got shown below. In your opinion do you think the AI workflow below is legit or do you think the AI is hallucinating with some of the content?  Thank you for your time.

MY AI PROMPT = How does one move private keys from an obsolete wallet over to a Coldcard-Q using Electrum software?

To move funds from an old wallet to your Coldcard-Q via Electrum, you'll import the old private keys into an Electrum wallet, create a watching-only version, then generate unsigned transactions for any needed movements to your Coldcard, sign them offline on the Coldcard, and broadcast. The most secure way involves exporting the Coldcard's wallet details (skeleton file) to an SD card for Electrum to read, then using Electrum to create transactions for the Coldcard to sign.

Method 1: Importing Keys into Electrum (Simpler)
1.   Get Keys from Old Wallet: Export private keys (WIF format) from your obsolete wallet (e.g., Bitcoin Core, another Electrum).
2.   Install Electrum: On your computer (preferably offline), install Electrum.
3.   Create New Wallet: Open Electrum, "Create New Wallet," and choose "Import Bitcoin addresses or private keys".
4.   Paste Keys: Paste your private keys, one per line. Add prefixes like p2wpkh-p2sh: for P2SH addresses (starting with '3') or p2wpkh: for native SegWit (starting with 'bc1') if needed.
5.   Create Signed Transactions: In your new Electrum wallet, create transactions to send funds to your Coldcard's receiving address. Save these as unsigned .txn files to an SD card.
6.   Sign on Coldcard: Insert the SD card into your Coldcard-Q, go to "Sign Transaction", load the .txn file, verify, and sign.
7.   Broadcast: Put the signed .txn file back on the computer and broadcast the transaction in Electrum.

Method 2: Using Coldcard Skeleton File (Recommended for Coldcard Integration)
1.   Export Skeleton from Coldcard: On your Coldcard-Q, go to Advanced/Tools > Export Wallet > Electrum Wallet. Save the new-electrum.json file to a MicroSD card (e.g., coldcard-export.json).
2.   Create Watch-Only Wallet in Electrum: Insert the SD card into your computer. In Electrum, create a new wallet, choose "Import Bitcoin addresses or Public Keys," and open the coldcard-export.json file. This creates a read-only wallet linked to your Coldcard.
3.   Import Old Wallet: Create another Electrum wallet (or use the same file if it's your primary) and import your old private keys as in Method 1.
4.   Create Transactions: In your old keys Electrum wallet, create transactions to send funds to addresses controlled by your Coldcard wallet (the watch-only one). Save these as unsigned .txn files.
5.   Sign & Broadcast: Sign these .txn files on the Coldcard-Q and broadcast from the Electrum instance connected to your Coldcard, following steps 6 & 7 from Method 1.

Key Security Tip: Always verify addresses and amounts on the physical Coldcard screen before confirming any transaction.

[nc50lc]

So, this has me wondering which set of PrivBase58 keys do I push through my offline Electrum Wallet? Is it only the 4 keys or is it the 650 keys that only display when the “Include Unused (Address Pool)” box is ticked?

The thing with cold-storage Armory's unused keypool is: It wont be able to track accurately which are actually used without being synced.
It can still mark those keys that have been used to sign your transactions while offline as 'used', but AFAIK, it doesn't include the unpent change address's private key until its used to sign in the next transaction.
So, as a precaution, it's safer to import all of the unused keypool to make sure that you're importing all of your used private keys to Electrum.

As for Sweep vs. Import workflows my basic understanding of the two approaches is summarized below:

• Sweep = Funds will be put into a new address with a new private key.
• Import = Continues to exist in same private key and public address.

This is correct.
But, I recommend to import them to a cold-storage machine to be able to safely send all of your bitcoins to your Coldcard.
In then end, your bitcoin are still sent to a new address with a new private key. (directly to your Coldcard wallet's)

Plus, it's basically the same since Sweep is just a regular transaction that spends all UTXO and send it to the wallet that you used to sweep.
There isn't something special in the sweep process and it requires you to type/paste your private keys on the online machine.
Meanwhile, the workflow I recommend can send it to your Coldcard wallet without exposing the private keys to the internet.

MY AI PROMPT = How does one move private keys from an obsolete wallet over to a Coldcard-Q using Electrum software?
-snip-
Method 2: Using Coldcard Skeleton File (Recommended for Coldcard Integration)

This just includes the steps to create a ColdCard watch-only wallet to Electrum which is in their official doc link above.
The rest is the same as Method1.

Method 1: Importing Keys into Electrum (Simpler)

It doesn't taken in consideration that when importing the keys offline, Electrum wont be able to sync the wallet to populate your spendable UTXOs.
If done offline, it requires an online watch-only wallet containing your addresses in your "Addresses" tab.
Refer to my link in your other thread for the correct import cold-storage workflow.

Basically what I said in my previous post:

• Import your private keys from Armory to your offline machine's Electrum
• Import their derived addresses to your Online machine's Electrum
• Create a PSBT in your watch-only wallet that sends (all of) your bitcoins to your Coldcard wallet.
  (refer to their official tutorial if you also want to use Electrum as Coldcard's watch-only wallet where you can get one of your address, you can open multiple instances of Electrum)
• Export that transaction and import it to the offline machine.
• In the offline Electrum, sign that PSBT, export that signed transaction and import it back to your online machine.
• In the online Electrum, after importing the signed transaction, review it 3x, then click "broadcast" to send.

Refer to my link in your other thread for the screenshots.

[Abdussamad]

To move funds from an old wallet to your Coldcard-Q via Electrum, you'll import the old private keys into an Electrum wallet, create a watching-only version, then generate unsigned transactions for any needed movements to your Coldcard, sign them offline on the Coldcard, and broadcas

If the originating wallet is electrum you have to sign the transaction with electrum not coldcard.

[nc50lc]

To move funds from an old wallet to your Coldcard-Q via Electrum, you'll import the old private keys into an Electrum wallet, create a watching-only version, then generate unsigned transactions for any needed movements to your Coldcard, sign them offline on the Coldcard, and broadcas

If the originating wallet is electrum you have to sign the transaction with electrum not coldcard.

I think that the AI mistaken his prompt containing "...using Electrum software" for both the obsolete wallet and Coldcard-Q and somehow mixed them together in the confusion.
And "obsolete wallet" is most likely the term that confused it since its not specific and the only named wallet in his prompt is Coldcard.

@matrix01
It's better not to rely nor even use it to ask for instructions since you'll likely get incomplete or inaccurate information from it.

[matrix01]

Nc50lc, thank you for your post. Regarding your previous post six step summary. I am trying to apply it to my situation but to do this I need to ask some questions.

Import your private keys from Armory to your offline machine's Electrum
Import their derived addresses to your Online machine's Electrum

In my situation I only need to import the PrivBase58 keys and not include the Blockchain Public Address as part of the import into the air-gapped Electrum setup? Is this correct?

Create a PSBT in your watch-only wallet that sends (all of) your bitcoins to your Coldcard wallet.
(refer to their official tutorial if you also want to use Electrum as Coldcard's watch-only wallet where you can get one of your address, you can open multiple instances of Electrum)

Not clear what multiple instances of Electrum helps with. My understanding was Electrum allows pasting as much PrivBase58 data that is necessary into the Electrum Wallet single PrivBase58 field.

Export that transaction and import it to the offline machine

In my situation my offline machine is the air-gapped Linux Mint Laptop (#1 Device) I have setup with Electrum Wallet and stores all my PrivBase58 data as two spreadsheet files. Additionally, my Coldcard-Q (#2 Device) can also be thought of as an offline machine.  Are you referring to a different "offline machine"?

In the offline Electrum, sign that PSBT, export that signed transaction and import it back to your online machine.

Am  I correct to think what you refer to as "your online machine" equates to my #3 Device shown in my diagram below?


Below is a diagram of my new Cold Storage setup:

Code:

      #1 Device                       #2 Device                          #3 Device                            #4 Device
Air-Gapped Linux Mint 
Laptop with Electrum   -----> Air-Gapped ColdCard-Q HW -----> Online LM PC with Sparrow Wallet  -----> Start9 Broadcast BTC Node.
installed & stores all                                                                                 Runs Bitcoin Knots, Electrs
PrivBase58 Data.                                                                                       and Mempool Space.

Lastly, my understanding was I need to setup a watch-only wallet between #2 Device and #3 Device. Are you also suggesting I also setup a watch-only wallet between #1 Device and #2 Device? 

Bear with me, but would it be too much trouble for you to modify your six steps so it correlates with my Cold Storage diagram shown above.  Thank you for your time.

[matrix01]

To move funds from an old wallet to your Coldcard-Q via Electrum, you'll import the old private keys into an Electrum wallet, create a watching-only version, then generate unsigned transactions for any needed movements to your Coldcard, sign them offline on the Coldcard, and broadcas

If the originating wallet is electrum you have to sign the transaction with electrum not coldcard.

I think that the AI mistaken his prompt containing "...using Electrum software" for both the obsolete wallet and Coldcard-Q and somehow mixed them together in the confusion.
And "obsolete wallet" is most likely the term that confused it since its not specific and the only named wallet in his prompt is Coldcard.

@matrix01
It's better not to rely nor even use it to ask for instructions since you'll likely get incomplete or inaccurate information from it.

Agree, I think the AI was hallucinating.

[nc50lc]

Import your private keys from Armory to your offline machine's Electrum
Import their derived addresses to your Online machine's Electrum

In my situation I only need to import the PrivBase58 keys and not include the Blockchain Public Address as part of the import into the air-gapped Electrum setup? Is this correct?

Correct, Electrum will automatically derive your address which you can see in the 'Addresses' tab ("View->Show Addresses" to enable)

Not clear what multiple instances of Electrum helps with. My understanding was Electrum allows pasting as much PrivBase58 data that is necessary into the Electrum Wallet single PrivBase58 field.

It's if you want to use Electrum as your ColdCard watch-only wallet.
You can open an instance where ColdCard watch-only wallet is open to get a receiving address; (created from an exported "skeleton wallet")
While another instance is the watch-only wallet of your air-gap imported Electrum wallet to create a transaction that will send to it.

In my situation my offline machine is the air-gapped Linux Mint Laptop (#1 Device) I have setup with Electrum Wallet and stores all my PrivBase58 data as two spreadsheet files. Additionally, my Coldcard-Q (#2 Device) can also be thought of as an offline machine.  Are you referring to a different "offline machine"?

I'm usually specific on those, like for ColdCard-Q, I usually call it "Hardware Wallet" or specifically "Coldcard".
For "offline machine" it's your offline computer.

Am  I correct to think what you refer to as "your online machine" equates to my #3 Device shown in my diagram below?
-snip-
Lastly, my understanding was I need to setup a watch-only wallet between #2 Device and #3 Device. Are you also suggesting I also setup a watch-only wallet between #1 Device and #2 Device?

You'll only need 2 machines (computers): 1 Air-Gap and 1 Online.
You use the Air-Gap machine for your offline Electrum containing your prvKeys.
And the Online Machine for your watch-only Electrum containing your addresses; in the same online machine, another instance of Electrum or Sparrow with your Coldcard watch-only wallet.