[ESCROW] Zenland V2: DAO-Governed Smart Contract Escrow | 1% Fee, $50 Max

[examplens]

edit: fulfilled

The contract has been created and is ready for you - feel free to accept and fulfill it at your convenience.

Good to know: With Zenland V2, you no longer need to ask a seller to log in to the platform. Just get their Web3 wallet address, create the escrow, and send them the PDF contract - that's it.

Looking forward to your feedback!

OK, I got it.
Here is my first impression.
Zen.land v2 looks much better now than before. I think that part is clearer now, and it's quite simplified.
For a better analysis, I will wait until the contract is fully executed, and I will have to create an escrow to test that part of the process as well.

Accept link from contract, lead me to error 404 page
https://zen.land/accept/0x3dCb130E16bB989F19EF34439E9e05fb35923536



Is NYKNYC your app?
I have to admit that I'm not a huge fan of web3 wallets, and NYKNYC just confirmed that I'm sticking to my current methods.
Although it is probably a simple wallet, the UX (I chose dark mode) made me quite confused. Everything is the same black color, input fields (seed input field  ), space, links, buttons... difficult to navigate


During the second transaction, this error appeared, if I understood correctly, the wallet did not immediately adjust the gas fee. After the re-publish transaction, everything was ok.

[Zenland]

edit: fulfilled

OK, I got it.
Here is my first impression.
Zen.land v2 looks much better now than before. I think that part is clearer now, and it's quite simplified.
For a better analysis, I will wait until the contract is fully executed, and I will have to create an escrow to test that part of the process as well.

Accept link from contract, lead me to error 404 page
https://zen.land/accept/0x3dCb130E16bB989F19EF34439E9e05fb35923536

NYC your app?
I have to admit that I'm not a huge fan of web3 wallets, and NYKNYC just confirmed that I'm sticking to my current methods.
Although it is probably a simple wallet, the UX (I chose dark mode) made me quite confused. Everything is the same black color, input fields (seed input field  ), space, links, buttons... difficult to navigate

During the second transaction, this error appeared, if I understood correctly, the wallet did not immediately adjust the gas fee. After the re-publish transaction, everything was ok.

Thank you @examplens, the funds were released.

With NYKNYC, we’re trying to address the adoption barrier in web3, though we recognize there’s still a long way to go. The goal is to combine the security of web3 wallets with a more familiar web2-like interface. I’ll add the redesign concerns to our backlog as we gather more user feedback.

Thanks for flagging the issue with the link - it’s already been fixed and will be rolled out in the next Zenland update. I appreciate your feedback and the time you took to review everything.

[examplens]

Thank you @examplens, the funds were released.

With NYKNYC, we’re trying to address the adoption barrier in web3, though we recognize there’s still a long way to go. The goal is to combine the security of web3 wallets with a more familiar web2-like interface. I’ll add the redesign concerns to our backlog as we gather more user feedback.

Thanks for flagging the issue with the link - it’s already been fixed and will be rolled out in the next Zenland update. I appreciate your feedback and the time you took to review everything.

Did I miss something?
The 10 USDT transaction is confirmed on the explorer, but I don't see it in the wallet. Only two transactions are within the escrow contract.
Just want to transfer and stake this reward as Zen.land agent, it seems that I will prefer to switch to my (hardware) wallet, where I have a greater sense of control and safety.

[Zenland]

Did I miss something?
The 10 USDT transaction is confirmed on the explorer, but I don't see it in the wallet. Only two transactions are within the escrow contract.
Just want to transfer and stake this reward as Zen.land agent, it seems that I will prefer to switch to my (hardware) wallet, where I have a greater sense of control and safety.

Thanks for pointing this out - let me clarify how it works.

This is one of the changes we made compared to the traditional Web3 wallet flow. The page you're currently viewing is focused on gas-related activity. Since gas is abstracted in ERC-4337 wallets, we separated this view to avoid confusion.

Your actual assets are still in your wallet, but they may not be visible yet because the token hasn’t been added. You can manually add USDT to your wallet here https://nyknyc.app/app/wallets/.
USDT Address on Ethereum 0xdac17f958d2ee523a2206206994597c13d831ec7

Also, regarding the transactions page - at the moment it only shows outgoing transactions. This is intentional. On Ethereum, wallets often receive a large number of spam or irrelevant incoming transactions (including scam tokens), and displaying all of them tends to create more confusion than clarity. For that reason, we currently focus on outgoing activity.

That said, we already have in our backlog an improvement to automatically detect and display popular tokens (like USDT) once they reach your wallet, so this process will become much smoother.

[examplens]

Thanks for pointing this out - let me clarify how it works.

This is one of the changes we made compared to the traditional Web3 wallet flow. The page you're currently viewing is focused on gas-related activity. Since gas is abstracted in ERC-4337 wallets, we separated this view to avoid confusion.

Your actual assets are still in your wallet, but they may not be visible yet because the token hasn’t been added. You can manually add USDT to your wallet here https://nyknyc.app/app/wallets/.
USDT Address on Ethereum 0xdac17f958d2ee523a2206206994597c13d831ec7

Also, regarding the transactions page - at the moment it only shows outgoing transactions. This is intentional. On Ethereum, wallets often receive a large number of spam or irrelevant incoming transactions (including scam tokens), and displaying all of them tends to create more confusion than clarity. For that reason, we currently focus on outgoing activity.

That said, we already have in our backlog an improvement to automatically detect and display popular tokens (like USDT) once they reach your wallet, so this process will become much smoother.

OK, I found it, thanks for clarifying.
Automatic recognition of major tokens and showing them would definitely be recommended. We are so used to it that I completely forgot that there is an addition process.

btw. When sending, there is no insight into the current balance, and even the "MAX" option does not recognize or enter the maximum amount.



The field for entering the seed phrase during verification is flat with a background, there are no frames or anything similar that would indicate that there is a field for entering text. Quite difficult to recognize, in dark mode, it is even worst



I will invite @bitmover, maybe he might be interested in learning about your platform.

[Baseplate]

Thanks @Baseplate! The minimum rank requirement is Full Member, but if no one else steps in within the next 48 hours, I’d be happy to proceed with you.

Also, have you had a chance to register as an agent yet?

I completely glossed over the rank requirements lol, sorry for that  

Regarding me registering as an agent, I still plan on it; once I get back the principal that I loaned out, I plan on staking those funds as USDT.

[bitmover]

thanks for inviting me examplens

Zenland, have you been to altcoinstalks.com?

There was recently an ethereum mixer project which scammed a lot of users. 
I think your service might be useful in that forum.

https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=330651.0

[examplens]

thanks for inviting me examplens

I wanted to point you to this https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5576960.msg66515566#msg66515566
The test is very simple, and you will see the functionality of the platform. In the end, I think you're a good candidate for an escrow agent.

Zenland, have you been to altcoinstalks.com?

There was recently an ethereum mixer project which scammed a lot of users. 
I think your service might be useful in that forum.

https://www.altcoinstalks.com/index.php?topic=330651.0

They were present on the altt forum. At least I opened a discussion about them. Also, I even started a reward campaign for testing, but the forum token was discounted, so I gave up then.
Test it, I think this is a different escrow model and is most practical for short-term deals.
Although maybe in the future they could think about a solution for the problem you mentioned.

[bitmover]

My review about the service so far. To be updated.

I created my account there. I didn't use Google mail as suggested in the topic. I created an account using my email.

At first I connected my Brave wallet. It was ok. But then I was requested 2 more wallets to connect as a recommendation. I thought it was necessary, but I was able to bypass it and add a passkey using only 1 wallet connect.
Personally, I find invasive to request more than 1 wallet to connect. I don't like people to know what wallets/addresses and balance history I do have. But, as it was optional, it is fine.

 

The interface is beautiful and website works well, everything smooth so far.

my address:
0x718cB3f68344e5FA0FE5AdbBeB764BEFF0150995

waiting for the next steps

[examplens]

waiting for the next steps

You need to post your wallet address from nyknyc, so Zen.land team can create an escrow contract.
note: NYKNYC wallet is just an additional feature, the basic functionality is the zen.land platform.

[bitmover]

waiting for the next steps

You need to post your wallet address from nyknyc, so Zen.land team can create an escrow contract.
note: NYKNYC wallet is just an additional feature, the basic functionality is the zen.land platform.

Thanks examplens.

Just edited my previous post with my wallet address.

I think I understand the platform better now. Already saw the place to upload the PDF, which they will send me.

[Rashlyowl]

Bros @Zenland, since you asked me to paste my NYKNYC address in your thread in our local board, does that mean I have to make the review in Indonesian, or is it mandatory to make the review in this thread?

Well, I asked it to avoid any misunderstandings at the end of the review, wanting everything to run smoothly.

[Zenland]

Bros @Zenland, since you asked me to paste my NYKNYC address in your thread in our local board, does that mean I have to make the review in Indonesian, or is it mandatory to make the review in this thread?

Well, I asked it to avoid any misunderstandings at the end of the review, wanting everything to run smoothly.

Hello Rashlyowl! We'd actually be very grateful if you could write your review in Bahasa Indonesia on the local board.

You have a strong reputation there, and it would mean a lot to have a local community member reviewing our service firsthand.

I hope it's not a problem

btw. When sending, there is no insight into the current balance, and even the "MAX" option does not recognize or enter the maximum amount.
The field for entering the seed phrase during verification is flat with a background, there are no frames or anything similar that would indicate that there is a field for entering text. Quite difficult to recognize, in dark mode, it is even worst

I will invite @bitmover, maybe he might be interested in learning about your platform.

Thank you, examplens! The first bug you found has already been fixed: GitHub commit

The rest of the bugs have been added to our backlog and should be resolved soon. And thanks for inviting @bitmover!

Zenland, have you been to altcoinstalks.com?

Yes, we're there! In fact, we're the only real escrow service on the platform: Zenland on AltcoinsTalks

We will update our thread there soon

My review about the service so far. To be updated.

I created my account there. I didn't use Google mail as suggested in the topic. I created an account using my email.

At first I connected my Brave wallet. It was ok. But then I was requested 2 more wallets to connect as a recommendation. I thought it was necessary, but I was able to bypass it and add a passkey using only 1 wallet connect.
Personally, I find invasive to request more than 1 wallet to connect. I don't like people to know what wallets/addresses and balance history I do have. But, as it was optional, it is fine.

That's a fair concern, bitmover. The reason NYKNYC asks for additional signers is to keep the wallet non-custodial while adding a safety net:

First signer - passkey. Your public key is stored directly inside your smart contract wallet. In normal use, you sign transactions in a second - with a fingerprint or PIN.

Second signer - backup key. This ensures that even if the NYKNYC site goes down, you can still sign transactions. And if you lose access to the device with your passkey, the backup key helps you recover control.

The goal was to make a wallet that's easier to use than browser extensions, without compromising on security.

Zenland works with any Web3 wallet - MetaMask, Brave Wallet, Rabby, WalletConnect.

Also, I think I've seen the bug you're describing - where you add a signer and it still asks for 2 more instead of recognizing that only 2 total are needed. I'll try to reproduce and catch it. Thanks for flagging that!

The interface is beautiful and website works well, everything smooth so far.

my address:
0x718cB3f68344e5FA0FE5AdbBeB764BEFF0150995

waiting for the next steps

Glad to hear it! Your contract has been created: View Contract

You can verify its authenticity at zen.land/verify

Feel free to accept and fulfill it at your convenience. Looking forward to your feedback!

[bitmover]

Also, I think I've seen the bug you're describing - where you add a signer and it still asks for 2 more instead of recognizing that only 2 total are needed. I'll try to reproduce and catch it. Thanks for flagging that!

Yeah  that really hhappened.

when I added the first wallet (and the only i added) ther was a message saying that it was required to add 2 more. The text was clearly saying 3 were required in total.
However, i clicked somewhere else and the message disappeared and I was able to complete the process with just 1 wallet .

I will take a look at the contract in a few hours. Thank you!