~
They are not, I already explained it above and you didn't read my post. Anyone who commits suicide because of this is at fault, not the apps providing the loans. Such loans are available by reputable establishments already such as banks and depending on the country the rates can be 5% to 25% or even more per year with many providing near instant approval. That is not any different from these instant loan apps that you talk about, which must have worse terms than the respective banks in the countries. We need to stop blaming others for our own decisions and faults, it is time to become more responsible people and not give excuses for the wrong decisions. Many of these loans were taken as spur of the moment decisions, for reasons of greed or envy. Definitely in those cases no blame at all falls on the loan provider, only on the loan taker.
I am not sure whether you are reading everything that I mentioned in my post. I will quote it for you again so that you can read what is written very clearly.
The second phase involves their collection tactics, which rely heavily on blackmail. Since almost all of these micro-loan apps are illegal and this is a major issue in India, I am certain the exact same thing is happening around the world as well.
~
The 22 year old BDS student from Kerala who died in April took a tiny micro loan explicitly because his mother desperately needed medical treatment. He was not trying to fund a luxury lifestyle; he was trying to save his mother. The operators went after his college faculty, morphed his photos, and harassed his social circle until the shame became completely overwhelming and took his life.
If you seriously think that this is normal behavior for instant loan app companies, then I have nothing more to say. I am not living in a utopian virtual reality to accept this as normal human behavior, nor should a financial company be allowed to blackmail and harass their customers just like that.
I did, and the case that you brought does not say anything against what I wrote. You took a very bad example and then made very big generalizations against all kinds of loan apps which is incorrect. We can never make judgements about a whole sector simply because there are some extreme cases. In most of these cases the issue lies entirely with the user. There are only 2 ways to get back your money from the perspective of the lender and they are either legal ways or illegal means. The reason why companies or individual resort to illegal means is usually either because the legal system is weak and does not protect the lenders properly or is very slow, or because the loan its is not legal in some way. In many cases loan sharks behave the way that they do not because they like to do it, it is because the people don't pay back the money that they owe in terms that they agreed on. We need to separate clear cases.
Case 1: Loan shark acting crazy, unreasonable, asking more repayment beyond what was agreed. This is truly bad and the fault lies at the loan shark and they can be considered evil. This is what you would see more often in movies.
Case 2: Loan shark demands money as agreed with the person, person does not pay back as agreed for whatever reason. This is when they try illegal tactics because they have no other choice! If the loan is illegal or it is a person or company that does crime, then there is no way to demand this money back legally. They can only try illegal tactics or accept that the person may never pay back. They can never accept that someone does not pay back or they will go bankrupt, everyone would try to get a loan from them and try to cheat them this way. That is why they enforce this system with violence, because it would not work at all otherwise!
So in cases of number 1 you are right to blame the lender, but in cases of 2 the blame is always at the borrower. If people paid their money back as agreed there would never be a case like 2 in existence, but they don't and that is why lenders get violent and do all kinds of illegal things like the blackmail that you have given as an example. Banks don't have to deal with that kind of stuff because they do things completely legally, they will take your house, collateral, or start legal proceedings against you without waiting even a moment. I really dislike people who don't pay back money, I have lost many friends to small amounts of money and I know many others who had the same happen. People who don't pay back what they owe are terrible people, it does not matter what you use the money for because it is not yours and you have to pay it back no matter what.
Again the point is, this person did not have to take the loan to provide medical treatment to his mother. Don't use good sounding reasons as excuses for bad behavior, that was not a trap because he inflicted it on himself. The responsibility in cases like that are always on the loan takers. For example if you take a loan from a local and known violent loan shark, then you accept anything that can come as a result from that!! Don't blame the world for your persona mistakes.
Although, you can’t create a budget without knowing the difference between your needs and your wants, which is the main reason for a budget. Because if you can’t differentiate them, even with a budget, you will still end up taking a loan. Which if the interest becomes higher you become disturbed, because you can’t pay it anymore, and the loan apps will definitely call for their money.
The issue with the young generation is also that they are letting the internet expand their needs with lies so many things that are wants they believe are needs. Also they keep increasing wants into all kinds of things that are not good for them, so that is making it worse too.