On November 10, 2021. After almost 847 days of waiting since the previous cycle top, BTC finally broke through and printed a new ATH of $69,000 - $69,044 to be exact on most exchanges.
This site is Bitcoin price on current date chart, and it is helpful for your need to check Bitcoin price on a same date over years.
https://charts.bitbo.io/price-current-date/But today, even after 5 years, $69k doesn't look so crazy anymore. But back then it felt like the moon and everyone was happy. Where were you on Nov 10, 2021?
Bitcoin has grown very strongly with time, years and market cycles, and after 5 years, Bitcoin is already in a new market cycle, so it's low price in this new market cycle can be higher than high prices in a previous market cycle.
People only feel magic when Bitcoin makes a new all time high, hits that price a first time ever. Anytime in the future, they will no longer feel similarly excited if Bitcoin hits that price again because they are already familiar with a new higher price band of Bitcoin.