Bitcoin Forum
November 18, 2026, 01:44:04 PM *
News: Latest Bitcoin Core release: 32.1 [Torrent]
 
   Home   Help Search Login Register More  
Pages: « 1 2 [3]  All
  Print  
Author Topic: Who pays for Bitcoin’s security when the block reward is almost gone?  (Read 351 times)
OsaiEmma
Full Member
***
Offline

Activity: 532
Merit: 208



View Profile WWW
Today at 07:58:58 AM
 #41


There are some ideas, with and without touching the 21 million limit, roughly ordered from "least" to "most" disruptive for the Bitcoin protocol:

- Merged-mined sidechains and altchains (already exist, but income proportion is tiny, we'd need much more attractive chains)
- Ordinals-like incentive mechanisms for certain coinbase transactions to work as as collectibles (I know this is highly controversial, but this is not the same thing as Inscriptions are)
- a second official token which could be distributed as tail emission (doesn't even need protocol changes in theory, but then it would not longer be "official", some of these tokens do already exist, above all in the Ordinals universe.)
- mandatory minimum transaction fee (like some altcoins have)
- a pooling mechanism to make fees more predictable (e.g. all fees in a month are collected and then distributed in the next month - doesn't solve the problem if the fee level is too low though)
- proof-of-stake elements to increase security even in low hashrate periods (many altcoins had done this switch in 2014/15 when PoW coins were still the norm and 51% attacks were increasing)
- an official tail emission like proposed by Peter Todd and implemented in coins like Monero

The last one is of course the "scariest", because the 21 million limit would be scrapped. The tail emission could however be designed to be so small that it would be less than 1) the coins lost in a year, and 2) economic/population growth.
But, aren't these ideas the same thing other altcoins are doing? Does that mean these other altcoins have been right from the start?

I feel we should improve things around the protocol instead, and not change things much especially the 21 million hard cap:

Since the adoption rate will increase significantly, and more users will be in the network transacting, we could:

- Reduce transaction confirmation time and increase block size/weight to enable more transaction in a single block; and thus, aggregate more fees.
- Reduce the cost of operation. I know this last one might be somewhat risky, but I feel it might be necessary to make the incentive worthwhile.
N/B: All these are aimed at making on-chain transactions convenient for increased utility/volume.

With these factors—which could accommodate higher transaction volume—I think the fees won't be that bad for miners. The network will generate more fees, and miners will be okay with it seeing their cost of operation is somewhat reduced.





I do not even have the faintest clue how you believe that fee income will be enough to secure the network when there continues to be zero evidence that it will do so. Fees are only a tiny percentage of compensation for miners, and it will remain that way for the foreseeable future. If fees were to increase to the point of being able to compensate miners, then the chain would become cost-prohibitive to normal economic activity. You could raise the block size, in accordance with technological improvements, but the community has constantly rejected that option. It would allow more txs, which could mean more cumulative fees for miners but not necessarily greater costs to users.
Bingo, that's what I proposed too.


However, the core problem is the 21 million and the block-halving algorithm. Even if you mitigated the things above, users are still not even remotely incentivized to actually use Bitcoin for anything but a digital paperweight.
That's not true. Volatility is reducing significantly, and at some point, the swings will be less aggressive/dramatic Cheesy. This will create less incentive in being just a "digital paperweight" (using your own words). With increased block size/weight, improved transaction speed, and increased adoption, there will be more transactions and more fees that could be enough to incentives miners—these are just possibilities.

ABCbits
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 3794
Merit: 10506



View Profile
Today at 08:46:47 AM
 #42

- Ordinals-like incentive mechanisms for certain coinbase transactions to work as as collectibles (I know this is highly controversial, but this is not the same thing as Inscriptions are)
- a second official token which could be distributed as tail emission (doesn't even need protocol changes in theory, but then it would not longer be "official", some of these tokens do already exist, above all in the Ordinals universe.)

Both of them partly covered by DMT-NAT token. But without demand or practical usage of the token, the income proportion is also tiny.

- proof-of-stake elements to increase security even in low hashrate periods (many altcoins had done this switch in 2014/15 when PoW coins were still the norm and 51% attacks were increasing)
- an official tail emission like proposed by Peter Todd and implemented in coins like Monero

The last one is of course the "scariest", because the 21 million limit would be scrapped. The tail emission could however be designed to be so small that it would be less than 1) the coins lost in a year, and 2) economic/population growth.

Personally i would rather choose tail emission over switching from PoW to PoS or PoW/PoS hybrid scheme. Tail emission have lower complexity (which means less possible bugs) and already proven work well enough on Monero.

gwestcot
Sr. Member
****
Online Online

Activity: 884
Merit: 293



View Profile
Today at 09:21:01 AM
 #43

- Ordinals-like incentive mechanisms for certain coinbase transactions to work as as collectibles (I know this is highly controversial, but this is not the same thing as Inscriptions are)
- a second official token which could be distributed as tail emission (doesn't even need protocol changes in theory, but then it would not longer be "official", some of these tokens do already exist, above all in the Ordinals universe.)

Both of them partly covered by DMT-NAT token. But without demand or practical usage of the token, the income proportion is also tiny.

- proof-of-stake elements to increase security even in low hashrate periods (many altcoins had done this switch in 2014/15 when PoW coins were still the norm and 51% attacks were increasing)
- an official tail emission like proposed by Peter Todd and implemented in coins like Monero

The last one is of course the "scariest", because the 21 million limit would be scrapped. The tail emission could however be designed to be so small that it would be less than 1) the coins lost in a year, and 2) economic/population growth.

Personally i would rather choose tail emission over switching from PoW to PoS or PoW/PoS hybrid scheme. Tail emission have lower complexity (which means less possible bugs) and already proven work well enough on Monero.

I have already created adaptive emissions, but simplicity is a credible concern. Tail emissions are easy to understand and easy to implement with a whole lot fewer edge cases. It really is all about what you desire and what you are willing to trade away with these sorts of design choices.
pooya87
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 4284
Merit: 12805



View Profile
Today at 01:27:26 PM
 #44

That is how bitcoin works. Higher demand will increase the investment in mining therefore it increases the hashrate and conversely a decreasing demand means some miners stop mining and hashrate/difficulty comes down to reach a balanced state.
Bitcoin mining farms, companies behind such farms, and individual Bitcoin miners have their own business to take care, and they need profit, but at least they need a draw. There are not many Bitcoin miners (either companies, farms or individuals) can survive a long time if Bitcoin market is too bearish and cost of mining exceeds total value of rewards they got from mining blocks and confirming transactions.

Each Bitcoin bear market has its time for mining capitulation and people are worrying about the future, when there will no longer bear market capitulation but a complete massive capitulation.

https://www.lookintobitcoin.com/bitcoin-research/bitcoin-miners-capitulating-but-their-stocks-are-soaring/
The beautiful thing about bitcoin is that how difficult it is to mine bitcoin depends on how many are mining it. So what you are saying is a game of whoever blinks first loses. he cost of mining is not the same for everyone considering the massively huge range of electricity prices and salaries around the world. So in each bear market, the most expensive operations shut down and hashrate comes down to make it easier for those who remain to continue mining bitcoin.

But I get the concern too. We are certain that price goes up but there is no guarantee it will! And if there is a significant drop in hashrate, it could open bitcoin up to certain attacks. We are very far away from that becoming a real risk though.

▄▄████████████████████▄▄
▄███████▀▀██████▀▀███████▄
█████▀██████████████▀█████
████████▄▄██████▄▄████▀███

██████████████████████████
██▄▄██████████████▄▄██████
██▀▀██████████████████▄▄██
██████▀▀██████████████▀▀██
██████████████████████████
███▄████▀▀██████▀▀████████
█████▄██████████████▄█████
▀███████▄▄██████▄▄███████▀
▀▀████████████████████▀▀
 
 DΞX.fo 
▄▄██████
█████████
██████████
██████████
██████████
█████████
▀▀██████

▄███████
▄██████████
████████████
█████████████
█████████████
|
▄▄█
▄████▀
▄███▀█▄
▄██▀█▄██
█████▀▀█
████████
████████
▀██▄████
▄████▄▄█
▄█████▀███
▄█████▀████▀
█████▀███████
▀██▀█████████
|..BTC......XMR...
..USDT.....LTC...
....Fees  0.8%.....
Pages: « 1 2 [3]  All
  Print  
 
Jump to:  

Powered by MySQL Powered by PHP Powered by SMF 1.1.19 | SMF © 2006-2009, Simple Machines Valid XHTML 1.0! Valid CSS!