~
First of all, why is this topic in Off-topic?
Cyrus, could you please move it to Meta?
I mean, how can such an important discussion about the future of independent websites and the challenges Bitcointalk itself is facing go unnoticed by those of us who rarely visit Off-topic?
Anyway, coming back to the topic...
I'd say either Bitcointalk is extremely lucky, or it's remarkably resilient despite running on software that belongs in a museum by now.

Perhaps its relatively simple design is actually an advantage, although I wouldn't underestimate the continuous maintenance and security work happening behind the scenes.
Secondly, I think Bitcointalk has become something of a historical archive of Bitcoin. We have discussions going back to the earliest days of Bitcoin, including posts by Satoshi himself. So I wouldn't be surprised if AI crawlers are particularly interested in indexing this forum. There is a wealth of information here that probably makes it an attractive target for training data collection and automated research.
Who would have thought that one day we'd have more AI agents desperately trying to read our posts than humans willing to write them?

Regarding your concern about running independent websites, I think it depends on the type of service being offered.
For SaaS platforms and other commercial services, I can imagine increasingly strict authentication, identity verification, and anti-bot measures becoming common.
I've also noticed that many services are pushing users toward mobile apps rather than traditional websites.
However, mobile apps aren't necessarily immune to AI-driven traffic or DDoS attacks. They still communicate with backend APIs, which can be targeted just like ordinary websites. Perhaps the advantage is that app developers have more options for device attestation and controlling how clients access those APIs.
But I'm particularly concerned about your prediction that ordinary websites might eventually require proof-of-personhood.
Imagine having to complete KYC just to read a forum post about why KYC is bad (and it's not even April 1st)!
I hope we can find better approaches, such as privacy-preserving authentication, rate limiting, or even computational proof-of-work challenges (not sure exactly how that would work, just thinking out loud), rather than forcing everyone to identify themselves just to browse the Web.
One thing I'd be interested to know is whether AI itself could help us detect and stop these AI bots.
After all, modern problems require modern solutions, right? But then we'd have AI fighting AI, and I guess that could turn into a never-ending cat-and-mouse game.
And if that's where we're heading, the biggest threat to the independent Web might not be Skynet taking over...
It might simply be Skynet making the hosting bills unaffordable for everyone else! [cry in AI meme]