I have zero respect for Ledger's "Donjon."
I have to disagree with you on this one, as much as I don't like ledger and everyone knows that.
Donjon team is the best part of the ledger company, and they actually discovered real bugs in different hardware wallets.
And thew gloated, and they gloated, as publicly as possible in order to promote Ledger... all while hiding their own code behind a closed-source license. That's slimy.
Other devs have found tons of bugs in other hardware wallets, but instead of publicly gloating, they privately contacted the devs behind those other wallets to help them patch the bugs... because keeping people's Bitcoin safe should be the priority.
I have zero respect for anyone who works at Ledger. Zero. I'm not even convinced they're good people. Yes, they have talent, but in terms of morality and basic human decency, I don't think they're good people. It takes a truly terrible person to put other people's financial security at risk in order for themselves to make a quick buck, all while selling a product that is supposed to help people keep their financial security secure.
Putting a key extraction API in hardware wallet firmware is poison. It's poison. And Ledger lied about it again and again.
"Your keys are always stored on your device and never leave it"
btchip, Ledger Co-Founder, on May 14th, 2023
That's a brutal lie. They were testing key extraction over the internet by the time he said that.
They said it on twitter:
"Hi - your private keys **never** leave the Secure Element chip, which has never been hacked. The Secure Element is 3rd party certified, and is the same technology as used in passports and credit cards. A firmware update cannot extract the private keys from the Secure Element."
Brutal. Why hack the chip when there's an API baked into the firmware to extract seeds from the chip, over the internet?
Ledger said keys never leave the secure element chip while they were writing an API to extract seeds from the secure element chip over the internet. Those kinds of false marketing claims are pure evil and they shouldn't be legal.
Ledger was knowingly lying to their customers, which explains why they had to scrub so many lies off their own website in 2023, when they launched Ledger Recover:
Lies, lies, lies. All scrubbed from their website in summer 2023 when they launched Ledger Recover.
Unbelievably, this lie is still on their website:
Never ever? ...except during key extraction over the internet, of course.
What a terrible company Ledger is.