Bitcoin Forum
November 20, 2026, 08:58:23 PM *
News: Latest Bitcoin Core release: 32.1 [Torrent]
 
   Home   Help Search Login Register More  
Pages: [1]
  Print  
Author Topic: [List] Collecting income ideas for miners when the block rewards end.  (Read 34 times)
d5000 (OP)
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 4830
Merit: 11463


Decentralization Maximalist


View Profile
Today at 05:33:58 PM
 #1

Bitcoin halvings, each 4 years, will reduce the reward for miners, and in 2140 there will be no rewards anymore. While some think this is not a problem because transaction fees could make up for the loss of the traditional block reward, regularly forum posts pop up that express worries about that problem. And I think also it's good to have a list of "Plan B" scenarios if the security budget gets too low.

So let's see some ideas. They are ordered roughly from "doesn't need protocol changes at all" to drastic changes like a removal of the 21 million coin cap.

Merged-mined sidechains and altchains

Via merged-mining, the miners can collect rewards from other chains (altcoins or sidechains) without having to provide more computational work. This already exists. but income proportion is tiny, we'd need much more attractive chains.

Ordinals-like miner-benefitting collectibles

Since Ordinals started in 2023, some people started to collect certain UTXOs from blocks like halving blocks or difficulty period starts/ends. This increases the fee level of these blocks artificially. I know this is highly controversial, but this is not the same thing as Inscriptions are. It can also be only a partial solution, because not all blocks would benefit from it.

A separate token which could be distributed as tail emission

An infinite tail emission could be paid out in a token which is not Bitcoin but lives on the same chain, or in an extension block (like Litecoin's MWEB).

If this is implemented "unofficially", e.g. via RGB, Omni or Counterparty, it doesn't even need protocol changes in theory. Some of these tokens do already exist, above all in the Ordinals / Runes universe (e.g. the DMT-NAT token). Currently, the same thing applies as to merged mining: the valuation of these tokens is too small to be relevant.

However, it could also be implemented as an "official" token, for example in an extension block, where more block space is allocated for it, or it could provide new features like privacy (e.g. like MWEB) or smart contracts. An extension block is something like an "official sidechain", i.e. a block extension which does not need to be validated by all mainchain nodes but only these who want to participate.

A mandatory minimum transaction fee

You can specify in the protocol that users have to pay a certain minimum fee per transaction - otherwise it would be invalid. This has been done in some altcoins already.

The problem here is that the fee could be so high that it discourages transactions, and thus it's not necessarily good for adoption. And this could in theory lead to even a lower fee level due to less competition for block space.

A pooling mechanism to make fees more predictable

An example: all fees in a month are collected and then distributed in the next month. This doesn't solve the problem if the fee level is too low though.

Proof-of-stake elements to increase security even in low hashrate periods

Many altcoins had done this switch in 2014/15 when PoW coins were still the norm and 51% attacks were increasing. The downside is obvious: PoS has a centralizing effect, and it is not fully understood if it is not "gameable" in some way ("nothing at stake problem"), even if Ethereum seems to prove the opposite.

A block size increase (not really a solution!)

Some think that a block size increase could increase transaction activity and thus lead to more fees for the miners.

However, this is not sure, only if it really triggers an enormous amount of currency use and paymemt activity. If activity instead only increases a little bit, then the amount of fees will decline, because there is less competition for blocks.

An official tail emission

A tail emission is a small reward which will be paid infinitely. This removes the 21 million cap.

This was proposed even by some developers like Peter Todd. It was implemented in coins like Monero too. A small reward (e.g. 0.1%, or 0.1 BTC which would be even less) would not really disrupt the "scarcity effect" of Bitcoin.

The problem is of course that Bitcoin is marketed as a coin with a "hard cap" and this would thus by many be considered a betrayal or dilution. So it would lead to very deep disputes, and could trigger a hard fork.

Personally, if I would design Bitcoin as a new coin, however, I think I would implement some kind of tail emission. There are ideas to make it react to demand a bit, for example.




Do you know other ideas or want to discuss the existing ones? Then this thread is for you Smiley

(This list was taken from a post by me in a topic that was - probably rightfully - deleted. I've chosen to expand it a bit more and make it a thread, as I'm also interested in other ideas circulating.)

CryptoHeadlineNews
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 1876
Merit: 1044


Want to run a Signature Campaign? Contac: @Hhampuz


View Profile WWW
Today at 07:59:42 PM
 #2

A mandatory minimum transaction fee

You can specify in the protocol that users have to pay a certain minimum fee per transaction - otherwise it would be invalid. This has been done in some altcoins already.

The problem here is that the fee could be so high that it discourages transactions, and thus it's not necessarily good for adoption. And this could in theory lead to even a lower fee level due to less competition for block space.
This would have been a very good scenario after the last Bitcoin block is been mined in 2140. By initiating the idea of paying a minimum transaction fee that will be fair to everyone and not an outrageous one that will scare people away from it. Because even now, we still pay transaction fees whenever we transfer our Bitcoin from one wallet to another, and having a measurable increase in the fees won't make any much difference, since we are already familliar with. Because the only time people will have issues with that is when its been capped at an exact percentage (i.e 0.1% OR 1%)

 
█▄
R


▀▀▀▀▀▀▀██████▄▄
████████████████
▀▀▀▀█████▀▀▀█████
████████▌███▐████
▄▄▄▄█████▄▄▄█████
████████████████
▄▄▄▄▄▄▄██████▀▀
LLBIT▀█ 
  THE #1 SOLANA CASINO  
████████████▄
▀▀██████▀▀███
██▄▄▀▀▄▄█████
█████████████
█████████████
███▀█████████
▀▄▄██████████
█████████████
█████████████
█████████████
█████████████
█████████████
████████████▀
████████████▄
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀██████
█████████████
▄████████████
██▄██████████
████▄████████
█████████████
█░▀▀█████████
▀▀███████████
█████▄███████
████▀▄▀██████
▄▄▄▄▄▄▄██████
████████████▀
........5,000+........
GAMES
 
......INSTANT......
WITHDRAWALS
..........HUGE..........
REWARDS
 
............VIP............
PROGRAM
 .
   PLAY NOW    
Smartprofit
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 3206
Merit: 2506



View Profile WWW
Today at 08:12:27 PM
 #3

For example, we could provide for miner fees not only for transactions but also for simply storing Bitcoin. We could, for example, provide for automatic periodic transfers of Bitcoin between different addresses controlled by the owner, with fees paid to the miners. 🙋

This isn't a new idea. It underlies the tax system of virtually every country. In addition to transaction taxes (VAT), almost every country has a property tax. The logic is simple: if you own real estate, you must pay taxes. Bitcoin is the real estate of the digital world. And since miners are the ones who secure the network, this income should belong to them. This way, they can effectively perform their functions.

The idea of ​​changing the consensus algorithm from PoW to PoS personally terrifies me. 🤷

▄▄███████████████████▄▄
▄███████████████████████▄
███████████████████▄█████
█████████████████████████
███████████▀█████████████
█████████▀███▀██████▀████
██████████████████▄██████
█████████▄▄█▄▄███████████
██████████▄▄▄████████████
███████████████████▀█████
████████████████▀▀███████
▀███████████████████████▀
▀▀███████████████████▀▀
 
 EARNBET 
|⚽ 🏀
 
🏈 🏓
 
🎯 🥊
 
⚾ 🎾
 
⛳ 🏐
 
🏏 🏎️
|


███████▄▄███████████
████▄██████████████████
██▄▀▀███████████████▀▀███
█▄████████████████████████
▄▄████████▀▀▀▀▀████████▄▄██
███████████████████████████
█████████▌████▀████████████
███████████████████████████
▀▀███████▄▄▄▄▄█████████▀▀██
█▀█████████████████████▀██
██▀▄▄███████████████▄▄███
████▀██████████████████
███████▀▀███████████

....HIGHEST....
VIP REWARDS

 ✔ G U A R A N T E E D   
| 
 🜲 
KING OF
THE CASTLE

$200K in prizes
| 
..PLAY NOW..
Upgrade00
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 2940
Merit: 3008


Community Manager - Brand Promotions ✅


View Profile WWW
Today at 08:21:17 PM
 #4

I can imagine archived versions of this thread getting shared in a 100 years and people then think the ideas actually helpful to them in their time with the limited information we have now.

I am against any fix that requires a protocol change like tail emissions or minimum fee for transactions to be accepted. I think naturally fees will go higher or purchases get valued in bitcoin which could be insanely expensive that the sats for fees are worth significantly more than now.

There was a suggestion of lightning getting more popular that on chain transactions gets lumped to times when channels are being opened or closed and a high fee is paid for this. The downside is this results in less on chain usage and lightning has not caught up enough to suggest it could be used so popularly.

███████████████████████████
███████▄████████████▄██████
████████▄████▄████▄████████
███▀█████▀█▄███▄█▀█████▀███
█████▀█▀█▄██▀▀▀██▄█▀█▀█████
███████▄███████████▄███████
███████████████████████████
███████▀███████████▀███████
████▄██▄█▀██▄▄▄██▀█▄██▄████
████▄████▄█▀███▀█▄████▄████
██▄███▀▀█▀███▀███▀█▀███▄███
██▀█▀████████████████▀█▀███
███████████████████████████
.
.Duelbits..REWARDING, BEYOND LIMITS...
█████████████████████████
█████████████████████████
███████████▀▀░░▀█▄░░▀████
████████▀░░░░░░░░▀█▄░████
███████░░░░▄▄░░▄░░░▀█████
██████░░░░░▀▀▄██▀░░░░████
█████░░░██░▄██▀▄▄░░░█████
████░░░░░▄██▀░░▀▀░░██████
█████▄░░▀█▀░██░░░░███████
████░▀█▄░░░░░░░░▄████████
████▄░░▀█▄░░▄▄███████████
█████████████████████████
█████████████████████████
█████████████████████████
█████████████████████████
█████████▀░░▀░███████████
████████░░░▄░█░██████████
███████████▌▐██░█████████
███████████░███▌▐████████
██████████░█████░████████
██████▀░▄░▀███▀░▄░▀██████
█████░▄▀░░░░█░▄▀░░░░█████
█████░░░░░░░█░░░░░░░█████
██████▄░░░▄███▄░░░▄██████
█████████████████████████
█████████████████████████
█
█
█
█
█
█
█
█
█
█
█
█
█

█
█
█
█
█
█
█
█
█
█
█
█
█

  PLAY NOW  
Ambatman
Legendary
*
Online Online

Activity: 1190
Merit: 1484


Don't tell anyone


View Profile WWW
Today at 08:41:31 PM
 #5

Haven't really thought much about an alternative since I usually take it that
If Bitcoin can make it till only fee era then it's already self sustaining.
Since a lower hashrate doesn't necessarily mean bitcoin is insecure
The relative cost of attacking the network being higher than the benefit could be a bare minimum.  

Quote
Since Ordinals started in 2023, some people started to collect certain UTXOs from blocks like halving blocks or difficulty period starts/ends
Ordinals were and are usually speculative and building security around those feels risky.

Quote
A separate token which could be distributed as tail emission
infinite almost reminded me of Fiat.
People would need a reason to buy for it to have real value and it moves bitcoin security
In a way to be dependent on another token.

Quote
Do you know other ideas or want to discuss the existing ones?
We could also try sticking with the boring route of making demand for blockspace attractive
Because if itself can be attractive to miners
Whatever alternative we can think of would always be temporary.



This isn't a new idea. It underlies the tax system of virtually every country. In addition to transaction taxes (VAT), almost every country has a property tax.
Like I pay Capital gain tax or something and would be forced to pay some tax as the years goes by
Who's going to spend the coins that would be paid as tax?
Or are they going to be paid by increasing the limit of bitcoin or something?

Pages: [1]
  Print  
 
Jump to:  

Powered by MySQL Powered by PHP Powered by SMF 1.1.19 | SMF © 2006-2009, Simple Machines Valid XHTML 1.0! Valid CSS!