Bitcoin Forum
November 22, 2026, 09:41:55 PM *
News: Latest Bitcoin Core release: 32.1 [Torrent]
 
   Home   Help Search Login Register More  
Pages: [1]
  Print  
Author Topic: Yet another Tether FUD: Is Tether really undercollateralised?  (Read 28 times)
fillippone (OP)
Legendary
*
Online Online

Activity: 3080
Merit: 22005


Duelbits.com - Rewarding, beyond limits.


View Profile WWW
Today at 02:47:54 PM
 #1

This tweet by @BladeDefi is doing the rounds and getting  a lot of traction.



This is the latest iteration of Tether FUD: If Bitcoin goes down, Tether will be forced to sell their Bitcoins, making the price spiral down.

Let's figure out what the situation is.

Firstly, a little zoom on the most interesting part:



This is from Tether's BDO quarterly attestation, dated 30 September 2026, available here:




On the same attestation they say they have around 183 billion  liabilities (Tether Tokens) backed by 191 Billion assets:



As of 30 September, bitcoin was valued at  83,621.23 USD and Gold at 4,157.41 USD/OZ, as per the attestation. This implies 100,060.35 BTC and 4,590,514.7 gold Ounces  (roughly 142.8 metric tons)

We can directly check  Tether’s known reserve address to have a confirmation:


Almost all the Bitcoins are in a single address.

Since then, a lot of action in the market has happened: Bitcoin is now trading at 60,000 USD and Gold at 3,538:



Since then, Tether's gold and BTC have already lost 15% and 28% for a cumulative loss of roughly 5.2 bln USD , hence at today's prices, I estimate excess reserves at 2.7-3.6bln USD, from 7.95 bln USD.



The buffer goes to zero with another -10/-15% in gold and BTC together. Gold matters far more than Bitcoin.

Two pieces are missing from the analysis of the original tweet and I added above, one in Tether's favour: profits, about $16.5M a day, and another against: the $4.18bn of public equities, which the report describes as indirect exposure to gold and bitcoin, that have as well probably deteriorated since the date of 30 September.

Tether is holding almost 140 billion USD in T-bills and other liquid assets. Those assets yield somewhere around 3.90%,  or 1.365 Billions per quarter. This number is extremely close to the last Tether Operating profit of 1.5 Billion (Tether has other small operating profits from other sources).
During the current quarter two things happened, with opposite effects on the results, but basically canceling out: while the holding reduced because of the shrinking of the issued token base, with current estimates around 130 USD billions, the yield on the same reserves grew to 4.15%, raising the operating profit. As I said, the two effects cancel out, and we still can think of 1.5 billion as a good estimate for this quarter.
This means that every month , Tether has 500 millions of extra cushion to absorb losses.

On the contrary, the analysis doesn't include Equities.
The report shows $4.18bn of "Public Equities" and describes them only as indirect exposure to gold, bitcoin and other assets through listed shares, valued at closing prices. No issuer, ticker or sector breakdown is given, so the mark-to-market has to be estimated.
My base assumption is the simple average of the two underlying moves since 30 Sep: BTC -28.3% and gold -14.9%, i.e. -21.6%, or about -$0.9bn.

Two cross-checks on these assumptions:
  • Listed proxies fell more than the underlyings: gold miners (GDX) -24% and MSTR -52% over the same period. A 50/50 mix of the two would be -38%, about -$1.6bn.
  • The line's own behaviour in Q3 points the other way: it rose 11% (3.76 to 4.18) while BTC gained 43% and gold 4%. Assuming no net buying, that fits a basket roughly 80% gold-linked and 20% bitcoin-linked, which today would be down about 18%, or -$0.7bn.
So the plausible range is -$0.7bn to -$1.6bn, and the conservative case moves between about $2.0bn and $2.9bn.
Loans and other investments are left at par.

Going back to the under-collateralisation part.
There is no liquidation price in the technical sense: Tether has no margin calls. There is a level at which the mark-to-market buffer hits zero, and it depends on two prices: Gold and Bitcoin.



With the same drop in both: -16.2% in the optimistic case (BTC $50,300, gold $2,970) and -10.6%  in the conservative one (BTC $53,700, gold $3,160). So the tweet's "-16%", recomputed from today, is the best case.
Rule of thumb: every -1% in gold costs $162M, every -1% in BTC $60M, every day of profit adds $16.5M. The exposure is 73% gold. Another week like the last one (BTC -14.9%, gold -8.8%) would cost $2.3-2.7bn.

Of course, we know tether is a money printing machine: what if they use their profits to replenish collateralisation?
In Q3 Tether reported $1.5bn of net operating profit, on about $140bn of T-bills and repos with the 3-month T-bill averaging 3.88%.
In Q4, supply has fallen from 183.8 to 174.8bn (burns, including the 4bn one on 20 Nov, retire tokens already redeemed): the average interest-earning base shrinks by about 4.5%. The 3-month T-bill, however, has risen to 4.24% (quarter-to-date average 4.16%). As I have already explained above, the two effects offset each other, and I still estimate about $1.5bn for the quarter or 0.5 a month.
As a sensitivity analysis: every $10bn of redemptions takes away about $105M a quarter; every +25bp adds about $82M. If the Fed hikes in December, Q1 2027 heads towards $1.6bn. The price effect on T-bills is negligible: average maturity is under 90 days.

At flat prices and with no dividends: recovering the $5.2bn lost this quarter takes about 10 months; each further -10% in gold and BTC ($2.2bn) is worth 4-5 months.
Carry is not the only lever. In the BDO reports, net capital movements are +$943M in the first half (against a result of -$3.2bn) and -$519M over nine months: shareholders put capital in while the buffer was shrinking and, by difference, took $1-1.5bn back out in Q3.
A word of caution: in Lugano Ardoino spoke of about 150,000 BTC versus 100,060 in the reserves, but USDT holders have no claim on coins outside the reserves.
Getting to 100% in T-bills alone is another story: the gap is about $43bn, seven years of profits.

What does the options market say?
Bitcoin is the only leg we can read on Deribit, so let's start there. Implied volatility has jumped: as of 22 November, the DVOL index is at 56, from 46 three days ago, and on the 25 December expiry the 50k put trades at 66% implied vol against 52% at the money. Downside protection is expensive.
From each expiry's smile we can derive the risk-neutral probability of BTC reaching the two levels above, 53,700 (conservative case) and 50,300 (optimistic case):



With gold flat, BTC would have to fall to 38,800 (3% by December, 10% by March) or to 24,000 (below 1% and 3%) to wipe out the buffer on its own.
But Bitcoin is only about a quarter of the exposure, and there is no gold on Deribit. So I combined the BTC distribution implied by Deribit with gold at 30% volatility (the gold volatility index, GVZ, was 28.7 on 20 November) and the 0.55 correlation the two have shown over the last 30-90 days, assuming profits are retained. This gives the probability that the mark-to-market buffer turns negative:



The first number is the optimistic case, the second the conservative one. These are probabilities implied by option prices, not forecasts: puts are expensive and inflate the downside tail.

The conclusion, in my opinion, is that the tweet starts with real numbers, adds sloppy math, ends with clickbait tone.
The substance holds up, though, and the updated figures are actually tighter than the tweet's: the margin is below June's level and one more leg down in gold is enough to wipe it out on paper.
That said, a negative buffer doesn't mean USDT is at 0.97. Redemptions are paid with T-bills and repos, which cover 75% of tokens; since 30 Sep $9bn has left at par, and in 2022 20% of supply left in two months. Treasuries are amongst the most liquid, if not the most liquid, asset in the world and can be sold in the market with little impact. The real risk is reflexivity: whoever redeems first gets out at 1, and the hole stays with those who remain.
I am pretty constructive at this point: Tether already has shrunk their token AUM considerably over the last weeks without any problem, and the liquidity and soundness of reserves, also thanks to the much improved, yet partial, transparency efforts over the last years, are not in question, so far.
What to watch: gold more than BTC, USDT supply and price, and the attestation due at the end of January.
Of course, I think that there was no need to have part of the reserves backed by bitcoin, or gold, when you have treasuries. I would have used the hard assets only for the equity part, at maximum.
Having said so, I highly doubt the market wants to see blood on them, even if it likes to hit the weakest link until it breaks, or not.

Jubilee58
Full Member
***
Offline

Activity: 462
Merit: 168


View Profile
Today at 03:56:45 PM
Last edit: Today at 04:14:12 PM by Jubilee58
 #2

I don't really think if tether is under collateralized, tether have ascertained they have have enough usdt in their reserve which is the same as the number of usdt in circulation, backed 1:1 with usd, and I think this is the main reason why tether or usdt is difficult to deppeg. There ar many other usdt out there including the one that of terra usdt that deppegged some time in 2022 by Do Kwon. I think tether have have not witnessed any collapse since it's inception, and for now I think tether usdt remains the most trusted, and despite that Gold and Bitcoin are dipping in their price, I believe tether usdt will likely withstand that pressure without being affected by the market volatility.
slapper
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 2730
Merit: 1259


CCC.io - Crypto Casino & Web3 Betting Platform


View Profile WWW
Today at 09:24:00 PM
 #3

Agreed on the equity part. Not 100% sure on "no need" though, depends on whose need we're talking about. Look at who gets what. As you point out (by difference), approx. 1-1.5bn was withdrawn by shareholders during the run up of BTC and gold in Q3. So the paper profits from that run up were cashed out. Now those same assets drop, with that downside risk borne by USDT holders (who presumably didn't want any exposure to either). The upside goes to the shareholders, tail risk goes to the end users. It's the same classic moral hazard problem you see with banks. Except in the present case there is no deposit guarantee and no real regulatory oversight.

I think I would take a stab at defending Tether, though it's not very palatable to me personally. Sure, they could back their tokens 100% with T-bills, arguably the safest investment available, except those are issued by the very body with the power to freeze Tether. So gold and bitcoin would act as hedges against that. Relying purely on T-bills when the T-bill issuer itself is your biggest risk puts them in a weird spot. Hedging looks paranoid? Possibly. But they've already relocated to El Salvador, so they clearly take that risk seriously.

And then there's the GENIUS Act. Well, under US laws, regulated issuers basically aren't allowed to hold anything other than cash and T-Bills, so of course Tether issued another coin backed solely by T-Bills to be used in the US. So anyone living in the US can be assured their US version is safe and boring. However, people living in countries such as Argentina, Turkey or Nigeria (to name a few) who actually depend on USDT as their dollar end up with a coin that still carries gold and BTC alongside those T-bills. Funny how that works.

Pages: [1]
  Print  
 
Jump to:  

Powered by MySQL Powered by PHP Powered by SMF 1.1.19 | SMF © 2006-2009, Simple Machines Valid XHTML 1.0! Valid CSS!