Bitcoin Forum
May 05, 2024, 11:27:22 PM
Welcome,
Guest
. Please
login
or
register
.
News
: Latest Bitcoin Core release:
27.0
[
Torrent
]
Home
Help
Search
Login
Register
More
Bitcoin Forum
>
Economy
>
Economics
>
Read this before having an opinion on economics
Pages:
«
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
[
9
]
10
11
12
13
14
15
»
All
« previous topic
next topic »
Print
Author
Topic: Read this before having an opinion on economics (Read 25890 times)
NghtRppr
(OP)
Sr. Member
Offline
Activity: 504
Merit: 252
Elder Crypto God
Re: Read this before having an opinion on economics
April 30, 2011, 04:48:34 AM
#161
Quote from: LH66 on April 29, 2011, 08:45:16 PM
Question: Do you believe that a single person can be harmed without it having a negative impact on others?
If you own a lemonade stand and I start giving out free lemonade while standing next to it, I'm harming you but I'm also helping other people by giving out free lemonade. The question is a matter of whether or not there is a net benefit to society by IP laws. Just because the lack of IP laws may hurt the author of a book doesn't mean it can't help others.
"The nature of Bitcoin is such that once version 0.1 was released, the core design was set in stone for the rest of its lifetime." -- Satoshi
Advertised sites are not endorsed by the Bitcoin Forum. They may be unsafe, untrustworthy, or illegal in your jurisdiction.
1714951642
Hero Member
Offline
Posts: 1714951642
Ignore
1714951642
1714951642
#2
1714951642
Report to moderator
1714951642
Hero Member
Offline
Posts: 1714951642
Ignore
1714951642
1714951642
#2
1714951642
Report to moderator
1714951642
Hero Member
Offline
Posts: 1714951642
Ignore
1714951642
1714951642
#2
1714951642
Report to moderator
LH66
Newbie
Offline
Activity: 42
Merit: 0
Re: Read this before having an opinion on economics
April 30, 2011, 05:09:30 AM
Last edit: April 30, 2011, 05:20:24 AM by LH66
#162
Quote
If you own a lemonade stand and I start giving out free lemonade while standing next to it, I'm harming you but I'm also helping other people by giving out free lemonade. The question is a matter of whether or not there is a net benefit to society by IP laws. Just because the lack of IP laws may hurt the author of a book doesn't mean it can't help others.
I see the net effect as harming both of us. You're giving people your resources in exchange for nothing in return. This results in a net loss for you. This is not sustainable. Unless you have the resources of a very wealthy person (and perhaps you do but I assumed we were discussing the ordinary person), you won't be able to afford to give away the lemons, the sugar, the water, the table, the chair, the sign, the napkins, the cups, not to mention the opportunity cost of losing that time to a money making endeavor.... maybe you could have been trading stocks instead of giving away lemonade.
Questions: what is your reason for giving away the lemonade? Do you foresee doing this for a long period of time? If so, how will you regain your costs so that you can continue? If won't continue for a long period of time, why not?
I, on the other hand, once I see that the lemonade market is not profitable, will either seek to make it profitable, or seek a market that is. I'm going to make money, one way or another. And I will do so by helping people.
I have found, the hard way, that people do not value what is given. I used to occassionally give away my time in the hope that the client would appreciate it. I found the exact opposite. The people who wanted, and got, my time for free were very ungrateful. The clients who pay are grateful. Just how it works.
NghtRppr
(OP)
Sr. Member
Offline
Activity: 504
Merit: 252
Elder Crypto God
Re: Read this before having an opinion on economics
April 30, 2011, 06:42:01 PM
#163
The point was only that some things can harm some people while helping others. That should be fairly uncontroversial. If you don't like the lemonade stand analogy then I'm sure you can tweak it a little so that it fits, instead of giving it away, selling it at a lower price or even the same price. I'm still hurting your business by not giving you the entire market to yourself. I'm sure you could come up with your own example if you gave it enough thought.
This leaves us with the real question regarding IP laws: are they a net benefit or a net harm to society? If you don't know one way or the other and can't provide evidence to backup your assertion then you have no business advocating the existence of such laws. One assumes that the state of nature is the default and that we don't keep laws on the books without good reason. I personally think that IP laws are a net harm because it stifles innovation, i.e. nobody can use the likeness of existing fictional characters to reinterpret them into new contexts and stories.
BitterTea
Sr. Member
Offline
Activity: 294
Merit: 250
Re: Read this before having an opinion on economics
April 30, 2011, 06:47:30 PM
#164
I feel that it comes down to a simple question.
Do you have the right to use force against me in order to control the way in which your idea is used?
NghtRppr
(OP)
Sr. Member
Offline
Activity: 504
Merit: 252
Elder Crypto God
Re: Read this before having an opinion on economics
April 30, 2011, 06:53:30 PM
#165
Quote from: BitterTea on April 30, 2011, 06:47:30 PM
Do you have the right to use force against me in order to control the way in which your idea is used?
Some people think initiating violence is acceptable as long as there is a net benefit to society. I disagree with that but I would also like to point out that it hasn't even been established that there is a net benefit to society as far as intellectual property laws are concerned.
BitterTea
Sr. Member
Offline
Activity: 294
Merit: 250
Re: Read this before having an opinion on economics
April 30, 2011, 07:00:20 PM
#166
I think it also has to be established that society can be benefited or harmed. No action can be taken against or for society, only against or for individuals. To say that the initiation of force is acceptable when it benefits society is to say that it is acceptable to aggress against some individual or group for the benefit of another individual or group.
LH66
Newbie
Offline
Activity: 42
Merit: 0
Re: Read this before having an opinion on economics
April 30, 2011, 07:57:05 PM
Last edit: April 30, 2011, 08:44:31 PM by LH66
#167
Quote from: bitcoin2cash on April 30, 2011, 06:42:01 PM
The point was only that some things can harm some people while helping others. That should be fairly uncontroversial. If you don't like the lemonade stand analogy then I'm sure you can tweak it a little so that it fits, instead of giving it away, selling it at a lower price or even the same price. I'm still hurting your business by not giving you the entire market to yourself. I'm sure you could come up with your own example if you gave it enough thought.
This leaves us with the real question regarding IP laws: are they a net benefit or a net harm to society? If you don't know one way or the other and can't provide evidence to backup your assertion then you have no business advocating the existence of such laws. One assumes that the state of nature is the default and that we don't keep laws on the books without good reason. I personally think that IP laws are a net harm because it stifles innovation, i.e. nobody can use the likeness of existing fictional characters to reinterpret them into new contexts and stories.
I liked your analogy very much actually. My conclusion from it is that without certain protections, people in my position are subject to the
free rider problem
. (
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_rider_problem
) Your analogy creates a net loss for society, not only for us individually. Neither of us can sustain the creation of lemonade so society loses since they can't get lemonade.
Speaking in terms of economic theory: my view is that IP laws attempt to take intellectual creations that would otherwise be
public goods
, and turns them into
private goods
.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_good
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Private_good
Without IP laws, intellectual creations would remain
public goods
and are then subject to the
free rider problem
. This means that the creators of those goods would not have an incentive to continue creating them, and society would lose since it would have fewer inventions, etc.
Without IP laws, how do you suggest addressing the
free rider problem
?
LH66
Newbie
Offline
Activity: 42
Merit: 0
Re: Read this before having an opinion on economics
April 30, 2011, 08:05:21 PM
#168
Quote from: BitterTea on April 30, 2011, 06:47:30 PM
I feel that it comes down to a simple question.
Do you have the right to use force against me in order to control the way in which your idea is used?
If you took one of my ebooks and tried to sell it without my permission, then I have the right to redress the situation via the judicial system.
As I stated above, all IP laws do is to take something that would otherwise be a
public good
, and turn it into a
private good
. This is to avoid the
free rider problem
.
For argument's sake, let's remove IP laws and turn all intellectual creations into
public goods
. (please see links above so we're using the same definitions for the italicized terms) What then is your suggestion to avoid the
free rider problem
?
BitterTea
Sr. Member
Offline
Activity: 294
Merit: 250
Re: Read this before having an opinion on economics
April 30, 2011, 09:16:22 PM
#169
Quote from: LH66 on April 30, 2011, 08:05:21 PM
If you took one of my ebooks and tried to sell it without my permission, then I have the right to redress the situation via the judicial system.
I think this simplifies to: individuals have the right to control the use of the ideas they share with others, through force if necessary. Do you agree with this? Keep in mind that if I don't acknowledge your right to drag me to court, police will come and take me by force.
We agree on the rights of life, liberty, and property. From these principles, how do you derive the right to control the use of your ideas?
Even if I agree that there is a right to intellectual property, I do not agree that it supersedes the right to liberty of thought or action. How do you arrive at the conclusion that it does?
These are the points of contention that prevent me from supporting the idea of intellectual property.
LH66
Newbie
Offline
Activity: 42
Merit: 0
Re: Read this before having an opinion on economics
April 30, 2011, 09:50:12 PM
Last edit: April 30, 2011, 10:00:16 PM by LH66
#170
I realize reading economic theory is probably not on
anybody's
list of things to do on a weekend....
but if you do, then you may know my answer to your questions.
The Script
Sr. Member
Offline
Activity: 336
Merit: 250
Re: Read this before having an opinion on economics
April 30, 2011, 10:41:14 PM
#171
Quote from: LH66 on April 30, 2011, 09:50:12 PM
I realize reading economic theory is probably not on
anybody's
list of things to do on a weekend....
but if you do, then you may know my answer to your questions.
Actually it
is
something I would do on a weekend...can you say nerd?
The problem with this, though, is:who's economic theory? Austrian? Keynsiansim? Chicago school? The conclusions we'd come to would vary depending on which school we "followed". This is why it's better if you actually explain your stand on Bitter Tea's questions instead of making us guess. That way, too, we can start the name calling when we discover we don't agree on economic theories.
NghtRppr
(OP)
Sr. Member
Offline
Activity: 504
Merit: 252
Elder Crypto God
Re: Read this before having an opinion on economics
May 01, 2011, 02:06:51 AM
#172
Quote from: LH66 on April 30, 2011, 07:57:05 PM
This means that the creators of those goods would not have an incentive to continue creating them, and society would lose since it would have fewer inventions, etc.
That is simply false. There is still the incentive for the enjoyment of creating, becoming famous from creating, selling live performances, donations, etc. There are people that wish to create but can't because you can't use characters from existing works for fear of lawsuits. So it seems to me that even though there will be some discouragement to some people there will be encouragement to others. Which outweighs which? Do you have anything to offer aside from your gut feelings?
LH66
Newbie
Offline
Activity: 42
Merit: 0
Re: Read this before having an opinion on economics
May 02, 2011, 03:15:31 AM
#173
Quote from: The Script on April 30, 2011, 10:41:14 PM
Actually it
is
something I would do on a weekend...can you say nerd?
haha yea me too.
Quote
The problem with this, though, is:who's economic theory? Austrian? Keynsiansim? Chicago school? The conclusions we'd come to would vary depending on which school we "followed". This is why it's better if you actually explain your stand on Bitter Tea's questions instead of making us guess. That way, too, we can start the name calling when we discover we don't agree on economic theories.
It's basic microeconomics 101. It's not advanced stuff, just took microecon two semesters ago and learned those concepts then, then came across those links as I researched my answers here.
If you don't want to read them, that's OK. But I have already explained the concepts in a nutshell. The italicised words can be referenced via the links. I think it would be helpful if you read the links, but like I said if you don't want to then that's OK too.
LH66
Newbie
Offline
Activity: 42
Merit: 0
Re: Read this before having an opinion on economics
May 02, 2011, 03:18:32 AM
#174
Quote from: bitcoin2cash on May 01, 2011, 02:06:51 AM
Quote from: LH66 on April 30, 2011, 07:57:05 PM
This means that the creators of those goods would not have an incentive to continue creating them, and society would lose since it would have fewer inventions, etc.
That is simply false. There is still the incentive for the enjoyment of creating, becoming famous from creating, selling live performances, donations, etc. There are people that wish to create but can't because you can't use characters from existing works for fear of lawsuits. So it seems to me that even though there will be some discouragement to some people there will be encouragement to others. Which outweighs which? Do you have anything to offer aside from your gut feelings?
If you don't want to read the links, that's fine, but I've stated my position and also supported it. It's not a gut feeling. I cannot continue this conversation since we're not playing equally - I have answered your questions, but many of my questions you have not answered.
BitterTea
Sr. Member
Offline
Activity: 294
Merit: 250
Re: Read this before having an opinion on economics
May 02, 2011, 03:40:56 AM
#175
Is there anybody that can answer my two simple questions?
From where do you derive the right to intellectual property, and why does it supercede my right to liberty?
The Script
Sr. Member
Offline
Activity: 336
Merit: 250
Re: Read this before having an opinion on economics
May 02, 2011, 08:08:12 AM
#176
Quote from: BitterTea on May 02, 2011, 03:40:56 AM
Is there anybody that can answer my two simple questions?
From where do you derive the right to intellectual property, and why does it supercede my right to liberty?
Well, to play the Devil's Advocate, where does your right to liberty come from and why does it supersede someone's IP rights?
The Script
Sr. Member
Offline
Activity: 336
Merit: 250
Re: Read this before having an opinion on economics
May 02, 2011, 08:11:46 AM
#177
Quote from: LH66 on May 02, 2011, 03:15:31 AM
Quote from: The Script on April 30, 2011, 10:41:14 PM
Actually it
is
something I would do on a weekend...can you say nerd?
haha yea me too.
Quote
The problem with this, though, is:who's economic theory? Austrian? Keynsiansim? Chicago school? The conclusions we'd come to would vary depending on which school we "followed". This is why it's better if you actually explain your stand on Bitter Tea's questions instead of making us guess. That way, too, we can start the name calling when we discover we don't agree on economic theories.
It's basic microeconomics 101. It's not advanced stuff, just took microecon two semesters ago and learned those concepts then, then came across those links as I researched my answers here.
If you don't want to read them, that's OK. But I have already explained the concepts in a nutshell. The italicised words can be referenced via the links. I think it would be helpful if you read the links, but like I said if you don't want to then that's OK too.
Oh hey, I guess I wasn't paying that close attention to what you meant. I'm familiar with those economic concepts (I took a basic microeconomics class too, and have done a fair amount of independent reading) but I'll take a look at those links later and get back to you. It's late and I'm on my iPad so it's hard to type long responses.
benjamindees
Legendary
Offline
Activity: 1330
Merit: 1000
Re: Read this before having an opinion on economics
May 02, 2011, 10:47:46 AM
#178
Quote from: BitterTea on May 02, 2011, 03:40:56 AM
Is there anybody that can answer my two simple questions?
From where do you derive the right to intellectual property, and why does it supercede my right to liberty?
The right to IP comes from my ability to keep it secret.
Civil Liberty Through Complex Mathematics
deadlizard
Member
Offline
Activity: 112
Merit: 11
Re: Read this before having an opinion on economics
May 02, 2011, 11:22:24 AM
#179
Quote from: BitterTea on May 02, 2011, 03:40:56 AM
Is there anybody that can answer my two simple questions?
From where do you derive the right to intellectual property, and why does it supercede my right to liberty?
From where do you derive rights at all?
btc address:1MEyKbVbmMVzVxLdLmt4Zf1SZHFgj56aqg
gpg fingerprint:
DD1AB28F8043D0837C86A4CA7D6367953C6FE9DC
wolciph
Newbie
Offline
Activity: 33
Merit: 0
Re: Read this before having an opinion on economics
May 02, 2011, 12:51:27 PM
#180
Quote from: bitcoin2cash on May 01, 2011, 02:06:51 AM
Quote from: LH66 on April 30, 2011, 07:57:05 PM
This means that the creators of those goods would not have an incentive to continue creating them, and society would lose since it would have fewer inventions, etc.
That is simply false. There is still the incentive for the enjoyment of creating, becoming famous from creating, selling live performances, donations, etc. There are people that wish to create but can't because you can't use characters from existing works for fear of lawsuits. So it seems to me that even though there will be some discouragement to some people there will be encouragement to others. Which outweighs which? Do you have anything to offer aside from your gut feelings?
I would also like to add that we have a plethora of real world examples of free (as in free speech) intellectual creations being created and quite often working out better than commercialized intellectual creations. We have loads of free software for example, and not many computer scientists would argue that msdos is a better kernel than linux. We also have wikipedia that accumulated around 16 million USD of donations last year. So not only are people willing to give away there time for free in doing tasks that benefit the community as a whole but also, people are willing to give them money for doing so.
I would also like to point out - although this can be considered a subjective opinion I suppose - that intellectual works made with only money as an incentive (e.g. most big movies) are plain crap since their goal is not the expression of an artistic vision from the creator but just creating as much money as possible by pleasing the evermore stupid crowd of people who will buy it.
Pages:
«
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
[
9
]
10
11
12
13
14
15
»
All
Print
Bitcoin Forum
>
Economy
>
Economics
>
Read this before having an opinion on economics
« previous topic
next topic »
Jump to:
Please select a destination:
-----------------------------
Bitcoin
-----------------------------
=> Bitcoin Discussion
===> Legal
===> Press
===> Meetups
===> Important Announcements
=> Development & Technical Discussion
===> Wallet software
=====> Electrum
=====> Bitcoin Wallet for Android
=====> BitcoinJ
=====> Armory
=====> Mycelium
=====> Hardware wallets
=> Mining
===> Mining support
===> Pools
===> Mining software (miners)
===> Hardware
=====> Group buys
===> Mining speculation
=> Bitcoin Technical Support
=> Project Development
-----------------------------
Economy
-----------------------------
=> Economics
===> Speculation
=> Marketplace
===> Goods
=====> Computer hardware
=====> Digital goods
=======> Invites & Accounts
=====> Collectibles
===> Services
===> Currency exchange
===> Gambling
=====> Games and rounds
=====> Investor-based games
=====> Gambling discussion
===> Lending
=====> Long-term offers
===> Securities
===> Auctions
===> Service Announcements
=====> Micro Earnings
===> Service Discussion
=====> Web Wallets
=====> Exchanges
=> Trading Discussion
===> Scam Accusations
===> Reputation
-----------------------------
Other
-----------------------------
=> Meta
===> New forum software
===> Bitcoin Wiki
=> Politics & Society
=> Beginners & Help
=> Off-topic
=> Serious discussion
===> Ivory Tower
=> Archival
===> Корзина
===> CPU/GPU Bitcoin mining hardware
===> Chinese students
===> Obsolete (buying)
===> Obsolete (selling)
===> MultiBit
-----------------------------
Alternate cryptocurrencies
-----------------------------
=> Altcoin Discussion
=> Announcements (Altcoins)
===> Tokens (Altcoins)
=> Mining (Altcoins)
===> Pools (Altcoins)
=> Marketplace (Altcoins)
===> Service Announcements (Altcoins)
===> Service Discussion (Altcoins)
===> Bounties (Altcoins)
=> Speculation (Altcoins)
-----------------------------
Local
-----------------------------
=> العربية (Arabic)
===> العملات البديلة (Altcoins)
=====> النقاشات
===> إستفسارات و أسئلة المبتدئين
===> التعدين
===> النقاشات الأخرى
===> منصات التبادل
=> Bahasa Indonesia (Indonesian)
===> Marketplace (Bahasa Indonesia)
===> Mining (Bahasa Indonesia)
===> Altcoins (Bahasa Indonesia)
===> Trading dan Spekulasi
===> Ekonomi, Politik, dan Budaya
===> Topik Lainnya
=> Español (Spanish)
===> Mercado y Economía
=====> Servicios
=====> Trading y especulación
===> Hardware y Minería
===> Esquina Libre
===> Mercadillo
=====> Mexico
=====> Argentina
=====> España
=====> Centroamerica y Caribe
===> Primeros pasos y ayuda
===> Altcoins (criptomonedas alternativas)
=====> Minería de altcoins
=====> Servicios
=====> Tokens (Español)
=> 中文 (Chinese)
===> 跳蚤市场
===> 山寨币
===> 媒体
===> 挖矿
===> 离题万里
=> Hrvatski (Croatian)
===> Trgovina
===> Altcoins (Hrvatski)
=====> Announcements (Hrvatski)
===> Off-topic (Hrvatski)
=> Deutsch (German)
===> Anfänger und Hilfe
===> Mining (Deutsch)
===> Trading und Spekulation
===> Projektentwicklung
===> Off-Topic (Deutsch)
===> Treffen
===> Presse
===> Altcoins (Deutsch)
=====> Announcements (Deutsch)
===> Marktplatz
=====> Auktionen
=====> Suche
=====> Biete
=> Ελληνικά (Greek)
===> Αγορά
===> Mining Discussion (Ελληνικά)
===> Altcoins (Ελληνικά)
=====> Altcoin Announcements (Ελληνικά)
=====> Altcoin Mining (Ελληνικά)
=> עברית (Hebrew)
=> Français
===> Actualité et News
===> Débutants
===> Discussions générales et utilisation du Bitcoin
===> Mining et Hardware
===> Économie et spéculation
===> Place de marché
=====> Échanges
=====> Produits et services
=====> Petites annonces
===> Le Bitcoin et la loi
===> Wiki, documentation et traduction
===> Développement et technique
===> Vos sites et projets
===> Hors-sujet
===> Altcoins (Français)
=====> Annonces
=> India
===> Mining (India)
===> Marketplace (India)
===> Regional Languages (India)
===> Press & News from India
===> Alt Coins (India)
===> Buyer/ Seller Reputations (India)
===> Off-Topic (India)
=> Italiano (Italian)
===> Guide (Italiano)
===> Progetti
===> Discussioni avanzate e sviluppo
===> Trading, analisi e speculazione
===> Mercato
=====> Mercato valute
=====> Beni
=====> Servizi
=====> Esercizi commerciali
=====> Hardware/Mining (Italiano)
=====> Gambling (Italiano)
===> Accuse scam/truffe
===> Mining (Italiano)
===> Alt-Currencies (Italiano)
=====> Annunci
===> Raduni/Meeting (Italiano)
===> Crittografia e decentralizzazione
===> Off-Topic (Italiano)
=> 日本語 (Japanese)
===> アルトコイン
=> Nederlands (Dutch)
===> Markt
===> Gokken/lotterijen
===> Mining (Nederlands)
===> Beurzen
===> Alt Coins (Nederlands)
===> Off-topic (Nederlands)
===> Meetings (Nederlands)
=> Nigeria (Naija)
===> Politics and society (Naija)
===> Off-topic (Naija)
=> 한국어 (Korean)
===> 대체코인 Alt Coins (한국어)
=> Pilipinas
===> Altcoins (Pilipinas)
=====> Altcoin Announcements (Pilipinas)
===> Pamilihan
===> Others (Pilipinas)
=> Polski
===> Tablica ogłoszeń
===> Alternatywne kryptowaluty
=====> Nowe kryptowaluty i tokeny
=====> Tablica ogłoszeń (altcoiny)
=> Português (Portuguese)
===> Primeiros Passos (Iniciantes)
===> Economia & Mercado
===> Mineração em Geral
===> Desenvolvimento & Discussões Técnicas
===> Criptomoedas Alternativas
===> Brasil
===> Portugal
=> Русский (Russian)
===> Новички
===> Бизнес
=====> Барахолка
=====> Обменники
===> Идеи
===> Кодеры
===> Майнеры
===> Политика
===> Трейдеры
===> Альтернативные криптовалюты
=====> Токены
=====> Бayнти и aиpдpoпы
===> Хайпы
===> Работа
===> Разное
===> Oбcyждeниe Bitcoin
=====> Новости
=====> Юристы
=> Română (Romanian)
===> Anunturi importante
===> Offtopic
===> Market
=====> Discutii Servicii
===> Minerit
===> Tutoriale
===> Bine ai venit!
===> Presa
===> Altcoins (Monede Alternative)
=====> Anunturi Monede Alternative
=> Skandinavisk
=> Türkçe (Turkish)
===> Bitcoin Haberleri
===> Pazar Alanı
===> Madencilik
===> Ekonomi
===> Servisler
=====> Fonlar
===> Proje Geliştirme
===> Alternatif Kripto-Paralar
=====> Madencilik (Alternatif Kripto-Paralar)
=====> Duyurular (Alternatif Kripto-Paralar)
===> Konu Dışı
===> Yeni Başlayanlar & Yardım
===> Buluşmalar
=> Other languages/locations
Loading...