Harry Potter Vs Lord of the Rings

[rohnearner]

both of the series mentioned above has many similarities b/w them .
I'm not talking about Books here I'm talking about the Movie series. 

[rohnearner]

My vote goes to LOTR

[amitrwt]

My vote goes to LOTR

My vote goes to Lord of the rings too..! it is so much fun to watch.. harry potter is good but not as good as LOTR..

[beetcoin]

i went with lord of the rings because harry potter is to kiddy for me. i also hate how that main wizard guy, in the early movies at least, told the students not to do something. then harry potter and co. do it. the wizard guy then rewards them for breaking the rules, npnp.

[rohnearner]

i went with lord of the rings because harry potter is to kiddy for me. i also hate how that main wizard guy, in the early movies at least, told the students not to do something. then harry potter and co. do it. the wizard guy then rewards them for breaking the rules, npnp.

Someone voted for Harry potter didn't mention his/her identity and why (s)he voted for it , would like to hear from him/her..!

[bluefirecorp]

Comparing apples and oranges. The LotR story was created around the language, plot, landscapes. The plot isn't based around any character per se. In reality you could toss in another dozen heroes, change the plot, and the story will still be amazing.


Harry Potter on the other hand is a story based around a centralized character and his friends. It's written to tell the story of one person, and a few followers. That's it.


Personally, I prefer the more personalized story as it goes into greater personal detail. LotR has way, way much going on everywhere to follow the story deeply.

[bizcoinz]

I like Harry potter because the story is more easy to understand and interesting.

[validium]

Harry potter for me soo many childhood memories.

[amitrwt]

I like Harry potter because the story is more easy to understand and interesting.

and just a question have you seen all parts of LOTR and if yes I don't think its difficult to understand..?

[jade1222]

I like both, they are both good movies.

[jinjuro]

I voted LOTR. One of the best series ever.

[leslie.leslie]

Harry Potter i had watched all the sequels and it is indeed fantastic.

[worth5868]

I like Lord of the Rings, for me this is one of the best movie i've ever seen.

[barney_stinson]

IMO, Harry Potter is better cos it is good fairy tail for people of different age categories

[KIRAZ]

I vote for Harry Potter.

[Divinespark]

Lord of the Rings
Just got more in it for adult viewers...

[Kluge]

I've never been able to sit through LotR. Didn't like the Potter movies, but I enjoyed the books when I was younger, so I'll go with that because I sat through them.

[airloom]

Lord of the rings

[Hazir]

So we are discussing only movie adaptation of books? In that case LotR is the best adaptation ever created. Nuff said.

[blueface]

Lord of the Rings