is bitcoin having real value?

[LOBSTER]

I'd say you have the difficulty which gives the value. For sure the supply and demand but as example, gold has also it's difficulty to find it and it's (like Bitcoin) rather rare.

[arieq]

Yes you have value because

1) There is people willing to pay for it
......

yeah... BTC has somehow connected itself to commodity values, once the Bit License is functional, hedge fund money will flow into
crypto, Happy Holidays.