Circle of Trust [Game/experiment] -- GAME OVER

[kwoody]

Sent 3.66666420 to Carlos L.

dcf3c26a41cb10c4e0d544f1366e946d22fb63f3ce24326c4a2dfa0e841fc5e9

[ingrownpocket]

Sent 3.66666420 to Carlos L.

dcf3c26a41cb10c4e0d544f1366e946d22fb63f3ce24326c4a2dfa0e841fc5e9

Someone post here an address before I forget I have them and spend it somewhere.

[x0Jakeyboy0x]

Let's hope you haven't forgotten yet. How many transactions are we up to by the way?

1JvRuTLAo3hMbEqEDZ5V6V9YbvhjbfhkuX
Received.

[ingrownpocket]

Let's hope you haven't forgotten yet. How many transactions are we up to by the way?

1JvRuTLAo3hMbEqEDZ5V6V9YbvhjbfhkuX

Hmm... You only have 151 posts. 

[x0Jakeyboy0x]

Let's hope you haven't forgotten yet. How many transactions are we up to by the way?

1JvRuTLAo3hMbEqEDZ5V6V9YbvhjbfhkuX

Hmm... You only have 151 posts. 

I believe the requirement is over 100 posts. There's been a few people passed on to with much less. Am i sub-par Full member? 

[Garr255]

Yeah if someone could update the transaction list that'd be cool.

[dooglus]

I fixed the post numbers and added the new players:

 ID NICK               RECEIVED BY                        POST_ID_AND_COMMENTS
  1 Garr255            189JHV6KPzvnPmjYCGPbvMMmZUWppere7h #2
  2 the joint          17EVRSvdPJGhk7uKHCpY9ghnWnx7j3pPAs #3
  3 sadpandatech       13YmfB6TeLzyCdnwsVZ5MdYVCLnfm5eNGF #4
  4 nimda              1KiZGitw2zEr4uPzZsT7dh7F6e5yoKGvE7 #5
  5 Al the Alpaca      1EWRJ5BeibZxMguujPLzqM8WWiHpFJtLLx #6
  6 pirateat40         1CR5BadHQt8wd4t98mE4rw9hUfSGQ4ZGDg #19
  7 rjk                17qypELtTKqr716m937wLWbapnFG6i4fyZ #20
  8 NothinG            1BjMLLGrwYk3hrcnSqEUEeGchkx9tiykfY #21
  9 PatrickHarnett     1KwECAhJGr8BPGgn6mezf5Z3jT7vG1HaAZ #27
 10 pekv2              12NcNYb2oEh6ANo95AakEjPqQdgbcxh4m9 #32
 11 unclemantis        12kM9BocNb5zSG7RMKp9wPxopK5NpayrMZ #33
 12 mb300sd            1HVmv5EtQZtcsFfXe6Crz972BrB1MwsNCM #38
 13 rudrigorc2         1MSPwixhqiwMLXxw3WXtNjg2nst6qVWhCX #43
 14 Brunic             16Hz2xA4NmAp4CU3Mr9aJy8H9D5XqXupHG #48
 15 fatigue            1Fj4QZbavJeKfagjDqUPFqQ4iJ4bHqFAMG #51
 16 Phraust            15UJrPbxd6ULPJaxASUoWUp6xc473T7mww #87
 17 adamstgBit         15nutdfqcS38hXdZoL7LNz5wBt8Aq4wCUT #88
 18 bluefirecorp       1PsQ8qFp6ZY94gXvFLP4cqcmoLQSDCqLJc #89
 19 Drakahn            1C1UMHsdPxgsWGWBhdaTC47kibJjFgWnhb #90
 20 Gladamas           1FVySmZNZ6LUvz1mKkt9zgRWjBzvkM4Roh #91
 21 phantitox          1GtGFJskG47Q6Q1NFsfMLWfNV9ivabbyab #92
 22 John (johnthedong) 1Cm2ymVqiHA42jv31rtyze684oWTDkreza #97 instawallet addy, DON't REUSE
 23 Keefe              1BZy1xxwcxQyRZErcYUFke72TSU7cV5Ptf #106
 24 Otoh               1G5apmPvo2iTtmkNWAHTCET7Y842Ufijs8 #109
 25 [Tycho]            1VayNert3x1KzbpzMGt2qdqrAThiRovi8  #74
 26 Dalkore            12SSYCcvaHadm8Myxb3mUTzyv96VNhyzeZ #66
 27 payb.tc            14no5MUE4ur2gyyEE3BHpHhV82gKm8NLbH #132
 28 damnek             17xbiU6EWdaf74rmwxPv9AQZc1MeKMWh5n #114
 29 Tril               1Xgeo7EQgrk22paxmKVrhNVSmauczL6EE  #116
 30 Scott J            18UVSvCAb6QGjPSdiXxveeu56ujmu3kTt4 #117
 31 honest bob         14x3n2ntSAGN4gGvGoLhi6NbUuuoWwvfdL #139
 32 giszmo             1KLYFWyv5aeci2PwJQs9aTRN1JRzDDL96o #142
 33 arklan             1F4j4Lha8BjL4wxwFVbGaQwMJ4Kd1brfXb #144
 34 dooglus            1BooBz2AEwUd6JepB7NhNsnAe58Q6obpcu #157
 35 riX                155gBnpiBQcpnP6coTX6V7znSK3G73uNjK #158
 36 RyNinDaCleM        1Bgi9fX1TD9cnuzBvWGLfm7D7sNVEq96UU #173
 37 hongus             1APyqdvGMvjfEMPKCo3oHSJ4CkJuXhTCy1 #238
 38 flatfly            1337sfeChyyzZLzdHLewXzcaAaJSNTM893 #243
 39 URSAY              1MzjNVW8z5SuMsGPgQfWZoyKaxsc1VkLXh #248
 40 nckrazze           111mamKazi1ofZ854rKTcAxhTVuGDPhhL  #257
 41 TYDIRocks          1PowhrA8kxnn9UBj2ESg7GQzkwTpcg44zm #272
 42 Gyrsur             1FSfmWAMUsuBzUTrXgKaTE9TsSjJw1knvw #274
 43 OneEyed            1MJS3FuUrWmyfvvRnm5gUYvpuFkYDzxCP4 #277
 44 Namworld           14x36ktcNuf3CNrkVH1XY7vXwGHb9mCZwF #281
 45 augustocroppo      161gEQewAVp6CFnoY5198vHchrbWLQytG7 #284
 46 CornedBeefHash     1FvXoLCFmmRTAHJv5xMZLoMoeKBJHMCLnY #291
 47 theboss            1EQfkKVZndiesJcwThRe5AAq15dZ56mZku #293
 48 Maidak             14bsB5cugXFYaVZWsuoEYABd9gvkowv42a #296
 49 scintill           1jCU7tevhLNaY3nDL4tinNu8NuSzDtwKh  #299
 50 chrisrico          1Mn7mjk69WJY85Ukwd4sFSRMALokoni13L #301
 51 jasinlee           1AvxDf5WPWvrUgLsPLpb6a8mYsPXNYxNMr #304  +.01BTC
 52 fabrizziop         1MFfixQTJJ4v2PUKrz5kotQq1dPSJFUA71 #311 +.0001BTC
 53 sethsethseth       1K42vUtvmg8hW6M6UjubCFhmJLv4jLby4C #314
 54 Spenzert           19nPdToTaAh2jVUuotaiDhPBxcPLuLEuXD #319 signed his message, +.0001BTC
 53 sethsethseth       1K42vUtvmg8hW6M6UjubCFhmJLv4jLby4C #322 <- keeping it in place of #54
 55 Fjordbit           1KZnfWkXXLdEjvQKYALbEsjbeWpvSG9NWB #328 +.0001BTC
 56 danieldaniel       17QAPwXnqXX771j2CB7y2ahuoX76X4aipv #340
 57 caffeinewriter     13373CuvtwQGgDWYv28pm3mTxy2bGS5U4D #342
 58 stan.distortion    13TasmL5GRp27JfbuTpGBAx1iDYyygb4gP #356
 59 MKEGuy             12Zu56v2CENZREzQnaEia37CeBEEDG96fK #358
 60 ianbakewell        1Q1k2uTUZ1ZSSufH2w9xnCnPPzC1QmreEa #371
 61 squall1066         1ES9YKx3RHSsFLsGAKJva4cG8W7xG4kHok #373 "Rounded up to 2.27BTC"
 62 Gavin Andresen     12r6DPnX5TNK4PhnTiShmuK6o4jE8Yh28C #377 "rounded up to 3.11 BTC (because eleven is my favorite number)"
 63 dreamwatcher       1JYMASNzjSPhQZi6zjpb2duBLo3wXPSWLj #380 "Upped it to 3.5 BTC"
 64 lightlord          13cjE1VDsiF5SjFEt5kg2izYmcvUmpwTi5 #381
 65 kwoody             1CvU9yqNQHKLHVrJnwgVQcoUJ9GfUzS8Ad #382 "Sent 3.66666420 to Carlos L."
 66 Carlos L.          18zSd8Ra4bioqQAfSVMqr8J6MtaY58xA31 #388 <-- currently has coins
 67 x0Jakeyboy0x       1JvRuTLAo3hMbEqEDZ5V6V9YbvhjbfhkuX #391

[giszmo]

Let's hope you haven't forgotten yet. How many transactions are we up to by the way?

1JvRuTLAo3hMbEqEDZ5V6V9YbvhjbfhkuX

Hmm... You only have 151 posts. 

Please be suspicious and paranoid if people with 101 posts that registered yesterday show up here. He registered June 2011.

[x0Jakeyboy0x]

Thank you giszmo. And I must say, very well put together dooglus.

[mrvision]

pirateat40        LOL!!! xDDD yeah you can trust that guy XD

[ingrownpocket]

Let's hope you haven't forgotten yet. How many transactions are we up to by the way?

1JvRuTLAo3hMbEqEDZ5V6V9YbvhjbfhkuX

https://blockchain.info/tx/129997175d9c642840e8295bdcb35fe710626fc8595ef54e33fe71739d5ce2fc

[x0Jakeyboy0x]

1JvRuTLAo3hMbEqEDZ5V6V9YbvhjbfhkuX
Received.

[Jakers]

This is getting a bit dangerous tbh. Awesome nonetheless, but dangerous.

If I can play I'll tag-team with someone - 14vCb4rr1SdWFLDFgW4NMUbodPYqcCoRm2

If not ignore this

[giszmo]

This is getting a bit dangerous tbh. Awesome nonetheless, but dangerous.

If I can play I'll tag-team with someone - 14vCb4rr1SdWFLDFgW4NMUbodPYqcCoRm2

If not ignore this

Too young, sorry.

I don't like that some people increase the amount. I hope the OP gets a reward for starting this and I hope that somebody does a sweet analysis of how much fees were paid on average, median, max and how fast the fastest 2-hops or 3-hops were etc. If we finally hit a scammer, it would take weeks until we finally decide the coins are lost and the focus would be on that one black sheep. This "circle" is not a group of trustworthy people as our dear pirate proofed so lets focus on what else this experiment can proof.

[x0Jakeyboy0x]

Jakers, as much as I like the name, I do agree you're a bit of a risk at the moment. Thanks for checking things out though, man.

giszmo, interesting thought. You know, I think the reason this experiment has survived through any scammers is because of the simple ratio of risk to reward. Any ill intentioned person who has taken the time to get up to "Full Member" or above simply just doesn't believe 1-4BTC is enough to lose their reputation for. In a way, even if you have plans of stealing, being apart of this game and playing legitimately may be seen as the investment in a greater opportunity. Really I think the only way we could "prove" things is if we upped the amount, or did an amount like 1 BTC for younger users like Jakers. Think we might get scammed out more often but also learn more from the experiment. Would be especially interesting to analyze the situations where scams do occur and try to learn what signs are there are to spot would be swindlers.

[giszmo]

Maybe some of the followers of this thread already feed some scammer account to jump in when it's worth doing so. We are now 2/3rd through the game and it's likely the reward for scamming will be 10Ƀ later on. Maybe I'm one of them trying to save my stash from cheaper scammers

Most likely it's 5h of work to feed an account to 100 posts and some users already have their sock puppet troll accounts that they can just as well make famous and start over.

My conclusion is more that 99% of all humans are trustworthy but 1% are capable of making huge damage. These 1% might not really care about 4Ƀ. These 1% are the reason we need rules and all kind of regulation – a society basically.

[Garr255]

How about if it gets up to BTC5 we require Sr. Member, and BTC10 we require Hero Member, just to further deter scammers?

[novusordo]

Count me in!

1novusxwhCh11QyXp1Jj3e6hdhk6qZZ3E

---

Received. Who's next?

[x0Jakeyboy0x]

Count me in!

1novusxwhCh11QyXp1Jj3e6hdhk6qZZ3E

Sounds good to me. Full member, good OTC ratings, sent.

https://blockchain.info/tx/2f5bdc1eaff2a6265e264a66bbecb70fcfab9f9bc8f11178fd19d7e58598dffb

[Jakers]

Maybe some of the followers of this thread already feed some scammer account to jump in when it's worth doing so. We are now 2/3rd through the game and it's likely the reward for scamming will be 10Ƀ later on. Maybe I'm one of them trying to save my stash from cheaper scammers

Most likely it's 5h of work to feed an account to 100 posts and some users already have their sock puppet troll accounts that they can just as well make famous and start over.

My conclusion is more that 99% of all humans are trustworthy but 1% are capable of making huge damage. These 1% might not really care about 4Ƀ. These 1% are the reason we need rules and all kind of regulation – a society basically.

Some of the forums I've been on have over 1000 pages of scammer reports. It's actually quite sad, like wth you wouldn't do that in real life would you? I guess people think it's different when it's over a computer screen