|
Title: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Nemesis on November 04, 2013, 07:31:41 PM Has anyone withdrawn btc from MtGox in the past 24hrs? Did you receive your btc? or is the transaction even broadcast or seen on blockchain.info?
Has it been like this recently? Fiat money withdrawal delays are due to regulation but BTC too ? whats taking them so long? Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: maxll on November 04, 2013, 09:48:59 PM Happening for me now. Tried to withdraw 17BTC yesterday (37 hous ago) but there is even no any new transactions on blockchain.info for now.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: mearylll on November 04, 2013, 09:52:16 PM Its not first time I hear there are few day delays last months at least to some users.
I believe your BTC transfers are safe Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: trade-for-pokermoney on November 04, 2013, 11:37:36 PM same thing here... withdrew and nothing got broadcast to the network
had to cancel my SEPAs and i am major pissed right now..... How can a multimillion USD company fail at so many simple things? Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Shallow on November 05, 2013, 05:12:42 AM How can they not have your bitcoins??? They better not fail when i try to withdraw
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: justusranvier on November 05, 2013, 05:17:49 AM How can a multimillion USD company fail at so many simple things? Back in 2011 they failed by having too much stored in their hot wallet, which allowed a hacker to steal it.So they started keeping more of their user's coins in cold storage, which means that somebody has to manually walk a transaction across the air gap when the hot wallet runs out. That somebody is probably Mark, and if he's sleeping or eating lunch, or taking the day off, you're probably SOL for a while. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Nemesis on November 05, 2013, 02:06:58 PM still not on blockchain yet..... un-fcking-belivable.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: justusranvier on November 05, 2013, 02:11:37 PM Another thing I've heard is that some miners direct their payouts to their Mt Gox accounts, which results in Mt Gox's hotwallet filling up with unspendable-for-100-block outputs and at least a few months ago their code wasn't smart enough to avoid attempting to use those unspendable outputs in withdrawals. Maybe they've fixed it by now.
Maybe. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: zeroblock on November 05, 2013, 03:14:07 PM Plain and simple capital controls.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Nemesis on November 05, 2013, 03:54:52 PM If you try to push the tx on blockchain.info yourself, you will get "invalid signature" . Their support is a joke. What i get is an automated reply saying they will escalate this to developers team.....
Right.... by developers team, they mean Mark. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Nemesis on November 05, 2013, 03:56:45 PM same thing here... withdrew and nothing got broadcast to the network had to cancel my SEPAs and i am major pissed right now..... How can a multimillion USD company fail at so many simple things? You must not know Mark... why dont you share with us of what you know about him? Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: zeroblock on November 05, 2013, 05:18:47 PM same thing here... withdrew and nothing got broadcast to the network had to cancel my SEPAs and i am major pissed right now..... How can a multimillion USD company fail at so many simple things? You must not know Mark... why dont you share with us of what you know about him? Gross incompetence. False statements to customers. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: chrisLG on November 05, 2013, 05:21:56 PM Had a BTC withdrawal not going through yesterday. Opening a support tickelt helped.
The fact that all withdrawals with Mt.Gox now go through an obviously bumpy process made me really nervous. I reduced my Mt.Gox balance down to .12 BTC Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Amph on November 05, 2013, 05:27:17 PM don't move such an amount, play with low values, like 1 btc at time
mine was fast, and i have also withdrawn my money in two day Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Nemesis on November 05, 2013, 05:29:22 PM I check mtgox api and saw an withdrawal of 700btc! I checked the address and hes been withdrawing the same amount for the past 3 days.
Some rich dude with connection.... Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: joesmoe2012 on November 05, 2013, 05:46:35 PM I don't think it's the hotwallet that's empty, that gives an error when trying to withdraw. I'm able to withdraw, but nothing showing on the blockchain. Likely due to freshly minted coins being sent to gox and needing 100 transactions before they can be sent.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Nemesis on November 05, 2013, 05:50:42 PM I don't think it's the hotwallet that's empty, that gives an error when trying to withdraw. I'm able to withdraw, but nothing showing on the blockchain. Likely due to freshly minted coins being sent to gox and needing 100 transactions before they can be sent. Does that give the error of "Invalid signature" when you're broadcasting the tx? Btw, who are the idiots using mtgox address for mining? Gosh, i want to slap them. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Nemesis on November 05, 2013, 05:51:13 PM same thing here... withdrew and nothing got broadcast to the network had to cancel my SEPAs and i am major pissed right now..... How can a multimillion USD company fail at so many simple things? You must not know Mark... why dont you share with us of what you know about him? Gross incompetence. False statements to customers. Pretty much this. Or at least this is the polite way to say it... Just tell us straight up what happened between u two? Did he scam you? Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: justusranvier on November 05, 2013, 06:29:17 PM I've heard second hand reports that Mark is in way over his head when it comes to operating a business the size of Mt Gox.
He's the only one there with managerial authority because he doesn't know how to delegate. This means all business decisions must be serialized through him. He's basically a programmer first and a CEO second. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Nemesis on November 05, 2013, 07:27:06 PM I've heard second hand reports that Mark is in way over his head when it comes to operating a business the size of Mt Gox. He's the only one there with managerial authority because he doesn't know how to delegate. This means all business decisions must be serialized through him. He's basically a programmer first and a CEO second. I would say its greed than skill. Its easier for us to criticize mistakes but how to avoid them is alot harder. Most of us dont have any experience to run a business this size in such a rapid evolving. BUT.... why didnt Mark seek for partners open up cooperation for others who are experienced in financial field? That i believe is pure greed. Hes too greedy and now hes gonna lose the market. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Nemesis on November 06, 2013, 01:29:26 AM 48 hrs now.... still nothing....
Anyone the same? >:( Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: gizmoh on November 06, 2013, 04:55:08 AM 48 hrs now.... still nothing.... Anyone the same? >:( Still no coins received? Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: joesmoe2012 on November 06, 2013, 05:06:43 AM At this moment, sounds like a programmer is what is needed...
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Nemesis on November 06, 2013, 05:09:36 AM 48 hrs now.... still nothing.... Anyone the same? >:( Still no coins received? Fcking mother fuckers. I just try to broadcast the tx myself and blockchain.info report.... "outpoint is already spent" MtGox is fcking double spending btc? Fcking piece of shit. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: joesmoe2012 on November 06, 2013, 05:28:57 AM 48 hrs now.... still nothing.... Anyone the same? >:( Still no coins received? Fcking mother fuckers. I just try to broadcast the tx myself and blockchain.info report.... "outpoint is already spent" MtGox is fcking double spending btc? Fcking piece of shit. Same error I'm getting. 48 hrs now.... still nothing.... Anyone the same? >:( Still no coins received? Fcking mother fuckers. I just try to broadcast the tx myself and blockchain.info report.... "outpoint is already spent" MtGox is fcking double spending btc? Fcking piece of shit. yes, mt go has been known to double spend. after a week or so most people so far seemed to get their coins. soo far at least. I hope it doesn't take that long :( Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: justusranvier on November 06, 2013, 05:30:50 AM yes, mt go has been known to double spend. Output selection for withdrawals is custom code written by Mark in PHP and MySQL...after a week or so most people so far seemed to get their coins. soo far at least. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: justusranvier on November 06, 2013, 05:33:17 AM Really the person to ask about what's going on behind the scenes at Mt Gox is Ukyo.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: justusranvier on November 06, 2013, 05:36:07 AM He showed up to a couple Bitcoin Meetups in Dallas during the summer and had lots of interesting things to say about Mark, Mt Gox, and Coinlab.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Nemesis on November 06, 2013, 05:37:44 AM He showed up to a couple Bitcoin Meetups in Dallas during the summer and had lots of interesting things to say about Mark, Mt Gox, and Coinlab. do tell Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: justusranvier on November 06, 2013, 05:39:58 AM Pretty much what I already posted in this thread, and what people generally tend to think of Vessenes already. Also he had some cool plans for Weexchange that seem to have not materialized.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Nemesis on November 06, 2013, 01:17:04 PM not even a second response since the "escalating to developers" auto BS.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: darrenb on November 06, 2013, 01:50:59 PM I made a withdraw of £40 GBP 3 months ago, Nothing yet... even after opening a ticket with them, I had a reply saying sorry for the delay and its on its way.
Doubt i will ever see it now.. it was when 1 BTC was only worth £64 Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: chrisLG on November 06, 2013, 05:09:49 PM i dont understand why people still use gox :/ +1 I'm pretty happy I got out of there with all my btc. Title: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Hic et nunc on November 06, 2013, 06:45:10 PM Delay of more than three days:
3 days ago I sent 700 BTC (The university of my son) to this address: ( https://blockchain.info/es/address/1PPWBeauKVg3PahkbA3VXXS6zrfvfsMNJC ) Three days later I'm still waiting. The balance in my account looks like he made the shipment but IT IS NOT TRUE. Where is my money? https://i.imgur.com/hMVoSC7.png?1 As you can see the shipping seems to have done but is not in the blockchain. This is what they answer me: (Marcus) Thank you for your email. We are sorry to inform you that we sense an issue in blockchain and looks like BTC withdrawals are appearing on block chain with a delay. We will have this checked and we will keep you updated on the status and we apologize for the inconvenience that this may have caused. Best regards... I've been waiting 3 days... Besides posting it here. What can I do? Any ideas please... Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: chrisLG on November 06, 2013, 06:50:59 PM I had the same experience. Tried to withdraw coins but they never showed up in the blockchain. After contacting support the coins arrived within a matter of hours.
How long ago did you file the support request? Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: X68N on November 06, 2013, 07:00:11 PM Holy shit expirienced the sam problem tried to get my 8 BTC out.
Never heard from this before. If the Mtgox support is like BTC-e support (1 sentence per day only), then i swear i never use Gox again. 13.406.911 USD Volume per day, and so unprofessional? (by the way every Bank would love them, but they stay at a shitty Bank which limits them, and causes 4 weeks fiat withdraws... unprofessional like hell) is there a live support (not email or helpdesk)?? Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Hic et nunc on November 06, 2013, 07:14:11 PM I had the same experience. Tried to withdraw coins but they never showed up in the blockchain. After contacting support the coins arrived within a matter of hours. How long ago did you file the support request? This reply was 2 days later my request. Before, your answer was nonsense: Not worth you waste your time reading that. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: chrisLG on November 06, 2013, 07:37:27 PM I had the same experience. Tried to withdraw coins but they never showed up in the blockchain. After contacting support the coins arrived within a matter of hours. How long ago did you file the support request? This reply was 2 days later my request. Before, your answer was nonsense: Not worth you waste your time reading that. I'm sorry - I obviously misread/misunderstood your post. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: 0xz[.] on November 06, 2013, 07:49:37 PM quote author=chrisLG link=topic=324918.msg3501632#msg3501632 date=1383766647]
I had the same experience. Tried to withdraw coins but they never showed up in the blockchain. After contacting support the coins arrived within a matter of hours. How long ago did you file the support request? This reply was 2 days later my request. Before, Their answer was nonsense: Not worth you waste your time reading that. I'm sorry - I obviously misread/misunderstood your post. [/quote] Sorry sorry chrisLG actually I meant something different, sorry "Their answer" My english is awfull :'( Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: chrisLG on November 06, 2013, 08:18:27 PM Not a problem. I just read your post and could relate. No harm done here...
I hope your funds arrive shortly. You definitely should keep this forum posted - if Gox can't honor BTC withdrawals anymore they're in pretty deep trouble. I had those problems on November 03 at about 21:00 CET. Maybe this information helps... Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: X68N on November 06, 2013, 08:19:18 PM Can someone give me a hint how to cantact the chat of MtGox?
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: gizmoh on November 06, 2013, 09:13:52 PM I also have 67btc withdraw in limbo since yesterday,support told to wait.
For what its worth it happened to me and many others a few weeks back. They had SAME issue and although they gave 'network congestion' Bullsh*t excuse , all those who complained on " MtGox withdrawal delays[Gathering]" or some other thread did receive their coins after 1-3 days. This time its taking longer and many more are affected. Well lets give Mark some time to take out our coins from Cold storage and transfer to the hot wallet for disbursement. I don't think our frenchy will run with the coins, he already owns in the tens of thousands. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: X68N on November 06, 2013, 10:10:57 PM i think its very unprofessional. the info says 1h max. And like we realise now that its usually 1-3 days, and only after contacting the support.
There should be a sticky warning in the forum about all that bullshit MtGox does. I mean its now over 2 years this company makes the same shit over and over! Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Nemesis on November 07, 2013, 12:39:17 AM Delay of more than three days: 3 days ago I sent 700 BTC (The university of my son) to this address: ( https://blockchain.info/es/address/1PPWBeauKVg3PahkbA3VXXS6zrfvfsMNJC ) Three days later I'm still waiting. The balance in my account looks like he made the shipment but IT IS NOT TRUE. Where is my money? https://i.imgur.com/hMVoSC7.png?1 As you can see the shipping seems to have done but is not in the blockchain. This is what they answer me: (Marcus) Thank you for your email. We are sorry to inform you that we sense an issue in blockchain and looks like BTC withdrawals are appearing on block chain with a delay. We will have this checked and we will keep you updated on the status and we apologize for the inconvenience that this may have caused. Best regards... I've been waiting 3 days... Besides posting it here. What can I do? Any ideas please... When i broadcast that tx for you, i got a double spend message: Code: An outpoint is already spent [(95290641, 0), (95467206, 1), (95120872, 0), (95020365, 0), (95556501, 1), (95552084, 0), (95420581, 1), (95575141, 1), (95563296, 9), (95476568, 1), (94788741, 1), (95325015, 1), (95491346, 1), (95496474, 0), (95418902, 1), (95593506, 0), (95590592, 1), (95578675, 0), (95588915, 1), (95593043, 0), (95348256, 1), (95403563, 0), (95348318, 1), (95599653, 0), (95473326, 1), (95590326, 0), (95045266, 0), (95363415, 0), (95399759, 0), (95382818, 1), (95417780, 0), (95590225, 1), (95535978, 1), (95290360, 0), (95337477, 0), (95580105, 0), (95588082, 0), (95550429, 0), (95545183, 0), (95335146, 0), (95453523, 1), (95078087, 1), (95531079, 0), (95202312, 1), (95588395, 0), (95243605, 0), (95560643, 0), (95600674, 0), (95570766, 41), (95563752, 0), (95263377, 1), (95601012, 0), (95193538, 0), (95115400, 0), (95546048, 0), (95100104, 0), (95581120, 0), (95192227, 0), (95598160, 0), (95055170, 1), (95118992, 0), (95308359, 1), (95588483, 0), (95383867, 0), (95375424, 0), (95536495, 0), (95579953, 1), (95356988, 0), (95575074, 0), (95409149, 0), (95492987, 1), (95429248, 1), (95440184, 0), (95600282, 1), (95584515, 0), (95593502, 1), (95592529, 1), (95580201, 1), (95359778, 0), (95550427, 0), (95305697, 1), (95591395, 1), (95591058, 1), (94987016, 2), (95596805, 0), (95490168, 1), (95464681, 0), (95531243, 0), (95592338, 0), (95413201, 0), (95531722, 0), (95453996, 0), (95518851, 0), (95085949, 0), (95371479, 1), (95591457, 1), (95501119, 0), (95595285, 0), (95293281, 1), (95519260, 1), (95460990, 1), (95380799, 0), (95480599, 0), (95052808, 1), (95542323, 1), (95599020, 1), (95549546, 0), (95336694, 0), (95594183, 0), (95392112, 1), (95394021, 1), (95246667, 0), (95396625, 0), (95573517, 0), (95572781, 1), (95358743, 1), (95511436, 1), (95544711, 0), (95517264, 1), (95524358, 0), (95092422, 11), (95562403, 0), (95486252, 0), (95260626, 0), (95489600, 0), (95584409, 0), (95403229, 0), (94801303, 0), (95406229, 0), (95185842, 0), (95433699, 0)] BTW, why do you have 2 acct on here. Something to hide? Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Nemesis on November 07, 2013, 12:40:37 AM I also have 67btc withdraw in limbo since yesterday,support told to wait. For what its worth it happened to me and many others a few weeks back. They had SAME issue and although they gave 'network congestion' Bullsh*t excuse , all those who complained on " MtGox withdrawal delays[Gathering]" or some other thread did receive their coins after 1-3 days. This time its taking longer and many more are affected. Well lets give Mark some time to take out our coins from Cold storage and transfer to the hot wallet for disbursement. I don't think our frenchy will run with the coins, he already owns in the tens of thousands. Funny where are all the fees they have for the past 3 days.???? Fcking bullshit Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: hlynur on November 07, 2013, 12:43:48 AM same story here,
withdrew yesterday afternoon. request answer: Quote Thanks for your email and sorry for the inconvenience caused. Few BTC withdrawals are delayed and the transaction should eventually go through. We will update you once the transfer is complete. Best regards, Mt.Gox Team no update but luckily coins arrived this evening. (more than 24 hours later!) btc transfer taking longer than fiat....gox, seriously? ??? Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: hmmmstrange on November 07, 2013, 12:47:59 AM Can someone give me a hint how to cantact the chat of MtGox? You can try on irc. Some guy named magicaltux banned me forever from #mtgox on freenode. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Nemesis on November 07, 2013, 12:50:16 AM same story here, withdrew yesterday afternoon. request answer: Quote Thanks for your email and sorry for the inconvenience caused. Few BTC withdrawals are delayed and the transaction should eventually go through. We will update you once the transfer is complete. Best regards, Mt.Gox Team no update but luckily coins arrived this evening. (more than 24 hours later!) btc transferl taking longer than fiat....gox, seriously? ??? Can you check if its the same tx id or did they make a new tx? Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: justusranvier on November 07, 2013, 12:50:43 AM Some guy named magicaltux That is the owner of Mt Gox, by the way.Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Wardrick on November 07, 2013, 12:53:54 AM MtGox is fucking trash. I sent a letter to them like 2 weeks ago because they're idiotic support team can't seem to understand that I live in two different places, and they haven't verified my account yet. They required me to send a priority mail letter with notarized documents, because I kept providing the documents they asked for, and somehow they were wrong each time. It's not worth messaging their support if you want to solve a problem, it's like any other support team, complete dipshits. I'm going to give them 1-2 more weeks before I just sell and re-buy my BTC in their account until I have $0.00
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: hlynur on November 07, 2013, 12:55:38 AM same story here, withdrew yesterday afternoon. request answer: Quote Thanks for your email and sorry for the inconvenience caused. Few BTC withdrawals are delayed and the transaction should eventually go through. We will update you once the transfer is complete. Best regards, Mt.Gox Team no update but luckily coins arrived this evening. (more than 24 hours later!) btc transferl taking longer than fiat....gox, seriously? ??? Can you check if its the same tx id or did they make a new tx? yap, they made a new one false txid was: 36e4e5e360989373a50e65c2c82cba9df57c1a5cc9749a0ba1aeb5f26937f1c4 new one: 41e95e9857200386d7d8be89e7d2c3bf5161621e4677a8512102dffbeb67eaeb Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Nemesis on November 07, 2013, 01:03:15 AM same story here, withdrew yesterday afternoon. request answer: Quote Thanks for your email and sorry for the inconvenience caused. Few BTC withdrawals are delayed and the transaction should eventually go through. We will update you once the transfer is complete. Best regards, Mt.Gox Team no update but luckily coins arrived this evening. (more than 24 hours later!) btc transferl taking longer than fiat....gox, seriously? ??? Can you check if its the same tx id or did they make a new tx? yap, they made a new one false txid was: 36e4e5e360989373a50e65c2c82cba9df57c1a5cc9749a0ba1aeb5f26937f1c4 new one: 41e95e9857200386d7d8be89e7d2c3bf5161621e4677a8512102dffbeb67eaeb So yours was double spent too... Do you mind letting us know the amount? I want to see why you do your tx first while mine is more than 3 days. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: hlynur on November 07, 2013, 01:09:31 AM i was already on it :) yap, they made a new one false txid was: 36e4e5e360989373a50e65c2c82cba9df57c1a5cc9749a0ba1aeb5f26937f1c4 new one: 41e95e9857200386d7d8be89e7d2c3bf5161621e4677a8512102dffbeb67eaeb So yours was double spent too... Do you mind letting us know the amount? I want to see why you do your tx first while mine is more than 3 days. Quote Estimated BTC Transacted 27.1096011 BTC shit, 3 days delay is f**ed up, especially during rally times. i don't know if my decent rant starting after 5 hours via request got gox support staff going, but i'm sure it didn't harm the overall process. ;D Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Hic et nunc on November 07, 2013, 01:16:39 AM Delay of more than three days: 3 days ago I sent 700 BTC (The university of my son) to this address: ( https://blockchain.info/es/address/1PPWBeauKVg3PahkbA3VXXS6zrfvfsMNJC ) Three days later I'm still waiting. The balance in my account looks like he made the shipment but IT IS NOT TRUE. Where is my money? https://i.imgur.com/hMVoSC7.png?1 As you can see the shipping seems to have done but is not in the blockchain. This is what they answer me: (Marcus) Thank you for your email. We are sorry to inform you that we sense an issue in blockchain and looks like BTC withdrawals are appearing on block chain with a delay. We will have this checked and we will keep you updated on the status and we apologize for the inconvenience that this may have caused. Best regards... I've been waiting 3 days... Besides posting it here. What can I do? Any ideas please... When i broadcast that tx for you, i got a double spend message: Code: An outpoint is already spent [(95290641, 0), (95467206, 1), (95120872, 0), (95020365, 0), (95556501, 1), (95552084, 0), (95420581, 1), (95575141, 1), (95563296, 9), (95476568, 1), (94788741, 1), (95325015, 1), (95491346, 1), (95496474, 0), (95418902, 1), (95593506, 0), (95590592, 1), (95578675, 0), (95588915, 1), (95593043, 0), (95348256, 1), (95403563, 0), (95348318, 1), (95599653, 0), (95473326, 1), (95590326, 0), (95045266, 0), (95363415, 0), (95399759, 0), (95382818, 1), (95417780, 0), (95590225, 1), (95535978, 1), (95290360, 0), (95337477, 0), (95580105, 0), (95588082, 0), (95550429, 0), (95545183, 0), (95335146, 0), (95453523, 1), (95078087, 1), (95531079, 0), (95202312, 1), (95588395, 0), (95243605, 0), (95560643, 0), (95600674, 0), (95570766, 41), (95563752, 0), (95263377, 1), (95601012, 0), (95193538, 0), (95115400, 0), (95546048, 0), (95100104, 0), (95581120, 0), (95192227, 0), (95598160, 0), (95055170, 1), (95118992, 0), (95308359, 1), (95588483, 0), (95383867, 0), (95375424, 0), (95536495, 0), (95579953, 1), (95356988, 0), (95575074, 0), (95409149, 0), (95492987, 1), (95429248, 1), (95440184, 0), (95600282, 1), (95584515, 0), (95593502, 1), (95592529, 1), (95580201, 1), (95359778, 0), (95550427, 0), (95305697, 1), (95591395, 1), (95591058, 1), (94987016, 2), (95596805, 0), (95490168, 1), (95464681, 0), (95531243, 0), (95592338, 0), (95413201, 0), (95531722, 0), (95453996, 0), (95518851, 0), (95085949, 0), (95371479, 1), (95591457, 1), (95501119, 0), (95595285, 0), (95293281, 1), (95519260, 1), (95460990, 1), (95380799, 0), (95480599, 0), (95052808, 1), (95542323, 1), (95599020, 1), (95549546, 0), (95336694, 0), (95594183, 0), (95392112, 1), (95394021, 1), (95246667, 0), (95396625, 0), (95573517, 0), (95572781, 1), (95358743, 1), (95511436, 1), (95544711, 0), (95517264, 1), (95524358, 0), (95092422, 11), (95562403, 0), (95486252, 0), (95260626, 0), (95489600, 0), (95584409, 0), (95403229, 0), (94801303, 0), (95406229, 0), (95185842, 0), (95433699, 0)] BTW, why do you have 2 acct on here. Something to hide? I also have several emails addresses, like everyone else. Is something wrong? How important is that? Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: gambitv on November 07, 2013, 06:51:53 AM Just to add my 0.02 btc worth. I am waiting on MtGox to send my coins to this address: https://blockchain.info/address/1CAkY8dUtuMN9chZjGdbw6fXrqrXDqTRJt.
No Sign of it yet. I paid the 0.001 fee to speed it up too. Edit: First of two withdrawals arrived. ( both sent within 2 minutes to the same address above ). So first one was 22 hours delayed. And I raised a helpdesk ticket to put attention on it. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: bernard75 on November 07, 2013, 07:09:13 AM Waiting for 2 digits withdraw since yesterday.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: gambitv on November 07, 2013, 07:19:59 AM I am surprised people are flocking to MtGox to sell now. I bet a lot of people bought at Bitstamp and sold on MtGox. Now that Bitstamp got same as MtGox for a while, people are trying to re-buy and return to Bitstamp.
Unfortunately, plan will have you holding 280USD coins when they are most likely going to be worth less than 180 in a few days time. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Nemesis on November 07, 2013, 07:36:21 AM I am surprised people are flocking to MtGox to sell now. I bet a lot of people bought at Bitstamp and sold on MtGox. Now that Bitstamp got same as MtGox for a while, people are trying to re-buy and return to Bitstamp. Unfortunately, plan will have you holding 280USD coins when they are most likely going to be worth less than 180 in a few days time. lol You're a dumbass for making wild guess like that. Why dont you check your crystal ball when you're gonna lose your virgin ? Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: bernard75 on November 07, 2013, 08:38:39 AM I wonder who the dumbass is...
Gox is making doublespend transactions, people are missing transactions on a large scale and there is another shrill i his shinny armor declaring its all bs. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Nemesis on November 07, 2013, 08:42:53 AM I wonder who the dumbass is... Gox is making doublespend transactions, people are missing transactions on a large scale and there is another shrill i his shinny armor declaring its all bs. Obvious you are since you couldnt even understand reading my post. Hint for you: its regarding the btc price. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: bernard75 on November 07, 2013, 08:44:30 AM Hint for you: Go and find that virgin and maybe you find a clue.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: akhentek on November 07, 2013, 08:45:07 AM thread is pretty long... has everyone received their coins back?
got the same problem Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Nemesis on November 07, 2013, 08:45:52 AM Hint for you: Go and find that virgin and maybe you find a clue. If i need a clue i would ask Josh for a quarter idiot. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: azyr on November 07, 2013, 09:23:16 AM I've got 43BTC stuck in MtGox since I made the withdrawal about 35 hours ago. I have sent email to the support and asked what happened to my money and their response was following:
Quote James Support, Nov 07 16:44 (JST): Hello, Sorry for the delay. We will escalate to the development team and update you once the transaction is processed. Best regards, Mt.Gox Team Not very useful... How do I broadcast this transaction again? What does it actually mean to broadcast an transaction? Did MtGox actually broadcast these transactions at all to begin with? I also saw some mentions about MtGox double spending the coins that were supposed to be withdrawn. What does it mean? Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Beans on November 07, 2013, 10:07:33 AM I made a btc withdraw hours ago. Still nothing. What a pain in the ass.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: gizmoh on November 07, 2013, 10:11:52 AM Other than 'hlynur' , anyone else received their coins?
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: onecent on November 07, 2013, 11:27:33 AM so I am not the only one facing this withdraw problem, I made a withdraw about 5 hours ago and received nothing. What the FXXXK GOX? >:(
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: bouboun59 on November 07, 2013, 11:38:39 AM so I am not the only one facing this withdraw problem, I made a withdraw about 5 hours ago and received nothing. What the FXXXK GOX? >:( in IRC, no time, no solution, wait wait Me after 38hours, nothing Mtgox it's not serious ! Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Hailo on November 07, 2013, 04:36:23 PM Nancy, Nov 06 10:07 (JST): Hello, Thank you for the email. Please be noted that When withdrawing or depositing bitcoins into your Mt.Gox account there may occasionally be a delay (1~24 hours) depending on network congestion, your internet connection speed and the time required to get 6 confirmations on the network. If you're sending to your computer's wallet, it's good practice to keep your bitcoin client running so it can download the block chain. For those that may not know the block chain is the complete history of all transactions made on the bitcoin network, and as such it can take some time to update and download the most current block and see the bitcoins in your wallet. We request you to check after few hours . We would also check and keep you updated once the BTC withdrawal is processed. Best regards, Mt.Gox Team https://www.mtgox.com [Attention: Please protect your account using OTP to ensure that your funds are safe and secure. Failing to do so makes your information vulnerable to hackers. Please visit https://mtgox.com/security] This is what they sent to me. It's been almost 48 hours. 9.2 btc. Sigh been using gox for so long. Now I'm seriously never using them again once this is resolved Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: X68N on November 07, 2013, 04:48:22 PM Seriously, the Forum Mod hre shuld made this sticky.
MtGox seems to convert into a fraud company. only thing, is we can warn everybody, so most people stop using them! since 23h i wait. Only answer i got is get informed about Updates... stupid crap! Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Hic et nunc on November 07, 2013, 04:58:30 PM Nancy, Nov 06 10:07 (JST): Hello, Thank you for the email. Please be noted that When withdrawing or depositing bitcoins into your Mt.Gox account there may occasionally be a delay (1~24 hours) depending on network congestion, your internet connection speed and the time required to get 6 confirmations on the network. If you're sending to your computer's wallet, it's good practice to keep your bitcoin client running so it can download the block chain. For those that may not know the block chain is the complete history of all transactions made on the bitcoin network, and as such it can take some time to update and download the most current block and see the bitcoins in your wallet. We request you to check after few hours . We would also check and keep you updated once the BTC withdrawal is processed. Best regards, Mt.Gox Team https://www.mtgox.com [Attention: Please protect your account using OTP to ensure that your funds are safe and secure. Failing to do so makes your information vulnerable to hackers. Please visit https://mtgox.com/security] This is what they sent to me. It's been almost 48 hours. 9.2 btc. Sigh been using gox for so long. Now I'm seriously never using them again once this is resolved Identical mail they sent to me. A copy and paste. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: jaybny on November 07, 2013, 05:05:37 PM If people cant get their BTC from MtGox then the MtGox spread over Bitstamp should be much lower.. currently it is almost $20.. this indicates that the "market" doesn't think its a long term problem.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: gambitv on November 07, 2013, 05:27:22 PM I am surprised people are flocking to MtGox to sell now. I bet a lot of people bought at Bitstamp and sold on MtGox. Now that Bitstamp got same as MtGox for a while, people are trying to re-buy and return to Bitstamp. Unfortunately, plan will have you holding 280USD coins when they are most likely going to be worth less than 180 in a few days time. lol You're a dumbass for making wild guess like that. Why dont you check your crystal ball when you're gonna lose your virgin ? I didn't notice this wonderful comment. I guess a slight exaggeration. But you can understand my meaning. Some of us are trying to exit gracefully from MtGox and make use of Bitstamp being higher than Mtgox's price ( since we purchased the coins ). We are at ATH levels and have been for a few days. How long did it stay at this level back in April this year. So call me names if you like, but my meaning is clear. EDIT: All coins recieved. I did raise a helpdesk ticket to draw attention to my issue, not sure if this helped. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: gizmoh on November 07, 2013, 05:33:09 PM I am quoting this person from Wall observer thread who resumes the technical issue quite well:
Mine has nothing to do with newly minted coins, I don't even mine, been waiting since last night. It doesn't matter what you do with your bitcoins.All the bitcoins that get deposited into Mt Gox get dumped into a single pile. Some of the coins are dumped in there by miners, whose coins can not be spent until 100 blocks after they were mined. Some of the coins are only spendable if a Mt Gox employee grabs the private key out of safe or something. The software Mt Gox uses to choose which coins to spend when customers want to withdraw bitcoins is apparently suboptimal. If their software tries to spend a coin which has not matured (>100 blocks since being mined), the entire transaction ends up in limbo. Another possible problem is that some transactions end up with too many inputs with an insufficient fee the transaction also ends up in limbo. If a withdrawal transaction fails, Mt Gox has to double spend those inputs before trying the withdrawal again because otherwise there's a possibility the original transaction will suddenly get mined and they will irrevocably pay out twice. so calm down folks, we will eventually get our coins soon, and its all beneficial while btc is still on rally mode. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: justusranvier on November 07, 2013, 05:44:19 PM I am quoting this person from Wall observer thread who resumes the technical issue quite well: Just so you know, I have no inside information about Mt Gox's current problems.Mine has nothing to do with newly minted coins, I don't even mine, been waiting since last night. It doesn't matter what you do with your bitcoins.All the bitcoins that get deposited into Mt Gox get dumped into a single pile. Some of the coins are dumped in there by miners, whose coins can not be spent until 100 blocks after they were mined. Some of the coins are only spendable if a Mt Gox employee grabs the private key out of safe or something. The software Mt Gox uses to choose which coins to spend when customers want to withdraw bitcoins is apparently suboptimal. If their software tries to spend a coin which has not matured (>100 blocks since being mined), the entire transaction ends up in limbo. Another possible problem is that some transactions end up with too many inputs with an insufficient fee the transaction also ends up in limbo. If a withdrawal transaction fails, Mt Gox has to double spend those inputs before trying the withdrawal again because otherwise there's a possibility the original transaction will suddenly get mined and they will irrevocably pay out twice. so calm down folks, we will eventually get our coins soon, and its all beneficial while btc is still on rally mode. I don't know for certain what the real problems are, but the circumstantial evidence points to those factors. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: zeroblock on November 07, 2013, 05:44:54 PM I don't buy the argument that newly mined coins are causing this. The poll I did back in August only has 13.5% of miners using Gox to cash out.
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=278675.0;viewResults Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: azyr on November 07, 2013, 07:51:24 PM I am quoting this person from Wall observer thread who resumes the technical issue quite well: Mine has nothing to do with newly minted coins, I don't even mine, been waiting since last night. It doesn't matter what you do with your bitcoins.All the bitcoins that get deposited into Mt Gox get dumped into a single pile. Some of the coins are dumped in there by miners, whose coins can not be spent until 100 blocks after they were mined. Some of the coins are only spendable if a Mt Gox employee grabs the private key out of safe or something. The software Mt Gox uses to choose which coins to spend when customers want to withdraw bitcoins is apparently suboptimal. If their software tries to spend a coin which has not matured (>100 blocks since being mined), the entire transaction ends up in limbo. Another possible problem is that some transactions end up with too many inputs with an insufficient fee the transaction also ends up in limbo. If a withdrawal transaction fails, Mt Gox has to double spend those inputs before trying the withdrawal again because otherwise there's a possibility the original transaction will suddenly get mined and they will irrevocably pay out twice. so calm down folks, we will eventually get our coins soon, and its all beneficial while btc is still on rally mode. Can someone elaborate on the last paragraph: Quote If a withdrawal transaction fails, Mt Gox has to double spend those inputs before trying the withdrawal again because otherwise there's a possibility the original transaction will suddenly get mined and they will irrevocably pay out twice. That would explain the "double spending" that is occurring at the moment. Why can those failed withdrawals get mined again? If the coins have been created once, how can they be created again? Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Hfertig on November 07, 2013, 08:51:04 PM I made a withdrawal of 10 BTC from Gox today and they went through within an hour. A bit slower than usual, but all went like a charm.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: justusranvier on November 07, 2013, 09:06:07 PM Why can those failed withdrawals get mined again? If the coins have been created once, how can they be created again? This is about transactions, not newly mined coins.One a transaction has been signed, it's valid as long as no conflicting transactions get added to the blockchain first. Once it's been broadcast to the network it could potentially be added to the blockchain at any time. If a signed transaction is broadcast but not immediately added to the blockchain by miners, the only way to make sure that it doesn't go through later on is to send those same inputs back to yourself and make sure the second transaction does. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Cablez on November 07, 2013, 09:39:59 PM I am coming up on 24hrs with no BTC delivered from Gox yet. Sheesh what a pain.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: akhentek on November 07, 2013, 09:43:21 PM Also coming up on 24 hours, no coins.
I already have a support ticket on the go. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: bouboun59 on November 07, 2013, 09:44:20 PM Also coming up on 24 hours, no coins. I already have a support ticket on the go. mE Since 48hours ;D and still nothing Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: n4ru on November 07, 2013, 10:32:14 PM Oh boy. I've got a friend with over 2,000 BTC in Gox. He's not going to enjoy hearing this.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Hailo on November 07, 2013, 10:43:04 PM Over 48hours and nothing. Support has stopped replying as well. Seriously beginning to totally doubt gox as a service now
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: jzcjca00 on November 07, 2013, 10:48:00 PM Oh boy. I've got a friend with over 2,000 BTC in Gox. He's not going to enjoy hearing this. Seriously, he needs to put his coins somewhere safer. Only keep at Mt.Gox money that you can afford to lose! Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: bernard75 on November 08, 2013, 12:01:48 AM Seriously, he needs to put his coins somewhere safer. Only keep at Mt.Gox money that you WILL loose! I fixed that for you.Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: azyr on November 08, 2013, 12:49:30 AM During the time I made my 42btc withdrawal I made a series of smaller ones (about 3-4 withdrawals). All of the small ones got through, one of them got stuck the same way the big one did but it came through today. Now I have been waiting for about 50 hours....
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: chasetopher on November 08, 2013, 01:09:31 AM Just received my withdrawal. PHEW! Took a little over 24 hours. I'm sad to hear that others have been waiting longer. :(
Well, so long Mt. Gox, I'm never using you again. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: HeliKopterBen on November 08, 2013, 01:19:43 AM I just tried a test to withdraw .1 and nothing yet. Its been an hour.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Pangia on November 08, 2013, 01:49:48 AM Did a double digit withdrawal (last coins in GOX). It's been over 24 hours and nothing.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Nemesis on November 08, 2013, 01:51:53 AM anyone got a way to contact Mark directly?
This is getting fcking ridiculous. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: bernard75 on November 08, 2013, 01:58:36 AM MagicalTux @freenode #mtgox
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Pangia on November 08, 2013, 02:01:34 AM Don't know how to say this, but I think we got robbed.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: n4ru on November 08, 2013, 02:56:03 AM Oh boy. I've got a friend with over 2,000 BTC in Gox. He's not going to enjoy hearing this. Seriously, he needs to put his coins somewhere safer. Only keep at Mt.Gox money that you can afford to lose! Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: TheJamesFund on November 08, 2013, 06:53:08 AM 2013/11/05 09:41:46 Withdraw 15.15000000 AND 1BTC
The 1BTC just got transferred now but still missing the 15.5BTC I'm glad to see I am not the only one getting F'd Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: TheJamesFund on November 08, 2013, 07:09:52 AM finally got it!!!!!!!
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: elbill on November 08, 2013, 07:46:03 AM After 22h ... unbelievable
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: azyr on November 08, 2013, 07:54:29 AM After about 60 hours of waiting I finally got all the coins out of MtGox. The biggest transfer of about 43BTC was the one that took the longest (not suprisingly).
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: crazy_rabbit on November 08, 2013, 08:26:06 AM I"ve been listening to these withdrawal issues for a little while, yesterday I tested it multiple times and get my withdrawal after about a minute for a number of different amounts. Small and large. So, I don't know whats up that so many people are having problems.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: huffyrox on November 08, 2013, 08:32:35 AM I made a double digit withdrawal yesterday and received in slightly over 24 hours. Got a little concerned reading all these posts but seems like they've come through, at least for me.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: laichzeit0 on November 08, 2013, 10:08:39 AM Well I'm at 48hours since the withdrawal request. Gox support replied today saying "it should go through eventually". In 2 years I've never had a problem with BTC withdrawals on Gox being delayed. Be careful guys.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: solex on November 08, 2013, 10:22:24 AM Well I'm at 48hours since the withdrawal request. Gox support replied today saying "it should go through eventually". In 2 years I've never had a problem with BTC withdrawals on Gox being delayed. Be careful guys. You've been trading on gox for two years and only just started posting on this forum?? Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: laichzeit0 on November 08, 2013, 11:00:44 AM Not sure what you're trying to imply? Yes I've been using Mt.Gox since it was $15 a bitcoin. I originally mined and then bought BTC on IRC through #btc-otc. Never had problems getting BTC in or out of Gox before ( I believe there is huge delays with international wire transfers?).
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: crazy_rabbit on November 08, 2013, 12:47:39 PM Well I'm at 48hours since the withdrawal request. Gox support replied today saying "it should go through eventually". In 2 years I've never had a problem with BTC withdrawals on Gox being delayed. Be careful guys. You've been trading on gox for two years and only just started posting on this forum?? He's not alone. Many people have been in bitcoin for years and skip the jabbering down here. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Nemesis on November 08, 2013, 12:50:27 PM I"ve been listening to these withdrawal issues for a little while, yesterday I tested it multiple times and get my withdrawal after about a minute for a number of different amounts. Small and large. So, I don't know whats up that so many people are having problems. are they double digit btc? I still havent received mine. Its closed to 5days now Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Cablez on November 08, 2013, 12:51:04 PM So after about 36 hours my withdrawal has finally hit my wallet. Keep the faith brothers it should come.
EDIT: I am going to try another one today so I will keep you posted. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: crazy_rabbit on November 08, 2013, 02:09:44 PM Well I guess I finally got unlucky with GOX, I deposited XXBTC this morning on my account, and now, 21 confirmations later, it still hasn't shown up on my account.
I've written support, but I suspect considering the issues, it might take awhile for them to get back to me. Hopefully nothing dramatic happens between now and it showing up (like a total crash), but I guess I was just being lucky having no problems earlier. :-[ Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: crazy_rabbit on November 08, 2013, 02:27:16 PM On the Gox "Help" Page:
Withdrawals and Deposits Marion posted this on May 31 17:13 Updated on November 8th 2013 (Delays are updated frequently) 07/11/13: Unfortunately some users are experiencing delays in their bitcoin withdrawals. Our technical team are aware of the issue and are working very hard to resolve it. We apologies for any inconvenience caused. ---Well that I suppose is enough to calm me for now. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: laichzeit0 on November 08, 2013, 02:42:01 PM Today I asked them for the raw tx so I could do a manual broadcast and no reply. Saw something on reddit about them messing up the tx, so this could be related.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: HeliKopterBen on November 08, 2013, 03:38:52 PM On the Gox "Help" Page: Withdrawals and Deposits Marion posted this on May 31 17:13 Updated on November 8th 2013 (Delays are updated frequently) 07/11/13: Unfortunately some users are experiencing delays in their bitcoin withdrawals. Our technical team are aware of the issue and are working very hard to resolve it. We apologies for any inconvenience caused. ---Well that I suppose is enough to calm me for now. Well at least they responded I guess. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: HeliKopterBen on November 08, 2013, 03:40:27 PM I got the 0.1btc after after about 9 hrs. I have since initiated a larger withdrawal. I will keep you posted.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: X68N on November 08, 2013, 03:50:06 PM i recieved them after 30h, until today (1,5 days later) they never noticed me or replied on my support ticket.
- i will use them never again. A business partner which lies to you and didnt communicate when a problem occurs is more then useless. Smells like fraud. This should be a lesson to everyone. Gox is a sinking ship. They will take the cash + the coins with them. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: justusranvier on November 08, 2013, 03:54:38 PM A business partner which lies to you and didnt communicate when a problem occurs is more then useless. Smells like fraud. By those standards they've been a sinking ship since 2011. They manage to stay above water though, somehow.This should be a lesson to everyone. Gox is a sinking ship. They will take the cash + the coins with them. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Xialla on November 08, 2013, 04:08:30 PM Well I guess I finally got unlucky with GOX, I deposited XXBTC this morning on my account, and now, 21 confirmations later, it still hasn't shown up on my account. ahh, same here. 23 confirmation, ~3 hours of waiting and still nothing.. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Zangelbert Bingledack on November 08, 2013, 04:42:35 PM Bad timing, as the rally is getting temporarily overheated and this is a perfect time to take a little bit of profit. Don't gox me bro!
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Hailo on November 08, 2013, 04:54:17 PM Reaching the 72hour mark. :-\ time to take some profits. But noooo....
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: akhentek on November 08, 2013, 05:53:53 PM got another support reply, same "escalation" copy as everyone else's
meh Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: X68N on November 09, 2013, 12:16:07 AM A business partner which lies to you and didnt communicate when a problem occurs is more then useless. Smells like fraud. By those standards they've been a sinking ship since 2011. They manage to stay above water though, somehow.This should be a lesson to everyone. Gox is a sinking ship. They will take the cash + the coins with them. there are 2 types of sinking ships, one with a small hole which coul reach safe land again, and Mt.Gox-Titanic which has 5 BIG holes which starts to sink. Dont over see the sings pal. 1. Bank Limit since 2 years... (ultra delitantic, in business terms) 2. Sized Money from US-Goverment 3. Multimullion Courtcases against them 4. Loosing Volume against competitioners. (Bitstamt + China are taking over) 5. Withdraw "delay" which is a perfect sign to hear the alarmclock... I mean as hobby investor you could ignore this all and try to stay a fan of Gox and become Goxed in the end. But when you need the Money as Income (Fulltime Investor) then MtGox has become a no-go. You should heard about the term "money management and risk management" (basic investment rules). greetings Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Hic et nunc on November 09, 2013, 01:27:59 AM Since 11/03/2013 18:20:20 GMT I sent 700 BTC to this address: ( https://blockchain.info/es/address/1PPWBeauKVg3PahkbA3VXXS6zrfvfsMNJC ) I'm still waiting. The balance in my account looks like he made the shipment but IT IS NOT TRUE. Where is my money? This was my operation and so appears on my Account history: https://i.imgur.com/jm6pTTo.png There are only 2 possible options: 1) my btc appear in my account so I can dispose of them, or 2) btc appear in the destination address ( 1PPWBeauKVg3PahkbA3VXXS6zrfvfsMNJC ). Since 11/03/2013 18:20:20 GMT I'm still waiting for a solution. Have they lost my money forever? Where is my money? Someone can help me?, Any ideas please? At last, after over 5 days Mtgox has made the withdrawal. I suffered a lot for your fault Goodbye forever MtGox. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Cablez on November 09, 2013, 01:29:55 AM My second withdrawal of bitcoin from mt gox has happened almost instantaneously. Looking at 3 confirms already. Let us hope that was the end of BTC delays.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Nemesis on November 09, 2013, 01:44:47 AM wow and i'm still waiting for mine. ::)
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: HeliKopterBen on November 09, 2013, 02:14:57 AM Nope. I tried a second withdrawal albout 30 hrs ago and nothing.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: joesmoe2012 on November 09, 2013, 02:43:27 AM Going on 72 hours here.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: gizmoh on November 09, 2013, 04:31:28 AM 96 hours here, oh well by the time it arrive btc should be 500 ::)
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: johnblaze on November 09, 2013, 06:21:45 AM At last, after over 5 days Mtgox has made the withdrawal. I suffered a lot for your fault Goodbye forever MtGox. good to hear that you finally got paid. 700 BTC is a large number Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Hic et nunc on November 09, 2013, 10:22:58 AM At last, after over 5 days Mtgox has made the withdrawal. I suffered a lot for your fault Goodbye forever MtGox. good to hear that you finally got paid. 700 BTC is a large number Thanks . Tonight I'll be able to sleep :) Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Hailo on November 09, 2013, 03:55:56 PM Mine finally went through after about 90 hours. Good luck to the rest of you guys waiting
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: X68N on November 09, 2013, 05:11:06 PM At last, after over 5 days Mtgox has made the withdrawal. I suffered a lot for your fault Goodbye forever MtGox. good to hear that you finally got paid. 700 BTC is a large number Thanks . Tonight I'll be able to sleep :) and also good to hear that you never use them again , like i do. :-) Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: akhentek on November 10, 2013, 07:46:49 AM transaction processed 72 hours later.
hope everyone's else's coins come though soon. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: joesmoe2012 on November 10, 2013, 03:47:15 PM Mine took 4 days, came through just after the crash. 100% out of gox now. Good luck to everybody.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: HeliKopterBen on November 10, 2013, 04:22:09 PM Got it in about 72 hrs and a few messages to tech support.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: jzcjca00 on November 10, 2013, 07:44:22 PM I transferred (with no transaction fee) 1 BTC from Mt.Gox a few hours ago. The transaction showed up within a couple of minutes, and it confirmed as expected. There was no unreasonable delay at all.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: pinger on November 10, 2013, 08:00:25 PM I transferred (with no transaction fee) 1 BTC from Mt.Gox a few hours ago. The transaction showed up within a couple of minutes, and it confirmed as expected. There was no unreasonable delay at all. +1 I get 2.4 BTC yesterday, and It was less than 10 seconds to see it on blockchain. I think this problem is solved except for the people affected a few days ago. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: passo on November 11, 2013, 11:19:03 PM nope, im experiencing delay. I decided it was a smart move to get out of gox.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: calmindifference on November 12, 2013, 12:12:17 PM still broken, been waiting over 12 hours now
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Jreche on November 13, 2013, 12:45:38 PM still broken, been waiting over 12 hours now also I have this problem. I've been waiting 36 hours or so. A new bug appears. Warning! this transaction is a double spend of 96,695,872. You should be extremely careful trusting When any transactions to / From this sender. https://blockchain.info/tx/55cf6305e1f7e4b4f14a5d40b4f09e580e6db6d0865667d8f1a83915ace31990 Meanwhile I'm still without my coins .. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: chrisLG on November 14, 2013, 06:20:03 PM At last, after over 5 days Mtgox has made the withdrawal. I suffered a lot for your fault Goodbye forever MtGox. good to hear that you finally got paid. 700 BTC is a large number Thanks . Tonight I'll be able to sleep :) I'm also happy for you! Glad you got your money back. Until they get their act straight Gox is an absolute no go for now. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: ||bit on November 15, 2013, 12:45:32 PM I transferred (with no transaction fee) 1 BTC from Mt.Gox a few hours ago. The transaction showed up within a couple of minutes, and it confirmed as expected. There was no unreasonable delay at all. Congrats! Is your account verified? Either way, please consider to answer the poll question I setup here: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=332420.0 Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: ||bit on November 15, 2013, 12:46:32 PM I transferred (with no transaction fee) 1 BTC from Mt.Gox a few hours ago. The transaction showed up within a couple of minutes, and it confirmed as expected. There was no unreasonable delay at all. +1 I get 2.4 BTC yesterday, and It was less than 10 seconds to see it on blockchain. I think this problem is solved except for the people affected a few days ago. Congrats to you too! Would you also consider to answer the poll I placed here: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=332420.0 It's for anyone that has a Gox account - verified or not. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: ||bit on November 15, 2013, 12:52:55 PM Since 11/03/2013 18:20:20 GMT I sent 700 BTC to this address: ( https://blockchain.info/es/address/1PPWBeauKVg3PahkbA3VXXS6zrfvfsMNJC ) I'm still waiting. The balance in my account looks like he made the shipment but IT IS NOT TRUE. Where is my money? This was my operation and so appears on my Account history: https://i.imgur.com/jm6pTTo.png There are only 2 possible options: 1) my btc appear in my account so I can dispose of them, or 2) btc appear in the destination address ( 1PPWBeauKVg3PahkbA3VXXS6zrfvfsMNJC ). Since 11/03/2013 18:20:20 GMT I'm still waiting for a solution. Have they lost my money forever? Where is my money? Someone can help me?, Any ideas please? At last, after over 5 days Mtgox has made the withdrawal. I suffered a lot for your fault Goodbye forever MtGox. Congrats! I bet you feel relieved - did you have to pay an extortion fee? BTW: Did you have a verified account? Please, take the poll in the linked thread. I'm being poll fanatic right now. Trying to get a profile on Gox's operation. https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=332420.0 Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: posormo on November 16, 2013, 11:28:30 AM Someone please nuke Japan again, or at least someone overflow them with easy problems so they can choke on their own stupidity. Well aren't you a fuckin moron. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: psychocoin on November 16, 2013, 12:13:07 PM Has someone withdrawn GBP lately? How long did it take?
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: bfldtc on November 17, 2013, 11:16:11 AM Am I the only one still waiting for my coins ? It's been 4 days now... got the standard response from support.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: dodgyjammer on November 18, 2013, 09:52:38 AM I also had issues withdrawing BTC yesterday - seems like they have different priorities for different amounts (either that or the system is purely random) as I made 2 transfers in quick succession, one took 5 minutes (the larger one) the other took 16 hours to show in blockchain...? For both I paid the "faster processing" fee.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Narydu on November 19, 2013, 02:20:26 AM I Withdrew a "FAIR" ammount of BTC the 6th Nov and it never went through!!! I've contacted several times MtgGox and I keep getting no other answer other than, we are having some issues with some transfers...
I didn't post before because I had no problem with waiting but it's been enough... Please advice me how to act... I could post additional information if needed. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: maz on November 20, 2013, 08:11:06 AM Withdrew 21 btc an hour ago, still not showing on block chain. Fully verified. Hope it's not going to be a 24hour affair!
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: bfldtc on November 20, 2013, 05:23:22 PM Mine came through yesterday, after 6 days. Thanks Mtgox, I'll never do business with you ever again.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: GIANNAT on November 20, 2013, 06:19:52 PM The fact that they ask 0.001BTC for "Faster Processing" withdrewal is utterly stupid also it took 4 hour to withdrew some btc
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: TheCoinBull on November 20, 2013, 06:57:04 PM Tryed to send a small amount as trial of 1.5 BTC, has not showed up on blockchain, been 4 hours lol
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: yellowdog on November 20, 2013, 08:19:13 PM Same is happening to me. I am verified. I am waiting for 3h and still nothing. Contacted support. I'll post more info if this fiasco will go to far.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: superduh on November 20, 2013, 08:41:46 PM does someone have to be verified to withdraw bitcoins now? or just fiat?
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: miffman on November 20, 2013, 08:44:14 PM It's been almost 24hrs for a withdrawl to show up. This is starting to annoy me. A lot
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: TheCoinBull on November 20, 2013, 10:17:06 PM Still not received my coins from withdrawal. Not showing up on blockchain, where are the coins sleeping? How this dosent turn into one of those hackers accessed our account type deals
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: yellowdog on November 21, 2013, 10:00:56 AM Same is happening to me. I am verified. I am waiting for 3h and still nothing. Contacted support. I'll post more info if this fiasco will go to far. After like 6-7h the btc came but blockchain.info says it is a doublespent of another transaction, and that another transaction has 0 confirmations. My transaction as we speak has 50 confirmations so i can assume i am the lucky one that got back my coins right? Anyway i am disappointed by mtgox, and i will avoid them till they fix this thing. Admins should post a sticky and users to post their problems for us to see when mtgox solve this thing. thx Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: TheCoinBull on November 21, 2013, 01:45:31 PM Withdrawl came through After abour 22 hours lol. Coins when up over $100 bucks lol
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Rampion on November 21, 2013, 02:01:06 PM Do not worry guys, is just that Gox's volume is so freakin' high that they are "overwhelming" both the biggest bank in Japan and the BTC network. They are just a victim of their own success, as they stated many times is just "the traditional banking system unable to keep up with BTC's thriving economy". It seems that the Bitcoin network is unable too to keep up with Gox's huuuuuuge volume.
Oh wait. Fiat deposits are still processed steadily, I guess its only the withdrawals what "overwhelms" the poor people at the bank. And BTC deposits are processed quickly too :( Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Mattzees on November 21, 2013, 05:05:26 PM Just FYI...
For what it's worth, I just withdrew a few BTC from Gox to my private wallet, and the transaction completed in less than three minutes. Check both boxes. Get 6 confirms, AND pay the .001 BTC fee. That seems worth it to me. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Luzio on November 22, 2013, 07:18:40 PM Same problem here today. Previous withdrawal was instant. And the new one today delayed, nothing is appearing on the blockchain. I payed the fee.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Bugpowder on November 22, 2013, 08:28:04 PM BTC withdrawls have been taking about 48 hours lately in my and my friends' experience. High volume I'm sure.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Luzio on November 22, 2013, 11:11:55 PM BTC withdrawls have been taking about 48 hours lately in my and my friends' experience. High volume I'm sure. That is just crazy. Still nothing happening on the blockchain, and not even a support reply. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: joesmoe2012 on November 23, 2013, 07:32:50 AM So glad i'm no longer part of this mess.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: solex on November 23, 2013, 07:50:45 AM So glad i'm no longer part of this mess. Yeah. MtGox is like that slow-mo van-off-a-bridge crash in "Inception" which lasted half the film. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: kkaspar on November 27, 2013, 02:22:53 PM Just after withdrawing out of MtGox I discovered that their bitcoin transaction can take 24h?!?!?!
How the hell can this be. Do they have baboons behind PCs with bitcoin-qt and typing in the transactions manually?! In an very important time I discover that MtGox is beyond incompetent. I will never use them again and I will tell everyone I meet to not use them. I will curse the day they decided to enter the bitcoin market system. Their incompetence will be very costly to me. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Luzio on November 27, 2013, 10:50:24 PM Indeed, do not use them. I did get my bitcoins after 24 hours. Their support replied 5 days later telling me that the transaction went through, what a bunch of tits.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: dimaze on November 28, 2013, 12:53:36 AM did an 8 BTC withdraw with a fee, nearly 36 hours later and no coins. Can't force the transaction, states it's invalid. No response from support either.
This will probably be the last time I use Gox as well. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: ||bit on November 28, 2013, 02:20:40 AM On the Gox "Help" Page: Withdrawals and Deposits Marion posted this on May 31 17:13 Updated on November 8th 2013 (Delays are updated frequently) 07/11/13: Unfortunately some users are experiencing delays in their bitcoin withdrawals. Our technical team are aware of the issue and are working very hard to resolve it. We apologies for any inconvenience caused. ---Well that I suppose is enough to calm me for now. But it's concerning that they have been "working hard" to resolve that problem since May. Your post was in November.... and apparently it still hasn't been resolved. Unless this is a new problem with the same effect. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: ||bit on November 28, 2013, 02:23:19 AM wow and i'm still waiting for mine. ::) Did you receive anything yet? It's been five days for you...or something like that. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: dimaze on November 28, 2013, 05:48:17 AM Got my BTC, but only after 38 hours.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: imperi on November 28, 2013, 05:53:33 AM I received my Bitcoin withdrawal after roughly 48 hours.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: n4ru on November 28, 2013, 11:52:56 AM Has anyone been successfully able to withdraw a good amount of coin - say, over 2,000? If so, how long did it take?
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: pinger on November 28, 2013, 11:56:07 AM I received my Bitcoin withdrawal after roughly 48 hours. I made a 0.6 withdrawal a few minutes ago, and is now on block chain. I'm still waiting my euros I withdraw a few days ago. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: ||bit on November 28, 2013, 03:03:53 PM I made three withdrawals. The first is still missing, this afternoon will be 72 hours. The second was received after about 48 hours. The third - which was the largest withdrawal - was nearly instant.
It makes no sense. Withdrawal size and order do not seem to matter. MtGox is unreliable. I'm going to close my account forever because of their delays and poor customer service. If I were a merchant, I would not use them. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: ||bit on November 28, 2013, 03:08:18 PM Has anyone been successfully able to withdraw a good amount of coin - say, over 2,000? If so, how long did it take? One person here withdrew 700btc. It took him five days to receive I think. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: pinger on November 28, 2013, 04:10:48 PM Has anyone been successfully able to withdraw a good amount of coin - say, over 2,000? If so, how long did it take? One person here withdrew 700btc. It took him five days to receive I think. According how the withdraws works on gox, I would make 7 withdrawals to take that 700, not a direct 700 withdrawal. Is better to be stocked with 300 btc than 700 btc. I hope you can understand what I'm trying to say, my english is becoming worst every day ;) Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: jzcjca00 on November 30, 2013, 04:33:20 PM I finally managed to get everything off of Mt.Gox successfully.
I cancelled the USD wire transfer that had been pending for over a month, put in a buy limit order 20% below market, and waited for a correction. When it finally hit, I transferred the BTC to Bitstamp and sold there. From that point it was less than a week to get the USD from Slovenia to my bank in the U.S. I think the infinite delays getting USD off of Mt.Gox are due to U.S. banks refusing to accept wire transfers from an exchange that is at war with the U.S. government. Banks are siding with their regulators. So don't bother trinig to do USD withdrawals from Mt.Gox to U.S. banks. I think the delays in BTC withdrawals are due to bottlenecks caused by their security measures. They only keep a small amount of BTC online, and when that is used up, they have bottlenecks getting funds from offline wallets. This is merely a mild annoyance, not indicitave of a real problem. The real problem is their lack of honesty. They could openly admit that they cannot process wire transfers to North American banks, but they keep quiet and pretend that there is not a problem. They could openly state that BTC withdrawals will take up to 48 hours, but they just don't seem to care. In my experience, when you do business with dishonest people, you eventually get burned. Is it worth the risk? Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: kingcrimson on December 02, 2013, 10:32:03 PM Been waiting three days now, 10 support tickets ignored. I'm moving all my business permanently to Bitstamp.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: pinger on December 02, 2013, 11:26:46 PM Has anyone been successfully able to withdraw a good amount of coin - say, over 2,000? If so, how long did it take? One person here withdrew 700btc. It took him five days to receive I think. According how the withdraws works on gox, I would make 7 withdrawals to take that 700, not a direct 700 withdrawal. Is better to be stocked with 300 btc than 700 btc. I hope you can understand what I'm trying to say, my english is becoming worst every day ;) Today I was not able to withdraw 1500 euros, I ever get an error. I'm not happy with Gox now, I never had a problem until now. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: pinger on December 02, 2013, 11:28:20 PM Has anyone been successfully able to withdraw a good amount of coin - say, over 2,000? If so, how long did it take? One person here withdrew 700btc. It took him five days to receive I think. According how the withdraws works on gox, I would make 7 withdrawals to take that 700, not a direct 700 withdrawal. Is better to be stocked with 300 btc than 700 btc. I hope you can understand what I'm trying to say, my english is becoming worst every day ;) Today I was not able to withdraw 1500 euros, I ever get an error. I'm not happy with Gox now, I never had a problem until now. BTW my 150 euros sent before, are still on the road, but I'm not able to found it on the log of gox. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: kingcrimson on December 03, 2013, 04:53:59 AM I was given a site that lists all live mtgox transactions that failed to reach the blockchain, and sure enough mine was there: http://skanner.net/MtGox/mtgox_tx.php
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: snioctib on December 04, 2013, 06:45:16 PM Same - I made a withdrawal for ~30 coins, and it's been over 26 hours with no luck.
My transaction isn't on the website above, but it is on here: https://data.mtgox.com/api/0/bitcoin_tx.php Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: kingcrimson on December 04, 2013, 09:39:11 PM Been waiting 5 days now, sent a dozen support ticket requests and got no response.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: joesmoe2012 on December 05, 2013, 01:48:08 AM Has anyone been successfully able to withdraw a good amount of coin - say, over 2,000? If so, how long did it take? It is recommended by Mark @ irc to break large withdraws into multiple small ones (i was told to keep it under 100 BTC each). Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Rampion on December 05, 2013, 10:43:59 AM Has anyone been successfully able to withdraw a good amount of coin - say, over 2,000? If so, how long did it take? It is recommended by Mark @ irc to break large withdraws into multiple small ones (i was told to keep it under 100 BTC each). That could only mean they are nearly broke and having liquidity problems. Otherwise, what does it change for the blockchain if the withdrawal is 100 or 1000? AFAIK the blockchain has no "limits" and in fact, AS WE ALL KNOW, dust is discouraged and for the network "the bigger the better" as it reduces blockchain bloating. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: snioctib on December 06, 2013, 02:45:55 AM Update: took 2 1/2 days, but I received my bitcoin (under a different transaction).
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: joesmoe2012 on December 06, 2013, 05:51:12 AM Has anyone been successfully able to withdraw a good amount of coin - say, over 2,000? If so, how long did it take? It is recommended by Mark @ irc to break large withdraws into multiple small ones (i was told to keep it under 100 BTC each). That could only mean they are nearly broke and having liquidity problems. Otherwise, what does it change for the blockchain if the withdrawal is 100 or 1000? AFAIK the blockchain has no "limits" and in fact, AS WE ALL KNOW, dust is discouraged and for the network "the bigger the better" as it reduces blockchain bloating. Actually it has nothing to do with them being 'broke,' but rather with the way they form transactions using many different inputs. A very large transaction will have hundreds of inputs @ mtgox, causing significant delays before it is processed. Smaller transactions have lss inputs and are thus processed more quickly. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: pinger on December 12, 2013, 10:32:53 AM Has anyone been successfully able to withdraw a good amount of coin - say, over 2,000? If so, how long did it take? One person here withdrew 700btc. It took him five days to receive I think. According how the withdraws works on gox, I would make 7 withdrawals to take that 700, not a direct 700 withdrawal. Is better to be stocked with 300 btc than 700 btc. I hope you can understand what I'm trying to say, my english is becoming worst every day ;) Today I was not able to withdraw 1500 euros, I ever get an error. I'm not happy with Gox now, I never had a problem until now. BTW my 150 euros sent before, are still on the road, but I'm not able to found it on the log of gox. My transfer just arrived, but not 150, just 136.62 €. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: GreenBits on December 13, 2013, 05:45:01 PM This just happened to me attempting to transfer 9.43573859 BTC from MTGox to Cex.io. Only been about an hour but I have very dim hopes for getting access to my btc in a timely fashion. ???
Oh, and I missed buying into the damn dip on Cex... icing on the cake. So, if you can read this, Goxians, and are in a position to help, please review Ticket #173858 Stuck/Incomplete BTC Withdrawal Its not showing up on skanner.net, but I have screenies so I'm not too concerned, just annoyed. ~Green Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: GreenBits on December 13, 2013, 09:38:19 PM Does Gox answer support on Sat/Sun?? Live chat is anything but. My support ticket hasn't been supported yet. This does not augur well for my weekend.
Will keep the folk updated. :-\ BTW, is there no forum member that acts as technical support/ PR liason for Gox? Now, perhaps if I had put my support request in a bottle, and violently flung the fucker into an ocean, maybe someone would have looked at it by now. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: HeliKopterBen on December 14, 2013, 02:11:36 AM Has anyone been successfully able to withdraw a good amount of coin - say, over 2,000? If so, how long did it take? It is recommended by Mark @ irc to break large withdraws into multiple small ones (i was told to keep it under 100 BTC each). That could only mean they are nearly broke and having liquidity problems. Otherwise, what does it change for the blockchain if the withdrawal is 100 or 1000? AFAIK the blockchain has no "limits" and in fact, AS WE ALL KNOW, dust is discouraged and for the network "the bigger the better" as it reduces blockchain bloating. Actually it has nothing to do with them being 'broke,' but rather with the way they form transactions using many different inputs. A very large transaction will have hundreds of inputs @ mtgox, causing significant delays before it is processed. Smaller transactions have lss inputs and are thus processed more quickly. Then why don't they just post a simple message stating that large withdrawals will take longer. I just withdrew 1 btc and then another withdrawal of 50 btc and both went through within a few minutes. I then tried a 100 btc withdrawal and still waiting 1.5 hrs later. I would gladly have broken it up if I knew this ahead of time but there was nothing alerting me to large withdrawal delays. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: bakada on December 14, 2013, 05:55:46 AM ,,
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: joesmoe2012 on December 14, 2013, 09:07:36 AM Has anyone been successfully able to withdraw a good amount of coin - say, over 2,000? If so, how long did it take? It is recommended by Mark @ irc to break large withdraws into multiple small ones (i was told to keep it under 100 BTC each). That could only mean they are nearly broke and having liquidity problems. Otherwise, what does it change for the blockchain if the withdrawal is 100 or 1000? AFAIK the blockchain has no "limits" and in fact, AS WE ALL KNOW, dust is discouraged and for the network "the bigger the better" as it reduces blockchain bloating. Actually it has nothing to do with them being 'broke,' but rather with the way they form transactions using many different inputs. A very large transaction will have hundreds of inputs @ mtgox, causing significant delays before it is processed. Smaller transactions have lss inputs and are thus processed more quickly. Then why don't they just post a simple message stating that large withdrawals will take longer. I just withdrew 1 btc and then another withdrawal of 50 btc and both went through within a few minutes. I then tried a 100 btc withdrawal and still waiting 1.5 hrs later. I would gladly have broken it up if I knew this ahead of time but there was nothing alerting me to large withdrawal delays. As i said, i was specifically told by karples that breaking large transactions into < 100 BTC chunks would make them go faster. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: HeliKopterBen on December 14, 2013, 11:48:12 AM Then why don't they just post a simple message stating that large withdrawals will take longer. I just withdrew 1 btc and then another withdrawal of 50 btc and both went through within a few minutes. I then tried a 100 btc withdrawal and still waiting 1.5 hrs later. I would gladly have broken it up if I knew this ahead of time but there was nothing alerting me to large withdrawal delays. You mean simple things like this splashed across the withdrawal page: "BTC : You can still withdraw up to 100.00000000 BTC provided you have enough on your account (your limit is 100.00000000 BTC per 24 hours )" Open your eyes. It says I can withdraw up to 2000 per day. Not 100. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: GreenBits on December 14, 2013, 04:51:10 PM Deposit made it into my CEX.io wallet sometime this morning. Thanks, if someone had to push any buttons/pull any levers to facilitate this. No response from support yet so I wonder if this just "unstuck" itself.
~Green Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: GreenBits on December 15, 2013, 01:16:44 AM so, i have to ask, from veteran Gox users, how often does this happen? am i statistically over the hump as far as this occurring again? esp on sub 10 btc amounts?
another user contacted me via email, got hit for 13.8. denying access to funds in this time sensitive market is the cardinal sin in this space. i want to use Gox (volatility is off the chain) but I'd almost be a fool to send them my coins again. Thoughts? ~Green sorry to keep bumping this thread so hard Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: pinger on December 15, 2013, 09:24:11 AM so, i have to ask, from veteran Gox users, how often does this happen? am i statistically over the hump as far as this occurring again? esp on sub 10 btc amounts? another user contacted me via email, got hit for 13.8. denying access to funds in this time sensitive market is the cardinal sin in this space. i want to use Gox (volatility is off the chain) but I'd almost be a fool to send them my coins again. Thoughts? ~Green sorry to keep bumping this thread so hard I get denied to extract fiat from Gox, and that is unacceptable for me. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: HappyBitCoinUser on January 02, 2014, 03:26:48 PM I sent a support ticket and getting no response too.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: bennybong on January 02, 2014, 05:44:40 PM I had this issue. Took about 2 days to finally show up. Not sure why, I guess we'll never know...
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: X68N on January 03, 2014, 07:51:43 AM The Fiat withdraw delay thread has already 137 pages.
Expect bitcoin withdraw delay thread will make the same progress! I cant understand why people still trust them. Maybe because in most cultures a boy doesnt become a real man until he gets goxed? ;D Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: bennybong on January 03, 2014, 10:11:43 AM The Fiat withdraw delay thread has already 137 pages. Expect bitcoin withdraw delay thread will make the same progress! I cant understand why people still trust them. Maybe because in most cultures a boy doesnt become a real man until he gets goxed? ;D Any idea when the last fiat withdrawal was received by anyone and how long it took? Waiting on 10k over here.... Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: HappyBitCoinUser on January 04, 2014, 01:53:08 AM The Fiat withdraw delay thread has already 137 pages. Expect bitcoin withdraw delay thread will make the same progress! I cant understand why people still trust them. Maybe because in most cultures a boy doesnt become a real man until he gets goxed? ;D Any idea when the last fiat withdrawal was received by anyone and how long it took? Waiting on 10k over here.... Over $10k probably got you flagged by the banks due to government regulations. If you take out $9500 multiple times that'll get you flagged for "structuring" which a crime. Its no-win. Just contact your bank or their bank, make sure its all authorized, etc. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Dirk83 on January 08, 2014, 06:25:13 PM I am having an issue again with withdrawing BTC, withdrawed over 24 hours ago. Anyone else experiencing problems now?
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: smoothie on January 09, 2014, 09:27:41 AM If I had to make a prediction for 2014 it would be that MTGOX would somehow cause some sort of news that would start a panic selling of Bitcoin. Not to imply that Bitcoin is not going up longer-term. But I sense a quiet before the storm surrounding MTGOX. They have been awfully quiet since summer of 2013.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: kwoody on January 12, 2014, 12:21:20 AM MtGox is holding some of my money hostage to the tune of $8,125.78 USD and 29.76 BTC. Been like this since December 9th.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: cozytrade on January 21, 2014, 03:03:25 PM Although it is not a new thing, I noticed my transaction is delayed and considered as double spending without reaching to the destination. "An outpoint is already spent" from blockchain.info I hope after a while I'll get it from difference transaction source as reported. Both fiat and BTC withdrawals have issue, Please correct the current estimation: BTC : 0-3 days EUR : 4-6 weeks (SEPA via Polish bank) JPY : 8days (JNB) - 3 weeks (other Japanese banks) SWIFT Wire transfer is in congestion. USD : 4 month or more (shorter if you pay 5% extra) GBP : 3 month or more (better use SEPA conversion) CAD : 3 month or more (5% extra works as well?) Perhaps price discrepancy from other exchanges indicates their financial risk. I wonder if there are any ways to short MtGox :-\ Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: clubminer on January 21, 2014, 04:34:02 PM mtgox bankruptcy. be very careful with them.
sell to them 148 BTC, not processed from November 2013 ago. :'( Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: pandata on January 25, 2014, 05:25:00 PM Still waiting for BTC withdraw from Mtgox for 4 days now (initiated on 21th Jan). Opened 3 tickets with no response from them.
Anyone with such delay ? Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: btbrae on January 25, 2014, 06:05:43 PM Waiting for 30 BTC withdrawal from Mtgox for 48 hours, they're not responding to my ticket...
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: pinger on January 25, 2014, 06:39:47 PM Waiting for 30 BTC withdrawal from Mtgox for 48 hours, they're not responding to my ticket... Do you have the transaction ID? you can cheek it here: https://blockchain.info Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: cozytrade on January 25, 2014, 06:43:15 PM Waiting for 30 BTC withdrawal from Mtgox for 48 hours, they're not responding to my ticket... Do you have the transaction ID? you can cheek it here: https://blockchain.info Before going to blockchain, better to check https://data.mtgox.com/api/0/bitcoin_tx.php (https://data.mtgox.com/api/0/bitcoin_tx.php) to find your transaction. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: btbrae on January 25, 2014, 07:23:22 PM It hasn't even arrived on the blockchain yet unfortunately....
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: cozytrade on January 25, 2014, 07:37:10 PM It hasn't even arrived on the blockchain yet unfortunately.... Now it is usual don't worry. :) Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Netprofits on January 26, 2014, 07:38:04 PM After nearly 36hrs., my BTC withdraw is still not showing up in the blockchain (BC). As time passed, I was growing increasingly concerned since this was the longest a Gox withdraw has ever taken me. Now I know exactly why.
I used the following site: http://thegoxreport.com/ The process was quick and easy to find my address on the list. I simply searched for the receiving address using: List of output addresses from Bad TX: Address List. Presto. The total amount of BTC affected by this is nearing 11,000 coins! Unfortunately, the only course of action at this point is to wait for this to clear. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Recon on January 26, 2014, 10:14:00 PM Well they golding goldcoins as hostage prity well. Each person i know still not get their bitcoins or sums in usd :D
Soon we will see if another bubble gona colapse at this point :) Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: seriouscoin on January 27, 2014, 07:46:30 AM my withdrawal has been over 4 days!!
They didnt response to my support ticket... how do i contact them ? Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: btbrae on January 27, 2014, 07:51:19 AM my withdrawal has been over 4 days!! They didnt response to my support ticket... how do i contact them ? Don't worry, they didn't respond to mine either. I repeat, Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: seriouscoin on January 27, 2014, 07:59:08 AM my withdrawal has been over 4 days!! They didnt response to my support ticket... how do i contact them ? Don't worry, they didn't respond to mine either. I repeat, Did you receive your btc? How long did it take ? its about 5 days now... Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: opet on January 27, 2014, 08:42:30 AM my withdrawal has been over 4 days!! The best way would be to hang out in #mtgox on IRC (FreeNode), and wait for one of their "support" people to show up. Don't get your hopes up, though, as their support folks aren't very useful.They didnt response to my support ticket... how do i contact them ? I just had my second (and final) Gox withdrawal get stuck a few minutes ago. My first one from Friday took 55 hours to clear, and that one required a manual push by one of their engineers... god only knows how long this second one might take... some people have been waiting for 6+ days now! :( Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: richardweiming on January 27, 2014, 09:43:08 AM my withdrawal has been over 4 days!! The best way would be to hang out in #mtgox on IRC (FreeNode), and wait for one of their "support" people to show up. Don't get your hopes up, though, as their support folks aren't very useful.They didnt response to my support ticket... how do i contact them ? I just had my second (and final) Gox withdrawal get stuck a few minutes ago. My first one from Friday took 55 hours to clear, and that one required a manual push by one of their engineers... god only knows how long this second one might take... some people have been waiting for 6+ days now! :( Where is the IRC? Can you give me a link? I will go complaining MTGOX Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: bahamapascal on January 27, 2014, 03:21:40 PM Just want to report, I have the same problem! Made a withdraw got an tx ID, but the transaction never got reported to the blockchain it seems.
My bitcoins did not appear on the receiver address and the tx ID they gave me dose not exist! Well I wrote them a support ticket, lets see if they can help....but I got a bad feeling about this :( Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: pinger on January 27, 2014, 03:25:06 PM Just want to report, I have the same problem! Made a withdraw got an tx ID, but the transaction never got reported to the blockchain it seems. My bitcoins did not appear on the receiver address and the tx ID they gave me dose not exist! Well I wrote them a support ticket, lets see if they can help....but I got a bad feeling about this :( Reading your problems, I decided to take my bitcoins from the exchange, no problems at all. In a few minutes I have my bitcoins on my hands. Maybe is a double spend problem or something weird. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: bahamapascal on January 27, 2014, 03:49:34 PM Just want to report, I have the same problem! Made a withdraw got an tx ID, but the transaction never got reported to the blockchain it seems. My bitcoins did not appear on the receiver address and the tx ID they gave me dose not exist! Well I wrote them a support ticket, lets see if they can help....but I got a bad feeling about this :( Reading your problems, I decided to take my bitcoins from the exchange, no problems at all. In a few minutes I have my bitcoins on my hands. Maybe is a double spend problem or something weird. I am glad to hear that you got yours! Untill now I had no problem with withdrawing BTC from them, but today I mad an rather large withdraw of 7 BTC and the transaction ID they gave me dose not exist in the network. f9ff755e93e1c7f57eef45fc2f63a4542907fef158f473c2dc33f128346de09c is what they gave me, but its not there on blockchain info :( BTW, I dont belive its an double spend, as a double spend would atleast show up on the blockchain but gets no confirmations. Had that problem once when some one send me some BTC (the other party actually send it from gox and they had the double spend problem) Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Netprofits on January 27, 2014, 04:07:12 PM I suggest when an event like this occurs, people should search similar threads for additional info. There will be few times that you will actually be the first one reporting issues, especially concerning Gox.
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=431117.0 https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=179586.msg4777734;topicseen#msg4777734 Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: pinger on January 27, 2014, 04:21:02 PM Just want to report, I have the same problem! Made a withdraw got an tx ID, but the transaction never got reported to the blockchain it seems. My bitcoins did not appear on the receiver address and the tx ID they gave me dose not exist! Well I wrote them a support ticket, lets see if they can help....but I got a bad feeling about this :( Reading your problems, I decided to take my bitcoins from the exchange, no problems at all. In a few minutes I have my bitcoins on my hands. Maybe is a double spend problem or something weird. I am glad to hear that you got yours! Untill now I had no problem with withdrawing BTC from them, but today I mad an rather large withdraw of 7 BTC and the transaction ID they gave me dose not exist in the network. f9ff755e93e1c7f57eef45fc2f63a4542907fef158f473c2dc33f128346de09c is what they gave me, but its not there on blockchain info :( BTW, I dont belive its an double spend, as a double spend would atleast show up on the blockchain but gets no confirmations. Had that problem once when some one send me some BTC (the other party actually send it from gox and they had the double spend problem) I Will follow your case, so please keep posting in here. I'm confused on what is going on with gox, I see some people with no problems at all, and sometimes, people with so many problems. I only have one, It doesn't allowed me to withdrawn fiat (I have other transfer pending at that time), It toked some time but it finally arrived. I finally decided to take all my BTC from there, I don't trust them now. Lets see if they start improving their service. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: bahamapascal on January 27, 2014, 04:59:48 PM Just want to report, I have the same problem! Made a withdraw got an tx ID, but the transaction never got reported to the blockchain it seems. My bitcoins did not appear on the receiver address and the tx ID they gave me dose not exist! Well I wrote them a support ticket, lets see if they can help....but I got a bad feeling about this :( Reading your problems, I decided to take my bitcoins from the exchange, no problems at all. In a few minutes I have my bitcoins on my hands. Maybe is a double spend problem or something weird. I am glad to hear that you got yours! Untill now I had no problem with withdrawing BTC from them, but today I mad an rather large withdraw of 7 BTC and the transaction ID they gave me dose not exist in the network. f9ff755e93e1c7f57eef45fc2f63a4542907fef158f473c2dc33f128346de09c is what they gave me, but its not there on blockchain info :( BTW, I dont belive its an double spend, as a double spend would atleast show up on the blockchain but gets no confirmations. Had that problem once when some one send me some BTC (the other party actually send it from gox and they had the double spend problem) I Will follow your case, so please keep posting in here. I'm confused on what is going on with gox, I see some people with no problems at all, and sometimes, people with so many problems. I only have one, It doesn't allowed me to withdrawn fiat (I have other transfer pending at that time), It toked some time but it finally arrived. I finally decided to take all my BTC from there, I don't trust them now. Lets see if they start improving their service. Well, the only news is that my transaction is now listed with 0 confirms and is marked as a double spending attack. Which I hope is a good sign, not sure though :P So far haven't heard back from customer support...only thing I can do is wait I guess. Last time I had the situation of a double spend from some one that send me BTC from there mtgox wallet, it took over 24 hours. Edit: The transaction disapeared out of the blockchain, keeping my fingers crossed that I will ever see my BTC...ofcourse I have not heared back from mtgox support. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: rizardus on January 27, 2014, 05:17:15 PM i have same problem :( its now about 2 days and still cant see transaction on blockchain ...
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: ericwang on January 27, 2014, 08:28:40 PM I have the same problem of transferring my bitcoin to my coinbase wallet, the transfer nerver shows in blockchain and there is nothing getting in me wallet for 24 hours now. opened a ticket, sure no answer so far.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: de3mka on January 27, 2014, 08:44:39 PM Same problem, waiting since Sunday morning. Tx still not listed in blockchain.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: cozytrade on January 27, 2014, 09:00:13 PM Same problem, waiting since Sunday morning. Tx still not listed in blockchain. Perhaps your transaction is listed in https://data.mtgox.com/api/0/bitcoin_tx.php (https://data.mtgox.com/api/0/bitcoin_tx.php) Be patient :) Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: jayson3 on January 27, 2014, 09:24:13 PM The problem seems intermittent. I had one BTC withdrawal fail and another succeed. Using skanner.net i found the stuck transaction and it indicated it was rejected by the network as a double spend. I submitted a ticket to Mt Gox and now waiting.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: opet on January 28, 2014, 03:20:43 AM I am glad to hear that you got yours! Untill now I had no problem with withdrawing BTC from them, but today I mad an rather large withdraw of 7 BTC and the transaction ID they gave me dose not exist in the network. I found your transaction on the list of broken TX at Skanner.net (http://skanner.net/MtGox/mtgox_tx.php?searchme=19L35u7Xsifduvck4iuEKhZBYpE9g2EYP6&Submit=Search (http://skanner.net/MtGox/mtgox_tx.php?searchme=19L35u7Xsifduvck4iuEKhZBYpE9g2EYP6&Submit=Search)). It is listed as being broken do to "ouputs already spent," which is the reason most of us are stuck right now. f9ff755e93e1c7f57eef45fc2f63a4542907fef158f473c2dc33f128346de09c is what they gave me, but its not there on blockchain info :( BTW, I dont belive its an double spend, as a double spend would atleast show up on the blockchain but gets no confirmations. Had that problem once when some one send me some BTC (the other party actually send it from gox and they had the double spend problem) Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: bahamapascal on January 28, 2014, 11:51:13 AM I am glad to hear that you got yours! Untill now I had no problem with withdrawing BTC from them, but today I mad an rather large withdraw of 7 BTC and the transaction ID they gave me dose not exist in the network. I found your transaction on the list of broken TX at Skanner.net (http://skanner.net/MtGox/mtgox_tx.php?searchme=19L35u7Xsifduvck4iuEKhZBYpE9g2EYP6&Submit=Search (http://skanner.net/MtGox/mtgox_tx.php?searchme=19L35u7Xsifduvck4iuEKhZBYpE9g2EYP6&Submit=Search)). It is listed as being broken do to "ouputs already spent," which is the reason most of us are stuck right now. f9ff755e93e1c7f57eef45fc2f63a4542907fef158f473c2dc33f128346de09c is what they gave me, but its not there on blockchain info :( BTW, I dont belive its an double spend, as a double spend would atleast show up on the blockchain but gets no confirmations. Had that problem once when some one send me some BTC (the other party actually send it from gox and they had the double spend problem) Thank you! Though I don't know when they are going to process my withdraw, I found reports of people that just got there withdraw from the 7 January :P Well I guess, just wait and hope for the best :( Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: gizmoh on January 28, 2014, 01:51:16 PM Good news BTC withdrawals are being resolved slowly but surely.I just received 100 btc which was pending for over 7 days.
So have some patience, you'l receive yours eventually. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: bahamapascal on January 28, 2014, 02:30:13 PM Good news BTC withdrawals are being resolved slowly but surely.I just received 100 btc which pending over 7 days. So have some patience, you'l receive yours eventually. Oh, thats good news :) Better late then never... Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: richardweiming on January 28, 2014, 03:07:42 PM gox resend around 200 failed transaction 3 hours before.
2 hours late. they come back the result, all failed again.It can be seen in the picture on http://thegoxreport.com/ Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: rikkejohn on January 28, 2014, 04:05:15 PM Good news BTC withdrawals are being resolved slowly but surely.I just received 100 btc which was pending for over 7 days. So have some patience, you'l receive yours eventually. Dude, like I said on the last thread (Broken transactions), 7 days can do a lot to the price of BTC. I want to control my own BTC. I certainly won't be laughing if I receive them in a week and they are valued at $500. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: bitkoinz on January 28, 2014, 04:29:13 PM I withdrew my coins last night from gox thinking it would be an hour or 2, until i started to panic and read this thread. I dont plan on selling them anytime soon so i guess ill have to wait either way :-\
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Netprofits on January 28, 2014, 05:12:30 PM I withdrew my coins last night from gox thinking it would be an hour or 2, until i started to panic and read this thread. I dont plan on selling them anytime soon so i guess ill have to wait either way :-\ https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=431117.40 Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Trits on January 28, 2014, 09:57:42 PM I read on a certain topic that one can 'push' on his own his failed TX (?)
Just wondering, is there anything one can do about a failed transaction or is the problem 100% from MtGox's servers side and the only remaining thing to do is...wait? Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: barbs on January 28, 2014, 10:06:51 PM I put a withdrawal for 6.25 BTC 6 hours ago nothing on the block chain or anywhere. :(
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: opet on January 29, 2014, 01:33:00 AM I put a withdrawal for 6.25 BTC 6 hours ago nothing on the block chain or anywhere. :( The number of broken BTC withdrawal TX just hit 1700.this is very very bad, folks.... :( Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: barbs on January 29, 2014, 08:06:12 AM I'm at 14 hours now and my 6.25 btc is nowhere to be found
After paying 200$ above market Goxxed Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: czzarr on January 29, 2014, 10:38:43 AM I just received 1btc that was previously stuck in a bad TX a few hours ago. Still 38btc stuck though.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: dfraser on January 29, 2014, 12:29:48 PM Geez... I wished I'd read this thread before I even did anything with my Mt Gox account. Maybe I'll get my little itsy bit of BTC, but probably not until hell freezes over.
Bitstamp on the other hand has been superb - no issues. As I'm in IT, I can't see any reason for things especially with Bitcoin, to be nothing but extremely automated. Trouble with fiat, I can understand, given the real world hassles and regulations, but BTC is all automated. Apparently you put anything into Mt Gox, and it becomes a no interest loan to them. I think they've been running a long con and now are wrapping up operations Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: oOoOo on January 29, 2014, 12:42:57 PM Just did a 5 btc withdrawal and it went through immediately. Another 10 btc, withdrawn on sunday, still nothing...
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: rograz on January 29, 2014, 02:25:23 PM I read on a certain topic that one can 'push' on his own his failed TX (?) Usually there is a good reason that the transaction got stuck, can't push a broken TX when it contains invalid double spends. Gox has had this problem for months, it's not until BTC prices started to drop after the latest price hike that it started to become a major problem. People who want to sell and cant get money out of gox has to transfer away and that I suspect has caused a huge surge in the amount of transactions out of gox. Withdraws are not completely broken it's just that the larger the transaction the more likely it is to contain double spends. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: barbs on January 29, 2014, 02:34:56 PM 24 hours now since my withdrawal
No BTC, (6.23), no answer on my support ticket, nothing whatsoever just straight robbery if my 4k euros /Btc. If I get out of this alive or not MTGox has totally lost my business for good this is unbelievable after paying 200$ above the rest of the market price on top of it now I can't sell on bitstamp and could take another big hit if the price drops more. Ffs Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: ldr77 on January 29, 2014, 02:50:15 PM Waiting as well, 72 hours.
My lesson learned: always check bitcointalk threads 1st ::) Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: seriouscoin on January 29, 2014, 02:50:46 PM approaching 7 days now, still havent received my btc
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: WesandEAC on January 30, 2014, 01:51:31 AM Hey fellas, I've used Gox for a while and still like them BUTTT of course they have some reliability issues! Hahaha, in saying that I withdrew 10 BTC today and ended up on the bad tx list 1400 and something hahaa.
They just rebroadcast that stuff later do they not? I do not want to bother with support tickets if there are 1500+ people in the same boat. I am sure they will get to it? Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: allbits on January 30, 2014, 03:37:48 AM 7.5 BTC - instant withdrawal
I feel lucky after reading about all you guys. Still got some fiat stuck in there. Not sure what I'll be doing with that. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: corsaro on January 30, 2014, 10:00:29 AM 7.5 BTC - instant withdrawal I feel lucky after reading about all you guys. Still got some fiat stuck in there. Not sure what I'll be doing with that. I suggest bitstamp.net It is very fast and reliable in sending and receiving btc and usd too via sepa bank transfer (2 days) Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: wojgp on January 30, 2014, 03:09:39 PM Hi
I have the same problem with mtgox :( 2014/01/30 00:21:33 Withdraw 1.98860000 BTC 0.00109446 BTC Bitcoin withdraw to 19m1x783fd2igAWXYeW7tCGVEv5jTxxxxx (full address hidden) No money since yesterday. Also no response from support :( Also there are 3 bank withdrawals never received since 16/11/2013, 18/11/2013 and from Jan 2014 - total about 5000 USD :( Do You have any idea how to deal with them ? Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: guugll on January 30, 2014, 04:06:37 PM my account has been robbed today and the BTC withdrawal in his case was quite fast:
2014/01/30 01:51:58 Fee 0.00100000 BTC 0.00078942 BTC Fees for Bitcoin withdraw to 1Q1Wo95FcXvrhDB5ieDMk52qDs2yNfpySN 2014/01/30 01:51:58 Withdraw 0.00800000 BTC 0.00178942 BTC Bitcoin withdraw to 1Q1Wo95FcXvrhDB5ieDMk52qDs2yNfpySN 2014/01/30 01:46:33 Fee 0.00100000 BTC 0.00978942 BTC Fees for Bitcoin withdraw to 1Q1Wo95FcXvrhDB5ieDMk52qDs2yNfpySN 2014/01/30 01:46:33 Withdraw 2.46000000 BTC 0.01078942 BTC Bitcoin withdraw to 1Q1Wo95FcXvrhDB5ieDMk52qDs2yNfpySN 2014/01/30 01:45:14 Fee 0.00891422 BTC 2.47078942 BTC BTC bought: [tid:1391042714891320] 1.48570364 BTC at $933.49998 (0.6% fee) 2014/01/30 01:45:14 In 1.48570364 BTC 2.47970364 BTC BTC bought: [tid:1391042714891320] 1.48570364 BTC at $933.49998 2014/01/30 01:45:14 Fee 0.00600000 BTC 0.99400000 BTC BTC bought: [tid:1391042714725595] 1.00000000 BTC at $933.49997 (0.6% fee) 2014/01/30 01:45:14 In 1.00000000 BTC 1.00000000 BTC BTC bought: [tid:1391042714725595] 1.00000000 BTC at $933.49997 and all is gone. i was waiting for $ withdrawal approval - today it was the first day i could withdraw $ but no $ anymore... how could somebody know that i will get my $ today out? i have bad feeling about mtgox employees. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Hawkix on January 30, 2014, 04:17:53 PM File a security report to support.mtgox.com.
Have you got 2FA enabled? Check your e-mail box security. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: guugll on January 30, 2014, 04:33:53 PM security report done
email security checked - pass changed to hyperParanoid what is 2FA - you mean the second level of authentication like yubi or how does it call - no i do not have it i waited 2 month to get approved and i just wanted to send my selv the $ on my account - today is the first day i can...i mean could Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Hawkix on January 30, 2014, 04:53:30 PM The attacker got access to your account. So (s)he either stole your MtGox password, or s(he) used password reset feature to change the password and stole the new password from your e-mail inbox.
Have you received a notification from MtGox about BTC withdrawals? There should be an IP listed. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: jayson3 on January 30, 2014, 07:51:25 PM The failed BTC withdrawals seem random. I have had 2 out of 8 that are stuck over the last 4 days. All are less than 1 BTC each.
Doe anyone have any idea how Gox fixes these (if they ever do)? Do they cancel the transaction and restore your BTC? or do the create a new transaction and resend your BTC? Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: guugll on January 30, 2014, 08:41:43 PM The attacker got access to your account. So (s)he either stole your MtGox password, or s(he) used password reset feature to change the password and stole the new password from your e-mail inbox. Have you received a notification from MtGox about BTC withdrawals? There should be an IP listed. U R right i found they got into my email and then into mtgox. i found so far this: 11:58 AM Signed in from Chrome (Windows) Prague, Czech Republic 11:58 AM Changed password Prague, Czech Republic 2:12 AM Changed password Lubbock, TX, USA 2:12 AM Removed recovery email: king2@email.cz Lubbock, TX, USA 2:11 AM Signed in from Firefox (Windows) Lubbock, TX, USA 1:36 AM Passed a sign-in challenge Lubbock, TX, USA Jan 27 Signed in from Chrome (Windows) do not know how the attacker got my password yet Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: pinger on January 30, 2014, 08:46:50 PM The attacker got access to your account. So (s)he either stole your MtGox password, or s(he) used password reset feature to change the password and stole the new password from your e-mail inbox. Have you received a notification from MtGox about BTC withdrawals? There should be an IP listed. U R right i found they got into my email and then into mtgox. i found so far this: 11:58 AM Signed in from Chrome (Windows) Prague, Czech Republic 11:58 AM Changed password Prague, Czech Republic 2:12 AM Changed password Lubbock, TX, USA 2:12 AM Removed recovery email: king2@email.cz Lubbock, TX, USA 2:11 AM Signed in from Firefox (Windows) Lubbock, TX, USA 1:36 AM Passed a sign-in challenge Lubbock, TX, USA Jan 27 Signed in from Chrome (Windows) do not know how the attacker got my password yet Check your computer for viruses/trojans. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: guugll on January 30, 2014, 08:50:27 PM the IP of the bastard from Lubbock, TX, USA is 67.221.255.66 at least that states in my gmail account
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: TheMuppet on January 30, 2014, 11:58:16 PM I did 4 transfers and only received 3.
What's even weirder is I CAN'T login anymore. I took out all my funds and coins from the account. I sent a "password reset" -- nothing came. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: princes12 on January 31, 2014, 04:55:53 AM my account has been robbed today and the BTC withdrawal in his case was quite fast: 2014/01/30 01:51:58 Fee 0.00100000 BTC 0.00078942 BTC Fees for Bitcoin withdraw to 1Q1Wo95FcXvrhDB5ieDMk52qDs2yNfpySN 2014/01/30 01:51:58 Withdraw 0.00800000 BTC 0.00178942 BTC Bitcoin withdraw to 1Q1Wo95FcXvrhDB5ieDMk52qDs2yNfpySN 2014/01/30 01:46:33 Fee 0.00100000 BTC 0.00978942 BTC Fees for Bitcoin withdraw to 1Q1Wo95FcXvrhDB5ieDMk52qDs2yNfpySN 2014/01/30 01:46:33 Withdraw 2.46000000 BTC 0.01078942 BTC Bitcoin withdraw to 1Q1Wo95FcXvrhDB5ieDMk52qDs2yNfpySN 2014/01/30 01:45:14 Fee 0.00891422 BTC 2.47078942 BTC BTC bought: [tid:1391042714891320] 1.48570364 BTC at $933.49998 (0.6% fee) 2014/01/30 01:45:14 In 1.48570364 BTC 2.47970364 BTC BTC bought: [tid:1391042714891320] 1.48570364 BTC at $933.49998 2014/01/30 01:45:14 Fee 0.00600000 BTC 0.99400000 BTC BTC bought: [tid:1391042714725595] 1.00000000 BTC at $933.49997 (0.6% fee) 2014/01/30 01:45:14 In 1.00000000 BTC 1.00000000 BTC BTC bought: [tid:1391042714725595] 1.00000000 BTC at $933.49997 and all is gone. i was waiting for $ withdrawal approval - today it was the first day i could withdraw $ but no $ anymore... how could somebody know that i will get my $ today out? i have bad feeling about mtgox employees. It’s very suspicious and seems like inside job. Look for users without 2FA and empty the wallets quickly with small withdrawals and without any delay. Nowhere to turn and nobody to blame. I wonder how many users are not reporting this kind of incidents? Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: sameev29 on January 31, 2014, 08:15:55 AM Can Japanese people withdraw money to their bank accounts at shortest time?
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Hawkix on January 31, 2014, 08:44:04 AM New MtGox statement about BTC withdrawals - https://mtgox.zendesk.com/entries/26501000-Statement-Regarding-BTC-Withdrawal-Delays
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: smoothie on January 31, 2014, 09:04:29 AM New MtGox statement about BTC withdrawals - https://mtgox.zendesk.com/entries/26501000-Statement-Regarding-BTC-Withdrawal-Delays As usual it sounds like they have no answers. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: mrsister on January 31, 2014, 10:36:49 AM New MtGox statement about BTC withdrawals - https://mtgox.zendesk.com/entries/26501000-Statement-Regarding-BTC-Withdrawal-Delays thank you! i'm experiencing this one right now. waiting for ~20h now... :-( it's the last time i used gox. for me, this chapter ends with this performance... Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: wez004 on January 31, 2014, 10:58:48 AM New MtGox statement about BTC withdrawals - https://mtgox.zendesk.com/entries/26501000-Statement-Regarding-BTC-Withdrawal-Delays thank you! i'm experiencing this one right now. waiting for ~20h now... :-( it's the last time i used gox. for me, this chapter ends with this performance... Yeah I'm finished with Gox to. As soon as I get my coin back I'm smashing my gox yubi key none of my bitcoin will ever be day traded on that site again. Mtgox is a complete shambles and the bitcoin foundation should do the decent thing and remove them as a recommended exchange and issue warnings against depositing money or coins with them. They bring nothing positive to bitcoin. Imagine somebody new to bitcoin who attempts to withdraw fiat or btc and weeks later no cash or coin, no replies to support tickets and no way to address the situation. It's a complete disaster and their style of operation can only lead to one thing and that's failure of their business. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: guugll on January 31, 2014, 11:08:39 AM my account has been robbed today and the BTC withdrawal in his case was quite fast: 2014/01/30 01:51:58 Fee 0.00100000 BTC 0.00078942 BTC Fees for Bitcoin withdraw to 1Q1Wo95FcXvrhDB5ieDMk52qDs2yNfpySN 2014/01/30 01:51:58 Withdraw 0.00800000 BTC 0.00178942 BTC Bitcoin withdraw to 1Q1Wo95FcXvrhDB5ieDMk52qDs2yNfpySN 2014/01/30 01:46:33 Fee 0.00100000 BTC 0.00978942 BTC Fees for Bitcoin withdraw to 1Q1Wo95FcXvrhDB5ieDMk52qDs2yNfpySN 2014/01/30 01:46:33 Withdraw 2.46000000 BTC 0.01078942 BTC Bitcoin withdraw to 1Q1Wo95FcXvrhDB5ieDMk52qDs2yNfpySN 2014/01/30 01:45:14 Fee 0.00891422 BTC 2.47078942 BTC BTC bought: [tid:1391042714891320] 1.48570364 BTC at $933.49998 (0.6% fee) 2014/01/30 01:45:14 In 1.48570364 BTC 2.47970364 BTC BTC bought: [tid:1391042714891320] 1.48570364 BTC at $933.49998 2014/01/30 01:45:14 Fee 0.00600000 BTC 0.99400000 BTC BTC bought: [tid:1391042714725595] 1.00000000 BTC at $933.49997 (0.6% fee) 2014/01/30 01:45:14 In 1.00000000 BTC 1.00000000 BTC BTC bought: [tid:1391042714725595] 1.00000000 BTC at $933.49997 and all is gone. i was waiting for $ withdrawal approval - today it was the first day i could withdraw $ but no $ anymore... how could somebody know that i will get my $ today out? i have bad feeling about mtgox employees. It’s very suspicious and seems like inside job. Look for users without 2FA and empty the wallets quickly with small withdrawals and without any delay. Nowhere to turn and nobody to blame. I wonder how many users are not reporting this kind of incidents? yes exactly my first idea - attacker withdraw BTC after 1 hour and 45 min my $ withdrawal was enabled - i logged just a few hours after the attacker Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: 7u83 on January 31, 2014, 07:45:46 PM I withdrew last Saturday one bitcoin and received it today.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: infoman on January 31, 2014, 08:29:08 PM hi all,
I had the same, withdraw 4 days ago and got it yestersday also withdraw yesterday and got it this morning but still have 4 transactions to go through, all started a day ago. there is hope just needs some patience Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: rikkejohn on January 31, 2014, 09:55:29 PM hi all, I had the same, withdraw 4 days ago and got it yestersday also withdraw yesterday and got it this morning but still have 4 transactions to go through, all started a day ago. there is hope just needs some patience Oh, but your scientific model is a bit .. erm .. just your own personal experience. I've been waiting 5 days now and nothing has appeared. There are people out there waiting longer, and Gox won't talk to many of us. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Beans on January 31, 2014, 10:45:54 PM I withdrew last Saturday one bitcoin and received it today. I've been waiting since Sunday, so hopefully your time frame is the same as mine.Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Bitnicity on February 01, 2014, 12:59:31 AM I had no problem withdrawal today, instant broadcast to the network; but my withdrawal the day before yesterday was still stuck in the broken TX list; try to break your large withdrawals into small installments.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Bitnicity on February 01, 2014, 06:44:03 AM I had no problem withdrawal today, instant broadcast to the network; but my withdrawal the day before yesterday was still stuck in the broken TX list; try to break your large withdrawals into small installments. Hi and welcome! So you decided to register here at bitcointalk just to share how instant you managed to withdraw from emptygox with your first post. Wow. Congratulations on doing that! I'd also like to congratulate the 10 other new nicks that have magically appeared to write their first posts in the various emptygox threads here at this forum the last week. This surely isn't odd and suspect at all. cut the sh*t, why don't you try yourself instead of speculating? i made two withdrawals today and they worked and I still have one stuck and hasn't shown in the block-chain, so i am also the victim. The purpose for the post is the report the status quo and provide real update and not to discredit any one and misrepresent the facts. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: sl317 on February 01, 2014, 07:35:39 AM Hello Mtgox
I have never encountered with delays transactions. My 100 BTC so far lost. I hope that this message will reach you earlier week. I promise to spread this message everywhere including on the Russian forums. Thanks The sl317 user. http://img-fotki.yandex.ru/get/9808/23942984.0/0_7a2b4_c90daff_XL.jpg Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: princes12 on February 01, 2014, 07:52:49 AM Hello Mtgox I have never encountered with delays transactions. My 100 BTC so far lost. I hope that this message will reach you weeks earlier. I promise to spread this message everywhere including on the Russian forums. Thanks The sl317 user. http://img-fotki.yandex.ru/get/9808/23942984.0/0_7a2b4_c90daff_XL.jpg Try to be positive and check your MtGox transaction ID from "http://skanner.net/MtGox/mtgox_tx.php". I'm also waiting my BTC withdrawal for more than 6 days. Hopefully it will arrive soon? Your transaction is in bad TX list. http://thegoxreport.com/output_addr_list.txt Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: OhShei8e on February 01, 2014, 10:38:06 AM After nearly 36hrs., my BTC withdraw is still not showing up in the blockchain (BC). As time passed, I was growing increasingly concerned since this was the longest a Gox withdraw has ever taken me. Now I know exactly why. I used the following site: http://thegoxreport.com/ See: https://data.mtgox.com/api/0/bitcoin_tx.php Was established by Gox many moons ago. Just as a hint. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: seriouscoin on February 02, 2014, 12:41:27 AM Mine is still not sent! It has been 10 days!!!!
>:( Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: btcinsight on February 02, 2014, 02:06:42 AM I withdrew 35 btc with 3x10 BTC, 1x3 BTC, 2x1 BTC tx a week ago. None of them actually shown up in the block chain.
All transactions seem to fail because of double spent outputs. Even transactions listed for other problems also contain double spent outputs, apart from the problem listed. MtGox keeps saying it's due to a technical problem, but even in this case, they have had plenty of time to manually send transactions now. Something could very well explain the situation: at least their hot wallet is empty, and their system keeps issuing transactions with already spent outputs, because there is actually no unspent outputs available. It seems very fishy to me, and I think all those who have significant amounts stuck in withdrawals should put pressure on Mtgox so they at least provide a proof they still own the funds. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: cryptog1 on February 02, 2014, 06:53:51 AM Although it is not a new thing, I noticed my transaction is delayed and considered as double spending without reaching to the destination. "An outpoint is already spent" from blockchain.info I hope after a while I'll get it from difference transaction source as reported. Both fiat and BTC withdrawals have issue, Please correct the current estimation: BTC : 0-3 days EUR : 4-6 weeks (SEPA via Polish bank) JPY : 8days (JNB) - 3 weeks (other Japanese banks) SWIFT Wire transfer is in congestion. USD : 4 month or more (shorter if you pay 5% extra) GBP : 3 month or more (better use SEPA conversion) CAD : 3 month or more (5% extra works as well?) Perhaps price discrepancy from other exchanges indicates their financial risk. I wonder if there are any ways to short MtGox :-\ Your estimates for JPY withdrawal seem to match my experience right now. I m not using JNB and it has been 12days since my first withdrawal request with no money actually transferred yet. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: cozytrade on February 02, 2014, 08:13:32 AM Now revised a bit Please correct the current estimation: BTC : 0-5 days (up to 10 days- unconfirmed) EUR : 4-6 weeks (SEPA via Polish bank) JPY : 8days (JNB) - 25 Calendar days (other Japanese banks) SWIFT Wire transfer is in congestion. USD : 4 month or more (shorter if you pay 5% extra) up to 7 months GBP : 3 month or more (better use SEPA conversion) CAD : 3 month or more (5% extra works as well?) For BTC withdrawal, better to wait for a week before pushing them, which would make the congestion worse. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: czzarr on February 02, 2014, 11:06:01 PM I've been receiving a few of the withdrawals I made last week over the last few days. Still about 3/4 of my withdrawals are stuck. I'm hopeful though.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: cryptog1 on February 03, 2014, 04:24:18 AM update: see https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=179586.msg4905508#msg4905508
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: skyrunner on February 03, 2014, 04:28:45 AM update: see https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=179586.msg4905508#msg4905508 you have delays, oh no! let me tell devs right away. For fuck's sake people customers have delays what are you thinking?? forgot to press Send button? damn it press it right away. Sir, Send button was pressed many times, you should see your bitcoins soon, have faith Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: bennybong on February 03, 2014, 04:29:52 PM I finally decided to pull all my funds out of gox. Have been waiting 3 days now for 17.1 btc to hit my wallet. Come on gox!!!
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: fabsen on February 04, 2014, 06:28:13 PM Hey,
i did a withdrawal for over 600€ on 02.Jan.2014. Still not arrived. Support "team" answered 2 times to be patient. http://s7.directupload.net/images/140204/temp/9g6uslzn.jpg (http://www.directupload.net/file/d/3523/9g6uslzn_jpg.htm) Makes me sad :-/ I sent the details to a lawyer, just in case... Cheers. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Mythul on February 04, 2014, 06:30:07 PM I really hope you guys can get out of Gox asap.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: cozytrade on February 04, 2014, 09:27:46 PM i did a withdrawal for over 600€ on 02.Jan.2014. Still not arrived. Support "team" answered 2 times to be patient. Sorry to hear that. You'd better post fiat withdrawal issue to another thread like https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=179586.0 (https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=179586.0) Actually this is a thread for bitcoin withdrawals. Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: allbits on February 05, 2014, 12:39:20 AM I tried to withdraw 10 btc in 10 separate withdrawals of 1 btc each
3 were immediately successful 7 are stuck ... Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: igorr on February 05, 2014, 11:15:02 PM Bitcoin and MtGox the largest frauds in recent history.
MtGox has lost credibility, or at least exchange office does not follow the price at MtGox, because in November and December of 2013 years, the price MtGox exchange office was allowed to rise without real money. (at push-button up) (great deception) Now as we can see, MtGox is in big trouble about withdraw money, It is so logical and clear Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: vleroybrown on February 06, 2014, 12:20:19 AM This continuing delay for what is most likely a majority of users based on success rates of those who have withdrawn funds in multiple smaller amounts, can in my limited technical understanding only indicates on thing, MtGox is insolvent. Every technical analysis I have read is extrapolated from past fiascos that hurt bitcoin values short to medium term. So with that all being the case again now, how much fallout in value and time will the offical statements or information getting out equal. Also what approach is the best one under the circumstances, the track they are on of silence or an offical reveal and a plan B scenario usful to the position of the sites users.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Bitnicity on February 06, 2014, 12:39:10 AM the latest email from Gox, they do mention they are not practicing "fractional banking" : ) and no definite date issue can be resolved :
------------------------------ Dear Valued Customer, We apologize for the delay in reply. We merged the tickets for a better follow up. We can see that your withdrawal is yet to be processed. The transactions are being re-issued automatically.All BTC are safe ,the transaction will be processed and they are not lost or stolen.We are working to resolve the issue, but at this point we are unable to give a definite date of resolution.Please be advised that BTC on MtGox are not fractional. We apologize for the inconvenience this may have caused and Thank you for your patience. Best regards, MtGox Team https://www.mtgox.com ------------------------------------ Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: ericwang on February 07, 2014, 03:50:05 PM After about 10 days, my bitcoins are back to my MtGox account, happy to have them again, like finding lost treasure.
Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: bennybong on February 07, 2014, 03:54:04 PM After about 10 days, my bitcoins are back to my MtGox account, happy to have them again, like finding lost treasure. Got mine back today. But they're still not actually 'ours', they're stuck in Gox again. I kind of need those BTC! Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: igorr on February 07, 2014, 03:57:50 PM MtGox is dead!
https://www.mtgox.com/press_release_20140207.html Title: Re: MtGox bitcoin withdrawal delay >:( Post by: Aambro on February 26, 2014, 10:58:42 PM After about 10 days, my bitcoins are back to my MtGox account, happy to have them again, like finding lost treasure. Oh, the irony. |
