ICO analysis demands

[Febo]

We need founders to deliver products(or at least MVP),and not only marketing

I agree but how it can be measured?
I've already mentioned a github activity monitoring. What else can be used to monitor product development activities?

ICOs are for so different projects that you cant compare them. IT is like comparing apples and pears.


Usually developers present timeline. You can at least measure how realistic they were.   But again projects many times totally turn sideways.   Lets look at Spells of Genesis. They basically finished half year ago all that they promised in ICO , but in year and a half of development there come new ideas how game should look like. And they develop those.

[AndyVarns]

There are some problem related ICO are like the founders say that they will build the structure of the company after the acquisition of financing.

IMHO this is the main problem
as usual there is no any financial plan or structure…
but

I think must there are rules for developers of ICO.

The main problem is that ICOs are unregulated and most data can be easily manipulated.

I hope that market can correct this situation, if we will invest into logical ICO
How do you think, if we will have any standard form (not state legislation), for example ICO dashboard, which will consist of different fields and if any field is not filled, then @thepo1m should include his skepticism

[densuj]

There are some problem related ICO are like the founders say that they will build the structure of the company after the acquisition of financing.

IMHO this is the main problem
as usual there is no any financial plan or structure…
but

I think must there are rules for developers of ICO.

The main problem is that ICOs are unregulated and most data can be easily manipulated.

I hope that market can correct this situation, if we will invest into logical ICO
How do you think, if we will have any standard form (not state legislation), for example ICO dashboard, which will consist of different fields and if any field is not filled, then @thepo1m should include his skepticism

Yes at least the markets have the data about developers of ICO, amount of ICO
or if be needed they can control the ICO on markets,
so wayl make better for Investment in ICO and it is not like new scam way.

[AndyVarns]

1.Total coins
2.Emission curve
3.Point of difference

Could you elaborate on what you meant?

[lashkatya]

We need founders to deliver products(or at least MVP),and not only marketing

I agree but how it can be measured?
I've already mentioned a github activity monitoring. What else can be used to monitor product development activities?

ICOs are for so different projects that you cant compare them. IT is like comparing apples and pears.


Usually developers present timeline. You can at least measure how realistic they were.   But again projects many times totally turn sideways.   Lets look at Spells of Genesis. They basically finished half year ago all that they promised in ICO , but in year and a half of development there come new ideas how game should look like. And they develop those.

I dont think u can automate timeline comparing, Its very subjective

[Febo]

We need founders to deliver products(or at least MVP),and not only marketing

I agree but how it can be measured?
I've already mentioned a github activity monitoring. What else can be used to monitor product development activities?

ICOs are for so different projects that you cant compare them. IT is like comparing apples and pears.


Usually developers present timeline. You can at least measure how realistic they were.   But again projects many times totally turn sideways.   Lets look at Spells of Genesis. They basically finished half year ago all that they promised in ICO , but in year and a half of development there come new ideas how game should look like. And they develop those.

I dont think u can automate timeline comparing, Its very subjective

You can. Some deliver on time other dont. It is easy. Well there is also third category. those that dont deliver on time and even fail to provide new timeline till that date.  ICONOMI investment found platform should be out at end of December, now is February and I still ( well i dont monitor that closely) dont know when will be out.

This is one thing that can be easily measured. But if it is really relevant I have no ideas. I guess they will measure some more relevant things and some less relevant. sometimes those small things makes a change.

[sonic212]

All that ICO bullshit will collapse soon, We need founders to deliver products(or at least MVP),and not only marketing,like chronobank does

hahah chronobank,i dont even understand the concept and they have no product

You think the same as me, I juka do not understand the concept that they use for the ico. so I think it's just a waste of time to see it and understand it.

[johhnyUA]

As i understand, it's some kind of ICO tracker. Sorry, but here too much project like that. As an example here this project - http://icotracker.net . Why do we need another service such like that? Maybe it will be better to develop services which already exists?)

[MarMoCoin]

1.Total coins
2.Emission curve
3.Point of difference

Could you elaborate on what you meant?

1. He means: How many coins exist and will exist ever
2. He means: How quickly are new coins created
3. He means: <- Curious for elaboration on this too

[zidorov]

What is the purpose of this? What are you trying to achieve/hoping to accomplish?

We want to streamline an ICO/post-ICO analysis for an investor: gathering of data for some metrics can be automated and for others a collaboration place could be made.
E.g. someone with a good skills in code quality assessment could share his/her estimation with someone else who is good with business model proving etc. Each could earn points/coins if his/her work is appreciated by other investors.

[Nevsky]

Here are some criteria to which I pay attention:

1) the well-known in their circles of the development team, a SEO, who does not hide his face;
2) the approval authority figures in the crypto world;
3) a clear roadmap and whitepaper;
4) ratings known publications;
5) the importance of the idea and the project as a whole;
6) capitalization, the total number of coins and issuance.

[artdor]

Here are some criteria to which I pay attention:

1) the well-known in their circles of the development team, a SEO, who does not hide his face;
2) the approval authority figures in the crypto world;
3) a clear roadmap and whitepaper;
4) ratings known publications;
5) the importance of the idea and the project as a whole;
6) capitalization, the total number of coins and issuance.

And tell me where you usually know all this information? In addition to this there is a forum where you read it all? I would be grateful for links to relevant resources.

[numismatist]

This is a nice idea but I don't really understand what you bring to the table that is different from what those ICO youtube channels do. I'm also sceptical of this because all the three post so far are all newbie accounts

zidorov, van0k and Sova could be from same family, that's okay.

Bullets 1. and 1) and 2) hit the point. An expert, to speak of myself, just takes a look at the so far produced code base.
A scammer always bundles all of his activities on propelling his scamm, not on writing program code. Even if they would be capable of writing code they tend to avoid that like the plague, thrieving to scamm instead.
How much of the idea made it into code versus how much is staying all smoke and mirrors on a "wipe" paper which is suitable only for your behind side once or twice a day makes the difference.

[lashkatya]

This is a nice idea but I don't really understand what you bring to the table that is different from what those ICO youtube channels do. I'm also sceptical of this because all the three post so far are all newbie accounts

zidorov, van0k and Sova could be from same family, that's okay.

Bullets 1. and 1) and 2) hit the point. An expert, to speak of myself, just takes a look at the so far produced code base.
A scammer always bundles all of his activities on propelling his scamm, not on writing program code. Even if they would be capable of writing code they tend to avoid that like the plague, thrieving to scamm instead.
How much of the idea made it into code versus how much is staying all smoke and mirrors on a "wipe" paper which is suitable only for your behind side once or twice a day makes the difference.

so you talking about github activity?

[Nevsky]

Here are some criteria to which I pay attention:

1) the well-known in their circles of the development team, a SEO, who does not hide his face;
2) the approval authority figures in the crypto world;
3) a clear roadmap and whitepaper;
4) ratings known publications;
5) the importance of the idea and the project as a whole;
6) capitalization, the total number of coins and issuance.

And tell me where you usually know all this information? In addition to this there is a forum where you read it all? I would be grateful for links to relevant resources.

I use Google and all that I find in the search engine. Another look that wrote such sites as Steem, Forklog, Bitcointalk and others. Write to me in PM, give references.

[artdor]

Here are some criteria to which I pay attention:

1) the well-known in their circles of the development team, a SEO, who does not hide his face;
2) the approval authority figures in the crypto world;
3) a clear roadmap and whitepaper;
4) ratings known publications;
5) the importance of the idea and the project as a whole;
6) capitalization, the total number of coins and issuance.

And tell me where you usually know all this information? In addition to this there is a forum where you read it all? I would be grateful for links to relevant resources.

I use Google and all that I find in the search engine. Another look that wrote such sites as Steem, Forklog, Bitcointalk and others. Write to me in PM, give references.

Nevsky, thanks for the links to interesting sites and information about the search. Now, I hope that I will invest only in good ICO company will always have a good profit.

[AndyVarns]

Here are some criteria to which I pay attention:

1) the well-known in their circles of the development team, a SEO, who does not hide his face;
2) the approval authority figures in the crypto world;
3) a clear roadmap and whitepaper;
4) ratings known publications;
5) the importance of the idea and the project as a whole;
6) capitalization, the total number of coins and issuance.

And tell me where you usually know all this information? In addition to this there is a forum where you read it all? I would be grateful for links to relevant resources.

I use Google and all that I find in the search engine. Another look that wrote such sites as Steem, Forklog, Bitcointalk and others. Write to me in PM, give references.

Nevsky, thanks for the links to interesting sites and information about the search. Now, I hope that I will invest only in good ICO company will always have a good profit.

what a cool talk

[Nevsky]

Here are some criteria to which I pay attention:

1) the well-known in their circles of the development team, a SEO, who does not hide his face;
2) the approval authority figures in the crypto world;
3) a clear roadmap and whitepaper;
4) ratings known publications;
5) the importance of the idea and the project as a whole;
6) capitalization, the total number of coins and issuance.

And tell me where you usually know all this information? In addition to this there is a forum where you read it all? I would be grateful for links to relevant resources.

I use Google and all that I find in the search engine. Another look that wrote such sites as Steem, Forklog, Bitcointalk and others. Write to me in PM, give references.

Nevsky, thanks for the links to interesting sites and information about the search. Now, I hope that I will invest only in good ICO company will always have a good profit.

Do not thank me. Learn to make money and not to lose. In the crypto earns one who understands well that makes .. Of course, greed should be turned off.

[AndyVarns]

1.Total coins
2.Emission curve
3.Point of difference

Could you elaborate on what you meant?

1. He means: How many coins exist and will exist ever
2. He means: How quickly are new coins created
3. He means: <- Curious for elaboration on this too

seriously @MarMoCoin what do you mean by "Point of difference"?
?the difference between what and what?

[MarMoCoin]

1.Total coins
2.Emission curve
3.Point of difference

Could you elaborate on what you meant?

1. He means: How many coins exist and will exist ever
2. He means: How quickly are new coins created
3. He means: <- Curious for elaboration on this too

seriously @MarMoCoin what do you mean by "Point of difference"?
?the difference between what and what?

I didn't type "Point of Difference", I asked for elaboration about what that meant from adhitthana.

Here's the original (which is at the top of the last page and also within my quote):

1.Total coins
2.Emission curve
3.Point of difference