This is the stupidest idea. First of all nobody will donate to a scam victim - period. Unless you are well established and the amounts are somewhat small then you have a tiny chance. Having this donation section will mean that people won't use escrow etc but instead just trade whenever they like with whatever because they think they're covered by the community.
Also, have you thought about the possibility of scammers faking trades with themselves and claiming that they got scammed and ask for donations? The scam accusation subforum is for reporting scams, not for people to beg for money out of the scams.
Its not stupidest, its rewarding for reporting scammers, there is no regulation on this market so its like the wild west here, no rules, dishonest people, the community need to organise itself because of that, even in the wild west was more organised, bring the outlaw dead or alive and be rewarded, more reports will come
Second: Even with escrow, not everyone in the community uses it
Third: scammers faming trades can easily be fixed with the following rules,
Rules:
1: No refund for recently created accounts or newbies, even if its has a high number of trust
2: The community should democraticly vote the percentage to be refunded of the victim
3: The community should also vote whether the scam victim should be refunded
4: The only members allowed to vote are the ones that are sr. member, hero member and legendary
5:Theses members allowed to vote need to have a certain number of +trust
6:Anyone can donate, from newbie to legendary
There should be a new subforum just for this community refund(crowddonation refund), it sounds better and correctly
Wanna a proof that this "stupidest ideia" could work? Yes?
Then go create a cryptocurrency whose objective is to refund partially or completely scam victims, I can feel in my gut it would be a huge success, in fact it would be more of a insurance cryptocurrency, you send the evidence to site, devs look at it and donate some of this insurance currency to you, the more legit the scam the more close to refund 100% of the loss, hell maybe even dogecoin could be this insurance cryptocurrency, it gots billions and the community is united