I think the second link is better than the first one, however still largely incomplete, almost useless. We could need a site which is collecting and comparing ALL of the ICOs, not just a handful.
Yes, ICO Stats is nice, but still, that would be awesome to have something much more comprehensive. However, a lot of effort is needed to keep everything on the radar screens especially now when there are so many token sales out there and their number is nothing but growing at a lightning speed.
We are likely to need to launch another ICO to develop a project for monitoring all ICOs' performance!