X16R - RVN - Miner head to head test log

[abanamat]

New free opensource x16r miner without a fee

https://github.com/sp-hash/suprminer/releases/tag/spmod-git1

will add some more speed later.

Thank you!

[1714973374]

1714973374

[1714973374]

1714973374

[1714973374]

1714973374

[1714973374]

1714973374

[1714973374]

1714973374

[JackIT]

Enemy 1.09 BETA 4 Vs. Enemy 1.08 Vs. sp-mod git1

For this test I used a single 12 GPU 1080Ti rig on Windows 10, split into three mining instances. All three mining instances were balanced to get as close to the same hash rate as possible.
Each mining instance is running at the same time on the same machine mining on the same pool.

All three instances have intensity set to 21, GPU target power set to 100%, no overclocking.

The instances/rig are managed by Awesome Miner, which restarts the miners for various reasons, based on rules I set.

The plan is to do three rounds of testing, each round lasting approximately 10-12hrs, at the conclusion of each round I'll rotate the miner to a new instance, until each miner has had a chance to run on each instance.
I'll then normalize the results to averaged blocks found per round, so that each instance/round is represented equally.

Miners tested:
Enemy 1.09 BETA 4 - 1% dev fee
Enemy 1.08 - 1% dev fee
sp-mod git1 - no dev fee


Results:

Round 1 - 143 Blocks Found - Duration: 705 minutes  (e1.09 restarted, accepted not increased in 4 mins)

• [Instance 1] Normalized: 140.60 RVN | Raw: 133.44 RVN - Enemy 1.09 - Pool Link
• [Instance 2] Normalized: 136.22 RVN | Raw: 129.28 RVN - Enemy 1.08 - Pool Link
• [Instance 3] Normalized: 121.73 RVN | Raw: 115.53 RVN - sp-mod - Pool Link

Round 2  - 148 Blocks Found - Duration: 660 minutes

• [Instance 1] Normalized: 116.01 RVN | Raw: 113.19 RVN - sp-mod - Pool Link
• [Instance 2] Normalized: 139.88 RVN | Raw: 136.48 RVN - Enemy 1.09 - Pool Link
• [Instance 3] Normalized: 123.45 RVN | Raw: 120.45 RVN - Enemy 1.08 - Pool Link

Round 3 - 162 Blocks Found - Duration: 732 minutes

• [Instance 1] Normalized: 130.23 RVN | Raw: 140.02 RVN - Enemy 1.08 - Pool Link
• [Instance 2] Normalized: 122.49 RVN | Raw: 131.70 RVN - sp-mod - Pool Link
• [Instance 3] Normalized: 131.67 RVN | Raw: 141.57 RVN - Enemy 1.09 - Pool Link

Normalized Average Results

#1	*	| Enemy 1.09	| 137.38 RVN
#2	-5.71%	| Enemy 1.08	| 129.96 RVN
#3	-14.41%	| sp-mod	| 120.08 RVN

Round 1 Graphed Progression:


Round 2 Graphed Progression:


Round 3 Graphed Progression:

[Bimmber]

Gentlemen, watch SP`s spectacular failure on this comparison 

[cirlama]

JackIT, enemy can go up to I 21.5 and sp to 21 only, may be a comparison with these settings would be more interesting?

[JackIT]

JackIT, enemy can go up to I 21.5 and sp to 21 only, may be a comparison with these settings would be more interesting?

I prefer a level playing field

[ruplikminer]

Gentlemen, watch SP`s spectacular failure on this comparison 

+1

Time to make REAL good miners for SP with jsut dev fees. And not trying to sell for BTC.

[sp_]

#1 was slow. #2 has been released with more speed

https://github.com/sp-hash/suprminer/releases/tag/spmod-git2

[ruplikminer]

#1 was slow. #2 has been released with more speed

https://github.com/sp-hash/suprminer/releases/tag/spmod-git2

How much more?

[sp_]

My free opensource miner without a fee is still in progress.
I am adding more speed to github, and won't build exe files for each commit.

you can follow the progress here:

https://github.com/sp-hash/suprminer/commits/master

[ruplikminer]

My free opensource miner without a fee is still in progress.
I am adding more speed to github, and won't build exe files for each commit.

you can follow the progress here:

https://github.com/sp-hash/suprminer/commits/master

thanks. I am following. Seems like no one can beat Enemy miner. Maybe you can?

[Bimmber]

He can`t, in his wildest dreams. Enemy KGB team has best miner available, with new 1.09 getting into final stages, they are getting even more speed compared to first alpha release.

[sp_]

The sp-mod private is around 10% faster than the enemy 1.09 miner. I will add some more opensource speed, and then add the more speed in the private bin.

[Xazax310]

I know that Enemy's miner seems to be the best miner, however the "extra" coin you get, does that really offset the cost of the Dev fee? Supraminer 1.6 is free.

[Bimmber]

How does extra 10% doesn`t offset 1% dev fee?

[JackIT]

The sp-mod private is around 10% faster than the enemy 1.09 miner. I will add some more opensource speed, and then add the more speed in the private bin.

Proof?

if the sp-mod private one is 10% faster than enemy 1.09, why bother making an opensource version that is 25% slower than sp-mod private?

[Johnjay06]

How does one get to use the private version?

[sp_]

if the sp-mod private one is 10% faster than enemy 1.09, why bother making an opensource version that is 25% slower than sp-mod private?

My mod is the fastest opensource, and the mod is not complete. In the opensource I haven't touched the important algos, where the most speed is gained. Most of the commits are the 80bit algos that are only used in 1/16 th of the time. These algos are not used in any other coins and can be spread without hurting my other mods. The sp-mod private is ccminer/spmod and you find it on some of the pools.

[prettycode]

I know that Enemy's miner seems to be the best miner, however the "extra" coin you get, does that really offset the cost of the Dev fee? Supraminer 1.6 is free.

This doesn't make any sense, with all due respect. If you end up with more coins in your wallet, it doesn't matter whether the dev fee was 1% or 10% or 50%. The dev mining fee is run while the miner is hashing, meaning the "fees" have already been paid before you're awarded coins.

[JackIT]

if the sp-mod private one is 10% faster than enemy 1.09, why bother making an opensource version that is 25% slower than sp-mod private?

My mod is the fastest opensource, and the mod is not complete. In the opensource I haven't touched the important algos, where the most speed is gained. Most of the commits are the 80bit algos that are only used in 1/16 th of the time. These algos are not used in any other coins and can be spread without hurting my other mods. The sp-mod private is ccminer/spmod and you find it on some of the pools.

You didn't answer my question.

 You claim to have the fastest open source and fastest closed source x16r miners, without any proof whatsoever... at least you're consistent

[preda]

The sp-mod private is around 10% faster than the enemy 1.09 miner. I will add some more opensource speed, and then add the more speed in the private bin.

which one? sp mod 2? like btx?