Margin trading & BTC - Good or bad?

[fluxlite]

Leveraged financial products have long been used by brokers in order to offer traders massive exposure to markets for a relatively small percentage of the total position.

I'm sure many of us have noticed the 'Margin trading (coming soon)' on Mt Gox, and I wonder what the community thinks to trading BTC on margin.

• Will Mt Gox be able to implement such a product with the price of BTC fluctuating as it is?
• Will (or should) margin accounts be different to normal trading accounts and will margin traders have to have more vetting & maintain higher collateral?
• Will margin trading destabilise the market even more? Is there enough depth? Will leverage ultimately decrease market depth?
• Day trading BTC might become more attractive, but do the advantages of trading BTC outweigh the advantages of, say, trading forex with SBs and CFDs?

[Sekioh]

Well obviously giving someone 2,10,20 times their account value is asking for trouble, the very first few will be able to swing the price easily. BUT after a few hours there will be other buyers that will put up a larger wall of these offers/bids on margin, so it should stabilize quickly and then what you have is a larger volume wall, that should in effect provide liquidity a bit better without such large swings.

But eh, we will see. It just means people will make-or-break faster and harder instead of slowly dying off from price changes before they can sell out.

[wndrbr3d]

Margin trading wouldn't be good for the exchanges because of two reasons:

1 - Market is easily manipulated. Someone could buy several deep in the money calls, sell a large number of Bitcoins ride the down slide and then exorcize the option. Netting them a hearty profit when the market eventually recovers.

2 - Exchanges would need to implement the same safeguards as every other brokerage house when granting people margin credit and option level 1+ trading. Otherwise, how would the exchange collect if someone got themselves into a call situation?

The big benefit for Bitcoin is that there's a sense of anonymity with it. For the most part, the exchanges follow this belief by not doing direct ACH transactions or collecting any personal information beyond name/email.

Now, don't get me wrong. For Bitcoin to be taken seriously by the trading community at large, exchanges will eventually have to mature to that point. I just don't think the current small Bitcoin community is ready.

[Stephen Gornick]

I'm sure many of us have noticed the 'Margin trading (coming soon)' on Mt Gox, and I wonder what the community thinks to trading BTC on margin.

Margin trading was to be a feature already possible at HelloBitcoin.com though being based out of the U.S. (they claim, though I've seen no proof of this) they are required to impose a minimum balance restriction of $2K USD.  Their order book is pretty thin yet though so even with a margined account you couldn't do much activity.  But it is possible today, apparently.

- http://www.hellobitcoin.com