I believe that majority in this forum are aiming to become bounty hunters and I would have also to agree that there are instances that some newbies do not really comply to the policy of the forum wherein the member should have to make constructive quality post. However, I believe in due time the newbies will start to learn and may improve in their postings. I know for a fact that merits really is hard to acquire but just continue to do good postings for time will come you may get it unexpectedly.
Your idea is utopian because people do not want to study - they want to earn money, and for this reason, they need to write a certain number of words regularly. And normal discussions on the case here will not work - it's not even about newcomers, but about the fact that the entire system of earnings makes you neglect what you write!