Is it possible sending BTC without a transaction fee?

[Malamok101]

If theres No transaction fee on sending bitcoin to other wallet that's impossible to happened because all altcoins have a fee for Sending or Withdraw.

[1715117020]

1715117020

[1715117020]

1715117020

[kingpin4321]

When sending bitcoin from your wallet to a receivers wallet there is normally a transcation fee or mining fee that must be paid before a transcation can be confirmed

[ellehcar]

I don't think this is possible. Remember that transaction fees go to blockchain mining which keeps the transaction in the network secured. So basically, it's the miners' reward for tracking and securing blockchain transactions. Even if the total mineable coins of bitcoin is mined, sending BTC without a fee would remain just a dream, as long as crypto is using blockchain to make transactions, especially now that the demand for the use of blockchain gets higher and higher each time.

[argon76]

Bitcoins are not controlled by any financial institution. Banks have nothing to do with this currency. And therefore, no intermediaries are required to conduct operations, and there is no one to pay a commission.

No one will be able to limit the amount of transfer or freeze your account. The only danger is the loss of a key from a bitcoin wallet. This is really a serious risk, since it is impossible to restore access to the wallet. Lost keys are lost forever.

[Ucy]

Not possible. Why do you even want a feeless transaction? I thought the purpose of Bitcoin fee is to prevent spam/ddos.  It's not even for the  Miners as some suggest.
 The fees very negligible by the way. It saves the network from attacks

[rdbase]

To do it individually it is not possible but if you use another sites services they can send your bitcoin and take on the transaction fee themself.
Some casino sites such as the sports books I use do not charge you to send bitcoin off their site.
I also use a wallet for exchange when I send bitcoin from their site they do not charge any sending fees too.

[Moshaid]

Absolutely not, transaction fee is what miners use in making transactions easier and swift for different parties. Without this it won't be possible for bitcoin to be sent out or in.

[SnapDown22]

I would know if it is possible to send BTC without a transaction fee regardless of theoretically or practicall..

at no cost is something that is difficult to happen because we know that developments and technology all need costs and funding to access them and for that every need of funds

[Kelvinid]

I would know if it is possible to send BTC without a transaction fee regardless of theoretically or practicall..

at no cost is something that is difficult to happen because we know that developments and technology all need costs and funding to access them and for that every need of funds

If we understand, those fees they collected are just for miners who did it and it is must in order to proceed the transactions we made. Fees are not so high and it we could set it into the lowest but it cause delays due cause the usually prioritize those transactions that have pay more satoshi's.
I will never make that hard if we would like to move it fast and quick transaction, the most important is it will never takes too long to wait before it confirmed.

[jerrison]

transaction fees are the compensation for competitive computation of complex mathematical problems initiated via the transaction within the blockchain network and in this case the bitcoin  option. it gets really interesting and makes the transactions get processed and brings in many miners to cover for the numerous transactions that gets initiated on a daily basis.

[eaLiTy]

So far I have not seen any site or exchange offering this. We know everything in cryptocurrency is about money and its business. I think there might be some instances for this but as to have a really free transaction, it is quite impossible. Energy is wasted in mining so it is difficult to give it for free.

You really cannot tell that there was no free transactions available earlier, most of the online wallets used to transfer funds for free without any fees before the transaction charges started increases because of the block limit and getting to a consensus took a really long time which made a lot of difference on how bitcoin is adapted since, now every online wallet does charge you fees for every transaction and nothing is free now, If you are using your own wallet then you can send transaction with very minimal fees, less than ten cents right now but without any fee is impossible if you are planning to send your coins .

[basty03]

I would know if it is possible to send BTC without a transaction fee regardless of theoretically or practicall..

As of now I don't have any incounter that there's no fee because most of in crypto have a fee if you do a transaction. And fee is the one thing they can use to develop their every platform.

[trader34]

I would know if it is possible to send BTC without a transaction fee regardless of theoretically or practicall..

I don't think it is possible, because the transaction fees serve to reward the miners' work, in addition to the emission of new bitcoins...

[crzy]

Not possible. Why do you even want a feeless transaction? I thought the purpose of Bitcoin fee is to prevent spam/ddos.  It's not even for the  Miners as some suggest.
 The fees very negligible by the way. It saves the network from attacks

Yeah, fees are here to make this market more secure. Its hard for a developer to run their system if there is no profit at all and chances are, they will just close the project. So fees is good sometimes, and its more affordable compare to other financial institutions.

[xWolfx]

although the use of cryptocurrency continues to be developed by scientists so that the holders can feel comfortable doing transactions without the costs that must be incurred I think that is not possible, because every transaction must require costs to be incurred

Yes, in order for a service to exist there some be some kind of compensation for it or it won't be online for too long unless someone rich who don't mind donating his/her money do it, in this case we talk about money of course. The worldwide compensation for services or products.

It just can't be done until society is perfect and money is not needed.

[nellakarisma]

if in my opinion. sending bitcoin at no cost is very pleasant. but if in my opinion it's impossible, bro. send without fees. because. in the real world, every shipment in the form of money or goods is subject to a transfer fee. My expectation is that transfer fees will be cheaper than the current transfer fee

[sujonali1819]

Always you pay transaction fees for transferring btc from one wallet to other wallet. Little bit of low or high. But must be pay fees.

But now I want to say about coinbase. Where they support transection btc Through coinbase email address. Where coinbase don't charge any fees for transection. And transection is instant. So I want to say it is the one way for transferring btc from one person to other without any fees. You can choose it. [ coinbase is an Exchange don't a wallet ] Thanks      

[mocacinno]

It's been a while since i last posted on this topic, but it filled with nonsense dribble once again... I guess no more than 25% of the posts in this topic make any sense (both gramatically and technically). Since newbies WILL be able to read this nonsense posted by higher ranking members, i have no choice but to set the record straight once in a while.

Everybody spreading false rumours in this thread will go straight to my ignore list from this point foreward...

Not possible. Why do you even want a feeless transaction? I thought the purpose of Bitcoin fee is to prevent spam/ddos.  It's not even for the  Miners as some suggest.
 The fees very negligible by the way. It saves the network from attacks

The miner can add the sum of all fees of all transactions he puts in the block he's trying to solve to the coinbase transaction... So the fee IS for the miners (as some suggest).
At the moment, the fees are neglectible, however, about a year ago there were fees upward of 400 sat/byte.

To do it individually it is not possible but if you use another sites services they can send your bitcoin and take on the transaction fee themself.

Wot

Some casino sites such as the sports books I use do not charge you to send bitcoin off their site.
I also use a wallet for exchange when I send bitcoin from their site they do not charge any sending fees too.

Offchain transactions between two sportbook "wallets" *can* be free because they are offchain... It's just the sportsbook updating the balance of your account in their relational database. As long as they don't broadcast a transaction, they don't have to charge a fee. If they allow you to withdraw your winnings for free, they're the ones footing the bill... it has nothing to do with 0 fee transactions (which are technically possible, but very improbable).

Absolutely not, transaction fee is what miners use in making transactions easier and swift for different parties. Without this it won't be possible for bitcoin to be sent out or in.

On a technical level, there is no "in" or "out", just transactions spending unspent outputs from the utxo set, funding addresses so new unspent outputs can be created. A fee does not make it easyer for a miner to add your transaction to a block, it just gives the miner an incentive to do so.

You really cannot tell that there was no free transactions available earlier, most of the online wallets used to transfer funds for free without any fees before the transaction charges started increases because of the block limit and getting to a consensus took a really long time which made a lot of difference on how bitcoin is adapted since, now every online wallet does charge you fees for every transaction and nothing is free now, If you are using your own wallet then you can send transaction with very minimal fees, less than ten cents right now but without any fee is impossible if you are planning to send your coins .

If you use the command line interface of core, the console of electrum, coinb.in,... It's still possible to create 0 fee transactions... The trick is getting them broadcasted/relayed and finding a miner that's willing to add them to the block he's trying to solve.

As of now I don't have any incounter that there's no fee because most of in crypto have a fee if you do a transaction. And fee is the one thing they can use to develop their every platform.

Huh So, because altcoins are using fees, bitcoins must be using fees? I don't follow that logic.
The fee does NOT pay the dev!

Yeah, fees are here to make this market more secure. Its hard for a developer to run their system if there is no profit at all and chances are, they will just close the project. So fees is good sometimes, and its more affordable compare to other financial institutions.

The fee does NOT pay the dev!

Always you pay transaction fees for transferring btc from one wallet to other wallet. Little bit of low or high. But must be pay fees.

But now I want to say about coinbase. Where they support transection btc Through coinbase email address. Where coinbase don't charge any fees for transection. And transection is instant. So I want to say it is the one way for transferring btc from one person to other without any fees. You can choose it. [ coinbase is an Exchange don't a wallet ] Thanks      

Once again: offchain transactions *can* be free since they're just an update in the relational database of the online wallet provider

[Akagum]

I do not think it's possible to sent bitcoin without being charged a transaction fee.
But I do know that one can use the custom function to adjust the transfer fee .
You either reduce or increase the fee using the custom function if you want accelerated confirmation or so I hear.

[SistaFista]

I would know if it is possible to send BTC without a transaction fee regardless of theoretically or practicall..

It has never been happening, but i don't know if we can manage to send bitcoins without fee in the future.
Even sending coin which using Proof of Stake (PoS) algorithm, it still need fee, although only small fee.
But in cryptocurrency, you only have to pay small fee without regarding of how much you send the coins.