Well, that's my point, remember we're talking about a scenario with no price increase and halving drop.
Mining gears will be worth a lot less then, but not to the extent of keeping industrial mining profitable, think about this way, home miners have nothing to pay but their power bill, so they in the worst case have 15-30% less expenses than industrial mining, they also have a much better overall risk:reward ratio, if they don't roi, they only lose what they paid for miner, if at any point mining becomes unprofitable, they shut it down and wait for bitcoin price to go higher, wait for the winter to come by or simply do it for the "technology".
Industrial miners don't have all these privileges, so really if we take all of these factors into consideration, we can go to extent of saying home miners are two times more profitable.
therefore,I don't think the equation is (if home miners are making "decent" profits, industrial mining will have to be there)
Because the moment you buy 20 home miners... it makes no sense why you wouldn't buy 4 big ones that are 5 times more powerful, right?
True, 20 miners is not home mining IMO, but it's not always 2 big miners = 4 small miners, because you can easily run say 2000w in your house, but highly unlikely find a wire/mcb that can handle 4kw , so home miners would prefer 4*1000w to 1*4000w.
This is the problem with targeting the so-called home miners, it's a very tight niche.
It is indeed, but once there is no other way around, it has to happen, it's not like they have another choice, you are also ignoring the fact that these home-friendly miners can sometimes perfectly work in industrial scale, this is one reason you don't see 5kw miners, take Whatsminer M20s 68 for an example, it's a 3.3kw miner that many people don't want to deal with due to the electricity infrastructure they have.
Hobby mining, that's something else, and this is why I would love a cheap silent miner that anyone could run just to support the network and that wouldn't make you raise an eyebrow when the bill comes. But that's wishful thinking and I know it.
Sidehack has
them, for hobby mining his stuff are perfect.