[Merit] Hey Newbies! Can You Sign A Message?

[janggernaut]

Code:

bc1q6m7lzys9tvasf6vzxevsxyrw9qhm3zymkrnz38

I am geast from bitcointalk.org

ID9P04mTP41ZKb+xqAVXV9tAX2716tPhWeIZnW6InheiUsgIRB9qAdx+UefDNzlg1v6eO0dTuXFmGJPQjA6bCnE=

Your history post is full of bounty reports, i don't think Og will rewarded you some merit.

Code:

Address: bc1qlx8d65ytsp3u2vn24xucjwnsd9vv7h3fwy6fzy
Message: Hello Mr, OgNasty. I m cryptomiles1. I just checked out your experiment and it works perfectly. thanks for help.

Signature: H5sQJ7c8PVlgUqVog2WC46uh7s+pIjXutl+tmDjzoTR8dh5g75zT198pGDrOlkugvjoMneGwdfcr+LPIlNQmcj0=

You are already Jr.member....(Not newbie)

[1714247097]

1714247097

[1714247097]

1714247097

[1714247097]

1714247097

[1714247097]

1714247097

[1714247097]

1714247097

[Cryptomiles1]

Code:

bc1q6m7lzys9tvasf6vzxevsxyrw9qhm3zymkrnz38

I am geast from bitcointalk.org

ID9P04mTP41ZKb+xqAVXV9tAX2716tPhWeIZnW6InheiUsgIRB9qAdx+UefDNzlg1v6eO0dTuXFmGJPQjA6bCnE=

Your history post is full of bounty reports, i don't think Og will rewarded you some merit.

Code:

Address: bc1qlx8d65ytsp3u2vn24xucjwnsd9vv7h3fwy6fzy
Message: Hello Mr, OgNasty. I m cryptomiles1. I just checked out your experiment and it works perfectly. thanks for help.

Signature: H5sQJ7c8PVlgUqVog2WC46uh7s+pIjXutl+tmDjzoTR8dh5g75zT198pGDrOlkugvjoMneGwdfcr+LPIlNQmcj0=

You are already Jr.member....(Not newbie)

But i have seen someone being merited by Og not only to newbie but someone people having other ranks, don't you want me to grow in the industry.

sorry to post. but read this

[Zanab247]

I don't know why things are hard for newbie to rank up? Does it mean we don't have facilitator in the community that will help people to achieve their goal. Merit will come for the right sources by posting quality post in the forum to help you see a good facilitator in the forum.

[Cryptomiles1]

I don't know why things are hard for newbie to rank up? Does it mean we don't have facilitator in the community that will help people to achieve their goal. Merit will come for the right sources by posting quality post in the forum to help you see a good facilitator in the forum.

That is why you have been given an opportunity to follow the process here and gain merits if you could be able to sign the signature then you will be given merit by Og and any other person whose find your signature is good.

Please follow the instructions very well and you will rewarded.

Note: Based on his earlier messages that if your account is associated with bounty program sorry you may not have it. Only account not running bounty can be able to gain it free from him.

[OgNasty]

Code:

Address: bc1qlx8d65ytsp3u2vn24xucjwnsd9vv7h3fwy6fzy
Message: Hello Mr, OgNasty. I m cryptomiles1. I just checked out your experiment and it works perfectly. thanks for help.

Signature: H5sQJ7c8PVlgUqVog2WC46uh7s+pIjXutl+tmDjzoTR8dh5g75zT198pGDrOlkugvjoMneGwdfcr+LPIlNQmcj0=

It didn't verify.

[Cryptomiles1]

Code:

Address: bc1qlx8d65ytsp3u2vn24xucjwnsd9vv7h3fwy6fzy
Message: Hello Mr, OgNasty. I m cryptomiles1. I just checked out your experiment and it works perfectly. thanks for help.

Signature: H5sQJ7c8PVlgUqVog2WC46uh7s+pIjXutl+tmDjzoTR8dh5g75zT198pGDrOlkugvjoMneGwdfcr+LPIlNQmcj0=

It didn't verify.

Okay watch this; I have signed another with a screenshot to show it is verified.

Code:

Address: bc1qlx8d65ytsp3u2vn24xucjwnsd9vv7h3fwy6fzy

Message: I have made another test run again

Signature: IAtGxZ7M2sOhkPNibfWjrLI2ebUx2U5odnBUTGhjOWtJWby4FrCgJ2sXE9OFOb0dv3P3flyAP8oJ/SqYe0/Gfo0=

Please check this image below to see the verification messages, this is from mobile App on coinomi

[janggernaut]

Try using legacy bitcoin address (starting with 1...) since segwit address can't be verified.

For your reference

-snip- BTW, I found that Bitcoin Core cannot sign using native segwit addresses (bc1...). Somebody should implement that. -snip-

You cannot sign messages using the SegWit address on Bitcoin Core. I've also tried it.

-snip-

I have also asked about this issue. Here's the answer from achow101:

There is no solution and you cannot sign a message with a segwit address. This has been the case since segwit was introduced. See https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/issues/10542

I have tried to verify your sign message many times from brainwallet and https://tools.bitcoin.com/verify-message/ but it didn't work

[Husna QA]

Code:

Address: bc1qlx8d65ytsp3u2vn24xucjwnsd9vv7h3fwy6fzy

Message: I have made another test run again

Signature: IAtGxZ7M2sOhkPNibfWjrLI2ebUx2U5odnBUTGhjOWtJWby4FrCgJ2sXE9OFOb0dv3P3flyAP8oJ/SqYe0/Gfo0=

Please check this image below to see the verification messages, this is from mobile App on coinomi

Try using legacy bitcoin address (starting with 1...) since segwit address can't be verified.
-snip- I have tried to verify your sign message many times from brainwallet and https://tools.bitcoin.com/verify-message/ but it didn't work

Bitcoin Core ^[1] and Brainwallet ^[2] cannot verify the SegWit address sign message.
Earlier I tried to verify the Cryptomiles1 sign message using Electrum; the results are "Signature verified".

 

^[1] https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5204167.msg53946278#msg53946278
^[2] I found the following thread: How to verify SegWit Signature with Brainwallet? (by converting the Bech32 address to a Legacy address first).

[Cryptomiles1]

Code:

Address: bc1qlx8d65ytsp3u2vn24xucjwnsd9vv7h3fwy6fzy

Message: I have made another test run again

Signature: IAtGxZ7M2sOhkPNibfWjrLI2ebUx2U5odnBUTGhjOWtJWby4FrCgJ2sXE9OFOb0dv3P3flyAP8oJ/SqYe0/Gfo0=

Please check this image below to see the verification messages, this is from mobile App on coinomi

Try using legacy bitcoin address (starting with 1...) since segwit address can't be verified.
-snip- I have tried to verify your sign message many times from brainwallet and https://tools.bitcoin.com/verify-message/ but it didn't work

Bitcoin Core ^[1] and Brainwallet ^[2] cannot verify the SegWit address sign message.
Earlier I tried to verify the Cryptomiles1 sign message using Electrum; the results are "Signature verified".

 

^[1] https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5204167.msg53946278#msg53946278
^[2] I found the following thread: How to verify SegWit Signature with Brainwallet? (by converting the Bech32 address to a Legacy address first).

Please could you check the first signature I signed earlier if it is verified because Og said not verified using this link 👇
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5275043.msg55575809#msg55575809

[Husna QA]

-snip-

Please could you check the first signature I signed earlier if it is verified because Og said not verified using this link 👇
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5275043.msg55575809#msg55575809

Just like OgNasty, I also can't verify your first signature. The message "Wrong signature" appears on Electrum.



There may be an error in your message or signature, e.g. there was an error during the copy-paste process, or characters are missing.
Try to re-create a signed message using the same message and bitcoin address, then check whether the signature that generated is still the same as the previous one or is there something different.

[Cryptomiles1]

-snip-

Please could you check the first signature I signed earlier if it is verified because Og said not verified using this link 👇
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5275043.msg55575809#msg55575809

Just like OgNasty, I also can't verify your first signature. The message "Wrong signature" appears on Electrum.



There may be an error in your message or signature, e.g. there was an error during the copy-paste process, or characters are missing.
Try to re-create a signed message using the same message and bitcoin address, then check whether the signature that generated is still the same as the previous one or is there something different.

Okay Og was right, the first one was wrong not verified. So I retest it again and it works from your previous quotes.
So are my entitled to be rewarded or nothing for me 😆

[Cryptomiles1]

Code:

Address: bc1qlx8d65ytsp3u2vn24xucjwnsd9vv7h3fwy6fzy

Message: I have made another test run again

Signature: IAtGxZ7M2sOhkPNibfWjrLI2ebUx2U5odnBUTGhjOWtJWby4FrCgJ2sXE9OFOb0dv3P3flyAP8oJ/SqYe0/Gfo0=

Please check this image below to see the verification messages, this is from mobile App on coinomi

Try using legacy bitcoin address (starting with 1...) since segwit address can't be verified.
-snip- I have tried to verify your sign message many times from brainwallet and https://tools.bitcoin.com/verify-message/ but it didn't work

Bitcoin Core ^[1] and Brainwallet ^[2] cannot verify the SegWit address sign message.
Earlier I tried to verify the Cryptomiles1 sign message using Electrum; the results are "Signature verified".

 

^[1] https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5204167.msg53946278#msg53946278
^[2] I found the following thread: How to verify SegWit Signature with Brainwallet? (by converting the Bech32 address to a Legacy address first).

From this as you said verified but let og check and very too let us know is from his end

[Husna QA]

Okay Og was right, the first one was wrong not verified. So I retest it again and it works from your previous quotes.
So are my entitled to be rewarded or nothing for me 😆

Why don't you combine your two posts above which are only about five minutes apart?
Have you managed to verify your first signature yourself?
Don't you intend to try again checking your first signature error?
It could be that the cause of the error is in the signature coding, as in the following cases:

why don't people read what was said in other comments before replying :D

the ONLY problem here is the encoding of the signature that when it generates r and s, r is 32 bytes, s is 31 bytes. it doesn't pad s so it ends up with a 64 (1+32+31) byte signature instead of 65 (1+32+(1+31)).

if you change that, the signature becomes valid. try the following and see for yourself:

Code:

IFkS40AxIuRGDN/vnjwavfV6R00h3MKArtDB7tpBbnqIADHOlkhiEJv8JuJTeyVW2Oo23jH9u8fFTqiOms4MM9k=

this is NOT a problem with Electrum, at least not the new versions. i DID test it with my own key and brute forced a signature with a smaller r or s and it DID generate the right signature encoding.

3. the signature I get: IFkS40AxIuRGDN/vnjwavfV6R00h3MKArtDB7tpBbnqIMc6WSGIQm/wm4lN7JVbY6jbeMf27x8VOqI6azgwz2Q==

your signature length is invalid, it should have been 65 bytes but what you posted here is only 64 bytes which means it is missing 1 byte.

this should not have happened, i can't see any bugs that could lead to this either. are you sure that you have not modified the signature yourself?

From this as you said verified but let og check and very too let us know is from his end

Do you doubt OgNasty's ability to verify Signed messages?

[OgNasty]

From this as you said verified but let og check and very too let us know is from his end

That signature doesn't include your name so I'm not going to spend time attempting to verify it.  If you have to ask me if it verifies or not, you shouldn't be posting it.

[Cryptomiles1]

From this as you said verified but let og check and very too let us know is from his end

That signature doesn't include your name so I'm not going to spend time attempting to verify it.  If you have to ask me if it verifies or not, you shouldn't be posting it.

Code:

Address: bc1q75udy75033ju75zzg9hryqxn5h4m08t9v8mth7

Message: Hello I m Cryptomiles1, I have ran several test-run to make sure I m qualify. thanks for the experiments and I have learnt a lot during the process.

Signature: H4T2gAx06uFuNGQJCJYVpimHBz/yGeti5o5F5QHbX4vtdDvNTG8Ch8YZ5x4uptm8l5X7qSJjlegNg2H0PPhJpDU=

please check the image below to show it's verified

[Anillop]

A well deserved merit?

Code:

Address: 19QtTqUCJ3SKhGwGW3Tyz1x1Y3Lzo6ACrD
Message: Im Anillop and this is my first message
Signature: IEhHqgDjFmjqip1vH+eNO1dzz5rR1FErIu26WibZ/7tDQ+LJBwpZjUab28PmoFG8JHfzFA/XVZ242iEmqfS0BQs=

[Eedward]

Code:

Address: bc1qkfgwvq48l7074p6a9ddcklvk3qfhjn2teuv45r
Message: I'm eedward and I can sign a message.
Signature: H2DD+QCBtNBd2rc2DgG5rqdhUokWCoLXt7WOeBRJJyIQB6vJDbxW9WOmPfSSTC6R+e+DyQsifLOas62gJTLRWwk=

Verified Sir!  
https://ibb.co/xgX4CJR

[kakonhat]

Address: 18DJbBHL2gtekrRvUPubZFWPLKs9VnerFy
Message: I’m kakonhat and I can sign a message.
Signature: ID7l/adPzf4qEkAnyoEwfwA/QMRWrvLEw9GKTqkpdk6lCYchPDJFfojf9KOzU+/NqAkYDGGLYwf4Z9N4ERiczhQ=

[Devid86]

Done

Code:

Address: 1A1dsTKdpBncvuTQGVQqtDkVcxNcBPtx5u
Message: I'm Devid86 and I can a sign message
Signature: INNHPUgVTyK7Am3oWoQZStDtgPvf3N5DpYltJ2vtSY0EfOh4t14XSLWHVsmh1OgpdejmJ7thzEIdIQPkD3S/EXQ=

[bear01ox]

Address: bc1qsl8ye20u0mlfjvykmq2xz55q2q70dn4c0yp763
Message: I am bear01ox. I can sign a message.
Signature: H0na0dn4xYFGh8vkM0fJfnWPhCdSaT29l8ZRYFRS/I7gUVUUINF1SD7MkQnp06n/jDEjJmPzdYS2d5dRcfiMWzM=