I Lost Some coins to exchange (and it feels like scam to me)

[Cryptoababe]

I have 39 matic token  ( polygon token which worth 50 dollars) on ftx. And I wanted to withdraw as polygon network matic But FTX only supports Erc20. which means i need to withdraw to another exchange which support polygon network matic token.
So, i withdraw them to my huobi account. I never know that huobi minimum deposit is 57 matic because I only noticed that after sending 39 matic to the exchange.
So, i decided to send more tokens (58 matic tokens). I only get 58 tokens deposit notification. And my previous 39 deposit was not added.
I contacted thier support and they said there is nothing they can do about it. Moreover, this exchange is not a DEX. Now i know why people call exchanges thieves.
Can anyone tell me why this minimum deposit is necessary in exchanges that are centralized?. Because i feel like its like an act to scam their customers.

[1715114035]

1715114035

[1715114035]

1715114035

[1715114035]

1715114035

[batang_bitcoin]

It is their requirement and discretion to have a minimum deposit and withdrawal. There is nothing we can do with that if they're requiring us with their minimum deposit. There's the recent update that they've made, I think that included that minimum deposit.
https://www.huobi.com/support/en-us/detail/24884454798546

[Cryptoababe]

It is their requirement and discretion to have a minimum deposit and withdrawal. There is nothing we can do with that if they're requiring us with their minimum deposit. There's the recent update that they've made, I think that included that minimum deposit.
https://www.huobi.com/support/en-us/detail/24884454798546

But my next deposit should have been added to the previous deposit.. Even if there is a minimum deposit. Now it means i dashed them my coins.

[Ultegra134]

It is their requirement and discretion to have a minimum deposit and withdrawal. There is nothing we can do with that if they're requiring us with their minimum deposit. There's the recent update that they've made, I think that included that minimum deposit.
https://www.huobi.com/support/en-us/detail/24884454798546

I do get that they have a minimum requirement and is written in their TOS and yada yada, however, the coins were still deposited to their address, it's probably not that of an uncommon mistake, the most sensible and logical thing would be to manually add the coins to his account. I mean, they already possess them, why would they keep hold of them like that?

[batang_bitcoin]

OP can still contest that so that the support that has answered him might got it wrong and bring it up to the higher ups that can look and check the backlog of his transaction. Sometimes there's also some problems through these supports that don't look through with the problems that have been brought to them. I hope that it's that issue when the support answered OP, there's nothing really we can do with this unless he's going to take the discussion back to the support.

[vv181]

It is their requirement and discretion to have a minimum deposit and withdrawal. There is nothing we can do with that if they're requiring us with their minimum deposit. There's the recent update that they've made, I think that included that minimum deposit.
https://www.huobi.com/support/en-us/detail/24884454798546

But my next deposit should have been added to the previous deposit.. Even if there is a minimum deposit. Now it means i dashed them my coins.

Cumulative deposits to add up the lower amount of minimum deposit only works on USDT, at least that is what is stated on their page (https://www.huobi.com/support/en-us/detail/360000105782).

~snip the most sensible and logical thing would be to manually add the coins to his account. I mean, they already possess them, why would they keep hold of them like that?

Technically, it also won't be exhaustive and resource extensive to automatically added up the balance, just like what they did to USDT on the link above. Although exchanges did it in a cheeky way, the sole responsibility relies on the user since they agreed to TOS/user agreements.

[inanilujimi]

There are also exchanges that have different addresses for BEP 20 and erc 20 which if we are wrong to deposit they don't want to return it, even though they clearly have access to that address.
this is a soft scams they are working on.

[Cryptoababe]

I do get that they have a minimum requirement and is written in their TOS and yada yada, however, the coins were still deposited to their address, it's probably not that of an uncommon mistake, the most sensible and logical thing would be to manually add the coins to his account. I mean, they already possess them, why would they keep hold of them like that?

Exactly what im trying to say. Why Would they keep my coins? Thats an act of stealing by them.
I wish users can have thier exchange wallets private keys.
From now, whenever i hear huobi, What i will think about is Scam Exchange .

[Ultegra134]

It is their requirement and discretion to have a minimum deposit and withdrawal. There is nothing we can do with that if they're requiring us with their minimum deposit. There's the recent update that they've made, I think that included that minimum deposit.
https://www.huobi.com/support/en-us/detail/24884454798546

But my next deposit should have been added to the previous deposit.. Even if there is a minimum deposit. Now it means i dashed them my coins.

Cumulative deposits to add up the lower amount of minimum deposit only works on USDT, at least that is what is stated on their page (https://www.huobi.com/support/en-us/detail/360000105782).

~snip the most sensible and logical thing would be to manually add the coins to his account. I mean, they already possess them, why would they keep hold of them like that?

Technically, it also won't be exhaustive and resource extensive to automatically added up the balance, just like what they did to USDT on the link above. Although exchanges did it in a cheeky way, the sole responsibility relies on the user since they agreed to TOS/user agreements.

Since it's on their TOS, not much can be done if they are not willing to. Despite their TOS, it's a completely shady practice to just keep OP's coins like that. Okay, I get it that there's a minimum deposit, so since your deposit is lower than that, they won't be automatically credited to your account, but their support should have helped, this is outrageous.

[vv181]

but their support should have helped, this is outrageous.

Well, their support already helped as @OP stated, they might be just not being helpful because this particular case is bound to the agreements that the user agreed, which they can't do anything about it.

Exactly what im trying to say. Why Would they keep my coins?

The only thing I can assume is:

They have a target of minimum profit/overhead cost that they are required to operate per each user. So in the first place, that is why they set up the minimum deposit requirement. Therefore, speaking about your cases, because of the current situation, your amount is low enough that they might be didn't simply care enough about it since solving the cases would outweigh the cost instead of the benefit (time = money).

Also, maybe they didn't have any automated process to solve these particular cases. Developing it would also require some cost and time to develop it.

[Cryptoababe]

The only thing I can assume is:
They have a target of minimum profit/overhead cost that they are required to operate per each user. So in the first place, that is why they set up the minimum deposit requirement. Therefore, speaking about your cases, because of the current situation, your amount is low enough that they might be didn't simply care enough about it since solving the cases would outweigh the cost instead of the benefit (time = money).

Also, maybe they didn't have any automated process to solve these particular cases. Developing it would also require some cost and time to develop it.

Maybe you are right, But i expect a big exchange like Huobi should not have this kind of issue. This exchange is popular and also have thier own blockchain.
This will make me think that thier blockchain might not be safe enough and can even be a centralised shitchain. I was so disappointed by not seeing my remaining 39 matic added because i dont except an exchange like Huobi to hold customer's coins and not add it to thier account.

[Ultegra134]

but their support should have helped, this is outrageous.

Well, their support already helped as @OP stated, they might be just not being helpful because this particular case is bound to the agreements that the user agreed, which they can't do anything about it.

Exactly what im trying to say. Why Would they keep my coins?

The only thing I can assume is:

They have a target of minimum profit/overhead cost that they are required to operate per each user. So in the first place, that is why they set up the minimum deposit requirement. Therefore, speaking about your cases, because of the current situation, your amount is low enough that they might be didn't simply care enough about it since solving the cases would outweigh the cost instead of the benefit (time = money).

Also, maybe they didn't have any automated process to solve these particular cases. Developing it would also require some cost and time to develop it.

I fully understand that, there's a chance that the customer support is actually unable to do anything in that case, meaning they have no physical access/permission to conduct such a move.

Anyway, it seems like there's not much OP can do, if no other solution is found, then I'm really sorry for your loss.

[vv181]

~

Another lesson learned, just don't try to have high hope for any centralized exchange ever. The amount seems a lot for you but there is nothing you can do but move on, and do your diligence if you try to use any platforms/services again next time.

Also, don't forget about:
Not Your Keys, Not Your cryptoBitcoin

[kensaii]

The only thing I can assume is:
They have a target of minimum profit/overhead cost that they are required to operate per each user. So in the first place, that is why they set up the minimum deposit requirement. Therefore, speaking about your cases, because of the current situation, your amount is low enough that they might be didn't simply care enough about it since solving the cases would outweigh the cost instead of the benefit (time = money).

Also, maybe they didn't have any automated process to solve these particular cases. Developing it would also require some cost and time to develop it.

Maybe you are right, But i expect a big exchange like Huobi should not have this kind of issue. This exchange is popular and also have thier own blockchain.
This will make me think that thier blockchain might not be safe enough and can even be a centralised shitchain. I was so disappointed by not seeing my remaining 39 matic added because i dont except an exchange like Huobi to hold customer's coins and not add it to thier account.

I think they did you dirty there, sure your first deposit was below the minimum amount to register it but your second deposit (on the same address, right?) would sort out the issue. They can't just pull "No, your first deposit is in the limbo and we can only give you the second deposit". Also, you shouldn't hold Huobi as a good, well-behaved, fair and square centralized exchange. They're there to take your money and will do all sorts of things if they can get away with it. The "we're good and trusted, willing to listen to your demand" is mostly just bullshit for marketing scheme, don't buy it.

[Chathusand]

They're working on a soft fraud here. There are also exchanges that have separate addresses for BEP-20 and ERC-20 that refuse to return it if we deposit it incorrectly, despite the fact that they clearly have access to that address.

[Quidat]

They're working on a soft fraud here. There are also exchanges that have separate addresses for BEP-20 and ERC-20 that refuse to return it if we deposit it incorrectly, despite the fact that they clearly have access to that address.

Take a look or some peek on Binance which they do have separate addresses or does have those kind of warnings about wrong deposits on wrong addresses which would result
into lost of coins. Im not aware on other exchange terms and methods where they do really have that minimum deposit amount because most of the time they dont really
ask out in most exchangers that ive been using through years.The only thing that op could do is to wait up for their response neither they would really be considering out
or totally couldnt solve it off.

[lenovop-70]

I am sorry to hear that dear, and i am sorry too because you didnt read it carefully before do transaction.

Your first deposit was wrong by system, and i think their costumer service doesnt have authority to access client wallet without higher approval from the admin.
And your second transfer was right by the system, and its showing on your wallet, but the system doesnt have accumulative automatic authority, thats why your first transaction did not showing on your wallet.

Your case should have special attention from them, because I think it relates to their automated system.

[Erdogan]

I have 39 matic token  ( polygon token which worth 50 dollars) on ftx. And I wanted to withdraw as polygon network matic But FTX only supports Erc20. which means i need to withdraw to another exchange which support polygon network matic token.
So, i withdraw them to my huobi account. I never know that huobi minimum deposit is 57 matic because I only noticed that after sending 39 matic to the exchange.
So, i decided to send more tokens (58 matic tokens). I only get 58 tokens deposit notification. And my previous 39 deposit was not added.
I contacted thier support and they said there is nothing they can do about it. Moreover, this exchange is not a DEX. Now i know why people call exchanges thieves.
Can anyone tell me why this minimum deposit is necessary in exchanges that are centralized?. Because i feel like its like an act to scam their customers.

Unfortunately, if the regulations state what the minimum deposit must be, your deposit is forfeited. There is nothing that is not officially written here, so you have to accept that you made a mistake and lost your money.

When it comes to minimum deposit amounts and withdrawals, they are set mainly to keep costs down. Simply small amounts are often less than transaction fees and this is to avoid such situations.

[dunfida]

I have 39 matic token  ( polygon token which worth 50 dollars) on ftx. And I wanted to withdraw as polygon network matic But FTX only supports Erc20. which means i need to withdraw to another exchange which support polygon network matic token.
So, i withdraw them to my huobi account. I never know that huobi minimum deposit is 57 matic because I only noticed that after sending 39 matic to the exchange.
So, i decided to send more tokens (58 matic tokens). I only get 58 tokens deposit notification. And my previous 39 deposit was not added.
I contacted thier support and they said there is nothing they can do about it. Moreover, this exchange is not a DEX. Now i know why people call exchanges thieves.
Can anyone tell me why this minimum deposit is necessary in exchanges that are centralized?. Because i feel like its like an act to scam their customers.

Unfortunately, if the regulations state what the minimum deposit must be, your deposit is forfeited. There is nothing that is not officially written here, so you have to accept that you made a mistake and lost your money.

When it comes to minimum deposit amounts and withdrawals, they are set mainly to keep costs down. Simply small amounts are often less than transaction fees and this is to avoid such situations.

This would be a lesson learned and moved on since this is his error on sending out coins which didnt able to reach out the minimum deposit amount and regarding with the rules then you do have
to deal with the violation and at least you are aware now and wont really committing the same mistake.
It isnt directly talking as a scam as long you had violated something and its just normal that you would really experiencing something like this.

[Bitcoin_Arena]

How could you have missed the clear warnings on the deposit page?
Not trying to support Huobi's act of not crediting the missing coins into your account, but if you had taken time to read the information, maybe it would have been available.
You should partly blame yourself for not paying attention to the warning.