Life and it's inconsistencies, every face with different inconsistency of life, some people who have been able to buy Bitcoin can hold as long as without contemplating selling as they life emergency happens while others can't even hold for two years, not to forget personal approach to life which causes a great difference also. Of course, they have emergency funds and that makes it more fantabulous but then that there is emergency funds is not a guarantee to not look to avoid avoidable emergency.
Like lose of job, it can be out of personal error or organizational structure, but anything personal that will lead to lose of job can always be avoided to a high percentage and preparation to face life should uncontrollable situations that will cause lose of job to happen can to an extent be also looked into.
Preparation for lose of job (mostly contract jobs) and preparation for retirement is some what similar. When such preparation is in place, as job is lost, accumulation of Bitcoin can just maybe hold on for a while but contemplating of selling Bitcoin asset won't be part of the thinking.
Altogether, this amplifies the need for different sources of income.
I think that's where financial management comes in play. Most emergencies are unavoidable but with good financial management we will be able to to sort out any emergency that comes up. With good financial management we are able to avoid any unnecessary spendings that will lead to complications that way our emergency fund will have limited work to do and will be available whenever unexpected emergency occur.
I don't know but
I don't think we can classify loss of job as an emergency situations in my opinion. When one loses his job I think it will affect our income and discretionary income so the investment completely is affected for the time being. In situations like that the emergency fund can't still come in play, they should be kept to protect us from selling our Bitcoin when a little problem arise.
Most of your post makes sense when it comes to abilities to avoid or minimize the likelihood of tapping into emergency funds, yet I have difficulties understanding how you would not consider loss of income to be problematic and potentially lead to situations in which emergency funds have to be used and even potentially needing to tap into bitcoin holdings.
Whenever there are losses of income and/or increases in expenses, we are faced with needs to figure out from where we are going to get our funds once we don't have any more income (or extra discretionary funds) to use for such purposes. So it would seem that discretionary funds would be used first, then reserve funds and then emergency funds and then bitcoin... So part of the reason to build up various back up funds would be so that we do not have to tap into our bitcoin, yet sometimes loss of income and/or increases in expenses will end up causing us to have to deplete our various back up funds and perhaps ending up causing us to run out of funds in those circumstances that we are not able to reverse the situation in order to increase our income and/or decrease our expenses.
Maybe the emergency starts prior to our even tapping into our emergency funds, and our level of preparedness may well help to inform us whether we need to panic or even we might be able to project how much time into the future we will be able to continue to pay all of our expenses that cannot be deferred.
Who even told you that their are every discretionary income you can afford to lose?
And who told that there are some discretionary income you can't afford to lose? This is ridiculous if you ask me because why then is it called discretionary income if you aren't willing to lose it.
I am having troubles understanding why guys are arguing about discretionary income.
Discretionary income means that it is extra income that can be used however guys want... so by its name, we should be able to recognize that discretionary income is generally considered to be available for wants rather than needs, since presumptively discretionary income is the amount that is left over after we have already accounted for our needs.
So if we have a pool of money that we can do whatever we want to do with it, how could that signify that the amount of money is what we are willing to lose... some guys want to spend their discretionary money right away and others are o.k. with deferring consumption... so then we consider that there are three ways that individuals can use their discretionary funds, which is to 1) invest, 2) save and/or 3) discretionarily consume.
Maybe we tend to consider that the portion of our discretionary funds that we are willing to lose is merely a subset of the total discretionary funds.
If we practice investing, saving and discretionarily consuming our discretionary funds, then it becomes quite likely we will get to know our financial and our psychological boundaries in regards to those discretionary funds and how we want (choose) to use them.
You are beginning to sound like a trader because it is only a trader that gambles with their portfolio. Any money that you aren't willing to lose is no longer your discretionary income. But by the way, does that make you an investor? because once you start investing with money that you can't afford to lose, you are both a trader and gambler.
You have chosen a strange way of making your points, and sure you seem to understand that investment involves being able to invest what you are willing to lose, yet at the same time, you seem to wrongly conclude that any guys should be ready, willing and able to lose all of their discretionary funds, which that part is not true, as I described above, there is an element of choice and an element of want in regards to how we choose to use our discretionary funds, and not everyone is ready and willing to lose all of their discretionary funds, even if they may be able to lose it... they still don't want to lose it, so they have to be ready and willing to lose it also, not just able to lose it.
From the little information that I have gathered from the OP, six months of emergency funds is too and will take a longer time to build it compared to three months of your monthly expenses. It still take a year or more to build an emergency funds of three months of your monthly expenses. Do you want to use two years or more to just be piling up cash when you have a bitcoin investment to grow and possibly buy aggressively when you can.
There's no need keeping too much cash that depreciates in value overtime. Instead, build your emergency funds of three months and channel the money into your bitcoin investment that's a store of value overtime.
You won’t take because cash depreciates in value overtime and refuse to make adequate provisions for your emergency funds. It is better for you have the cash readily available in your emergency funds account, and it depreciates in value than being caught in the middle of an emergency without adequate funds to tackle the problems. Cash depreciating in value don’t just happen overnight, some take years to happen, and you never can tell if the emergency that will hit you will take that long to happen. The simple truth is that, build your emergency fund to the capacity you feel is comfortable for you, according to your financial flow. There’s no rubber stamp that it must be 3 months
or 6 months.
We talk about 3 months of back up funds in this thread, and I also frequently repeat (maybe I should start YELLING louder), that guys better have some good fucking justifications if they believe that normal people who are in the early stages of building their bitcoin holdings should be holding 6 months of cash.. that is absolutely ridiculous absent some good justification for doing so, and maybe I should start to delete the posts of guys who are presenting the holding of 6 months of cash as if it were some kind of a reasonable thing to do for regular guys.
What if your capacity is up to having an emergency funds that can cover you for a year or more? Are you are saying that the investor shouldn’t do it?
You are already retarded if you are referring to keeping 6 months of cash, and you are even more retarded if you are talking about keeping more than 6 months cash.. Normal people should not be doing that. They will be having fun staying poor if they are keeping large portions of cash, unless they have some good reasons such as having various investments that likely would be worth several years of their expenses (whether through investing into it and/or through appreciation).
Before going into holding there are things you keep in place and make available so that during this time if anything unexpected happens no matter how difficult it is you will not be affected and your investment plans will not be changed. First of all you don't go into long term holding with the money you will be needing in the next couple of days or years. You have to have your emergency funds which will serve as powerhouse to cover up emergency cases and the next thing is your back up funds which is essential if you must be successful in our long term journey. As an investor if you plan without considering your emergency funds and back up funds you will not achieve your plans because emergency must occur whether you expect it or not.
Back up funds and emergency funds both serve the same purpose so i don’t see the need for an investor to build them as separate requirements for investing as long as they have enough accessible money that they can use to handle unexpected expenses and ordinary financial needs without being forced to sell their bitcoin; and this amount should be accrued depending on their individual income, responsibilities and financial predicament.
Sometimes people get to misunderstand the words and all you needed to do was just to explain it to him better for better understanding. Backup funds to some people can be classified to be both emergency funds and reserve funds, while to some people it just emergency funds. In any case emergency funds is very important in every successful investment but we can’t just delay investing because we don’t have emergency funds.
In most cases (out of practical purposes), guys are going to be in the practice of keeping both emergency funds and reserve funds, even though they might label them differently.
For example, let's say that a guy gets paid every two weeks (let's say he makes somewhere in the ballpark of $1k every two weeks an his expenses are somewhere in the ballpark of $700 every two weeks), and so he has $300 in his discretionary income and once a week he buys $50 in bitcoin and he also allocates $50 per week for his emergency funds, and that leaves him with $50 per week for discretionary consumption.
Let's say that the guy had been in bitcoin for 12 months, so he had been doing the same thing for 12 months, which means that he had invested $2,600, he had put $2,600 into his emergency funds and he had discretionarily consumed $2,600. And, by the way, since his expenses for 3 months is right around $4,500, he believes that he is still building his emergency funds in order to get it up to $4,500.
So then let's say that he get's half way through the pay period and he runs out of money because he spent all of his discretionary funds, and so he has a whole week that he has to wait before he gets paid. He then finds out that his sister is having a birthday party in 3 days, which is 4 days before he gets paid, and so he does not have any money besides his $2,600 in his "emergency funds." Let's say that historically, he has tended to spend $100 on his sister's birthday party.. but for some reason this year he forgot about it, and he feels that he has to spend $100 on his sister's birthday party, but he has absolutely no money for 1 week, except for the $2,600 in his "emergency funds."
His sister's birthday is not an emergency in the sense of a basic expense that has to be paid, yet he is still likely going to draw from his "emergency funds" for the $100, which means that he had been treating a portion of his emergency funds as reserve funds...and it seems to me that for practical purposes almost everyone is going to retain some flexibility, even when they are building their emergency funds, they are likely going to have some portions of those emergency funds that are really reserve funds and that they have flexibility in terms of how they can be spent. Strict emergency funds probably could not be spent on anything other than basic expenses that cannot be deferred.
I personally believe that it is healthy to build up emergency funds and reserve funds at the same time, and yeah, even though we might want to be strict in our building of our emergency funds in the earliest times of our investing into bitcoin, we still might have to have some flexibilities in terms of changes that we might have in our income going down and/or our expenses going up.. and we also have things that are both needs and wants, and frequently we are not going to want to defer some of the wants that we have. And, yeah, it is not an emergency to spend on non-basic needs yet we will do it, and if we do not have discretionary funds, then we would be using reserve funds for that, even if we call it emergency funds, some of us mislabel our funds, since practically we likely need to build up both kinds of back up funds (emergency funds and reserve funds).
From the little information that I have gathered from the OP, six months of emergency funds is too and will take a longer time to build it compared to three months of your monthly expenses. It still take a year or more to build an emergency funds of three months of your monthly expenses. Do you want to use two years or more to just be piling up cash when you have a bitcoin investment to grow and possibly buy aggressively when you can.
There's no need keeping too much cash that depreciates in value overtime. Instead, build your emergency funds of three months and channel the money into your bitcoin investment that's a store of value overtime.
You won’t take because cash depreciates in value overtime and refuse to make adequate provisions for your emergency funds. It is better for you have the cash readily available in your emergency funds account, and it depreciates in value than being caught in the middle of an emergency without adequate funds to tackle the problems. Cash depreciating in value don’t just happen overnight, some take years to happen, and you never can tell if the emergency that will hit you will take that long to happen. The simple truth is that, build your emergency fund to the capacity you feel is comfortable for you, according to your financial flow. There’s no rubber stamp that it must be 3 months or 6 months. What if your capacity is up to having an emergency funds that can cover you for a year or more? Are you are saying that the investor shouldn’t do it?
Emergency funds is to make provisions for eventualities that can happen at anytime whether you're prepared for it or not so it is better to be prepared Incase it happens, if it doesn't happen yet your money still remains yours. We should look beyond fiat depreciation when we are considering setting money aside for emergencies because your preparedness for the unexpected is more important than what you can lose through inflation.
It doesn't make sense to invest all your discretionary funds in Bitcoin investment while leaving yourself vulnerable Incase something happens unexpectedly like sudden health chalange that requires urgent funds, you will be forced to sell your Bitcoin probably at a lose to meet up the expenses. Remember that in times of emergencies it might not be easy to spend your Bitcoin because it is not widely accepted for now so it makes sense that as you're making provisions for buying your Bitcoin you're also keeping something aside for emergencies and other discretionary wants.
I was criticizing 7juju for seeming to put too much emphasis on cash accumulation and you (@Akaenyi) seem to be criticizing him for putting too little emphasis on cash accumulation.
Frequently, I suggest that guys build their cash from where-ever they are at, so they will tend to be building both bitcoin and cash, yet there is a need to figure out the amounts in light of our own cashflow circumstances, and in this thread we are emphasizing getting started buying bitcoin and also making sure to not overdo it...
I had already, several times, suggested that if a guy comes to bitcoin and he has absolutely no bitcoin and he already has 3 months or more cash saved up in his expenses, then he may well need to consider immediately allocating half of that amount to bitcoin, and then building back up his back up funds and perhaps even give greater priority to building bitcoin faster than the cash back up funds.
Whatever balance we choose to make remains within our judgement, including considering
our 9 individual factors but also considering our expectations of future income and expenses that may well affect how we balance out our allocations towards buying bitcoin versus building up (and maintaining) cash backups.