[AUCTION] Multi-lot 14x Casascius 2013 Gilt/Gilded 1BTC coins REDEEMED

[10casproj]

i think i already win some of it

Well what you did is very unethical. You did bids, then you saw other user put a list without your bids, you saw people continued using old list and said NOTHING.... so you say you won because people used wrong list?

[Geosgaen0]

i think i already win some of it

Well what you did is very unethical. You did bids, then you saw other user put a list without your bids, you saw people continued using old list and said NOTHING.... so you say you won because people used wrong list?

I didnt even notice that ither didnt use my list, im busy replying to op about rule change, once i realize that, i quote the highest bid

[SurfinPanda]

I think this should be re-done. I stopped bidding waiting for clarification then the rule changed back again and I was out of time to figure out which lots were even still open at that point.

[10casproj]

Garrett,

bids from geo should not be valid, he did bids, saw other users using wrong auction list and he said nothing about the mistake to take profit. Besides that the fact we had to put full list made impossible to bid for lots for more than 5 minutes.

You should really consider repeat the auction with less coins.

[Steeley]

Fine, lots close individually. I'm done changing anything, original rules stand, I'll be back to sort it out when all the bids are done

I agree this is a mess. Forums are a shit way to run auctions as it turns out

Forum auction actually are the best I have ever participated in. I think the format you chose was just not right for the number of coins you were selling. The LIFO system works really well for future reference. All lots extend, etc.

A happy medium to keep all happy may be this, Give one coin to all winners, but not multiples to one buyer. Reset the multiples for tomorrow.

[Geosgaen0]

I dont think redo auction is fair for everyone.

[10casproj]

i think i already win some of it

Well what you did is very unethical. You did bids, then you saw other user put a list without your bids, you saw people continued using old list and said NOTHING.... so you say you won because people used wrong list?

I didnt even notice that ither didnt use my list, im busy replying to op about rule change, once i realize that, i quote the highest bid

Sorry but I dont believe you, you did your bids and just after 5minutes you claimed them when people was still using wrong one.... We are not stupid.

[bavicrypto]

Fine, lots close individually. I'm done changing anything, original rules stand, I'll be back to sort it out when all the bids are done

I agree this is a mess. Forums are a shit way to run auctions as it turns out

As far I can see, the bids below should be the winning bids according to the original auction rules. Ofcourse, to be confirmed by OP:
1   1800 elianite
2   2000 Inelasticsupply
3   1900 geosgaen0
4   1800 elianite
5   1850 bavicrypto
6   1800 elianite
7   1850 bavicrypto
8   1800 elianite
9   1750 bavicrypto
10   1750 10casproj
11   1900 geosgaen0
12   1900 geosgaen0
13   1850 JackBauerCsgo
14   1900 10casproj

[Geosgaen0]

i think i already win some of it

Well what you did is very unethical. You did bids, then you saw other user put a list without your bids, you saw people continued using old list and said NOTHING.... so you say you won because people used wrong list?

I didnt even notice that ither didnt use my list, im busy replying to op about rule change, once i realize that, i quote the highest bid

Sorry but I dont believe you, you did your bids and just after 5minutes you claimed them when people was still using wrong one.... We are not stupid.

I didnt mean to do that, and its by OP rule that everyone should take attention to bid.

[Garrett Burgwardt]

Fine, lots close individually. I'm done changing anything, original rules stand, I'll be back to sort it out when all the bids are done

I agree this is a mess. Forums are a shit way to run auctions as it turns out

As far I can see, the bids below should be the winning bids according to the original auction rules. Ofcourse, to be confirmed by OP:
1   1800 elianite
2   2000 Inelasticsupply
3   1900 geosgaen0
4   1800 elianite
5   1850 bavicrypto
6   1800 elianite
7   1850 bavicrypto
8   1800 elianite
9   1750 bavicrypto
10   1750 10casproj
11   1900 geosgaen0
12   1900 geosgaen0
13   1850 JackBauerCsgo
14   1900 10casproj

At the very least Geosgaen0 won lot 1, the lists got out of sync. I should've done the auction format differently and handled it better. I'm very sorry to bidders who feel slighted, I don't blame you. Frankly I just want this done.

I'm going through the list to find winning bids now

[Geosgaen0]

Fine, lots close individually. I'm done changing anything, original rules stand, I'll be back to sort it out when all the bids are done

I agree this is a mess. Forums are a shit way to run auctions as it turns out

As far I can see, the bids below should be the winning bids according to the original auction rules. Ofcourse, to be confirmed by OP:
1   1800 elianite
2   2000 Inelasticsupply
3   1900 geosgaen0
4   1800 elianite
5   1850 bavicrypto
6   1800 elianite
7   1850 bavicrypto
8   1800 elianite
9   1750 bavicrypto
10   1750 10casproj
11   1900 geosgaen0
12   1900 geosgaen0
13   1850 JackBauerCsgo
14   1900 10casproj

Lot 13 is clear win  1700 geosgaen0

[10casproj]

Fine, lots close individually. I'm done changing anything, original rules stand, I'll be back to sort it out when all the bids are done

I agree this is a mess. Forums are a shit way to run auctions as it turns out

As far I can see, the bids below should be the winning bids according to the original auction rules. Ofcourse, to be confirmed by OP:
1   1800 elianite
2   2000 Inelasticsupply
3   1900 geosgaen0
4   1800 elianite
5   1850 bavicrypto
6   1800 elianite
7   1850 bavicrypto
8   1800 elianite
9   1750 bavicrypto
10   1750 10casproj
11   1900 geosgaen0
12   1900 geosgaen0
13   1850 JackBauerCsgo
14   1900 10casproj

Lot 13 is clear win  1700 geosgaen0

Garrett,

again consider bids from geosgaen invalid, He did bid but the next message another user put a list without his bids and the next guy used that list, so the entire bidders we missed his bids. He could have sent a message warning about the mistake, instead he reminded silent so he could take profit. This is not ethical and he should not be awarded winning auctions.

[bavicrypto]

Fine, lots close individually. I'm done changing anything, original rules stand, I'll be back to sort it out when all the bids are done

I agree this is a mess. Forums are a shit way to run auctions as it turns out

As far I can see, the bids below should be the winning bids according to the original auction rules. Ofcourse, to be confirmed by OP:
1   1800 elianite
2   2000 Inelasticsupply
3   1900 geosgaen0
4   1800 elianite
5   1850 bavicrypto
6   1800 elianite
7   1850 bavicrypto
8   1800 elianite
9   1750 bavicrypto
10   1750 10casproj
11   1900 geosgaen0
12   1900 geosgaen0
13   1850 JackBauerCsgo
14   1900 10casproj

At the very least Geosgaen0 won lot 1, the lists got out of sync. I should've done the auction format differently and handled it better. I'm very sorry to bidders who feel slighted, I don't blame you. Frankly I just want this done.

I'm going through the list to find winning bids now

Lot 1 ended at 04:04:42 PM so, it was won by ''elianite'', as the bid from geosgaen0 was at 04:04:53 PM (more than 5min passed, so lot was closed)

[Geosgaen0]

no 13 already finish, 1700 geosgaen0


1   1900 geosgaen0
2   2000 Inelasticsupply
3   1900 geosgaen0
4   1900 geosgaen0
5   1900 geosgaen0
6   1900 geosgaen0
7   1900 geosgaen0
8   1800 elianite
9   1900 geosgaen0
10   1900 geosgaen0
11   1900 geosgaen0
12   1900 geosgaen0
13   1850 JackBauerCsgo
14   1900 geosgaen0

highest bid is this

I did remind everyone

[Spokanistan51]

Garret B just needs to review each lot and tell us who won within OP rules. Agree a shitshow. Having a seasoned vet like MJ handle these is always best. This made my head spin Even if I lost, congrats to everyone that was a lucky winner!

[SSS_Trader]

My bids should be considered valid and not out of time. I started bidding when auction was on time and I had to update the list like 13 times.... I do not understand why my bid is invalid? I was following rules of putting the full list.

[10casproj]

no 13 already finish, 1700 geosgaen0


1   1900 geosgaen0
2   2000 Inelasticsupply
3   1900 geosgaen0
4   1900 geosgaen0
5   1900 geosgaen0
6   1900 geosgaen0
7   1900 geosgaen0
8   1800 elianite
9   1900 geosgaen0
10   1900 geosgaen0
11   1900 geosgaen0
12   1900 geosgaen0
13   1850 JackBauerCsgo
14   1900 geosgaen0

highest bid is this

I did remind everyone

Oh yes you remind when there was 10 seconds left,  you had 5 minutes to remind.... and you did NOT! See how many bids were done on these 5 minutes and you were silence.

[bitcoinbass]

SSS-Trade , elianite , 10casproj are for sure winners and  i really dont know about the rest.

Get MJ here to clear the situation.

[SSS_Trader]

Again, I followed the rule of putting full list, so each time I was clicking POST  I was getting a red warning saying there are new posts. Then I was copying and trying again to post my bids. I followed this rule and I was relaxed about timing because if there were new bids  means auction was still open. I spent more than 10 minutes trying to send my bids. Why my bids now are out of time? I just followed that rule... I think winners should be highest bids, no matter the time, considering forum was overload and people could not send bids like me.

[Garrett Burgwardt]

Fine, lots close individually. I'm done changing anything, original rules stand, I'll be back to sort it out when all the bids are done

I agree this is a mess. Forums are a shit way to run auctions as it turns out

As far I can see, the bids below should be the winning bids according to the original auction rules. Ofcourse, to be confirmed by OP:
1   1800 elianite
2   2000 Inelasticsupply
3   1900 geosgaen0
4   1800 elianite
5   1850 bavicrypto
6   1800 elianite
7   1850 bavicrypto
8   1800 elianite
9   1750 bavicrypto
10   1750 10casproj
11   1900 geosgaen0
12   1900 geosgaen0
13   1850 JackBauerCsgo
14   1900 10casproj

At the very least Geosgaen0 won lot 1, the lists got out of sync. I should've done the auction format differently and handled it better. I'm very sorry to bidders who feel slighted, I don't blame you. Frankly I just want this done.

I'm going through the list to find winning bids now

Lot 1 ended at 04:04:42 PM so, it was won by ''elianite'', as the bid from geosgaen0 was at 04:04:53 PM (more than 5min passed, so lot was closed)

If a lot ends at 12 and you add five minutes, it ends at 12:05.