COPA have filed a document containing their analysis of CSW's "evidence", with explanations of why almost everything he submitted is a blatant forgery.
You can find the document here:
https://bitcoindefense.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/AmendedPOCandSchedule.pdfHere are just a couple of my favorite parts:
2. The document has been backdated. The document contains hidden, embedded Grammarly timestamps indicating its true date to be later than 18 August 2019 at 9:10am (UTC). [PM25 at 8-13]
3. Searching online revealed the presence of a very similar document uploaded by Dr Wright to the website SSRN which was created just a few hours after the Grammarly timestamp of ID_000199, on the same date 18 August 2019. That uploaded document (the “SSRN Upload”) was created with software that did not yet exist in 2007. [PM25 at 40-46]
So not only is CSW completely unaware that computer files contain metadata which include such information as to when they were created and modified, but he also used software which didn't exist at the time he is claiming to have written these documents. Even his forgeries are utterly incompetent. Plenty more of the same sort of thing over a variety of his other documents:
3. The document contains embedded references to fonts including Calibri Light and Nirmala UI [PM25 at 20]. Those fonts were not yet published in 2008 [Madden Report at 165]. Further, the designers of those fonts have given evidence relied on by COPA in these proceedings that the fonts were not yet conceived of or designed by the purported date of this document.
3. Equations within ID_000227 were created with MathType software v6.9, a version dating from February 2013 which did not exist in 2008. [PM40 at 32, 42]
5. The hidden embedded text within the document includes references to a web page URL which did not exist until on or after 11 April 2019. [PM26 at 21]
But then it seems at some point CSW does become aware of metadata, and thinks that changing his computer clock will be enough to fool it:
4. ID_000504 records an impossible edit time in excess of 41 days. In percentage terms, the recorded MS Word Edit Time equates to more than 100% of the time difference between the Created and Last Saved dates. This is consistent with the use of clock manipulation techniques. [PM28 at 5-6]
4. The document contains an impossible edit time of minus 13 years, 7 months and 4 days [PM9 at 70].
There is plenty of more evidence if you want to read through it, from CSW referencing events which hadn't happened yet, sending emails from domains he hadn't registered yet, linking to websites which didn't exist yet, and more. COPA even got the manufacturer of a physical notepad that CSW supposedly hand wrote notes on to provide evidence that they did not manufacture that notepad at the time CSW claims he used it.
